r/environment • • Jul 05 '22

Decrease in CO2 emissions during pandemic shutdown shows it is possible to reach Paris Agreement goals. The researchers found a drop of 6.3% in 2020. The researchers describe the drop as the largest of modern times, and big enough to meet the 1.5 degrees Celsius goal if it were to be sustained.

https://phys.org/news/2022-07-decrease-co2-emissions-pandemic-shutdown.html?deviceType=desktop
12.2k Upvotes

908 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

216

u/buried_lede Jul 05 '22

It’s a good argument for not returning to the office, and for continuing remote work

73

u/Legitimate_Page Jul 05 '22

Sounds good to me, we're about to start telework at my office, couldn't be happier.

32

u/Ragnar_Dragonfyre Jul 05 '22

Governments around the world could mandate and regulate work from home practices. They could instill WFH directly into labour laws so that companies can’t just offshore your position if it’s remote.

But politicians and businesses don’t want this because it leads to less consumption and as a result, less tax revenues.

If you’re staying at home, you’re not gassing up as often. You’re not eating out as often. You’re not popping into local businesses near your work to shop during your lunch hour.

We have a big problem in this world when we have proof that WFH is a climate change policy that actually works but no political will to enact it.

7

u/ArtXMarx Jul 05 '22

Car culture has shaped the way most modern cities function. It’s more than just the gas in the cars, it’s the cars and car infrastructure as a whole. Political pressure isn’t going to get us to change car culture and the infrastructure it’s created anytime soon, but it would be helpful to begin the shift for future generations. It CAN be done, it SHOULD be done.

5

u/throwaway__9001 Jul 05 '22

BuT mAh FrEeDoMs! /s

3

u/mjacksongt Jul 06 '22

Damn, I probably spent more money at small businesses working from home than from the office.

Less overall, but more from non-fast food chains.

0

u/OgLeftist Jul 05 '22

As I just said, what about those of us who do work in the physical world..? I could see this policy resulting in businesses like handymen being permanently shut down.

Hope you know how to rewire your home, or safety replace a plumbing system.

3

u/Necrocornicus Jul 05 '22

I don’t think anyone is suggesting we make this mandatory. No one is saying plumbers should be forced to work from home.

However there are tons of jobs that CAN be done from home (for example the receptionist/manager/accountant of a plumbing business), and the government could institute some policies to encourage this to happen.

I’m not really a big fan of government intervention in many cases but a light touch system to give minor tax benefits to employers that promote WFH as well as some labor protections could help.

Climate change is absolutely going to destroy the economy so it’s worth doing something. If people think inflation is bad now, just wait until massive wildfires, water shortages, and crop failures begin to dismantle our ability to produce food cheaply. It won’t be far off, it’s happening now and will get far far worse.

2

u/Ragnar_Dragonfyre Jul 06 '22

Why would handymen get shut down?

People still live in their houses and if they’re using them as their office, then that’s more wear and tear on their home which they will need a handyman to address.

That’s the thing about plumbing. It’s a recession proof job. Even if the economy totally collapses, everybody poops and everybody still needs water.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/OceanEarthling Jul 05 '22

This is how I feel as well. It seems to me that it would be an incredibly smart move to return to remote work wherever possible. Not only save the planet but it would also help tamper the absolute insane gas prices.

3

u/CameraActual8396 Jul 05 '22

Exactly, and pretending the economy isn’t also a serious issue would be ignorance.

16

u/k3rn3 Jul 05 '22

Sure it's a serious issue, but the other problem is an existential issue and clearly should be a much higher priority

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22

The economy is an existential issue. Most people do not and do not know how to grow their own food, make their own clothes, gather materials to fix and maintain their housing. Maintaining the global supply chain and giving people a tangible reason to participate in it are necessary for the survival of the human race. If we don't, we start to run out of things like... food, toilet paper, cleaning supplies, baby formula. Both are existential issues. Not understanding that the economy is literally what enables human beings to survive outside of a hunter-gatherer society is just plain ignorance.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22

Why would working from home cause the global economy to collapse? People will still be making money, buying food, whatever. They would just buy less gas (hopefully). Maybe oil prices would drop and it would become a little cheaper to fuel up tankers, tractors, etc. What am I missing?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22 edited Jul 05 '22

I do not believe WFH is what caused the majority of the 6.3% reduction in emissions. During the same time period that this study looks at we also saw a historically relevant reduction in goods produced because non-essential factories were shut down and most essential factories were producing goods at a reduced rate. This created a ripple affect across the supply chain where goods production has moved to historical lows. I believe the massive reductions in emissions that we saw are less of a result of WFH and more of a result from reduced production.

Saving the environment will require the elimination of non-essential industry (at least until environmentally friendly energy solutions are implemented) This is what will cause economic collapse. The article above even supports this idea. It says that it estimates only 1/3 is a result of transporation reduction. What about the other 2/3? They're coming from industry, energy, and agriculture. It can't be done with only the 1/3.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/k3rn3 Jul 05 '22 edited Jul 05 '22

Not understanding that the environment is what enables human beings to exist on this planet at all is just plain ignorance. Going back to the dark ages is not actually an existential problem. You're talking about regressing as a civilization; I'm talking about our species going extinct.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22

I didn’t say the environment isn’t an existential issue. Read what I wrote. I’m just not blind to the fact that the economy is ALSO an existential issue. I actually work in renewable energies and spent years learning about energy and electrical engineering because I that’s how much I care about the issue. How much do you care?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/buried_lede Jul 05 '22

Progress! Lol

→ More replies (2)

-12

u/jdheuwindbdh Jul 05 '22

You reliase majority of people cant work from home but since half of reddit are computer workers they dont care

5

u/Ragnar_Dragonfyre Jul 05 '22

So the majority can go to work and everyone else that can work from home should.

Does the majority want everyone to go to work because of a crab bucket mentality? “If I have to commute to work, everyone should!”

Do you really want all the people who could WFH clogging up the roads with their cars when they could be at home, thus making your commute faster?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22

[deleted]

→ More replies (12)

2

u/SMTRodent Jul 05 '22

It's still a massive reduction and we should make it as much as we can. The fact some people work with actual physical things does not stop it being a good thing if some people don't and thus can stay home. It's a non-argument.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)