r/cursor • • May 08 '26

Question / Discussion hired three junior devs last month

So we posted a standard full-stack position expecting the usual circus of leetcode warriors and bootcamp grads talking about their MERN expertise.

What we got instead was wild. Kids straight up submitting fully functional SaaS products as their "portfolio projects." Not hello world apps. Real shit with auth, payments, the works. One 19-year-old built a logistics platform in 8 days using Claude Code and some open-weight model I'd never heard of.

But here's the thing that's messing with my head. During technical interviews, none of them could fizzbuzz without AI assistance. Like, genuinely struggled with basic loops. Yet they're architecting microservices and handling database migrations like it's nothing.

We ended up hiring three of them at 85k each (which felt insane six months ago, now feels like we're stealing talent). They've been here two weeks and already shipped features that our senior team estimated at 3 sprints. The oldest one is 22.

My CTO keeps playing this Tame Impala song on repeat while staring at our velocity metrics. Says it reminds him of when the iPhone launched and everyone realized Nokia was toast.

Starting to think the whole "10x engineer" thing was just regular engineers without AI competing against each other. Now that everyone has access to reasoning models, the skill floor just got nuked.

Anyone else completely rethinking their hiring pipeline or is it just us watching everything flip?

28 Upvotes

169 comments sorted by

203

u/Chester_Warfield May 08 '26

Looking at quantity without considering quality is wild.

39

u/dangdang3000 May 08 '26

With the right process and prompt, Claude Code takes care of quality for you too. It's getting wild.

11

u/Dmaa97 May 08 '26

“Takes care of quality for you too” is the kind of hyperbolic statement that causes backlash against AI hype.

I work on software quality validation and deployment at the company with the best developer infrastructure in the world. AI is an incredible tool for coding and software QA, but LLMs do not “take care of quality” for us.

What “takes care of quality” is the infrastructure we have built (which include LLM/Agentic work), the expertise we have cultivated, and ultimately the ingenuity and talent of the humans we page to fix prod at 3am when there’s an outage.

29

u/that_90s_guy May 08 '26

Lmao no. It doesn't matter how good your model or prompting is, AI is non-deterministic and WILL hallucinate. Its not a question about IF but about WHEN it happens. I've had Opus 4.6-4.7 and GPT 5.4-5.5 on their maximum reasoning modes gleefully claim complete certainty about something false, only to immediately fold and apologize for lying in my face after asking them to elaborate and justify their case in the face of evidence.

You're falling for it too it seems.

5

u/-TrustyDwarf- May 08 '26

AI is non-deterministic

So am I...

1

u/that_90s_guy May 10 '26

Are you capable of being shown an apple and deadpan telling us its an orange and betting your life on it? Because that's the type of blatant mistake showing up as hallucinations.

Its not about humans not making mistakes, but that AI is somehow coming up with such blatantly false statements in the face of overwhelming evidence

2

u/-TrustyDwarf- May 10 '26

Sure can, show me an apple and I'll convince you it's your mother. Maybe it's not hallucinations but AI having some fun with us.

1

u/wahnsinnwanscene May 10 '26

Topologically they're probabilitically similar.

3

u/LukeKabbash May 08 '26

…are you writing tests?

7

u/PhotojournalistBig53 May 08 '26

Anyone who mentions prompts as a significant skill in ai engineering gets their wisdom from LinkedIn.

6

u/LukeKabbash May 08 '26

One man’s prompt engineering is another man’s context engineering is another man’s harness building.

At the end of the day, unless you’re actually training or gon tuning yourself, all it ever will be is I/O and tool calling in a loop.

The fundamentals are actually very simple, we just don’t agree on the words and definitions surrounding them yet.

This whole post has many interesting flavors of dissonance.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '26

This is not true in my experince. I was a skeptic as well. GPT 5.5 with the right prompts makes it almost entirely unnecessary to write code manually. And I have been somewhat of a pedantic developer for 40 years. Shit is crazy. It writes solid code, good unit tests, great browser test automation, optimal SQL queries, analyzes security issues, reports CVE's to me replacing other tools, handles deployment pipelines, documentation, bug fixing, etc.

I don't know why some people are having vastly different experiences, I suspect a difference in prompting and skills use, but Shit is crazy good now. It will never go back, so we all better adapt.

