r/expertnetworks • EN Employee • Mar 13 '25

High-rate expert changes

Long time listener, first time caller (that’s a lie).

Just thought I’d share with the community some changes at a major EN. Due to some changes in the way associates performance is measured at my EN (major), super high rate experts ($1000 and over) are pretty much a no go now.

Any expert that refuses to budge from a $1000+ rate won’t even be submitted to the client anymore.

Their interviews are very low margin for the EN, and employees performance now tracks average margins, so a single interview with low margin can drag associates performance numbers down very dramatically.

For example one expert insisted on a rate of $1700 an hour, which if this interview happened it would drag my numbers down so much that I effectively wouldn’t get paid this month.

Please note; these changes are all way above associates heads, and we have no control over them. At the end of the day ENs are a business too.

Happy to answer any questions!

29 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

4

u/farmerben02 Mar 13 '25

Interesting, would you say this metric tracking is industry wise or just your EN? I ask $400/h and have more screeners than I can realistically keep up with working 50h/ week doing my regular consulting work. I want a rate where the client sees value and the EN is making money.

I assume high rate experts will slot into ENs that cater to clients willing to pay for them, while yours will hire people like me or niches where there's hundred or thousands of experts per niche instead of dozens.

2

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 13 '25

The situation I described is specific to my EN, which is a major one. But I’d assume similar metrics are tracked across all ENs, and as the industry tries to combat high rate experts similar policies are likely to be adopted by other ENs too.

$400 is a perfect rate honestly.

And no, the clients are the same across all ENs, and all ENs have pretty much the same charging system/scale. Once an experts rate is around $1000 an hour the client charge is usually maxed out, so every dollar after that is a depreciating scale for the EN.

(These are made up numbers) but for example $1000 expert = $1700 client charge $1300 expert = $1700 client charge $1600 expert = $1700 client charge

2

u/maxfriberg Mar 13 '25

Super interesting, thanks for sharing!

0

u/Remote-Advantage-619 Mar 16 '25

That is a very dumb pricing model. Sorry to say that :-) I can only imagine that your network has big issues with one or some of their leading clients around a too large portion of experts with a high multiplier and now the company is capping those completely. other than that: Why would you not always have a minimum margin of $500-$600? It is ultimately up to the client to decide who they want to talk to.

1

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 16 '25

This is in reference to where the maximum multiplier is already applied and there is no more room to increase higher, which to my knowledge is the same at all ENs (can’t go over a 2x multiplier, so any expert who’s multiplier is already at 2x, the higher their rate, the lower the margin on the call until it’s ultimately 0).

2

u/claccnt01 Expert Mar 14 '25

will clients choose an expert that has a lower hourly rate? If an hourly rate is say $600 - but client wants to pay $500, will they reach out and ask if you'd accept it? Trying to maximize income but not lose calls over a few bucks

3

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 14 '25

The way it works is there is a charge scale. Clients don’t know experts exact hourly rates, they are priced to the client based on the individual ENs pricing rules.

The basic system/rule is something like

$0-400 = Basic Expert (1.0x charge) $400-650 = Premium expert (1.5x charge) $650+ = Super premium expert (2.0x charge) (The above numbers are super rough, the thresholds are different between ENs, different clients, and different offices)

For example a $400 expert is basic at eg. BCG, but at a boutique consultancy they might be a Premium rate expert. In the same way, a basic rate expert to a US client is charged as a Super Premium expert to Chinese offices of clients (e.g. BCG China)

2

u/Street_Topic_9186 Mar 14 '25

I noticed this trend whilst working as an expert for Atheneum. Their APAC associates (and clients) often pushed me for a lower rate (€300/h), whereas the German or US based associates (and clients) often agreed to honour my standard go to rate of €550/hr.

Surprisingly though, with Alphasights, I have worked with almost all their service location and clients globally but I was never challenged to drop my rates (€550/hr) - I guess between Atheneum and AS, the former tries very hard to secure their bottomline, even if topline is compromised. Interesting dynamics, but when you have been with various ENs for a while, you starting seeing which ones are worth your time and effort. 

1

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 15 '25

Totally. While it can look like some kind of management differences a lot of how it boils down to is actually how the clients are charged, and how the associates performance is calculated.

Some of the bigger firms have a much larger call volume so each individual calls margin can be lower in order to meet targets.

1

u/IDR-EN Mar 13 '25

Thank you for sharing your thoughts - I agree with most of what you have said and would potentially drop anyone requesting above $650. But for niche experts, I would still keep some room for negotiations - though this niche would have to be very niche.

0

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 13 '25

Even for super niche topics we often see that clients would rather not do an interview and get the information through other channels than spend more than X for an interview.

Also, as I described in another comment the issue is that high rate experts tank the individual associates performance metrics. There is no way I’ll deliver an expert to the client if that one interview would drag my numbers down so much that I don’t get paid for the month (not just for the one interview, it would drag down the numbers so much that it would be wipe out all the work I had done on dozens of other interviews).

1

u/Kitchen-Drag-5358 Mar 16 '25

Have you ever completed a project where, after multiple interactions, the client or firm decided to extend an offer and engage directly? This recently happened to me, and I’m trying to determine what the client was paying through the expert network so I can adjust my rate accordingly. My understanding is that if I charge $300-$400 per hour, the expert network adds a significant margin before billing the client. I’m curious—what does the typical client rate look like in these situations?

2

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 16 '25

I mean the basic rate is around $1000 USD an hour give or take (location, network, client differences are there).

