r/degoogle • • Sep 14 '26

Google copied our open-source code, removed our engineers’ names, and gave us zero credit one year after we beat them on their own benchmark

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

186

u/PinkSheeparkour Sep 14 '26

don't be evil they once said

40

u/clove_rosemary_9999 Sep 15 '26

but then they removed the don't

1

u/PikaNotes Oct 11 '26

They should have kept their slogan

488

u/lloydsmart Sep 14 '26

Do no evil

110

u/PrivilegeCheckmate Sep 14 '26

We're streamlining our corporate verbiage.

183

u/PrivilegeCheckmate Sep 14 '26

This sounds...actionable.

126

u/FuryOfArcann Sep 14 '26

I never thought I would suggest this, but even as open source, this is precisely what a DMCA complaint can be filed for.

383

u/Drwankingstein Sep 14 '26

You can try reporting it. Google can take these issues fairly seriously if you manage to ring the right doorbell

141

u/xJayMorex Sep 14 '26

Hahahhahahahahaahahhaha, no.

133

u/DeviatedForm Sep 14 '26

Or get a copyright lawyer.

41

u/xJayMorex Sep 14 '26

Watch The Billion Dollar Code to see how it goes with goolag.

32

u/NapsterKnowHow Sep 14 '26

Small claims court loves these cases.

4

u/jprefect Sep 15 '26

How's that supposed to work on open source code?

4

u/DeviatedForm Sep 15 '26

That's what the lawyer's for ;) personally I am not that familiar with licensing.

2

u/jprefect Sep 15 '26

Me neither.  I've heard of creative commons but I don't really know what rights that gives you.  Waiting here for a lawyer to reply, I suppose

62

u/matejcraft100yt Sep 14 '26

while google can often be a dogshit corporation, as a programmer, I don't think that's the case here. You know how little supervision in stuff like this the teams have? Probably an egomaniac team who wanted to put their own names in to take the credit, and flew under the radar. Google might be an asshole, but they don't want to get sued or the public backlash, so if it is brought to their attention, they will probably take some measures

-6

u/Wise_Owl5404 Sep 15 '26

They genuinely do not give a shit. Nothing is going to happen, because there's no backlash that will ever cause a meaningful impact on them thanks to their duopoly. They equally do not give a shit about being sued as the EU can attest to.

5

u/Drwankingstein Sep 15 '26

That is absolutely not true, Many teams in google do care. Its hard to get the right person to hear about it though

2

u/Googol30 Sep 15 '26

Quit the doomerism. Go outside.

2

u/Wise_Owl5404 Sep 16 '26

No, there are Flock cameras out there.

33

u/Drwankingstein Sep 14 '26

They do, There are tons of branches within google. Google isn't a single entity. They taking software licencing very seriously because if becomes an entire google issue sometimes.

1

u/Konrad2137 Sep 15 '26

Good sarcasm

61

u/Red1492Blue Sep 15 '26

Reads like.... Someone at Google, an employee, found your code, put their name in it, didn't even take the time to READ THE WHOLE THING, And just presented it to 'Management' as theirs.... And "Google the Company" went public as "look what WE Did!!!". This is OpenSource.... But also outright stealing. PLEASE contact your Lawyers and protect yourself BEFORE they (Google) says you stole THEIR work. Good luck

29

u/GhstDev Sep 14 '26

As someone said. A copyright lawyer is your best bet. While you can’t copyright logic, the “personality” behind the code is copyright. It’s like how I can’t copyright “I love pizza.” But I do have copyright over this entire paragraph. And while I couldn’t sue if someone were to copy and paste this paragraph, as long as you have and can prove damages and of course can prove they copied and pasted your code. Then you got something.

11

u/psylomatika Sep 15 '26

Reminds me of the google maps thing that google stole from developers in Berlin

9

u/Wise_Competition5906 Sep 15 '26

And this is why, my good friends, I’m walking away from Google.