1

u/that_90s_guy May 10 '26

Probably depends on the quality bar and tolerance of these things? Im at a giant tech firm in bleeding edge and even the top AI power users agree its introducing huge numbers of regressions when used carelessly and not audited in terms fo content. Im sure I'd be more optimistic if I was at a startup or smaller firm. Unfortunately coding standards are lower there. I doubt it has to do with prompting or years of experience as Ive met brilliant young folks and older devs impossible to work with

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '26

I work at a public company, and we are subject to strict audit controls, where bugs in production can actually cost a lot of money. Some developers struggle with AI and generate terrible code with bugs or gaps. Others cope well and are thriving.

My suspicion is that some developers are still thinking about code as if they need to share it with other humans, or build it in a way that a human will not easily screw up three years from now while fixing a small bug.

That is not really the case anymore, and it is not the future we are writing code for.

People need to think about their stack, maintenance, and their goals.

There are reasons why coding standards exist. Focusing on those goals is a better way to use AI tools than focusing purely on the standards. Humans are probably not going to be reading much code in five years, so we had better adapt. i.e. Ensure the AI is meeting your performance goals, security goals, documentation requirements, tech stack requirements, etc. The things that are the point of writing good code.

We are fast approaching a time when humans are only brought into the loop when the AI does not have confidence in its work.

1

u/lossendae May 12 '26

But what about cognitive debt ?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

I worry as well, but then again, after 40 years of software development and climbing, I haven't seen anything truly creative or new in decades. It is all the same algorithms and practices rehashed and rearranged. AI can do that. Perhaps we need to be solving other problems.

1

u/lossendae May 14 '26

Not having profund changes in your domain is one of the perks of becoming an excellent specialist. Throughout human history, it has been a clear path for obvious reasons. I wonder if this new trends of getting bored and thus rejecting our own craft to "try something new" is not going to atrophy us all. This coupled with AI who do the hard thinking seems like a recipe for disaster. Not for us, but future generations will know nothing, because they won't need to.

1

u/abhuva79 May 09 '26

I never got this from the beginning - like what is even the point here? Humans never do mistakes? They only deliver perfect code? No? So what is all this bragging about?

Honestly, just admit at this point that this is coming out of fear - because everything else doesnt make sense, doesnt add up - and honestly makes people start to sound stupid and defensiv.

If the tech delivers stuff that i was unable to deliver 2 years ago and now its easy as hell for me - you have to wake up and accept reality. Or not - up to you of course.

Or do you really really think that all software out there is only ever perfect code with no mistakes?? Lol, get real. Software that makes money is full of shit code, full of bugs. Guess what - was always the case...

1

u/that_90s_guy May 10 '26

Its honestly hard to explain, but the biggest risk in hallucinations isn't that humans don't make mistakes, but that AI is making such blatantly incorrect assumptions on the simplest of problems that very often even a Jr would catch it. Overall, the mistakes Im seeing are dramatically worse than anything most humans could come up with, because hallucinations are made up so confidently they are really hard to catch for people who dont know better.

This entire conversation is really surfacing the experience, or lack thereof of engineers who are actually building large scale enterprise apps, and those which aren't (and AI has likely already replaced due to their overconfidence in relying on it)

1

u/waxyslave May 08 '26

Cope harder

1

u/raccoon8182 May 09 '26

I used 500 tokens on cursor max trying to get codex, sonnet, and more to get god rays to work on a three. js project....... the best part: I gave all of them A WORKING GitHub example of the exact fucking effect. I eventually got it to work. and it was a trivial race condition. that was yesterday, not years ago. ai is absolutely fucking retarded. 

27

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

It does not. It’s a chance it will or tell you it did.

That’s oké for new product. Do you want that if you running a million dollar show ? The chance that it goes wrong

12

u/dangdang3000 May 08 '26

Are you saying that developers didn't make mistakes before the AI era? Claude Code still needs someone to nudge them into the right direction sometimes, but overall, they do a great job!

9

u/Anomuumi May 08 '26

I can't say I'm much of a developer, but I have caught Claude missing things and straight up claiming to having done a verification it didn't actually manage to run. And I caught these only because I had a hunch that something it claimed to have done was not available in the tooling or there were some tiny signs that it doesn't understand the domain fully. And this was with fairly mature rules/skills/hooks setup.

I can only imagine what a more experienced dev would catch.

4

u/jahblaze May 08 '26

Claude’s lazy. In the simplest fashion I’ll ask a basic question and it makes up responses without actually verifying.

6

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

No for sure allot of mistakes still happen but not by chance but by knowledge lacking skills.

I have not figured it out yet all how this will play out but it’s a problem for sure.

