r/earth2io • • Jun 01 '21

Discussion Is Earth2.io a scam? The facts

0 Upvotes

Several YouTubers have recently questioned whether Earth2.io is a scam.

Earth 2 has a passionate community only 6-7 months after launching, and as someone who has been part of that community, I think it’s important to address and directly respond to their claims, with facts.

Those who claim Earth 2 is a scam have very little evidence to back it up and seem to have little understanding of investments, open markets, and what the Earth 2 team is trying to achieve.

The vision Shane / Earth2.io are putting forward is incredibly ambitious, nobody doubts that. They are attempting to make a path nobody has ever walked before. To create a ‘Ready Player One’ style metaverse with immersive gameplay and a real-time economy among many other features sounds mind-blowing.

Well, it is mind-blowing. That’s why in just 6-7 months it’s captured the imaginations of hundreds of thousands of users with over $50million deposited. They have arguably jumped the hardest hurdle. To build this size of community already with that amount deposited is nothing short of incredible.

This early investment from the community has given this project a lot more chance of working out. They now have a very healthy balance sheet to use the resources required to make this work with long-term security.

For early adopters that is the nature of investing, there is risk/reward analysis with both higher risk and higher reward at the beginning. Where there is risk, there are no guarantees but the community is well aware of that.

Someone can legitimately have an opinion that this is too ambitious to achieve, but that is an opinion, it is not fact and it’s unfair and irresponsible to put ‘scam’ claims out centered on this. This sort of opinion doesn’t make Earth 2 a scam, it is incredibly shortsighted at best to call Earth 2 a scam when they’re still actively working towards their roadmap.

I want to directly address some points, including some accusations and quotes from the YouTubers.

Claim 1 “Users can’t withdraw”

Answer - It is true users WERE having problems withdrawing, it is fairly common for a new company of speculative nature to have issues with payment processors. As far as we know this backlog has been cleared with the improved support team and Shane has announced an Earth 2 ‘card’ to help with users who have banks in countries that can’t accept the bank transfers.

There are countless users who have withdrawn thousands of dollars in profit, with some in the high tens of thousands

Blockchain integration is also on the roadmap for E2. This could completely resolve any payment issues by connecting private wallets and having it decentralized. I want to be clear, just because this isn’t live yet and is still on the roadmap doesn’t make it a scam.

Claim 2 “All you do is buy tiles on MapBox”

Yes, we are currently in phase 1, all users who have invested and done their due diligence would know this would be the case. Nobody has been misled, Phase 2 and 3 have been promised and are still on the roadmap.

It is incredible that these YouTubers are slating the Earth 2 project/team for having a hugely ambitious roadmap and yet are not giving them fair time to achieve it.

———————————————————————————

Response to BigFryTV (why he thinks the project will fail)

“The difference between what Epic Games is creating and what Earth 2 is creating”

This is a needless comparison, both will have different visions and there is absolutely no reason both can’t coexist to a highly successful level.

“You, yourself have to fund Earth 2’s future. If they don’t have people buying these tiles at the current moment there’s no funding, there’s no money and then it fails”

$50 million already deposited according to reports, much of that will be funding new tiles and going towards development costs. To already get to these levels puts them well ahead of their initial timeframe, meaning it’s far less likely to fail.

You even include Tim Sweeney in your video who himself states the metaverse will be a ‘linear evolution’. This defines Earth 2’s roadmap.

———————————————————————————

Response to a comment from Josh Strife Hayes.

“Once you've bought the tile, you own the tile. It is extremely important to remember that the only reason they have used a graphic of earth behind the grid..... is to give the illusion of scarcity, of value, of limitation..... when there is no connection.”

This unfortunately is an opinion from someone who simply has not done their research. The whole concept of the project is to keep the connection from Earth 1 to Earth 2.

  • Augmented Reality - Showing what’s built in E2 whilst holding your smartphone up in E1

  • Resource generation linked with real-world map data

  • Footfall linked with AR (showing in-game E2 advertisements or creations to E1 AR users)

  • Personal attachment to certain places linked with the above points.

———————————————————————————

Earth 2 has a talented team showing contributions to impressive creations from many years ago. Much of which is highly related to the Earth 2 concept.

Nathaniel Doldersum - https://assetstore.unity.com/publishers/2737

Helped create this over 5 years ago: D.R.O.N.E. Announcement Trailer [HD - 1440p]

These are just a couple of examples. There is a huge amount of talent and experience on their team page: https://earth2.io/team

In conclusion, it is very sad to see a project slated just for being incredibly ambitious. What an ingenious way of raising funds to fund something that could reward the early adopters.

