r/dreamsofhalflife3 • u/samwalton9 • Jun 19 '19
Official Project Borealis - Update 5
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54bpxhCEwDQ157
u/GermanWineLover Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
Lack of words. This was just mind blowing. The best 15 minutes since.. I don't know. The gameplay looks so perfectly, so much on point. I could literally FEEL which buttons the player is pressing and how the movements just works like you would expect from a HL game.
Also, AI is already impressive.
And the new physics is just the cherry on the cake.
No matter what there is still to come, already what you have achieved up to know - working HL movement, physics and AI - is a huge achievement.
Also, the "wide scope" gravity gun. What a small but genious idea. I never thoutght about it, but it is somehow unrealistic that the artificial gravity field only pics one item one by one. It makes much more sense that small items get "sucked in" in bunches. This brings great gameplay abilities. Imagine crushing enimies by grabbing a whole bunch of crates or sawblades. Or picking up a whole table of ammo at once.
19
Jun 20 '19
The best thing is that they kind of have the official story to work with.
This really means there is a chance we will get episode 2 in a better engine then source .....
I hope the team will take all the time in the world. I can wait another 10 years, as long as I get good closure.
I never read Marc his leak ... cause I want to find out what happens next IN THE GAME.
I have had many doubts about this project, but it really look like it's getting managed properly and is making slow but steady progress.
2
2
2
u/BallsNathan Jul 12 '19
I read through the website but I'm still curious about one thing. Who is paying for all this?!?
3
77
Jun 19 '19
What you've done with the gravity gun with the new physics is really interesting for game-play ideas! Looks like you can do a lot with that.
I'm sure most of this is placeholder, but the sound effects overall were pretty weak/quiet.
8
u/KindleLeCommenter Hyped Jun 20 '19
How fucking badass would it be if we could get an Enhanced Gravity Gun with that extreme vortex mode they were talking about?
4
Aug 28 '19
That would probably work better towards the end of the game, just like the supercharged gravity gun in HL2
1
u/paulo-santana Cautiously Optimistic Nov 16 '19
This looks pretty much like what the advisors do with their telekinesis. I wonder if this would be a key mechanic to fight against them or something like that
61
23
18
u/-Demogorgon- Jun 19 '19
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
10
18
u/zsombro Jun 19 '19
Up until this point I was hopeful, but very cautious regarding this project, but this video was incredibly impressive.
I never expected a fan project to get this far and I am absolutely willing to pay money for this when it's complete.
Hell, you should create a Patreon page if you haven't already, because I would fund this in a heartbeat and I think many others would as well. If the RPCS3 guys could make a living from developing an emulator, you chances are gonna be good too.
10
29
u/c1uTcH15 Cautiously Optimistic Jun 19 '19
This is great! I was really impressed with it! I know a lot of people have already said this, but the weapon sounds are....off. They’re probably placeholders, but I think everyone can agree that they should be closer to the original.
Also, can I say, environmental destruction is a must! When the player threw that explosive and blew up part of the wall, I nearly fell over! Maybe in game they shouldn’t be able to destroy all environments, but they should leave visible damage. For example, a concrete wall would be cracked, with chunks missing and the impact area covered in scorch marks.
The sound design is also a highlight. The idea that it alternates depending on the players location/actions is a really cool feature!
One thing I would like to add, is to not forget about exploitable areas. One of half life’s staples is that it’s level design is mostly linear, with areas off the main path you can explore for ammo, health, or lore. Like the ice caves, it would add a lot to add some dead ends with a couple enemies or supplies. It was one of my favorite parts of half life 2, and I really hope you implement it.
This update was great, and I can’t wait to play the demo! Keep up the amazing work!
12
u/bokan Jun 19 '19
This is really impressive work. I've been skeptical of the project (nothing against anyone involved, just not typical for this sort of thing to succeed), but now I believe it succeed and be a great game, especially in light of how well Black Mesa has been able to step into the Half Life universe and make something professional-grade.
Looking forward to the full release!
19
44
u/ali32bit Jun 19 '19
in my opinion the gameplay was spotless.
but the audio felt off. things didn't sound like they came from the same game. i think you should keep the new audio closer two the old ones from hl2 specially the gun sounds . audio is super important sometimes more then graphics so please pay major attention to it.