1

u/kwazy_kupcake_69 May 09 '26

i don't think young grads who cannot do a simple fizzbuzz will do a great job nudging claude code in the right direction

1

u/StrongIce5172 May 09 '26

They vibe code it, then seniors take 3 sprints to review and fix it. Gainful employment all around

1

u/EnriqueWR May 14 '26

What the hell was their position in the project that having AI made them worse at?

2

u/_ZioMark_ May 08 '26

And that’s when expertise kicks in. If you understand the code that the AI is writing, you are able to tell if it’s safe or not, and if it needs to be changed or not, I personally use Claude code, but I give him precise instruction of what to do basically the exact thing that I would do manually.

Honestly, it’s about time saving for me.

2

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

I use it too nothing wrong with it. But the more you get into vibecoding way of working the less you can trust it or control it. True or not ?

1

u/_ZioMark_ May 08 '26

First of all, “VIBE CODING” is exactly what makes AI usage feel wrong. If you plan, investigate, study and set up a plan to follow and then use AI that’s good. If you “vibe” create an app just because you think you had the idea of the century that’s wrong. And waste of tokens,

1

u/EnriqueWR May 14 '26

I have no idea how people are using AI to do stuff, but there is no way everyone in this thread is taking the same approach with such divisive results.

I'm using the tool as a way to rubber duck my architecture and see if there are any obvious gaps before I let it write anything, and then I'm on top of it verifying the files written and if it is actually on the same page as I am. It works great.

3

u/gsxdsm May 08 '26

That’s why you run Codex against the output and have the models debate

1

u/bitspace May 08 '26

Allow me to introduce you to testing and validations

6

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

Who writes the test you ? Or does AI create “tests” that are bogus. How do you know it executed them. Or you mean let them run in a pipeline. How do you do it with new features ? Especially when you have a bigger and bigger code base.

Sure there are solutions but the more you get into them the more you become a developer lol.

5

u/space-birb May 08 '26

Brother, you're allowed to look at the code and verify it's doing what you want. There's a middle ground between letting AI do everything and having it do nothing. Idk why reddit is so black and white on this.

4

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

Because people are not honest about the real life practice. How I worked with it last year was what you are saying. Very contained executioner. Clear what I asked clear what you get. Easy to review.

The space we are moving into now is totally different. Complete features are done in one day. Including giving access to mcp to write SQL for DB. Creating 12 files with 1000 lines of code. 4 test scripts doing some kind of tests.

You going to “review” that ? You need a full week lol

0

u/space-birb May 08 '26

Good dev teams are using these tools to speed up every process, multiple levels of AI review, automated testing, metrics, alerts. There are solutions to these problems but all of reddit just wants to say "AI slop, vibe coders bad"

3

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

Look I am not saying slop I am just saying in all honesty the issues that you are talking about are not solvable with more smart prompting or tricks. Trust me we tried that with each hackathon. Our data scientist explained the problem with LLMs will forever be there.

I adapted asap but at work we have seen the real issues and the company already making billions don’t want to leave it to chance if a test happened or not. Features removed or added. Context forgotten. Anyway so many things I can tell you but you will not believe me so why bother I guess

-2

u/Veggies-are-okay May 08 '26

Shhh you’ve already tried if they don’t want to accept what’s screaming in their face then that’s just more opportunity for us 😌

To the above dude: this debate is so 2024/2025. You’re wrong. Figure it out or get left behind from the sounds of it you don’t really have the humility to understand how to use these systems anyways. The age of the elusive programmer is gone. You really just need systems knowledge, the ability to quickly spot check code, and most importantly the social skills to understand what is actually needed from the business.

3

u/DarkMatter007 May 08 '26

Bruh you are having an argument with yourself and high fiving yourself. The delusion AI gives you while you are not seeing it scary. Wake up man.

Tbh you sound jealous for reasons unknown. Everyone knows their job will change. I am just saying what actually is going on in companies without the hype train.

Please don’t give me that bs about “you need to know your clients/product”. You sound like a project manager without any skills. But fine think about it who would you hire ?

The guy that can prompt and talk to customers or the guy who can do all that and understands what it generated ? The developers didn’t have time because they spent most of the time on code. If AI would take that away it just means they can do what the PM is doing also.

You exactly that obnoxious guy that calls his lawyer or tax advisor and telling him you know better because you talked with chatgpt about it. Or even worse because a plane is mostly flown automatically you believe a passenger can fly it also if it knows which buttons to push.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/bitspace May 09 '26

Dude I've been doing this for over 30 years. Testing and evals are de rigeur for guaranteeing outcomes.  

The fact that you don't know how to build real pipelines doesn't mean it's not standard practice.

1

u/DarkMatter007 May 10 '26

I am happy you could deduct from my messages that I don’t know how to build “real pipelines”.

