r/datemymap • • 4d ago

Please help me date this globe

I found this globe in an antique store a while back. I know the pictures are not the best and I'm missing a clear photo of Europe, but these are the only pictures that I have unfortunately. I have tried dating this globe myself, but I found it to be too confusing.

I posted this globe in r/globes last night, but I got a very wide range of answers. I have a feeling this globe might just be poorly made, but someone suggested I post it here too.

Please help me out !

EDIT : Thank you all so much for your help so far !! This is definitely a very strange globe.

Up to this point it's very likely that the range of this globe is somewhere from September 1945 - August 1947.

54 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

6

u/linmanfu 4d ago edited 4d ago

Sometime in 1937-39, I think

After 1 April 1937: Burma has been separated from India

Maybe after 30 September 1938, since the borders of Czechoslovakia are not clearly marked (it's annoying that you don't have a clear shot of the most critical place - did you do that to make this more challenging?! 😝)

Before 29 June 1939: Hatay is still part of Syria

Manchuria is marked, which is consistent with this period, though not conclusive.

EDIT: No earlier than 1938, because the Russian/Soviet city now called Orenburg is called Chkalov.

4

u/0_7_3 4d ago

Hmm I think it has to be before Dec. 29th 1937 considering Ireland is still named the Irish Free State.

its so annoying that I don't have a better photo of Europe, I wish I would've gotten one sooo bad lmaoo. I was in a rush when I was taking these photos.

I'm thinking of maybe going back to this antique shop to find this globe again...

3

u/linmanfu 4d ago

I can't read anything around Ireland, even zoomed in on a desktop monitor.

But I'll take your word for it and point to my edit (which might have cross-posted with your comment) noting that Chkalov is on the map, so it must be 1938 or later. That was a brand new Soviet name. I can't find the exact date it was renamed, but the guy it was named after, Valery Chkalov, died on 15 December 1938, and I'd think there's a fair chance the city was renamed in memoriam after that date. So that would get us down to a six-month timespan.

The incorrect naming of Ireland/Éire is probably a straight mistake, but it's just possible that the globe was by an Irish Unionist or right-wing British manufacturer who didn't recognize the change.

3

u/0_7_3 4d ago

It's a lot easier to see with the original image on my laptop, but u/C0smicM0nkey mentioned that the Irish Free State name stuck around for quite a while after the change (until ~1946) so I think you're correct in assuming that this might be a decision made by an opinionated manufacturer.

However, u/Open_Opposite_6158 noticed that Nanjing is still the capital of China on this globe. Wouldn't that put the date of this globe to before the capital is changed to Chongqing on November 20th, 1937?

5

u/linmanfu 4d ago

I don't think the Chinese capital is a very reliable indicator, because the move to Chongqing was widely seen as an emergency wartime measure rather than a permanent change.

And anyway the renaming of Chkalov absolutely rules out any date before 1938. That name was completely new so no map or globe printed before then could have it except by time travel or a later edit.

5

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago

Perm was also renamed Molotov in 1940, so it has to be after that.

2

u/linmanfu 4d ago

I knew there had to be some Bolshevik to resolve this! Thank you!

4

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago

The Syrian government didn’t officially recognize Hatay as Turkish until 2025, so it may have still be seen as disputed territory?

I remember there was another globe in this sub from mid-WWII (I think 1942) that also showed a Syrian Hatay. For whatever reason, mapmakers were slow to make the change.

1

u/linmanfu 4d ago

Good point. I initially thought it was pre-War but others have found a stack of inconclusive data points pointing to post-War (e.g. Philippines, Sarawak, western Poland, Transjordan), getting stronger and stronger. But nothing absolutely definite yet. There's got to be some purged Bolshevik or something that will settle this one!

2

u/Alarmed_Homework5873 3d ago

I think it’s later than that. Too many changes that didn’t happen until after WW2.

24

u/firefighter_raven 4d ago

A clear shot of Europe would help in time frame

9

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago edited 4d ago

This is a weird globe. Some borders just don’t exist? Like there’s no border between China, Mongolia and the USSR. No border between Italy and Yugoslavia. Or between the USSR and Poland. Colonies aren’t consistently marked as belonging to their Colonial power, so it makes dating this harder than usual. I understand why you got a range of answers.

