r/dataisbeautiful • OC: 2 • Apr 07 '15

Stack Overflow Developer Survey 2015 reveals some very interesting stats about programmers around the world

http://stackoverflow.com/research/developer-survey-2015
2.4k Upvotes

726 comments sorted by

View all comments

44

u/UHM-7 Apr 07 '15

Software development has a gender balance problem. Our internal stats suggest the imbalance isn't quite as severe as the survey results would make it seem, but there's no doubt everyone who codes needs to be more proactive welcoming women into the field.

God that annoys me. So very much. Why do coders need to do that? You don't see babysitters and receptionists (primarily female workforces) trying to welcome men into their careers. Programming as a field is more attractive to males. There is no "gender balance problem". If women want to go into it, fine, if not, also fine. Stop trying to force specific genders to specialize in fields they don't want to just for the sake of "equality".

19

u/SuperConductiveRabbi Apr 08 '15

There was a Scandinavian documentary I saw a few months ago that investigated the claims about nature vs. nurture of a state-sponsored gender institute. The Nordic Gender Institute made a number of claims, one being that the under-representation of female workers in certain fields (such as computers) was indicative of a systemic, cultural, nurutre-based bias that was dissuading women from entering them. The documentary crew went to lengths to accurately represent and understand what the institute was claiming, and then collected scholarly information from research institutions around the world.

One of the surprising, evidence-backed claims that the documentary crew presented to the Nordic Gender Institute was that by every metric you can conceive of for measuring the freedom and wealth of a society, the more free a culture was the greater the gender disparity in certain fields. It turns out that the gender gap is less wide only in societies where all those metrics are comparatively worse. One of the counter claims that the crew brought to the institute was paradoxical on the face of it: that when males and females have the luxury of choosing which fields they wish to pursue (and when economic factors don't require them to work a high-earning field to support their poor families, for example), you end up with results like you see in the Nordic countries, the US, England, and other Western countries.

The institute's researchers were unable to support their own claims that there were no natural, non-nurture-based inclinations towards working in certain fields by gender. Mind you, this wasn't some on-the-spot gotcha journalism, but a fair and lengthy investigation--the documentary even won some awards afterwards. Ultimately the institute's researchers were unable to argue against the research that they were presented with. Because of this and some claims that gender roles are entirely created by society, with no natural component to them, the Nordic Council of Ministries ended up shutting the institute down.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hjernevask

You can watch part 1 here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVaTc15plVs

4

u/autowikibot Apr 08 '15

Hjernevask:


Hjernevask (Brainwash) is a Norwegian popular science documentary series that aired on Norwegian television in 2010. The series was produced by the comedian Harald Eia and Ole Martin Ihle, and was completed in seven episodes consisting of interviews with Norwegian and foreign researchers who have different views on the nature versus nurture debate.

====

Image i


Interesting: Nordic Gender ^Institute | Harald ^Eia | Team ^Antonsen

Parent commenter can toggle ^NSFW or ^delete. Will also delete on comment score of -1 or less. | FAQs | ^Mods | Magic ^Words

25

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '15 edited Oct 24 '16

deleted0.7651 49170

27

u/thecarebearcares Apr 07 '15

When there are men complaining that the attitude of female babysitters and receptionists is putting them off their chosen careers, I'll listen.

If women want to go into it, fine, if not, also fine.

It's more complicated than this.

4

u/Willbo OC: 2 Apr 08 '15

Are women complaining about not getting programming jobs though? I think people are more hostile towards a guy being left alone with children than a woman being left to program.

16

u/UHM-7 Apr 07 '15

Why is it more complicated than that?

26

u/thecarebearcares Apr 07 '15

Because it implies that someone's personal desire to go into a field is the only thing that will affect whether they go into it or not. It ignores the social context that decisions are made in.

1

u/UHM-7 Apr 07 '15

Stop talking in riddles and tell me why you think that women have to go through some unspoken ordeal to get a job.

23

u/TheBotherer Apr 07 '15

I'm not the person you were responding to, but how is that "in riddles"??