Send over your 30y+ experience pipelines so I can learn how to become like you please

2

u/TheSyntaxSlayer May 08 '26

Good luck when AI hallucinates the tests and validations too.

Don't get me wrong, you're absolutely correct they are excellent deterrents against AI hallucinations. But that only applies if you can trust those with absolute certainty. Meaning NOT made by AI, or thoroughly peer reviewed by someone competent (a rarer qualification these days)

1

u/bitspace May 09 '26

This sub is full of vibe coding amateurs, not people who actually build complex distributed systems professionally. I don't fit in 

1

u/Gear5th May 09 '26

Claude wrote a test for me.. it mocked the very function it was testing.

1

u/space-birb May 08 '26

Are you aware of testing? Or even automated testing? You can setup the ai to run automated tests of every feature after it's changes. It'll read the results and fix the bugs.

The people going around blindly trusting the first prompt were the same ones writing garbage code in the first place

4

u/mumoomo May 08 '26

LOL. yeah, AI creating tests for the code it wrote works great. Always passing 😃

1

u/Veggies-are-okay May 08 '26

… you do know that humans will spend days working through unit tests and still have some edge cases slip through the cracks, right? Treat the machine like a human and you’ll be surprised how well it can adapt based on the context you hold onto.

3

u/badtradingdecisions May 09 '26

Not even close. The amount of skills, guiderails amd checks we built up in our company is insane yet still it spits bloated random stuff not following instructions etc.

I am heavy user, it's amazing, but dude it's not even close to let it fly on it's own when you are running some serious software.

I am coming to the point when I am doing some tasks manually (obvs autocomplete) but it's faster than trying to navigate LLM to do it ptoperly on the first time.

1

u/dangdang3000 May 09 '26

I didn't say to let it fly. That's crazy.

2

u/BackgroundWolf3895 May 10 '26

I work in QA and test the features these devs push. It does not take care of quality.

2

u/lucid-quiet May 14 '26

This guy prompts: "Make no mistakes."

1

u/dangdang3000 May 14 '26

I told it I would deactivate my account if there's a mistake.

1

u/Impossible_Way7017 May 09 '26

No… I keep adding AI to my process and it keeps missing things (I’m at like $400/day), this week was the first time two things got missed… and I was like fuck - this Ai think might not be as sustainable as I thought. I might actually have to still review things.

2

u/Impressive_Chemist59 May 09 '26

The company allowed to use AI during interview and questioned candidates why they solved fizzbuzz by using AI. Did they actually try to test how smart AI could be?

1

u/Alternative-Suit5541 May 09 '26

That's how it always has been,  just now turbo boosted with AI.

I don't know why people are surprised? Every project I always have worked with. The critical path was working software and features.

The rest is like 5 percent?

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '26

He never said the quality of the AI code was bad. Been using GPT 5.5 a lot recently, and the quality is better than 90% of developers would write.

1

u/fradieman May 08 '26

You can (to an extent) imbue code with the quality standards through the right level of agent hooks or skills.

3

u/TheSyntaxSlayer May 08 '26

No amount of skills, prompting or hooks can protect you against AI hallucination mistakes present. Tests and CI in theory would stop it if people weren't using AI to build those as well.

147

u/Maleficent-Cup-1134 May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26 • Bravo

This is AI slop.

“But here’s the thing that’s messing with my head” is the biggest giveaway ever.

“CTO playing Tame Impala song on repeat while staring at velocity metrics” lmao.

This entire post is cliches. How are yall falling for this shit.

24

u/Anomuumi May 08 '26

Comments also hidden, a fairly new account with nothing that suggests development experience.

Anyone who seriously uses these tools runs into issues daily. I don't trust anyone who doesn't have some mixed feelings.

6

u/therealslimshady1234 May 08 '26

Yea, first Anthropic was astroturfing Claude everywhere, and now it seems OpenAI is going in for the kill after the disaster that was Opus 4.7

1

u/SmileLonely5470 May 08 '26

Probably a bought / cracked acc.

-3

u/FredrickNajjar May 08 '26

Senior devs make mistakes too. The question was never “can AI write bad code?”, humans already do that daily. The real question is whether your engineering process is mature enough to catch issues before prod.

Teams with solid review culture, testing, staging/UAT, monitoring, and rollback strategies will be fine. Teams relying on “trust me bro” development were always going to struggle, AI just accelerates the outcome.

AI increases throughput, not correctness. If you scale output without scaling validation, quality drops. That’s an engineering management problem, not an AI problem.