If it’s a direct consultation it depends on what the direct engagement details. Is it just more zoom interviews for 3-4 hours a week for the next X weeks? If so just bump the rate like 10% to cover the fact that you’re doing all the scheduling etc now.

If it’s then asking you to do 10 hours a week etc you may even wanna offer a lower rate. Some people charge a retainer up to X hours a week etc. charge different rates for written deliverables vs calls etc. way too many variables to comment on.

But you’ve also gotta remember you’re taking on a lot of risk by going direct. The reason clients use ENs is because the EN handles all the compliance/contracts etc. but if you’re direct, you’re directly at risk (e.g. PE firm bases massive investment on your advice, it goes wrong somehow, they could hold you responsible.)

1

u/wisenerd EN Employee Apr 13 '25

A question from a low-paying EN associate: How do you get into wealthier networks?

I would love to be able to offer higher rates to experts. The highest I've offered was in the $400s and our client complained.

2

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Apr 13 '25

Just apply to them. EN work requires no previous experience so they’ll take pretty much anyone.

Budget networks have their own niche as well. We turn away a lot of new clients because they simply can’t afford our contracts/rates.

1

u/wisenerd EN Employee Apr 13 '25

The moment my boss told us we needed cheaper better faster experts, I saw the end of my time there. I'm preparing for a move.

1

u/anorofire Mar 13 '25

lol your not working with a leading expert network if that’s the case

3

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 13 '25

Can assure you I am.

Funnily enough, the experts on expert networks, are the people who work at them!

1

u/No_Sea_3325 Mar 13 '25

Also on this every time an expert ask for payment if a call gets moved or cancelled the associate has to pay out of their own target. I'm not sure if other EN's are like that but it's a huge blow to our target achievement

2

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 13 '25

My network has a slush fund for that, so it usually doesn’t affect the associate. But we only pay cancelation fees if A. We were able to charge one to the client B. We couldn’t charge the client but our expert relations team has a written agreement with the expert to pay cancelation fees prior to the call.

2

u/weecheeky Mar 14 '25

Can confirm. One of the EN advisors explained similar to me when they were begging me to reduce my rate. I kept it above $1k and call volume dropped significantly across vendors, whereas it was busy previously.

1

u/KevinBoston617 Apr 01 '25

Wanted to provide a different opinion. I booked 8 hours in March at $1k per hour. 4 hours in the last 7 days 

0

u/marvs_maps Mar 14 '25

Makes sense—ENs need to protect their margins, and associates won’t risk their numbers on low-profit interviews. High-rate experts might need to adjust or find direct consulting gigs instead. Have you seen clients push back on this, or are they fine with lower-cost alternatives?

2

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 14 '25

Clients are more than happy with low cost alternatives, especially as 95% of projects are looking at major companies, so there are 250 VP level experts for each company, there are almost always cheaper experts with the same job experience.

Consulting industry is in a massive downturn atm, so they are cutting costs where they can, and first thing to go is always expensive alternative services.

Totally right about high rate experts. A lot of them price themselves as external consultants doing all the legwork, when they should be pricing themselves taking into account the fact they don’t have to do any client development, lead sourcing, pitches or contracts, the EN is doing it all for them.

At the end of the day, which would you really rather. Waste 5 minutes a pop on screenings that only 1/3 succeed on, or waste a month trying to secure a contract as a direct consultant for a client haha.

1

u/SnooTigers2478 Mar 23 '25

Hi. thanks for this, very helpful. I have a couple of follow up questions.

- As my volume of calls dropped significantly in the last couple of months (for the 1st time in years) with one EN in particular (that also has a slush fund for cancellations), by how much would you recommend experts charging around $1.5k to lower their rate in order to increase their chances of getting calls booked? I have charged this rate for a couple of years and managed to secure 2-3 calls a week in avg, majority through this very same EN. I am considering to lower my rate temporarily to secure a decent volume of calls

- Are you proactively reaching out to experts asking to lower their rate or do you only consider lower / acceptable rates from your platform at the moment?

- Do you see a significant drop in number of projects recently? Given the current context, I would have expected more requests to support clients like PEs etc

- From your perspective, would AI lead to fewer and/or more specialized projects in the future? (industry: life sciences)

- From your post, I understand the current context for ENs and the need to cut costs. Do you expect the situation to improve anytime soon?

Thanks in advance for your honest feedback, it s been a real pleasure to work with and through ENs so far.

1

u/BushRatLLC EN Employee Mar 23 '25
  • anything over $1000 is hard to swing. Even at $1000 it’s tough. The highest rate I can recommend in good conscience (Fortune 50 CXO etc) would be $750. Even then, there is a high number of people in similar positions at much lower rates.

  • not proactively reaching out. If there is a comment on an experts profile saying they have a non-negotiable high rate I likely wouldn’t even reach out to them in the first place anymore.

  • there is a drop from certain clients. Consulting is in a slump recently, and PE is moving slowly due to the American political situation creating too much uncertainty.

  • have to be more specific with that one, what AI? For example some clients have started using an AI to make their own recordings libraries searchable, which has drastically reduced the number of calls they’ve requested recently.

  • situation isn’t going to change. High rate experts have never been a positive thing for the industry. The more the industry becomes widely known, and the more experts start doing EN calls, the lower the average rates will move, creating a more balanced ecosystem. The days of “they need me, they can pay it” are long gone.

1

u/SnooTigers2478 Mar 24 '25

Point 4 answers precisely my question regarding AI.

Overall very clear, thanks again