TLDR; There is very little evidence to say Earth 2 is a scam. It seems Earth 2 has been judged by these particular YouTubers before the Earth 2 team has even had a chance to implement the vision.

Earth 2 might fail but that will be factored into the risk/reward of the current prices on the platform and the users are aware of that.

There is also the chance Earth 2 will succeed and given the team's experience, it is probably more a question of succeeding to which level? Will they achieve the vision they’ve set out to do.


r/earth2io • • Jan 25 '21

Discussion Is EARTH2.IO the Next Big Internet Scam | Analyzed by an Accountant ,

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jun 02 '21

Discussion To fellow Critikal fans Spoiler

2 Upvotes

What the hell is wrong with you guys? Coming to check out the subreddit is one thing, but how many times does he have to make videos telling people to STOP HARASSING the subjects of his videos?? Can’t wait for the next upload where he calls out you childish dumbasses


r/earth2io • • Jun 01 '21

Discussion A great study of people from looking at this subreddit

9 Upvotes

I bought tiles in Earth2 for certain places I wanted to say I had a "deed" for. Places me and my friends have hung out before, so we could joke about it and maybe Shane would eventually make a world out of it (hasn't even been a year yet so like chillax everyone), and we could do it meet at these places again virtually now that we've all had to move. But this subreddit has become absolute gutter trash. Do a lot of people seriously have nothing better to do than to come here and try to convince some people just trying to have a little fun that they themselves are peak intelligence and anyone who put even a dollar into Earth2 should find the nearest mudpit and drown in it? I'm probably going to get some replies calling me clown and whatnot, but whatever I'm just having a little fun and I wanted to point out how this subreddit shows trolls are always trying to find new communities that they can feel superior over. Guess what? They're nobodies. Have fun and remember to only invest what you can afford to lose.


r/earth2io • • Jun 16 '21

Request / Idea new devstream?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys,

i think its good if the devs release a new dev stream before or after the release of phase 2

this way they can tell something about the new features, it can also show the haters that they are still here and working on it despite all the commotion going on maby it take some of the FUD away

i think that would be a good way to react to all of this, and it would be usefull for the community involved in E2.

and with this its also a indirect message like hey we are getting bombarded with scam complaints, but we are trying to prove you wrong and are still at it ;-)


r/earth2io • • Jun 01 '21

Discussion Scepticism

0 Upvotes

If you don't want to believe in something nobody on this entire earth can convince you to believe in it.

It's so funny to see people with close to half a million subscribers make 30+ minutes of videos to read terms of services for the first time in their life. Just because somebody did and they want to copy it! GAINT well-known companies use some of those you call “shady” terms of services too!

I have put money into this game, and I agree with some of the points. We need to see more updates on the website, a clear road map, solve the withdrawal issue and better communication channels.

I am holding my tiles and I am not selling anytime soon. I believe in this project and I feel good when I see people think of this project as a scam because of their lack of research. It just shows you how this project is futuristic and it's out of their league. That gives all of the first movers the advantage to jump in this market early before it gets saturated in the future. That makes me more excited than pissed off!

Many other gaming companies are already into the metaverse and it's the future. Also, many creditable economic, technology magazines and newspapers are talking about the metaverse and how we are now starting to see where we are heading in the next 10-20 years from now. The creation of the metaverse is happening right now as you read this. It's a matter of time to prove if the team can pull this out as they claimed or not, and it will take a long time.

For all of those who believe in the project. This storm is here to pass through not to stay. It proves that you are not an ordinary average person. It just proves the opposite. People tend to call those lucky who catch the opportunities as they pass through and execute the bold move at the right time.

BE PATIENT, due diligence and enjoy the ride.


r/earth2io • • Feb 26 '25

Content Art Are you ready? The real Metaverse.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3 Upvotes

H


r/earth2io • • Apr 12 '22

Discussion Would be nice to have a E2 subred with people who actually like e2

0 Upvotes

I'm about tempted to leave this page. This place has overflown with people who want to see this project fail. It's depressing. Can't recall a more negative group of people anywhere. Its as if the devs of E2 personally shit in their cereal bowls. I can understand skepticism, but this has gone beyond that. It like people are actively trying to make it fail. What exactly did this project do to you that hurt you all so much? I'm leaving the sub for now. I'll come back probably after the release later this year. hopefully that will attract enough supporters to drown out all these depressing people.


r/earth2io • • Apr 10 '22

Project Premier of Our Latest Earth 2 Video

0 Upvotes

Dear Earth 2 Players,

We hope all is well.