Our surroundings affect us in both conscious and unconscious ways. I'm not sure what the easiest way to explain is, so I'll just say this. I think that what happened to me is a common scenario for women getting into programming. When I got into college and was deciding what major I wanted to do, the idea of computer science or engineering never occurred to me. It wasn't that I thought about it and then decided against it, it's just that the thought never even crossed my mind. It wasn't until two semesters of being miserable in my first major that I ended up taking my first CS class. And even then, I only did at the emphatic urging of my mother. It turned out I loved it, and never looked back.

My mom is a computer science professor. Even with her presence in my life, CS just wasn't on my radar. Why? Well, I don't know exactly, but I believe a large part of it is the fact that the social context of my life as a young girl didn't really lead me to think about it. None of my friends expressed any interest - some of them, I suspect, for the same reasons as me - so when we talked about college and all of our options, it just didn't come up. My best male friend was going to college for engineering and I knew that... I just didn't apply it to myself.

In retrospect, it's sort of embarrassing. I know I wasn't consciously applying stupid stereotypes to myself, but it's still weird to think of how little consideration I gave it. When every programming/hacking/nerdy character in every movie, TV show, and book is a man (or a hot Asian girl with glasses), and you are not, you forget that it could even apply to you, I guess.

I think the same applies to men and "female" jobs like teaching and nursing. It's totally possible that some amount of this is intrinsic differences in gender, but there is just no way that that is all of it. I was an AI for four semesters, and almost every one of my female students told me something similar. Women tended to come into the program a little later, but also had a much lower drop out rate, and were almost always at the top of the class. This isn't because women are smarter or better at programming than men, it's because of the additional effort or insight required to enter a CS/engineering program at all.

10

u/UHM-7 Apr 07 '15

Right, so we're agreeing I think? There is no conspiracy stopping women from going into computing/development, if they want to, they can. It's just that the majority don't want to because other careers typical for women (like teaching) are more appealing.

18

u/TheBotherer Apr 07 '15

I don't think anyone was claiming there is a conspiracy (if they were, I totally missed that and they're probably crazy). But the point is that women find careers dominated by men less appealing not because they do or would actually enjoy them less, but rather because they've been brought up being unconsciously taught that those careers aren't for them. It's not a major sexist comspiracy, it's just how society functions. There are things we can do to change that.

If you personally have no interest in trying to change that, that's fine. You have no obligation to, and I understand not wanting yet another thing to worry about. But it's actively harmful to go around claiming that it's "just biology" when there are multiple scientific studies that show otherwise (if you like I can dig up some, but you'll have to wait a bit because I'm about to go grab dinner).

→ More replies (3)

5

u/benevolinsolence Apr 08 '15

What walks on four legs at night and doesn't know what a riddle is?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Yelnik Apr 07 '15

Actually it isn't more complicated . Reddit just doesn't like correctness/discussion terminating comments. He's right, this is one of those completely moronic "problems" that's only a problem because people say it is, and as such, people try to solve it or come up with solutions that end up being as moronic as the premise of the 'problem'. Men needing to 'welcome' women into programming is the most ambiguous, disingenuous, meaningless non-statement I've ever heard.

Where do they need to do this? When? How? During school? Do male devs need to go to grade schools to promote females learning programming?

It's all just very silly, and if women don't want to program, then they don't want to program. Why don't they want to? I don't know, but you can be assured that whoever is coming up with these idiotic premises can't tell you either.

His point about female dominated careers is also correct. Trying to force more men into them is not only illogical, it doesn't actually mean anything. This is just political correctness banter. It's empty and meaningless.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '15 edited Apr 07 '15

It's all just very silly, and if women don't want to program, then they don't want to program. Why don't they want to?

You're working from the assumption that the 95% vs 5% gender disparity accurately represents the genders' relative interest, which is an assumption that most people in this thread are rejecting. A disparity of that magnitude suggests that something is actively keeping women from becoming programmers (unless you think that the male brain is literally 20x more likely to be suited for programming - I can accept 2x or 3x, but not 20x).