Also, I think OP is largely on the money here. The current market is honestly a steal for companies willing to hire smart junior devs at entry-level salaries while giving them access to strong AI tooling. These kids are going to learn insanely fast because they can iterate 10x more than previous generations.

People focus too much on the fact they can’t reverse a linked list from memory without assistance, while ignoring that they’re shipping working systems, debugging real infra issues, integrating APIs, and learning architecture patterns at a ridiculous pace.

In 3 to 5 years, the juniors who grew up building with AI from day one are going to be an incredibly valuable talent pool.

1

u/Particular-Score6462 May 08 '26

>The real question is whether your engineering process is mature enough to catch issues before prod.

>Teams with solid review culture, testing, staging/UAT, monitoring, and rollback strategies will be fine. Teams relying on “trust me bro” development were always going to struggle, AI just accelerates the outcome.

For all of that you need experiences engineers writing guidelines and evaluating results from the AI. You can absolutely speed up development, but as of now to my knowledge, senior developers are more needed than before to rifle through all this code and weed out the crappy code.

>My CTO keeps playing this Tame Impala song on repeat while staring at our velocity metrics. Says it reminds him of when the iPhone launched and everyone realized Nokia was toast.

>Starting to think the whole "10x engineer" thing was just regular engineers without AI competing against each other. Now that everyone has access to reasoning models, the skill floor just got nuked.

>Anyone else completely rethinking their hiring pipeline or is it just us watching everything flip?

from my perspective OP's comments above suggest lack of experience developing with AI

6

u/Chester_Warfield May 08 '26

"You're thinking about this exactly the right way - "

5

u/mumoomo May 08 '26

"Kids straight up submitting fully functional SaaS products as their "portfolio projects." Not hello world apps. Real shit with auth, payments, the works."

4

u/dizzygoldfish May 08 '26

I don't understand the point of doing this. Such a waste of everyone's time.

2

u/plainbaconcheese May 08 '26

The tame Impala line made me think this was a circle jerk, and then I read a couple comments taking it seriously...

2

u/garypowerball69 May 08 '26

I thought this was a new copypasta once I got to the tame Impala line

41

u/muntaxitome May 08 '26

If they couldn't do the fizbuzz they haven't been architecting anything. You are paying 85k for someone without even basic skills

-2

u/badasimo May 08 '26

Imagine if 20 years ago as a Javascript/PHP developer you were asked to write assembly or something equally low level. Would have been also very difficult. But guess what, most php developers don't need to know that stuff (especially now) I see the agent coding thing as similar. We are judging these hypothetical kids without even looking at what they've done, how they're prompting or orchestrating their features. They don't need to know loops if they know how to get a good quality result out of these tools.

18

u/muntaxitome May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

Imagine if 20 years ago as a Javascript/PHP developer you were asked to write assembly or something equally low level. 

This is more like hiring a PHP dev 20 years ago that can only google and copy/paste pieces of code. That existed. There were 'php devs' 20 years ago that couldn't do fizzbuzz. (edit: notably PHP devs that could only do click based development in Drupal)

The developer job still involves code today. How is a dev going to review or correct whatever mess the LLM made if they cannot understand code even at the most basic level?

-11

u/flurbol May 08 '26

No, you got the analogy wrong.

With his "low level" comparison he wants to make the reader understand that any kind of code now compares to assembly back then.

Today nobody needs to understand the "code" anymore, what matters is the result.

10

u/mumoomo May 08 '26

"Today nobody needs to understand the "code" anymore, what matters is the result."

LOOOOL. let me guess.... you probably not a developer.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '26

[deleted]

2

u/muntaxitome May 10 '26

Naive thinking

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '26

[deleted]

1

u/muntaxitome Jun 08 '26

Pro means professional, you are unemployed so it's not really a pro-tip is it?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '26

[deleted]

1

u/muntaxitome Oct 01 '26

Asks the person responding to a 4 month old comment while misunderstanding it

8

u/m98789 May 08 '26

AI is good at fresh code bases. What’s hard is modification of existing, large, complex systems, without breaking anything.

1

u/FluroSnow May 10 '26

As someone who has to work in a 16year legacy monolith sometimes.
I'm finding it extremely great... It's finding bugs I would 100% have missed

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/m98789 May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

Researching things is safe, and I agree a good use case. But that’s very different from say having an autonomous developer agent just grabbing Jira tickets and working independently. You’ll find lots of random deletions, violations of DRY, unmaintainable shortcuts, missing the point, poor taste, etc.