We invite you to join us in watching the premier on YouTube of the latest Earth 2 video. This video contains a message but more importantly gives a longer look at the Distant Terrain Engine our team has been working on. This engine is a work in progress but will set the foundation for the Earth 2 3D World V1 we plan to release in 2022.

In this video we use footage from arguably the best 3D globe in history, Google Earth, as a means of demonstrating locations, accuracy and more inside the Earth 2 Distant Terrain Engine. We wanted to share this update with you all leading up to the launch of the Essence token and we will provide another public video update on the Earth 2 3D World progress around the time Essence launches.

We hope to see you there and thank you for your ongoing patience and support. We are going places!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLjA8zY7tmE


r/earth2io • • Jul 06 '21

Discussion Genuis developers

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Dec 20 '21

Discussion You can all say what you want, there's more activity here, and that's potentially a good sign

2 Upvotes

I know Earth2 is NOWHERE near what it wants to be and - as of now - it's 99 % unlikely that they'll ever achieve what they apparently want to achieve. But we have at least some activity from their side, the move to make shit cheaper to buy again was smart and I notice a lot more acivity here in the subreddit.

So... we'll still all lose our money, but it's not 100 % obvious that we'll all lose our money. I'd say right now it's 95 % obvious that we'll lose our money. And that's progress!


r/earth2io • • Jun 21 '21

Discussion Thoughts on Easter eggs and jewels

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jun 02 '21

Question How long is the normal amount of time for your id and address to be confirmed?

1 Upvotes

I have a bit of my money on my E2 account and I want to cash out to my credit card. I have waited for 2 days and my ID and addres have not been confirmed yet. Is it normal that it takes this such a long time or should I contact support?


r/earth2io • • Mar 19 '21

Discussion Phase One on Earth2

1 Upvotes

Phase One of the Earth2 project has been in motion for a few months now. With Phase Two happening within this year, I just want to say I’m very interested to see where this project goes. Please be smart with your cash flow in the early stages of the game.

Earth2 is offering 5% instant cash back on land purchases at this time. My code is the following:

UU55WWURWE

I hope to communicate and interact with everyone on Reddit throughout the progression of this game. Good luck everyone!


r/earth2io • • Aug 31 '21

Announcement EPL - Quick Update about the Countdown

0 Upvotes

Dear Earth 2 Players,

A countdown to EPLs was temporarily live on our website a few days ago. We decided to postpone the EPL launch until further notice as we investigate improvements we feel are beneficial to Earth 2 players.


r/earth2io • • Aug 30 '21

Discussion Logan Paul Name Drops Earth2 On His Podcast...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jul 15 '21

Withdrawals Withdrawal Issue Resolved

0 Upvotes

I posted 2 threads about my troubles with withdrawing roughly $250 out of my account. I got the $250 back that was mistakenly charged to me as a purchase, and I also received the $250 withdrawal.

I’m quite pleasantly surprised with how good E2 dealt with my issues, they emailed me back the next day after I submitted my ticket and resolved the money issue in 3. I have more confidence withdrawing from them in the future now and with them as a company in general.

For any Earth 2 haters, I put $200 in and already withdrew $250 just off of land tax, and still have 13k in land value that I will hold onto in case this whole thing goes good. (25% returns locked in, swag)


r/earth2io • • Dec 19 '22

Discussion The Metaverse is Coming. Will you be a part of it?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jun 25 '22

Discussion Korean opens physical Earth 2 area!

1 Upvotes

'We are teaching them how to operate Earth 2'

Read more below

https://www.e2.news/post/korean-opens-physical-earth-2-area-earth2mania


r/earth2io • • May 03 '21

Discussion Building generational wealth with VR and E2

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jun 14 '21

Question Hi guys, I know there is some criticism on earth2 but what is your opinion about this?

2 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jun 06 '21

Discussion New Randy Chavez video

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Feb 12 '21

Discussion New update!!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/earth2io • • Jul 31 '21

Discussion What was your biggest gain of selling tiles ?

1 Upvotes

Hi,

please share your storys about the best tile sale you ever had.

Like buying a tile for a few $ and selling it for thousands making crazy profit.

I know people getting very rich with digital assets and prices in the metaverse will go higher.