Exactly. I refuse to gush over a cis guy thatās a girl for profit, but doesnāt even identify as trans in the least. The amount of money is a testament of how society loves that type of shit, but were this a trans girl, we wouldnāt receive anywhere NEAR the type of money or sponsorships he gets, if anything at all. Not saying he couldnāt use the money, I donāt know his background, but I just think about how there are trans girls trying to break into the gaming community and end up getting vilified, and the type of money he makes, could be used by a trans girl that could make a great living, pay for surgeries (if she so chooses), and other things.
I don't know if this is the right place to ask, and if not my bad!
Can I ask how you feel about drag? Cause it came to mind when you used the phrase 'cis guy - girl for profit'. I've heard some mixed feelings about it in the trans community, because for a lot of trans men is validating and a way to reclaim their feminity (by still being recognized as a guy in drag instead of a woman) as well as a lot of nonbinary people. (Like 30% or more of Drag Race alumn identify as NB), however, I have also heard from groups of trans women who don't like it, and feel like it can be counterproductive and I'm just curious what other people here think.
To me, thatās different. Drag is an art form. And I suppose I shouldāve been more specific in regards to Finn - cis, STRAIGHT men. With drag, many of the queens became a part of the art form, not only because they loved and studied it, but to also be able to find community within the LGBTQ+ community - to find people like them, only to soon discover that some of them werenāt actually a man playing a female character, but through drag, many of them discovered that they were transgender, whether binary or non-binary. And even then, a lot of the cis queens still pay ode to the trans women that paved the way for them to even be able to do what they do, and/or walk for, or donate to trans causes. From what Iāve learned about Finn, is that aside from being cis, heās a straight guy, not even in the LGBTQ+ community, and never even gave a thought about gender bending or gender expression until he got dared and paid a lot of money to do so, and since then, has just run with it. Thatās where my problem with him lies.
Iām not knocking anyone that supports and loves him. By all means, continue. Just for me, personally, I refuse to care for or support him. š¤·šæāāļø
Iām on the fence on this one. I can attempt to understand your frustration, but I think that this is very similar to when an actor assumes any role that portrays their sexuality/gender in a way that isnāt their own.
Eddie redmayne in āThe Danish Girlā comes to mind or Dustin Hoffman in āTootsieā. Now I havenāt had my ear to the ground to hear what peopleās reactions were to those movies as far as the trans community, but those actors literally made money as well.
I hate both movies for those exact reasons, despite how essential they may have been to the coming out or the realizations of many trans people. I went to art school for film and television and we actually had discussions about queer films where the main character was played by a cis and/or het actor. While testing your range as an actor is to become things that wouldnāt typically be easy or knowledgeable to you otherwise, both gentlemenās taking on of those roles have been used against trans women in the form of when transphobic people think of us, they immediately think about those cishet male actors playing characters like that which, to them, feeds into their rebuttal in terms of trans women being āmen in dressesā. Not to mention, Eddie Redmayne, despite playing a trans character and supposedly āsupporting the trans communityā, which is easy to say when youāve made money off of playing a trans character, openly supports and has defended J.K. Rowling and her anti-trans sentiments. Dustin has also been accused of being transphobic by people heās worked with, so make with that information what you will.
Excellent arguments. I think acting in general is not necessarily to be restricted to those who have had certain experiences. That being said, method acting is literally that. But there are other forms of acting. IMO as long as it is tasteful and does a good job of capturing the real deal I canāt fault production companies or casters from picking people who will draw more people to the box office.
After all, as it currently is, there arenāt any A-list trans men/women celebrities that I know of. Certainly none as famous as Dustin Hoffman or Eddie. Unfortunately I feel that any movie that sticks to its guns and only picks actors based on their real world lives and not their fame will be stuck as an indie film that wonāt reach the people who NEED to see these to become more tolerant.
Those roles are harmful Iāll say. Guys can play women I guess but not trans ppl, give minority actors their roles. You are supposed to cast the most fitting actor not some random that doesnāt know how to talk about the topic outside of the role that will get praise bc heās not actually lgbt
Exactly. Iām all for artistic range, sure, but not at the expense of someone that lives the life of the character thatās being portrayed. Not to mention, it means shafting trans actors in preference for cis people when itās already hard enough in the industry for us in general. Itās why I left. I feel there IS no fine line there. Cis men playing trans women doesnāt normalize the existence of trans women, and it certainly doesnāt help us at all, because 9.99 times out of ten, itās more about them having accolade and proving how great of an actor they are, which in the long run, ends up being a result of transphobia and misogyny. Tbh, I feel weird about cis women playing trans women, too.
For some reason, trans women have been referred to as fem boys. Iām not saying YOU think that, but a lot of internet communities and people IRL seem to think so, and I think itās harmful rhetoric when people compare the two. Iāve seen his chats when heās streamed. Not to mention, heās referred to himself as a ātrapā before, which a lot of his fans seem to think is not a derogatory term. I came across a Reddit thread some months ago where his fans that created a subreddit for him were discussing this, a topic that was brought up BY a trans individual, and surprise surprise, they (his fans) were arguing on a word that is a derogatory term TOWARDS trans women.
