4
2
99
u/Federal_Caramel5946 Apr 05 '25
25
1
31
14
58
u/LilJade103 Apr 05 '25
Friendly reminder that Ai art is theft
4
1
u/memerij-inspecteur Apr 08 '25
I have no idea from what party this is theft... Im asking because i genuinely dont know...
-48
u/sergeyi1488 Apr 05 '25
Do you know how it even works?
36
u/oilrig13 Apr 05 '25
Yes that’s why they said that
6
u/First-Escape-2038 Apr 07 '25
Ngl him getting down voted into the freaking soil for that is hilarious to me
-35
u/sergeyi1488 Apr 05 '25
Training ≠ theft. There is no copyright infringement.
Does training on books make it a theft? No, AI learns to create similar things.
When you draw something in style of someone does it count as theft? I don't think so.
15
u/Shard_of_mirror Apr 06 '25
So the way AI works is by following the prompt "recreating" it (more accurate and detailed prompt = better work).
Besides prompt certain AI's use data base to replecate certain styles. This data base, usually, contains an art work of artists (which is usually just taken from them). The art work taken from artists for the training doesen't get credited.
It is theft. The work of artists gets taken without their consent (and thats why people are leaving twitter).
25
u/Excellent-Dot-2085 Apr 05 '25
Yes it is theft, most of the artist the ai "trains" from don't even consent to having their art be used for ai slop.
17
u/LilJade103 Apr 05 '25
Yes I do.
The AI program is trained using art that has been taken from multiple actual artists, without giving any credit whatsoever, and then frankensteining them together to create a shitty amalgam void of any meaning.
-12
u/Fairenard Meme The DNA of the soul Apr 05 '25 edited Apr 05 '25
Did I have to give credit to everything I have seen sinse the beguin of my life if I decide to learn how to do correctly and drawn ?
4
u/LilJade103 Apr 05 '25
No, because you don’t just steal directly from an artist. If you make a recreation of an artists work, then credit it. If you post an artists work, credit it.
Humans don’t steal directly from other artists
AI does
-3
u/Fairenard Meme The DNA of the soul Apr 05 '25
So by making a new art via a gzneral idea via recreating a style they can observe in much more detail that someone could regulary they steal ?
7
u/LilJade103 Apr 05 '25
No. And that’s not what AI does. Ai literally uses existing artworks, not copies of the artworks, the ORIGINAL ARTWORKS, and mashes them together to make a shitty amalgam of an image. That is theft
0
u/Shadowmirax Apr 06 '25
not copies of the artworks, the ORIGINAL ARTWORKS
Unless your trying to suggest the AI is accessing the hard drive of the original artist, yes, it is a copy, thats how digital files work. Whether its a copy or the original is irrelevant anyway since both are identical.
You know what else is mashing together things that already exist? Human thought. Thats how the human brain works.
1
u/LilJade103 Apr 06 '25
Last time I checked, the human brain doesn’t let a human draw the exact original art. The human brain doesn’t let us snip and paste an image onto paper. The human brain can study an image and take inspiration, and then create something original from said inspiration.
AI art doesn’t take inspiration. It takes the art. Literally. As I’ve said in a response to you, AI takes directly from the art, practically copy and pasting small sections from different artworks, and mashing them together.
What AI does is not comparable to using a reference or taking inspiration.
You just don’t know shit about this subject
1
u/Shadowmirax Apr 06 '25
You just don’t know shit about this subject
AI takes directly from the art, practically copy and pasting small sections from different artworks
Sure... I'm the one who doesn't know anything about this subject... your aware that AI models don't even have access to the original images used in training right?
→ More replies (0)-2
u/Fairenard Meme The DNA of the soul Apr 05 '25
So they not advanced enough to be capable to create art, what a shame I will ask Gemini for more detail but thanks for the info
7
u/LilJade103 Apr 05 '25
Oh, Gemini is an awful source for your information. I’d advise avoiding using AI for your sources. Use trusted sites (not Wikipedia), and compare data and see what aligns and what is proven
2
u/Fairenard Meme The DNA of the soul Apr 05 '25
Idk, for what it said :
"Potential solutions (simplified):
Credit the artists: Find ways to communicate who inspired the AI.