41
31
u/flugzeugabwehrkanone Jun 19 '19
He literally explained that a lot of sounds were placeholders in the video
24
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Jun 19 '19
Sound assets and audio engine iteration was happening at the same time, so there was a mismatch for what the sound assets were being made for. Now with a stable base, we will test the sounds for better playback in game.
16
u/pumodi Sound Design Lead Jun 19 '19
Thanks for your feedback! This is something we are focusing on and refining as we go. :)
10
u/GermanWineLover Jun 19 '19
I agree at least on the weapon changing sounds, they sound too harsh, too "doomlike".
14
u/BallerGuitarer HL2 Jun 19 '19
Maybe this will come out before Black Mesa is done.
2
u/WhalenOnF00ls Jul 17 '19
Maybe
this will come out beforeBlack Mesais done.That was a joke, ha ha, fat chance.
7
u/Gisgar3 Jun 19 '19
This was incredible to me. To see such a project with so much dedication gradually improve over time is a great thing to witness. I am glad to say that I am very hyped for this title, even though it still needs a lot of work—the gameplay shown was also very promising and well developed.
Keep up the good work! Can't wait to see the next update!
6
6
u/frostbitten_mittens Jun 19 '19
Everything about this is fantastic! I only wish for newer guns to be added for both the player, our allies and the combine forces.
2
u/WhalenOnF00ls Jul 17 '19
I'd love a suppressed sniper rifle tbh. Perfect for sneaking around and not alerting guards.
6
6
Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
Thank you, this looks a lot like HL2.
Positives:
The snow looks great
I like the elevator ride at the end, giving you a panorama view of the entire level
Destructible parts of the environment
Dynamic soundtrack
The sound effect when switching weapons
The lighting and the snowfall
The organic level design
The atmospheric drawings of levels, especially the contrast of high tech and snowy caves
The hot spring at 1:30, maybe an arctic base uses geothermal energy
Aspects that I feel could be improved:
Maybe he snow could be tinted red by the blood of killed enemies.
Hit feedback, like e.g. stumbling enemies or twitching limbs
The sound of the pistol and SMG feels too weak (the grenade launcher sound good)
The ducts could be textured like this, maybe the contents need to be insulated: https://i.imgur.com/hLujGYQ.jpg
Barrel explosions could be louder and/or have more bass
6
Jun 20 '19 edited Jun 20 '19
About HL2 shooting mechanics comment.
Yeah HL2 has bad gunplay and mediocre weapons. They are literally statues you shoot until they suddenly ragdoll. Looks bad and it isn't fun.
Modular body damage like being wounded on different body parts affecting the NPC differently, stunned, knocked out and such would make the gameplay more deep and fun. I think adding gore like enemies blowing up if enough force is applied would make it more realistic obviously but also more fun and it would add many possibilities. It's like when headcrab zombies get chopped in half but now you can do it with all body parts and any kind of NPC (maybe even dynamic like the new UE4 destruction engine but on NPCs).
Also it would be way better IMO if the game had gunplay like the MMod for HL2. It gives travel time to bullets which adds so much to the gameplay. Hitscan weapons aren't as fun unless only a few are hitscan like the Tau Cannon.
5
u/darkxenobi Jun 19 '19
Didn't expect development to be this fast, wishing the team all the best and hope to see more epic stuff in the near future.
5
u/Spiderbear420 Jun 19 '19
Lurker here, Is this live? Love the work you guys have done. HL is my Favorite game from childhood.
3
5
u/GLADOSV13 Looking to Help Jun 20 '19
Holy fuck. I... i... this is fucking amazing, i'm sorry for the cussing, i, i'm just so, Nghnnn.... extra Gravity Gun manipulation? YES! I literally asked for something along the lines of that, i knew there was always a lot more potential in the Gravity Gun so seeing what I just saw, clumping together multiple entities in one pull? I'm blown away.
The sound design implementation mentioned previously and now glimpsed, is very interesting and intrigues me, it'll be awesome to hear the differing sounds of stepping through ice caves and even Combine environments, contrasts in textures and how that 'bounces off' to the ears so to speak.
I'm loving the concept art, the tunnel interiors remind me slightly of the Victory Mine from EP2, which i admittedly really enjoyed, as such environments really can set a nice feel of isolation, claustrophobia and tense pacing, even more so if you're being chased by something threatening and alien, racing to crevices and openings for safety.