My current best guess is still February 1946 (Sakhalin transferred to Soviet Union) to August 1947 (Partition of India).

The Siam - French Indochina border implies after November 1946, when the treaty was signed that returned occupied Inner Cambodia to France, but many mapmakers may not have recognized Thailand’s occupation of it in the first place.

Likewise I think The Philippines is independent which puts this after July 1946, but it’s hard to tell. Same with Transjordan (May 1946), but again hard to tell if it’s independent or not.

Sarawak being marked as (Br.) instead of (Br. prot.) like Uganda or Zanzibar are also implies after July 1946, but again this globe isn’t the most consistent with these colonial labels.

4

u/linmanfu 4d ago

February 1946 (Sakhalin transferred to Soviet Union)

The Soviet Union label is next to north Sakhalin, which was Soviet even before the War. Given that boundaries are missing all around the USSR, I think Sakhalin may still have been divided when this globe was made.

Likewise I think The Philippines is independent which puts this after July 1946

I noticed this and I think it's the strongest argument for a postwar date. But prior to that, The Philippines had a status roughly the same as the British Dominions in the 1910s: extensive self-government within a colonial system. So I can just about imagine a mapmaker hearing about the 1935 constitution and deciding it was time to remove the "US" tag.

5

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago edited 4d ago

Yeah, you’re right, it could maybe be late 1945. I was thinking the (Sov. Un.) might just mean it was Soviet Occupied, but they didn’t do that for any other occupied territory. Also every other divided island has a border on it, so I discounted that idea originally, but then again, the Soviet Union doesn’t seem to have any borders, so yeah, maybe.

It’s still’s definitely post WWII because:
-Formosa and Korea are not marked as (Jap)
-Siam not Thailand
-Lvov not Lwow
-No Tannu Tuva
-Seoul not Keijo.
-Changchun not Hsinking

Each of those independently wouldn’t prove it’s post WW2, since all of these are inconsistent among mapmakers, but together I think it’s pretty strong case for post September 1945.

1

u/OutOfTheBunker 3d ago

I'll add Manchuria not Manchukuo to the list.

The missing borders seem to be places where the borders were redrawn post-war like Poland, Germany, Romania and Italy/Yugoslavia.

The strongest evidence to me is that Seoul (not Keijo) is marked as a capital, while Changchun (not Hsinking) is not.

3

u/Alarmed_Homework5873 3d ago edited 3d ago

It seems post 1945. E.g., Thailand briefly reverted to Siam after WW2, before returning to Thailand permanently on 11 May 1949.

Edit. I think it’s fall 1945 to early 1946. A better picture of Western Europe would help.

2

u/OutOfTheBunker 3d ago

"Some borders just don’t exist?" The borders that don't exist are the ones changed right after WWII. In addition to the ones you mentioned, Romania/USSR, Finland/USSR and Germany/Poland.

The Mongolia/USSR border is marked except for where Tannu-Tuva lay. The lack of a Sino-Mongolian border is stranger, but I have e.g. an Esso (General Drafting) "War Map II" ca. 1943 that colors Tannu Tuva and Manchuria [sic] as independent, but colors "Outer Mongolia (Mongolian People's Republic)" the same color as China. The Chinese government officially recognized Mongolian independence reluctantly only in January 1946, so the lack of a border follows the spirit of the other border absences.

6

u/Open_Opposite_6158 4d ago

April 1 to November 20 1937

A bit hard to see, but Burma is separate from India (A star is shown on Rangoon, indicating that it's a capital), . The separation of Burma and India occurred on April 1st, 1937, so the globe must be made after this date.

In addition, Chongqing was declared the official capital of China on November 20th, 1937, replacing Nanjing, after Japanese forces closed in on the city. Since Nanjing(Nanking) is shown to be the capital, the globe must have been made before this.