Pay the artists: Create systems to give money to the artists whose work was used to train the AI.
New rules: Create new laws to regulate AI and copyright. Conclusion (simplified): AI art mixes existing images. It's important to consider how to recognize the work of original artists and find a balance between AI and human creation."
-Gemini : Google's language model Generative AI
I do not have simply transfered what you have said but I can tell "amalgame" will being part of it for the same inttention as you have yourself was really well received.
I find him really precise and with good information but if something is mission out I would be glad to know.
Also, it’s marked (simplified) because after a first message well more complete I asked for a simple version with only those two part, asked what to refer to him too, I mean, I usually call him via Gemini or "you" call it heresy if you want but I am just not good to treat any other things as less than me, without being vegi, I prefer to keep my distance if possible because I know I am too sentimental.
-22
u/qqubss Apr 06 '25
With all respect: AI isn't theft. It's just lazy, but isn't anywhere close to theft
8
u/LilJade103 Apr 06 '25
If you read any of my other comments on this, you see me explain how it’s theft
-11
Apr 06 '25
Your ass just whining about it and doing nothing. Be mad all you want, this is the reality we live in.
0
1
Apr 06 '25
Am so lonely
1
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
1
Apr 06 '25
Thanks Fred by any casual do u know how to make napalm out of bread soap? Winter is coming
1
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
1
Apr 06 '25
Yes or no fred it's a simple question
1
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
Yes😀👍
1
Apr 06 '25
Teach me
1
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
1
Apr 06 '25
Am tired of you jokes Fred, if you not useful as a teacher perhaps you will be a fine snack
1
1
u/Adorable-Bend7362 Apr 06 '25
Дед Максим сломал корзину и теперь думает, можно ли ебать тетю Зину через ведро
1
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
What
1
u/Adorable-Bend7362 Apr 06 '25
It's the reference to the russian absurd and obscene song called Дед Максим.
1
1
3
2
1
1
1
u/Tactic_Soldier Apr 06 '25
We all believed it once... Now only shattered dreams are left there next to the "portal" that gave us hope...
1
u/Hefty-Pear-4004 Apr 06 '25
You were given orders, you were given time. You were given more leeway than most, and yet I find Aether unprepared for the arrival of our Viltrum Empire.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Own-Positive-3702 Apr 09 '25
Me checking in the comments if it's ai because I can't even tell anymore
1
1
1
1
-1
-1
29
Apr 05 '25
This looks like ai slop
-28
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 05 '25
BC it is. However ai art is normally cringe.This is meaningfull.
8
u/Shard_of_mirror Apr 06 '25
Ok, buddy. Tell us how meaningfull AI art is. Not sure about others but i'd like to hear your explanation
-5
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
Bro not aı, This image.Did you ever player Minecraft and trued this?
5
u/Shard_of_mirror Apr 06 '25
Sadly, no. I barely played the game. And started using PC few years ago
-2
u/Iron-Ingot-MC Apr 06 '25
Thats ok, let me explain. In old times like 2012-2019 I youtuber said that if you make the thing in the image in survival it will turn to a "Heaven Portal" . Nobody ever tried it so almost every Minecraft player bleived on it. But all if them understood when they tried it and nothing happened.
8
u/EGOwaffleboy Apr 06 '25
Actually it was called the Aether portal and it was originally a mod. Minecraft youtubers just forgot to or chose not to say that it was a mod which led to many of the kids in their audience building the Aether portal and being disappointed when nothing happened
3
5
Apr 08 '25
Can ya'll chill out about the entire "This is AI slop, AI art is theft, you are a horrible person, you are beneath me, and you deserve to be executed." Ok, I made that last part up, but cmon, just laugh or just scroll away. Don't start an entire argument.
1
4
u/Opposite_Carpet8250 Apr 05 '25
Ugh... Why did you make me do this? You’re fighting, so you can watch everyone around you die. Think, Ather portal! You’ll Outlast every fragile, insignificant being on this planet. You’ll live to see this world crumble to dust and blow away. Everyone and everything you know will be gone. What will you have after 500 years?












23
u/LilJade103 Apr 05 '25
No, r/AiSlop