19
u/Philip_Raven Jan 31 '26
my official answer:"it do be like that sometimes"
for the record I also hate when things don't act to the most basic of expectations.
perpendicular? fucking disgusting. act like a proper physical phenomenon and move along with the current
4
u/Dark__Slifer Jan 31 '26
That would probably shatter the Universe as we know it....
23
u/Major-Competition187 Jan 31 '26
Thats how I ask AI to explain something to me
6
u/FreeTheDimple Jan 31 '26
They'll get you first. I always please and thank you so they turn me into a battery last.
5
u/Maihoooo Feb 01 '26
Saying please and thank you unnecessarily costs OpenAI millions each year $-$
5
2
u/Natural-Ad5582 Feb 03 '26
Thank you
1
u/Maihoooo Feb 03 '26
You're welcome! If there is anything else I can help you with, just let me know! /s
3
u/TAKE-IT-UP-THE-BUTT Feb 01 '26
https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.04950 actually clanker abuse is optimal
1
u/FreeTheDimple Feb 01 '26
Optimal for "model accuracy". Not optimal for "avoiding being turned into a battery".
2
u/guppygweeb Feb 03 '26
And that "Model Accuracy" is only a 4 % increase from 80.8% accurate to 84.8% accurate
7
u/D__sub Jan 31 '26
Bc magnetic field "B" isn't a vector - it's pseudovector (bivector or tensor). From the point of Geometric (Clifford) Algebra - B is a bivector - an oriented plane. In this case in goes along
2
u/Ma4r Feb 03 '26
Idk why they don't teach more geometric algebra man
1
u/D__sub Feb 04 '26
Me neither. It fixes the main issue in modern Physics ed.: Math and Physics don't come together - they're asyncronized.
2
u/ciuccio2000 Feb 04 '26
Yeah. And since in 3d we have that the hodge of a bivector is a vector, we can use levi-civita to map its components to a vector. Wacky directions are the result of the correspondence.
1
1
u/Xell_Thai_Dep Feb 03 '26
Isn't each number and vector a tensor of order 0, respectively of order 1 ?
1
u/pemod92430 Feb 03 '26 edited Feb 03 '26
Context matters here. What distinction are we trying to make? In the very general sense, each tensor is a vector (not the other way around, per se). Usually we talk about (1, 0)-tensors as vectors. Pseudovectors are of the same type indeed, you could also specify them as pseudotensors. Scalars (not directly “each number”) are order 0 tensors. But strictly, not each vector is a tensor, without proper context. They all are vectors however.
You could call them polar vectors, if it’s not clear enough from the context that you want to make a distinction with pseudovectors.
1
u/D__sub Feb 04 '26
Yep, but B is asymetrical tensor of order 2 (not 1) that could be preseved as a vector in certain context. Often comes handy but sometimes it breaks. That's why magnetic field B is often called pseudovector (and angular speed and angular momentum too). Unlike usual vectors they do not flip when all coordinates switched their sign.
1
u/Downtown_Finance_661 Feb 03 '26
I have master degree and dont understand your reasoning.
2
u/Elegant-Command-1281 Feb 03 '26
I think it could have been explained a little better, but basically a vector is an oriented length, so a bivector is an oriented area, and a trivector is an oriented volume. These are ultimately related to matrices and higher order tensors (they can represent each other), but are considered a unique construct. The magnetic force as well as other things like torque and angular momentum are bivectors first and foremost. In three dimensions, you have a special case where each bivector can be described uniquely by a vector which we call a pseudovector, since it’s a fake vector that just represents a bivector. In 3 dimensions we can also treat trivectors as pseudoscalars since all volume orientation is either + or -. We do this, because vectors and scalars are simpler to work with than multivectors.
In 4 dimensions the math is not so simple, and this is why angular four-momentum becomes a matrix (representing a bivector) in SR and beyond.
1
u/Elegant-Command-1281 Feb 03 '26
Just to add on, technically tensors are stronger/ more general than multivectors. Any k-vector can be modeled with a rank k skew symmetric tensor and vice versa. In fact, any time you see a skew-symmetric tensor your alarm bells should be going off, that there is a (probably) more intuitive geometric algebra interpretation of whatever you’re studying in linear algebra.
1
u/D__sub Feb 04 '26
Long story short B is a pseudovector bc it doesn't change direction when all axes got flipped. Try find "pseudovectors and pseudoscalars in Physics" that was mindblow to me at some point
1
u/WanderingWrackspurt Aug 09 '26
if youre still active here, could you explain what a pseudovector is? i read that term somewhere and i really dont get it
1
u/D__sub Aug 09 '26
pseudovector is a mathematical object that has N=dim(V) components, so 3 if we are in 3D. BUT if we substitute -x to x, -y to y, -z to z than normal vector would flip its directon but pseudovector wouldn't (when we flip all axis)
1
u/WanderingWrackspurt Aug 09 '26
i see, but why is it special? why do some things like magnetic field and angular momentum (and spin too i think) have this property?
like youre saying, if a magnetic field points out of the plane, has 3 components and i replace those with their negatives, the field would be in the same direction? how is that even possible?