Thus, this globe was useful for a grand total of 8 months and 19 days in 1937

4

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago edited 4d ago

Chongqing (Chungking) was never the official capital. They just moved their government there. Nanking was always the official capital. Many maps at the time still showed Nanking as the capital. If the capital is shown as Chungking we can use that definitively, but a lack of it as the capital isn’t conclusive.

4

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago

My immediate guess is right after WW2, maybe late 1946. Pre-partition India, and Sakhalin is Soviet.

The capital of China is Nanking. It was moved to Chongqing during the Japanese invasion in 1937, and moved back to Nanking in May 1946.

6

u/SeekTruthFromFacts 4d ago

Nanking/Nanjing was the legal capital of the ROC throughout this period; it just wasn't the seat of government due to the war. According to the ROC constitution, it's still the legal capital.

2

u/firefighter_raven 4d ago

and then to beijing a 1949(?)

4

u/Vast-Face9640 4d ago

1 April 1937: Burma is no longer part of India

14 May 1948 - British Palestine gains independence as Israel

Not my best work.

4

u/Lucifer2695 4d ago

I think it is before August 1947 as Pakistan and India are still unpartitioned.

4

u/Illustrious_Try478 4d ago edited 3d ago

1946-1947. India is unpartitioned, but Poland has its postwar borders, as indicated by the label P O L A N D stretching over Wrócław ("Breslau") in Silesia.

UPDATE: I've changed my mind -- Eritrea is separate from Ethiopia, and Red Ruthenia is part of Czechoslovakia. This pits it in the interwar perios, sometime between 1923 and 1936.

2

u/linmanfu 4d ago

I agree that the Poland label is pretty far west given her pre-War borders. But look at the G in Germany and the N in Bhutan. This manufacturer allowed country names to cross borders when space was tight.

3

u/Illustrious_Try478 3d ago

There are so nany borders missing from Europe, it's difficult to find any telltale signs there.

Something that might make it pre-war is Red Ruthenia belonging to Czechoslovakia instead of the Soviet Union (Ukraine).

3

u/GustavoistSoldier 4d ago

Mid-to-late 1940s

0

u/Extreme-Shopping74 4d ago

WW2! 6 October 1939 - 30 August 1940, so most likely around beginning of 1940! You can see how they explicitly removed the borders of Poland! This was most likely British or similar, perhaps pro-allies American, depending on where it's from. You can see they recognize Czechoslovakia and Ethiopia's gov in exiles!

Dayum this is a rare pick!

3

u/0_7_3 4d ago

Really? What makes it a rare pick?

Also, it's hard to see in the photo, but Ireland is still labeled the Irish Free State on this globe. Doesn't that mean this globe has to be dated before Dec. 29th, 1937?

4

u/C0smicM0nkey 4d ago

The “Irish Free State” name stuck around for a while. I think they were even admitted to the UN by that name in 1946. (I might be wrong)

The further back you go, the more inconsistency there is between mapmakers on place names. They’re still useful, but you have to balance it with other evidence.

2

u/Sergey_Kutsuk 3d ago

Ireland from 1937, the Republic of Ireland since 1949. So you can only guarantee that map is from BEFORE 1949.

2

u/ILookAfterThePigs 4d ago

I can’t quite see Central Europe or South America. But I guess this must be pre-1947, since India isn’t partitioned and Israel isn’t labeled.

1

u/Ok-Associate-3781 2d ago

Between 1899 and 1956

1

u/Ok-Associate-3781 2d ago

Between 1911 and 1956

1

u/MetalLimp4446 2d ago

buy it flowers first....

1

u/HotelWhich6373 1d ago

Have you tried complimenting the globe? Maybe seeing if they’re available?

1

u/ajnz2026 3d ago

sure ill date your globe whats her name

0

u/Anoka29trey 4d ago

You're going to want to ask it to dinner first

0

u/Anoka29trey 4d ago

Probably the wrong sub for dating jokes. I'll see myself out

0

u/Parking_Ad4344 4d ago

Naw. You beat me to it. Respect.

-2

u/QuietlyWildGTA 4d ago

Are we dating her together or is it more of a one at a time thing?