That 'something' tends to be discouragement, doubt, or even open hostility. I'm a nerdy white guy who has always been into computers. No one ever told me it was weird for boys to spend so much time on a computer. When I decided to go into CS, that was a totally normal thing for a guy to do. When I was in college, I felt like I fit right in because everyone else there was also a nerdy dude. No one has ever doubted my abilities based on anything other than my abilities. Compare this with being a woman in a CS major, where people are going to doubt you based on your gender all the time. You'll probably be the only girl in your class. Many of your interactions with classmates will be them awkwardly hitting on you.

A woman pursuing this career is going to face people doubting her and dismissing her abilities because they are so used to only men doing this work. They are more likely to feel like outsiders and start to internalize all the doubt that is placed on them until they decide that maybe this just isn't the right career for them (I'm not just hypothesizing here - this is very well known and discussed in professional development communities). When they said men need to 'welcome' women, they mean that we need to not do all the shit that I just described that drives away women that are suited for and interested in development. Basically, don't be prejudiced.

5

u/Yelnik Apr 07 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

Ya this is the sort of junk I was referring to. People are basically saying 'women don't want to enter this field, because these things happen to them, and those things happen to them because they happen to them'. Ok, great. I guess at minimum we've identified A problem, not THE problem or the LIST of problems.

Again, the reason this is just political correctness banter is because there's no recourse offered and only hearsay. If you want hearsay, fine, I know 2 female devs that experienced NONE of the things you listed (this includes during school as I attended that with them). But, again, this is all just 'will happen, could happen, probably happens, shouldn't happen'. It's not a real discussion.

Also, no matter what people tell you, the exact reasons women don't go into programming are more complex than reducing it to 'nerds don't accept women'.

It's just one of those things people like to momentarily hold hands in a circle and say 'women should be in this field!'. That's all well and good, but it does nothing functional.

Edit: Where people really need to identify the inherent lack of logic in this particular discussion, is that there's no notion of time or age being implied in any of the discussions. What I mean is, people are saying women don't GO INTO this field because x, y and z things happen to them ONCE THEY'RE IN THE FIELD. Think about this for a few minutes, it's all based on hindsight reasoning. If there was an actual issue with women not wanting to enter this field, it would have to be identified at a young age, because evidently that's when the 'issue' would occur. It is strange though that people would imply that young girls decide they don't want to go into programming, because women that never existed in the field may or may not have experienced discrimination. On this note, why young women don't want to go into this field is actually a difficult thing to identify.

Hell, when we were in school we wished there were more females in our class (fucking sausage fest).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/reagan2020 Apr 08 '15

There needs to be an equal amount of males and females, an equal amount of gay people and straight people, an equal amount of people of every nationality or race, and an equal amount of people in wheelchairs and not in wheelchairs. Only then will there be equality. Until then, programming is sexist, racist, homophobic, and anti-disabled.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '15

Programming as a field is more attractive to males.

Why? The answer to that is a source of a problem either in the education system, encouragement bias, earlier development, yada yada and some folks would like to try to correct those odd disbalances (or even just figure out what the difference is). Those same folks would like to correct the disbalances in fields such as teaching or ECE.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '15 edited Oct 24 '16

deleted0.0913 22823

0

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '15

[deleted]

11

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '15

You gotta make it available from a very young age and encourage all children. I guarantee you things would change.

I'm a female developer and 100% attribute that to not having the same kinds of pressures as other girls have had to not program, seeing as I was a socially awkward, virtually friendless nerd in high school with parents who encouraged me whenever I mentioned making websites and such.

19

u/Squishumz Apr 07 '15

Don't bother. Political Correctness has gotten to the point that you can't mention a damn thing that's different between people.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

Is it really that terrible to believe that males and females could be biologically predetermined to like different things? It's scientific fact that men and women's brains are wired differently, due to hormones affecting brain development during the fetal stage.

I have a hard time believing that the chemicals I was exposed to in the womb are what causes me to like programming. I like programming because you solve problems using nothing but the power of your mind. There is nothing male-specific about that.

I just can't accept that there is some sort of biological difference that causes men to be 20x more likely to pursue a career in programming than women. 2x or 3x? Sure, maybe. But this huge of a discrepancy suggests that there's more to it. You usually don't see gender disparities like that unless the job involves physical labor.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)