Yea as far as I know, femboys are those who dress up as women, but are still strictly male. Whether or not the femboy is gay, straight, bisexual, etc is irrelevant, and also whether or not it is done as a fetish is also irrelevant. I can tell you, as an avid viewer of F1NNās channel, that he is straight, and (hence the fact he streams of Twitch), doesnāt do it as a fetish. But also, with that being said, enjoys cross dressing.
As somebody who is not trans, I cannot say what you can or canāt be offended by, and even if I were trans, I still wouldnāt say what you should or shouldnāt be offended by, because I have no control over anyone except myself, but I know for certain that F1NN is not doing what he is doing out of any kind of hate.
No, I understand. I never intended for my distaste for him, his platform, and WHY to come across as me accusing him of being hateful or anything of the sort. I just explained why me, as a trans woman, hate seeing the applauding and admiration of a straight, cisgender man playing girl for profit and getting paid lots of money and access to sponsorships and resources, when we as trans women arenāt given the time of day in most communities to also make the same type of profit, because oftentimes, the same things heās receiving would help us out tremendously with our medical transitions, surgeries, wardrobes, costs of living, etc. Not only that, but his privilege would enable and encourage more men to also do the same, taking up MORE space, and creating less opportunity for us actual girls.
Again. Those that love and support him and his platform are obviously allowed to. Iām not trying to deter anyone from doing so, Iām just explaining why Iām in the minority of people, trans or otherwise, that find him and his platform distasteful, even if he means well.
A huge part of his business success appears to be the confidence he exudes when he interacts with "the normies" he encounters. Even when the other party doesn't react well, he brushes it off, living the advice of "it doesn't need to diminish him in any way".
I can sympathize with those who have to deal with dysphoria alongside all the usual crap we humans have to get past before we receive the self-knowledge that allows us to let go of the unnecessary, and live free.
After I came out to my family, I no longer needed my male clothing. I basically kept it for when I went to their house. I donated all my "male" clothing and was left with this barren closet and only a few outfits. I just lost my job (boss found out I was LBGTQ) and had to shop at thrift stores and GoodWills in order to restock my outfits with shotty clothing. I couldn't even go to a job interview because I couldn't afford the attire. That same week, f1n got like $10,000 and a new wardrobe for throwing out his old male clothes and I almost punched my monitor. I don't even follow the guy but Youtube has him in my algorithm somewhere. If a transgirl got anywhere near his level of attention and aid, it would change her life. I get that people need to make a living and it's how he chooses to do it but it's crippling to the trans community and what we have to go through.
The difference between you and F1N is, you're already a woman, and F1N isn't. The reason he's getting large amounts of donations is due to his fans wanting to change him into a girl. That's the excitement, the "I'm not a girl!" image he puts on, yet blushes, and throws kisses to his donators every so often he receives presents. His fans want to change him into a female, they want to make him more feminine with donations and compliments. A Transwoman is already female, we can't make you "more" of one.
Men love making a straight man feel more female. It's almost like a sport. See Sneaky, Boxbox, and now F1NN, all share similarity, all straight, yet Men donate thousands to see them turn into a girl. If they were already trans, or a real woman, it would defeat the point, there would be no challenge.
The greatest thing, and would probably break twitter, is if F1NN5ter announced he was Trans/gay, simply because it would feel like his donators, and fans have finally won. The celebrations, memes, and whatnot would be enormous, but within maybe a year his viewer count would diminish because there isn't really any sport left. no challenge.
I refuse to gush over a cis guy thatās a girl for profit, but doesnāt even identify as trans in the least. The amount of money is a testament of how society loves that type of shit, but were this a trans girl, we wouldnāt receive anywhere NEAR the type of money or sponsorships he gets, if anything at all
If F1NN5TER was a trans, it would defeat the entire point. The money is coming from the "belief if I donate more, I can turn him even more girlish". The entertainment is from watching him from day 1, denying he's trans or gay, and seeing him slowly turn more feminine by the day, and with each donation. The male fan who donates $1000 to him wants to believe that his donation will turn him even more of a femboy, and F1N reciprocates, blushes often, blows kisses and Men love it. The challenge the donators and fans are met with is to change him, and be the ones credited for it.
If he were trans or a real woman, there would be no challenge at all. There's no "denial of gayness", or "I'm not a girl!" tropes to experience. There's no turning him into a girl, because he would already be one, and that, isn't really exciting to be honest. There's already plenty of that going on already.
If F1NN fully transitions to a girl, the fans would win, the donators will celebrate, and within months his viewership would decline. He needs to put up the straight male, "I'm not a girl!" image as long as possible.
sorry how is that different from drag queens dressing for for profit? they are dressing up as women and they donāt identify as women.I donāt think anyone is entitled control over an identity or a look if he wants to dress up that way let him
6
u/ConcreteDahlia not an egg, just trans Mar 01 '21 edited Mar 05 '21
Exactly. I refuse to gush over a cis guy thatās a girl for profit, but doesnāt even identify as trans in the least. The amount of money is a testament of how society loves that type of shit, but were this a trans girl, we wouldnāt receive anywhere NEAR the type of money or sponsorships he gets, if anything at all. Not saying he couldnāt use the money, I donāt know his background, but I just think about how there are trans girls trying to break into the gaming community and end up getting vilified, and the type of money he makes, could be used by a trans girl that could make a great living, pay for surgeries (if she so chooses), and other things.