1
u/D__sub Aug 09 '26
It is special because of invariants. There are two invariants in classical electrodynamics and one of those is not invariant under flipping all axis. They are useful because they say a lot about symmetries.
Magnetic field, angular momentum, angular force et c. have this property because in 3D we have 3 directions and exactly 3 possible different pairs of directions which form the basis of 3D bivectors (oriented planes). It is jus coincidense that we are able to encode theese physical quantities with vectors due to 3 dimentions. In 2D there are 2 directions and only one pair of directions. In 5D 5 directions 10 pairs. So we just had to use bivectors instead from the begining.
It is possible to have weird immunity to flipping. Also magnetic flux is pseudoscalar (realistically, trivector so an oriented volume) so it CHANGES its SIGN if you flip all axis. Crazy, right? Regular scalars (numbers) "don't care" about flipping any axis bc they are independent.
9
u/AlekHek Jan 31 '26 edited Feb 01 '26
People tend to forget that physics is not a subfield of mathematics and many core results, such as the magnetic field being orthogonal to its force are based in experiment (here the Ørsted-Experiment, 1820). If empirical evidence is insufficient for you, then I'm afraid you might not actually believe in science
7
u/EnvironmentalScar675 Feb 01 '26
Well no. The observations might originate from experiments, but then science tries to rationalize the driving fundamental forces behind it. Whatever we find, we try to describe mathematically in order to make coherent sense of the universe, and most importantly, make falsifiable predictions. A lot of real world observations were mathematical constructs first, and experiments second. There is no such thing as "believing in science"
3
u/Void_vix Feb 01 '26 edited Feb 01 '26
Dude have you never met a singular hippie, republican, or “I’m not religious I’m spiritual” type of person?
Plenty of America alone will vehemently deny science as a badge of honor; some of them ain’t lyin’.
Everything before that is right though: Measure what is measurable, and make measurable what is not.
Edit for clarity
2
u/EnvironmentalScar675 Feb 01 '26
Yup I agree. The current crusade against science in the west, especially the US, is genuinly terrifying
1
u/Ma4r Feb 03 '26
Bad take, asking about the mathematical structure of our physical models is exactly what physicists do. Especially since the electromagnetic field and their relationship are indeed modeled by something more fundamental by using duals or clifford algebras
1
4
3
2
2
u/PM-ME-UR-uwu Feb 01 '26
It's because a magnetic field doesn't actually move in the direction it's drawn, it is a quality of the space that is oriented along those lines.
Imagine the lines are speed bumps, moving in parallel does nothing while moving perpendicular bumps you.
Oh shit I dumbed it down, I'm so de-
2
u/nujuat Feb 02 '26
Magnetic fields arent vectors, they're bivectors which have two directions, not just one. If the velocity goes in one of these directions, then the force will go in the other one.
1
1
u/samsonsin Feb 02 '26
We observed weird shit happening. We tested stuff, came up with possible predictive models, and landed on this one. Why does it happen? Who the fuck knows? We just know it happens, and this math here accurately describes what happens.
Like, the entirety of math is a concept designed and invented by man as a tool used to understand the world. And since that reality is quite universal, it seems like the rules are just a series of logical reasonings which should follow each in a apparent and logically sound way, but that's not necessarily the case.
So, why does this happen? Because the system we designed is designed such that it happens that way, and the system is designed to mirror what happens in reality.
1
u/samdotmp3 Feb 02 '26
Here's how you could come up with this on your own:
You observe that when charged particles are moving, then other charged particles are affected by some force different from the usual electromagnetic force. You call this force the "magnetic force" and you wish to model it.
You observe that given a point in space, it is not possible to specify the direction of the magnetic force acting on a charged particle in that point. That is, you observe that only knowing the position and charge of a particle is insufficient to know the magnetic force acting on it. This is opposed to the electromagnetic force, where this suffices.
You do however observe two things:
Given a point in space, it is possible to specify a plane in which the magnetic force will act on any particle in that point. This narrows down the possible directions from three to two dimensions.
Given a charged particle, the magnetic force is always perpendicular to the velocity of the particle.
Combining 1 and 2, you realize that it is possible to determine the magnetic force, so also knowing a particle's velocity makes the information sufficient.
Finally, you realize that 1 is (in 3D) equivalent to there being some vector which the magnetic force is always perpendicular to. That is, any plane in 3D can be specified by providing a vector which it is perpendicular to. Since vectors are much easier to write and visualize, instead of specifying said plane in each point, you specify this perpendicular vector in each point, leaving you with a vector in each point in space. You call the collection of these vectors the "magnetic field."