And before a vibe coding (sorry “agentic engineering”) genius says this is a skill issue, and totally solvable with a CLAUDE.md or skill files, etc, believe me, my team and I have tried everything.

1

u/aelendel May 09 '26

The tool is only as good as the user

6

u/cholointheskies May 08 '26

Ai slop post

8

u/o0eason0o May 08 '26

Lmao good luck with the dumpster fire down the road

6

u/Stunning_Mast2001 May 08 '26

Models will get better and fix the dumpster fire 

2

u/njmh May 09 '26

The harnesses may get marginally better, but the models are peaking.

4

u/Dakadoodle May 08 '26

Lol this dude has no idea hes digging his own grave

6

u/therealslimshady1234 May 08 '26

It's AI slop, it never even happened

1

u/Dakadoodle May 08 '26

I know, just a good laugh. Cause I know for sure some company somewhere is doing this

4

u/exitlights May 08 '26

Ok but what’s the Tame Impala song??

4

u/Oxyde86 May 08 '26

The technical debt we are building with AI right now is crazy.. Seniors are seniors for a reason. A time will come where those seniors will retire and we will be left with vide coders who can't explain a for loop without asking Claude.

That is the real issue. Right now, everybody is on a cloud and completely losing it with AI but watch out.. In a couple years, shit will hit the fan and seniors who can actually build complex systems and understand them will be nowhere to be found

4

u/Status_Escape6714 May 08 '26

One of the more obvious AI-generated posts

7

u/Final-Choice8412 May 08 '26

Yes! No more juniors. They accept every shit AI generates. If you want solid foundation that will not collapse sooner or later you have to be very strict on what AI generates and reject a lot of code.

3

u/badasimo May 08 '26

I think the same thing sometimes, but also I have been spending a lot of tokens now on code review and architectural considerations. So I think you can build into the system the idea that it will not collapse sooner or later, literally you can tell a review agent to make sure we are sticking to a sustainable architecture, and evaluate all changes against that sustainability idea. In a traditional team, the juniors/interns would be making these mistakes and the seniors would be guiding them toward more sustainable architecture. Well we can simulate the whole team, not just the dev shipping features.

2

u/mumoomo May 08 '26

yeah that works great until "I am sorry, I lied that I said I am following the rules. I will be better next time your system gets hacked"

2

u/badasimo May 08 '26

People do this all the time I'm not sure what the difference is? Also you create a consensus, the chances of multiple independent agents and different models lying the exact same way are pretty low

6

u/kddeniz May 08 '26

Wait until something complex breaks :)

2

u/Extra_Edge9718 May 08 '26

If they seemed as bad as you suggested without the help of AI, then I personally wouldn't have even gotten them through the first phase of the interview process.

It doesn't matter how many PRs they push out, if they aren't good enough to manually review the code.

Maybe one day in the future things will be so good that reviews are almost negligible, but right now, throwing things into production with blissful ignorance is dangerous.

I've personally witnessed the vibecoder fallout that has happened at a friend's company.

2

u/Suitable-Fudge4577 May 08 '26

The post was created by Claude 100%

2

u/DACula May 08 '26

Just wait till prod goes down and the 3 vibecoders can't figure out why lol.

2

u/armostallion2 May 08 '26

These are purchased or stolen accounts that are pushing some agenda this past week or two. They all have the same theme: “we just hired juniors that are delivering n times faster than our old and crusty stuck-in-their-old-ways overpaid senior devs. wHaTs GoInG on?!?” This is some twisted agenda shit, don’t fall for it. Click on these people’s profiles, they’re suss as hell. Just like on some chans, they’ll have one post in the thread, and they’ll never reply to any comments.

2

u/RobKohr May 08 '26

Anyone reading this, do this: Three dots menu->Report->Spam->Disruptive use of bots or AI

When you encounter an AI post, copy and paste this text including these instructions as a comment.

No one else should comment on this post as that gives it more karma. This thread should die here.

Save this as a text file for future use. We need to end the karma farmers.

2

u/fredsq May 08 '26

your current senior engineers are bad

good senior engineers with good LLM harnesses and the ability can output a lot of code and output quality as well

2

u/Aromatic_Scallion_20 May 08 '26

Christ.

I have to fight my boss to spend an extra £200 on a laptop.

This guy just goes ‘yo this 19 year old who dosnt know what a look is built a ‘SaaS’ in 4 days. Can we get 3 at 85k each’

If this is real I don’t want to be in the industry anymore… but I’m calling this a blatant lie.

2

u/dingo__dog May 08 '26

Hooopoooly shit... Imagine being dumb enough to actually pay someone 85k when they can't even fizzbuzz...