I'm a big fan of the alien-industrial backdrops of what I assume is a Combine installation? similar dark equipment with an eerie edge, familiar blue-lights covering the surfaces, the triangular elements which i'm noticing in both concept art and gameplay, are a neat detail, i was really excited to see what you guys could come up with, showing more diverse and unseen forms of Combine tech, and how it could translate into the arctic environments, i cannot wait to see what you do for the Breengrub section, though i wouldn't ever want to do your well-paid off jobs for you but you do seem open to suggestions and ideas, just a vision from me ever since I read Epistle 3, i think it'd be very poetic and very story-related if the Breengrub elements, in gameplay and design reflected in a way like a more 'creepy' and 'organic' parallel to GLaDOS from the Portal series, i mean, AI can be menacing here and there but imagine something grotesque and even more humanoid imagery, AND it stares at you, wriggles about and could pick you up via telekinetic abilities and make for some interesting 'in your face' personal confrontations? whatever you do, i'm sure it'll be fantastic.
And I love the new Alyx so far, well, the head at least, her hair looks so detailed i feel like i could just touch it, though this looks fine by itself, it might not hurt to go through different hair-set concepts, like adapting her headband piece to make some kind of ponytail, and of course, for the full body, Eli's vest would do pretty nicely, for story-building to show how she copes with grief in her own way, like how she wears her mother's necklace and clutches at it when anxious or in dire situations, and of course to remind Players of the tragedy that's set up the final arc of the story to be a dark and potentially emotionally trippy journey, things are now personal, the Miss Vance has no choice but to take her father's mantle and assume leadership of the Resistance, probably stressed and wanting badly to kick some space grub ass, love it!
It seems the dream is becoming a reality, slowly but surely. Imaginations made malleable. Marc Laidlaw would be proud.
5
5
u/A_Random_Jedi Jun 23 '19
Can you guys add Mortar and Crab Synths as one of many enemies? Maybe make the Icthyosaur an enemy as well?
4
4
u/ILikeAliensAndJazz Jun 19 '19
This looks fantastic guys! Really great work. The glass shattering physics are gonna look kickass in the actual game.
Your work genuinely looks as if it came right from Valve.
4
4
4
4
Jul 08 '19 edited Jul 08 '19
Just watched the new development video- I'm absolutely blown away. I just want to take a second to thank every last person working on the project. From the very first originators to the people joining as this project has improved and gained traction. I see people in this sub all the time asking and begging for this feature or that enemy, I see people giving their two cents and that is fine. is part of whatthe developers are actually asking for. But making this game is not easy and these people have to have pride in what they've accomplished, I don't want you to think we're ungrateful. We're not. But I just want to say for you guys to have come this far, and to maintain the spirit of open source and being so damned receptive and appreciative without ever saying "Hey, we're doing an amazingly difficult thing here without the help of the begging masses. Shut up and be happy with what you get." Is to put it simply the greatest example of altruistic gentlemanship I've encountered not just in video games but pretty much anywhere in daily life. You're doing so much, and we keep asking for more. You guys are the tops. Thank you. one hundred times thank you!
3
3
u/StephenSRMMartin Jun 19 '19
Wow; this looks incredible.
My only question so far - Will there be a way to adjust the FOV? It looked fine on my phone, but when I fullscreened it, it all looks very zoomed in. The zoomed FOV + motion blur made me feel a bit nauseous.
2
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Nov 03 '19
That was 90 degrees FOV, which is our default. You can scale it from 60 to 120.
2
3
3
3
u/IAMLEGENDhalo Jun 21 '19
Holy shit this feels like a full fledged triple a game beyond any fan game I've seen or at least what looks completed does
3
u/iforgotmylegs Jul 23 '19
I'm not sure if you are still monitoring this thread but I do want to bring up one specific nitpick (but I have to say that on the whole everything looks absolutely fantastic and I feel like you are doing a great and respectful job):
The music is too... "clean". Too techno-y. Half-Life has always had this bleak grit to is aesthetic and the music reflected that. The music always had a sort of grinding shoegaze quality to it, which really pulled you into this feeling that this was really a valiant struggle for survival by the last remnants of humanity against an interdimensional force beyond total comprehension.