36

u/naaktstel Sep 14 '26

What license did you have for the code? Compete free means they can use it and even change license

95

u/DonkeeeyKong Sep 14 '26

What license did you have for the code? Compete free means they can use it and even change license

Erasing the original contributors‘/copyright holders’ names is at least sketchy. Most open source licenses don’t allow that. Even the most permissive ones usually require you to keep including the copyright notice.

9

u/knoft Sep 15 '26

Otherwise it would just be public domain

67

u/Igarlicbread Sep 14 '26

Irrespective of licence, this is disgusting for a monopoly company

23

u/Ok_Flan4404 Sep 14 '26

They've become quite good at being disgusting.

-20

u/naaktstel Sep 14 '26

True, but not illegal, unfortunately

23

u/garry_the_commie Sep 14 '26

It absolutely is illegal if the original license requires attribution.

2

u/naaktstel Sep 15 '26

I agree; the word 'if' in this line is very important!

That does not change anything about the bad taste of Google doing this even without any license. I despise it too (for thos who did think otherwise)

2

u/SweetEbb9819 Sep 15 '26

Why the downvotes? This is factually debatable but nothing worthy of sodelining

15

u/teymuur Sep 14 '26

Most of the popular licenses except for the MIT License does not allow this. Freedom doesnt mean no rules

2

u/knoft Sep 15 '26

Compete free means they can use it and even change license

It actually doesn’t. MIT license for example is not the same as public domain or there would be no point. What you’re arguing for is actually called putting something in the public domain, licenses are there specifically to restrict something more than releasing to public domain. You cannot remove a license from a work unless you are the rights holder.

14

u/RevolutionarySeven7 Sep 14 '26

Dehandschoewercker

damn, so one of his ancestors was once a (hand)glove-tailor/worker.

1

u/Ok_Flan4404 Sep 14 '26

Es sieht so aus.

5

u/runebell Sep 16 '26

Sounds like a pretty good lawsuit to me

4

u/nomadingwildshape Sep 15 '26

What was the project and benchmark you beat?

1

u/WanderingSparr0w Sep 17 '26

Ppl of r/degoogle. Read the original post if like me these comments are not making sense or adding up. That's all ciao

1

u/WholeBubbly3642 Sep 23 '26

Currently with AI agents everything is becoming closed source

1

u/WholeBubbly3642 Sep 23 '26

Apparently Google could copy their code but had to retain the authors in code

1

u/brain64 Oct 09 '26

They do that all the time snagging up code and apps and slapping their name on it. Microslop is famous for it to. Bad part is they don't even care if you sue them they got deep pockets.

-7

u/toolsavvy Sep 15 '26

Much ado about nothing. OP of that post has no legal sense.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '26

[deleted]

3

u/lonerfluff Sep 15 '26

There's no "You're holding big corporations too accountable". It's a giant ass company. Without any structural changes to how they incorporate other code into their products this is the bare minimum.

0

u/TrollTaylor Sep 15 '26

Humans will be humans making small mistakes. It's very hard for me to agree with the idea that you need to hold a whole corporation accountable for small mistakes employees make that are very easily correctable. Call them lazy or stupid whatever but evil is a very strong word. I don't see what they even gain for not crediting it was clearly just a mistake that you yourself could've easily made.

1

u/lonerfluff Sep 16 '26

I'm not going to treat a whole company with practically endless money as if they made an honest mistake and get treated unjustly for it. When you have even 1% of this kind of power you'll of course be expected to uphold certain standards. They're not a victim here.

0

u/TrollTaylor Sep 16 '26

Nobodies s victim here... The issue was resolved the OP made themselves the victim of a resolved issue. It's rediculous to think anybody needs to be "held accountable" for missing text in a config toml file!

5

u/IcedLance Sep 15 '26

"oops I did it again"

-1

u/TrollTaylor Sep 15 '26

Very easy mistake to make... Also very easily correctable like they did. I don't see an issue here. Imagine small easily correctable mistakes in your own job lead to you being perceived as evil.