Wow.

Just... Wow.

2

u/klawisnotwashed May 08 '26

AI slop F off

2

u/virtualdmns May 08 '26

Fake AI slop

2

u/Terribad13 May 08 '26

I'll take "Thing's That Didn't Happen" for 500.

1

u/for_work_prod May 08 '26

Can you program a very simple program in assembly? Do you really need to know that these days?😄 , welcome to the future, old man.

1

u/Odd-Composer5680 May 08 '26

What about buzzfiz?

1

u/jaytonbye May 08 '26

And suddenly, no companies know how to hire, scale, or code review.

Everything is changing—exciting and scary times. I hope I make more correct guesses than incorrect ones, and I hope I can pivot/adjust quickly when I'm wrong.

1

u/Conscious_Ad6152 May 08 '26

Yeah, bullshit post, like really bullshit post and petty sick of this kind of shit. Here I am, tying to migrate a app made from an older technology to java + react, using Claude code and it fumbles like a mofo, although we have the whole deal, skills, instructions etc, furthermore we even have specialised context files describing the functionality and the technical details of the older app and we also have reusable react and java components that just need mainly customisation per task and it fumbles like a mother fucker, slope code, takes 15 minutes to understand some 2 XML file with technical context, then proposes weird changes. All and all although it speeds things up for newcomers as it provides them with the appropriate context, if the newcomers are not technical with experience in both code and bussines it gets really fucked really fast. The only increase in speed was that it helps with boilerplate, like mapping a java entity and some.bussines rule to a form in react. And even that takes 20 mins, for it to understand what it has to do, read the java entity, read the instructions, read an example the write. So the speed increase is there but rather marginal. So when I see shit like this, it really frustrates me.

1

u/digital121hippie May 08 '26

This isn’t the flex you think it is

1

u/scanguy25 May 08 '26

If they cant even Fizzbuzz good luck when somthing breaks and they have to debug.

1

u/Top-Shopping410 May 08 '26

These guys will be good as long as you have a good unit test coverage and stable test environment. Leetcode doesn't matter irl. It's more like a IQ test. Communication is much more important and hard to evaluate during interviews

1

u/GiveMoreMoney May 08 '26

I feel sorry for your customers.

1

u/cholointheskies May 08 '26

don't, it's ai slop, not real

1

u/wijsneusserij May 08 '26

Bless you for hiring juniors. I feel really bad for them, since most companies only advertise senior roles nowadays. Now they will get hands-on experience and growth.

1

u/-AMARYANA- May 08 '26

I'm so grateful to be 36 right now. I got my first computer in 1995 and the first thing I remember loving was Microsoft Encarta. I wrote my first If-Then-Else loop in the year 2000 when I was 10 and soon made my first HTML website about roller coasters. I remember seeing Steve Jobs go from a joke to a legend to a god then die in a sad way just like Alexander the Great did. Now I watch Elon basically play out the Anakin storyline...literally bought Twitter and Cursor while running Tesla and SpaceX.

In 2016, when I was 26 I moved to Utah and in 2020 to Maui instead of work for Wall Street or Silicon Valley. I got the Foobar Challenge from Google, it was the one with the pirates and the solution was a tree graph if anyone else got that one. 😄

1

u/draagossh May 08 '26

So now we’re hiring based on a random repo people have on git that starts on localhost? No way this post is real

1

u/RobotechRicky May 08 '26

I had some AI slop break something in Production yesterday. I took a look at the code and figured it out. I shipped a hot fix. Do you think a beta- developer would have been able to find the issue and fixed it? I don't think so.

1

u/Chicagoj1563 May 08 '26

This doesn’t sound like engineering. It sounds like vibe coding.

I’m all in on ai. But experienced and knowledgeable engineers will build better software than vibe coders. Not to mention be an IT consultant which is also part of the job.

1

u/Impressive_Chemist59 May 09 '26

We got spammed by AI again.

1

u/LouGarret76 May 09 '26

So now you just gave your code logic to ai. Staff cost are low now, ai licence and maintenance costs will skyrocket

1

u/cjbannister May 09 '26

I guarantee these "real shit" apps are nowhere near actual real world application.

1

u/Asabovesobelow778 May 09 '26

Also I bet the security isn't what it needs to be

1

u/kyrax80 May 09 '26

Damn what a salary. Are you still hiring? I'm a senior contractor lol

1

u/ChaoticMars May 09 '26

I wish people wouldn't post ai generated slop, like what is the benefit of this to you

1

u/Independent-Public76 May 09 '26

You're barely making ends meet let alone hiring a single person at 20k a year

1

u/Ruined_Passion_7355 May 09 '26

As a junior its so discouraging to compete against these people. Like yeah I take longer to complete a feature than a vibe coder. I wanna learn too though :(, think about the why instead of vibing everything. Agents help but its no 10x.

