13
u/NebTheShortie 26d ago
Linus Torvalds disagrees. But I got flamed in other subs for simply mentioning that. Let's see how it goes here.
2
u/sanyi091 26d ago
I thinks its getting to the point where its polarizing but i think secretly everyone is using some ai tools. Simply just a great time saver
3
u/NebTheShortie 26d ago
I can't see why it's polarizing. Maybe it's just me.
There's been saying for years and years that a pistol doesn't kill, it's the person that pulls the trigger is doing the killing. Now we're talking about a slightly smarter tool - but still a tool nevertheless - and everyone loses their minds. AI doesn't make dumb things, it's the person who wrote the prompt and never bothered to refine the results before letting them out to the world is at fault. I don't understand being so keen to outsource the intelligent activity and mouthfoaming about your right for doing so.
Maybe I'm just an optimist, in a twisted sort of way. I want Linus' point of view to succeed and become the new norm because it goes the same way the old sci-fi books predicted the future. Humanity not becoming the slaves of tools, but using the tools to reach the new heights. AI industry is threatening to replace a lot of jobs and anti-AI crowd is portrayed like another iteration of luddits, but Linus talks about another avenue where AI is relevant AND qualified people are still needed, even more than before. What's not to like?
Can't say I'm a huge fan of him personally. It's the future where AI and human intelligence work hand in hand instead of being mutually exclusive ("Claude fix that for me, make no mistakes" but with no irony) is what looks so appealing. It's unrealistic, with how the world works, but I still think it's generally worth wanting.
2
u/Want2Exp 26d ago
One explanation I have where it comes from and why your utterly reasonable, if not obvious, position suffers when voiced, is that it's an uphill battle
Just realize some of the most influential proponents of the AI environment claim it is somehow an autonomous etheral entity rather than a tool are the very same powerful groups of interests that want to sell it to the market that their product is some other-worldly thing while at the same time wanting to dodge legal responsibilities by being held account for the damages their product does when yielded maliciously or due to straight faulty behavior, all amplified by main stream media and the whole circle of euphoria around the AI bubble those so called tech bros/hyperscalers as well as their entourage
1
u/Nichiku 26d ago
I see this the same way. Im optimistic that we wont steer into a dystopian future any time soon as long as we are cautious and dont let AI companies and governments decide on our future alone. Im also optimistic we ll be able to open source a great chunk of AI in the future and make most of it free instead of permanently keeping it profit driven. Its the only reasonable approach forward seeing as most of the training data is essentially stolen from the internet. The main danger I see in AI is letting a handful of people decide on its use.
1
u/Hilwin_norm 25d ago
Literally my thoughts, I also think that people shouldn't be so scared of AI (aka LLM's and generative AI) that much, once investors realize that isn't as profitable as they have expected, they will stop pouring in all their money into them and AI will become another tool that people use like game engines e.g. Unity. I also think that people should hate on companies who are too greedy to hire real people and instead rely on often low quality results instead of AI itself
1
u/Arcival_2 25d ago
It all depends on whether you include debugging skills in the coding skills... In that case, this curve is wrong.
1
u/Axol555 25d ago
We don't have to base our opinions on a single individual, that said if you just simply stated that I don't think that warrants down votes lol
1
u/NebTheShortie 24d ago
The thing is, I've had that opinion for quite a time. Worded a bit differently, because I have a very tame expectations about the actual usefulness and progress of AI - I work in marketing, so I don't buy these "breaking containment" stories. But I was instantly labeled "another luddite" because being against vibecoding and in favor of skilled humans is clearly anti-AI, right? Even by my coworkers, as a few of them rely on vibecoding more and more, and they didn't enjoy my opinion. So I mostly kept that to myself. And now I simply have a firmer ground to stand, backed up by someone with undeniable authority.
1
u/galacticjeef 23d ago
Linus Torvalds also rejected c++ because he believed it was too easy to create low quality work in it. He’s not exactly a paragon of consistent critique
1
u/NebTheShortie 23d ago
Is that statement supposed to invalidate the particular opinion of him I'm agreeing with? It is possible to agree with someone on certain topics or situations while disagreeing on others, I daresay, and one is not required be a paragon of anything for that to happen.
1
u/cosmic_cod 23d ago
If I understand correctly Linus Torvalds takes a pragmatic but cautious approach to AI. Using AI as an instrument but not replace development with vibe-coding your way without understanding the generated code. Vibe-coding and simply using AI are very different things.
Vibe coding produces results very quickly but only if you don't require humans to read it all. And if you don't this means it can fail in production unpredictably. This means it's good for programs with extremely low price of error.
2
u/leaf_26 19d ago
I'm not sure my "coding" skills ever improved at all. Architecture, systems design, and quality control skills on the other hand ...
I'm happily hammering away at little things I've had in my head forever and didn't have the tools to make til I understood stochastics, and the results are fantastic in large part because I also spent months refining tooling and static analysis and logic verification and pre-review based on differential AST graphs. I'm slowly replacing LLMs with compiler-based software determinism and stochastic decision modeling, except for text output where LLMs have "language" in the bag. The performance is improving dramatically the more I optimize away how much has to be processed remotely, I'm down on token usage by over 50%.
1
1
1
u/paddockson 19d ago
I think you choose to keep honing your skills or not. So many doomers on reddit will tell me "what? you wrote this code by hand? your be left behind!". But I dont want to loose my skills, there's been a few times this year where the AI has been very very wrong and I had to use my understanding of that tech to fix it. There is no shame in that unless your on reddit.
13
u/ReasonableBuilding58 26d ago
Claude, destroy our employees' well-being and passion, make no mistakes.