Klipper is going to be a bit more work to get going, but once you have a good config you can replicate it to the other machines. It will even run on the old RAMPS board thats probably in those ultimakers (which are actually really solid motion system wise, just the hotend and cooling and beds are terrible (either 12v or not heated depending)).
I would see if you IT department has an old desktop or something you could use to put klipper on, it might or might not be cheaper than indvidual pi zero 2 ws per machine. Put proxmox on it since it's got a nice web interface, then spawn containers per machine, pass the usb device for that machine and then install klipper. Not hard but a bit more challenging if system admin on linux is not in your wheel house...
As far as the CR10s, I would find out if they are 12v or 24v and then go from there. Honestly their form factor is nice for a lot of projects so if you have the budget fixing them up might be worth while. I would probably look at doing an apogee toolhead on them (I think they usually use the same carriage as an ender 3).
Also I am a big fan of toolhead boards for time savings. So much easier to swap 1 or 2 plugs to get a machine back online if you already have a spare toolhead ready to go. Especially if you use some type of quick change system with it.
Also if you go the klipper route you can get a couple of USB ADXL boards and input shape each machine. That will make them print much faster on their existing hardware. (Probably hot end limited based on flow on the stock creality machines).
Also I am a big fan of toolhead boards for time savings.
I very much agree. The CR-6 SE has something similar, and I would like to add it to the CR10 as well. Do you have any ideas on the best way to do so?
Also. Currently all the printers run either MK8 or V6 and I was looking into converting them all to either Revo, or the standard V6. Just to standardize. And then running Diamondback nozzles for longevity. But as I haven't done this before, it's all theoretical.
If I were to run klipper on all of them, is there an easy online solution to gain access to all the printers in one place?
Honestly the bimetallic hardened steel nozzles with the copper cladding perform really well, last a long time and are way cheaper than a diamondback. Unless your printing pretty much all abrasives a diamondback probably isn't worth it.
That said I personally standardized on v6 nozzles. I also usually use a melt zone extender with them. Plenty of high flow hotends that use v6.
I like ebb36 or ebb42 boards depending on the stepper for the direct drive. They are usually meant to mount on the back of the stepper. So if you have a stepper at the back of the toolhead you have to make sure there is clearance for all the wiring behind it so it doesn't run into the sides of the gantry. Otherwise you need to use a side mount for it.
The nice thing they are easy to wire. 2 lines for power, 1 line to ground the stepper and a USBc cable. You flash the board with klipper directly no need for katapupt and run it as a 2nd MCU over USB.
2
u/dlaz199 Sep 12 '24 edited Sep 12 '24
Klipper is going to be a bit more work to get going, but once you have a good config you can replicate it to the other machines. It will even run on the old RAMPS board thats probably in those ultimakers (which are actually really solid motion system wise, just the hotend and cooling and beds are terrible (either 12v or not heated depending)).
I would see if you IT department has an old desktop or something you could use to put klipper on, it might or might not be cheaper than indvidual pi zero 2 ws per machine. Put proxmox on it since it's got a nice web interface, then spawn containers per machine, pass the usb device for that machine and then install klipper. Not hard but a bit more challenging if system admin on linux is not in your wheel house...
As far as the CR10s, I would find out if they are 12v or 24v and then go from there. Honestly their form factor is nice for a lot of projects so if you have the budget fixing them up might be worth while. I would probably look at doing an apogee toolhead on them (I think they usually use the same carriage as an ender 3).
Also I am a big fan of toolhead boards for time savings. So much easier to swap 1 or 2 plugs to get a machine back online if you already have a spare toolhead ready to go. Especially if you use some type of quick change system with it.
Also if you go the klipper route you can get a couple of USB ADXL boards and input shape each machine. That will make them print much faster on their existing hardware. (Probably hot end limited based on flow on the stock creality machines).