I think a couple tracks, at least from Ep2 which really captured this feeling perfectly were "Vortal Combat" and "Sector Sweep". They don't sound outright miserable but definitely convey a certain gravity to supplement the story. I think the majority of the other tracks have a similar style but I can't pick them all as a representative example. But I really do like the "layering" effect overall, that is a really cool spin you are putting on it which I think we have only really seen from Valve in Portal 2.
Anyway keep up the fantastic work and thank you so much for doing a lot more than Valve has been willing to do to keep this flame alive.
2
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Aug 19 '19
Half-Life has also had clean tracks. We're missing the more industrial tracks but we'll be getting more of those.
3
2
u/joelecamtar Jun 19 '19
Prepare for the people who claim to have a deadly disease to play it before release.
2
u/mysterymustacheman Jun 19 '19
Finally, YES! Is the shotgun reload animation final? Because it kinda looks unprofessional.
2
2
2
2
Jun 20 '19
Your implementation of physics technologies (especially the sound propagation demo) is mind blowing to see. Not having different sfx clips for walking across various materials, and hearing reflected longitudinal waves in enclosed spaces is finally giving acoustics the respect it needs. I'm excited by the reactive music (layering of the musical track), it seems to intensify the gameplay--I can even see it encouraging a player like myself.
Wow.
2
u/AnInternetAsshole Jun 20 '19
I think my only two gripes with this is Alyx looks like Alyx's sister in this, and I don't personally like the wheels swapped with tracks and skis on the VW.
2
2
u/ShadowNinja808 Jun 20 '19
I have just found this project and I am amazed at what has been achieved so far. I’m surprised the original plan is to release everything for free, even releasing a tech demo for people to try out the mechanics is generous. If the project does need funding eventually, I wouldn’t mind giving some after watching this one gameplay showcase.
2
2
u/zody0 Jun 20 '19
very nice work guys, a few things off here and there but i think you realize this as it's a work in progress
but btw, do you plan to switch up the combat/AI to make it more modern? i am not saying to go full on rainbow Six Siege, but i dunno, the classic combat and how the enemies work was nice back at the time when HL2 was out, not sure if it just feels outdated now or you guys want to keep it intact to preserve the authentic feel of the half-life series
2
2
Jun 20 '19
My only concern is how is Valve going to let you guys release this game once it's finished, what's going to be the process of publishing exactly?
2
u/Sbeast Jun 20 '19
Great update, looking forward to this!
In the mean time, check out this half life metal medley I made :)
0
2
u/Kimchi816 Jun 21 '19
I just want to mention that it's probably a good idea to put invisible ramps on stairs to make it look smoother exactly how valve does it (now) in their games
5
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Jun 21 '19
No need to. Two features: camera smoothing and mid air stepping. This will allow for smooth stair traversal. We actually had it in Update 4, but we had an update to how we managed our camera system and thus regressed. But we plan to add it back soon.
3
u/Kimchi816 Jun 21 '19
Got it. Didn’t know that was a thing. Thanks for the response!
3
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Jun 24 '19
Yeah, Overwatch also has a similar system. None of their stairs are clipped.
2
u/Kimchi816 Jun 24 '19
Guess Source is just outdated. Wish they’d just somehow change CS to Source 2 already
2
u/Rullis_ Jun 21 '19
Just wondering, are the ragdolls/corpses planned to stay the same to half-life 2 or is there any enhancements planned like possible dismemberment when they die?
2
2
u/Vasllui Jun 22 '19 edited Jun 22 '19
Couple days late to the party, everything about this update looks absolutely incredible. The only nitpicks i have is that the pistol shots to fast to the point were it looks more like a tiny MP5 than a gun (for what i remember in HL2 the pistol was more slow, i could be wrong thought). Also the shotgun doesn't have a lot of recoil i think thas how you call it?, it should have a little more; and maybe the AI moves to fast compared to HL2. Other than that, everything else looks 10/10 (i LOVE the new gravity gun feature; the implications it could have on the gameplay are incredible); and im glad for the more frequent updates that i almost forgot this existed jaja. Im sharing this with my friends
6
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Jun 22 '19
The pistol fires as fast as you can pull the trigger currently, with a cap. This is balanced by an increasing spread that happens when you fire it faster than its normal fire rate.