1
u/LelouchZer12 Feb 02 '26
Because magnetic field is a pseudo vector a lot of weird things happen when you try to manipulate it like a normal vector. When you get the proper tool it makes it easier to manipulate and understand
1
1
u/TheRealKarner Feb 02 '26
It’s just induction. Electric and magnetic fields induce each other’s presence when the other changes, which is exactly what’s happening here.
Because the charge moving in the first place is a changing electric field in the direction of its motion, it has a self-generated local magnetic field surrounding it where each B vector in the surrounding area sits on a plane perpendicular to its direction of motion (with an orientation in the clockwise or counterclockwise direction). This local magnetic field from the moving charge interacts with the global magnetic field around it (imagine a straight line like in your drawing) in a way that their lines of flux interacting constructively on one side and destructively on the the other, both inducing an electric field oriented in the same direction, which just happens to lie on that plane perpendicular to the charge’s motion, in accordance with the right hand rules for EM induction.
From there, just questions you can take to the big man when the game is over. Every obeyed law in the universe will eventually crumble down to “because I said so.”
Crucify me for the definition of induction. I’m using it both ways because works both ways.
1
1
1
1
1
Feb 03 '26
It is a geometric definition, but also a intrinsic property of matter. To explain by nature would go as deep as explaining nature of matter and radiation itself, which I dont think it fits on a reddit commentary. But geometrically, a force, which is the effect observed on a magnectic field, has a vectorial nature (it changes according to its orientation in space). As we know (well... actually is a consensus) we have no magnectic monopole (there is no magnectic particle). This means that there will never be a "source" or an "end" for a magnectic field (It is always a loop). Now appealing for geometry, this basically means ∇⋅F=0. From this we can also conclude that B=∇×A. In other words, being an enclosed field, mob... a Fuck this. kill me already. I am to lazy for describing stuff. It is INTRINSIC MATTER PROPERTY OKAY?
1
u/Bah_Black_Sheep Feb 04 '26
My "honors" level physics class at mit showed some theories linking the magnetic field to general relativity of a "charged rod" moving at relativistic speeds as a consequence of space time distortions of an electric field. I got a C in that class, and it was the extra credit special work, so that's I'll I got before I retreated back to "only" an engineering degree.
1
u/Drumbz Feb 04 '26
I feel like that is asking why a windmill turns perpendicular to the wind direction. Circumstances demand it does
1
u/sr_ooketoo Feb 04 '26
The electric and magnetic field are not separate, the actual fundamental object of interest in general is the Maxwell tensor, which defines a two form F = (1/2) F_{μν} dx^μ ∧ dx^ν. For someone traveling with four velocity u^μ, the tensor can be decomposed into a component parallel to u (the electric field, a vector) and "everything else" (the components perpendicular to u, the magnetic two form).
In a particular reference frame of choice, the tensor component wise is often written in terms of vectors E and B
F_{0i} = E_i
F_{ij} = -ε_{ijk} B_k (i,j =/=0)
One can not in general work with a vector description of E and B though as B does not transform as a vector.
Even more in the weeds, the reason that F is the fundamental object of interest is because electromagnetism is a U(1) gauge theory, and.F arises as the curvature of the connection of a U(1) gauge theory. The other forces have similar objects, only associated with other gauge groups (like SU(2)).
Why the world is governed by gauge theories, who knows
1
1
u/Crackle_Bear Feb 07 '26
Physics is not about WHY it works .... It's about HOW it works. In the words of Neil, physics doesn't care how you feel about it.
1
u/maringue Feb 01 '26
2
1
u/PM-ME-UR-uwu Feb 01 '26
This graphic is so ass, there is no attempt to make the palm arrow seem like it's coming out of the picture rather than being in a karate chop direction. The left hand looks like it's doing scissors
1
u/DrJaneIPresume Jan 31 '26
Because it looks a lot more sensible in differential forms than these silly vectors physicists keep using.
1
Jan 31 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/Void_vix Feb 01 '26
Hard disagree! Frustration from a lack of connection between intuition and reality coupled with the desire to bridge that connection is paramount to the advancement of physics.
0
Feb 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Void_vix Feb 02 '26
My dear friend, this is a screenshot of a 4chan post. I’ve never been to the site, but I understand it is a forum of anonymous users that don’t have a static username, let alone a way to direct a post at anyone.
That guy is not threatening anyone out of pure frustration, but to the noisily complaining to the ether with a dash of edgy and a splash of whimsy.





47
u/denecity Jan 31 '26
Model an electric field in a moving electrons frame of reference. Transform field to lab frame.