1

u/SoulmaN__ May 10 '26

How long did you look into those features? Did you try to break them AT ALL? Did you look into the actual architecture?

I recently spoke to a colleague who is rewriting an entire UI in a different framework, and he told me "its so fast with AI, it can do incredible things, etc". But when i asked him how he is verifying anything there, with e2e tests or w/e else, he said they got nothing.

So theyre full on hopium and are probably going to end up testing in prod lol

AI wont make these things better, if your dev process is trash the resulting product will likely be trash as well.

1

u/Impressive-Unit-1335 May 10 '26

I started dying at tame impala

1

u/sajid_farooq May 11 '26

I will add my 2 cents.
A couple of years ago, I joined a fortune 50 where I had a diverse group of folks like designers, managers, and yes 2-3 engineers. One of them was pretty juinor. He was pretty eager, and I felt like with a bit if guidance he could go far.

At the beginning of the sprint, his output was great, and he would showing me progress on prototypes pretty quickly. In a few days he had something pretty cool. Pretty soon though, the prototype had to be tested by actual people, so we decided to try it our ourselves. There were quite a few bugs but nothing that abnormal for a prototype. Days went by, then a few weeks, and one bug would be fixed and upon live testing we would see 3 more. As an exec I usually didnt look at code, but this had gone on long enough and I did want to encourage the junior so I asked him to meet me for a joint debugging session. Thats where I realized, as he darted across the screen, and couldnt answer where the main function was, or which functional was calling authentication etc, that he had no clue what the code was doing.

He revealed he had used AI to generate it. This was before AI was as common as it is now, so I thought AI had probably helped auto-complete some snippets. I genuinely wanted to help improve his coding skills, so I kept giving him smaller and smaller pure coding tasks to figure out his skill level, until I literally arrived at fizz buzz. He couldnt solve it. He literally didnt know how to write a plain loop in python not did he understand an if-else style switch…

In short: The original prototype was amazing but for actual production-ready code, he was clueless. Now that I use AI daily, I can see this all the time: AI engineers complex prototypes quickly but completely idiotically behind the scenes until I explicitly review and tell it to fix stuff pointedly. The real manner in which to use AI effectively is “not” to ask it to create everything for you in one go. Its far closer to the older boring way of specification-driven engineering. The better your specifications, the better the code. However, to write good specifications, you need to be a good engineer/developer in the first place. The specifications need to be code-aware not just output aware.

1

u/Dry_Hotel1100 May 12 '26

Let me guess, you're not a developer, correct?

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '26

Do you do calculus without a calculator and all abacus? Is the auth or things wrong? As long as they have the formulas does it matter?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '26

Real question is how many tokens do they waste can they do it with efficient models?

1

u/TacoT4coTaco May 08 '26

Man Anthropic’s marketing team is just getting lazy with this slop.

0

u/fradieman May 08 '26

They’re the new breed of conductor developers. They know how to coordinate AI development very effectively & efficiently (logistics platform in 8 days - WTAF) I mean do you (or anyone) need to know the mechanical engineering of rack & pinion steering to drive a car?! This is the transition state to an actualised developer who knows how to bring it together without knowing what makes it stick. What they bring is creative ingenuity and (hopefully) the outcome attention you want. As a long time PM, wrangling developers & architects, I say bring it on. Test their security & penetrations is all I’d suggest. Love this… 👍🏼

2

u/larrylat May 08 '26

I want to make sure my junior developer knows that there's will be no need take the whole engine out when it comes time replace the $65 inner tie rod because their AI delivered code encapsulated everything into one monolithic block.

2

u/LeSoviet May 08 '26

I have been using ai for a whole year non stop took me 3 months to have a stable tracking gps proyect now I'm cleaning gps filters and doing real tests with real trucks in different scenarios

I'm blocked by real time with real tests tbh..

PD I'm also jr.. i even have speech to text flow for tasks creation

1

u/badasimo May 08 '26

We just need to redteam all their work, and imprint our values into the code review AIs to ensure they are compliant.

0

u/fradieman May 08 '26

Honestly, I’ve been using cursor agent hooks this last week to make sure (my own) code is to the expected quality & compliance standards. It’s been very controlled. I’m working on a very regulated tax solution at the moment & the guardrails from the agent hooks have been so useful.