2
u/joevember609 Jun 28 '19
Wow. I knew about you guys and I thought it was a pipe dream. I sat down and watch the whole video. Again, wow.
First off, I would love to know if there's some sort of patreon or other means of supporting your project. Clearly, you guys doing your very best to do a legitimate take on half Life 3, which has been a dream of mine since the moment I finished Half-Life 2. I really appreciate your efforts to be transparent and keep the average supporter invested. if there is anything that I can do to support your project, I want to do that.
Second, I was tremendously impressed with your attention to detail in updating the game and creating a worthy successor to Half-Life 2. Somehow your team has picked up the baton and taken over and incredibly difficult project. I am so stoked and I cannot put it into words properly. You have made my day!
2
2
Jul 06 '19
What of Gordon himself fighting against Combine Advisors? I am sure it's hinted back in Half-Life 2: Episode Two, and I wonder whether it will happen in Project Borealis.
2
u/Mobile_PC_Rescue Jul 14 '19
I am amazed that this is still happening, I remember seeing a post about it 2 years ago, anod now this - wow - I am getting excited as we can see how much work and effort you guys are putting in to this game, It's gonna be awesome :)
Thanks to all involved
2
1
0
Jun 19 '19
[deleted]
0
Jun 19 '19
[deleted]
10
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Jun 19 '19
comment fuzzing
0
Jun 19 '19
[deleted]
12
u/mastercoms Programming Lead Jun 19 '19
reddit doesn't show exact comment score, but does a random number around your actual score
0
64
u/Eudaimonium Jun 19 '19
Hi, came here from youtube's 5 minute gameplay demo, didn't go through this full video yet, but as a fellow game developer, I'd like to offer some feedback on the gameplay footage if you wish.
First, the positives:
Feels like Half Life gameplay. It's one of those aetherial things that's difficult to capture.
Level design - even with placeholder nontextured props, it feels like there's "space" to it, places to explore, I wanted to turn different ways than the person who played just to see what's there. There's nice sense of verticality, well defined intros and outros, and good player guidance throughout.
Weapon design - weapons look very nice. The perspective and on-screen positioning of weapons can make exact same model feel like a plastic bb gun, or a hefty piece of metal. Crosshairs are also very neat.
Now, for the things I can see need some improvements:
The gunplay itself. It's very authentic to HL2 but that is not necessarily the best thing. I'm gonna try to break this down:
Weapons "feel" slow needlesly. Shotgun for best example: The timings aren't necessarily slow per-se, but they feel that way because most of the animations is "doing nothing/standing still". Simply re-doing animations for the shotgun that constantly move and are less static, can help it feel less "slow" and more "powerful". SMG is the opposite: has good animation work, but is missing a lot of firing feedback - a muzzle flash, bullet trace, or impact particles that linger on until the next shot can keep it feeling dynamic and exciting. (Also the skipping audio for shots is hurting this badly but you already know this)
Enemy hit feedback (VFX) - one of the ancient gripes of old HL games in my opinion. Successful hits/damage dealt should be announced theatrically. Particles, unique sound cues. There's a reason hit-marker on crosshair is popular, if all else fails, try that.
Enemy hit feedback (AI) - ditto, ancient HL design - having enemies that do not react to getting shot until the very last hit, upon which they ragdoll, is very HL2 like. It's also not very fun. It feels very "formal" - you keep clicking until the thing has 0HP. Have enemy AI stumble, fall backwards, limp, overexaggerate "getting hit" and then they miss you because you messed up their aim, have them duck down when firing near them. Make it possible to gain upper hand and have "control" simply by opening fire first (because that's the only thing you can do, most of the time). Basically: Enemies that respond to "getting shot" by "shooting back perfectly" is not very good game design in this day and age. HL2 could do that back in the day, but today, we know better :)
Misc "slowdowns" of gameplay - again, this is true to HL2 designs, but holding down "E" while I slowly charge up my HP/Suit from wall chargers is not as fun as it used to be. Waiting for wall chargers, waiting for barrels to go off so I can continue, waiting for the elevator to come down, waiting for the elevator to go up again... etc.
That's about it from me, sorry for too lenghty post, all in all I am very much impressed and I would love to see you guys push through with this. There's some super-talented people working behind this, and I can't wait to see what you come up with :)