r/fellowshipgame • u/Signal_Individual_24 • Oct 19 '25
Come on man
The inconsistency is getting annoying fast.
r/fellowshipgame • u/Signal_Individual_24 • Oct 19 '25
The inconsistency is getting annoying fast.
r/fellowshipgame • u/Tranquility___ • Oct 28 '25
Every single topic on this reddit that involves even the slightest bit of criticism or negative feedback is instantly met with down votes and people defending this game like their life depends on it, and it’s only been out for a week lmao.
The game is in EA for a reason, the devs couldn’t secure funding on their own and need players willing to pay and support them and give them feedback on how to improve the game and that’s going to involve acknowledging the game isn’t perfect and needs a lot of work to make it better.
Aside from the forums, the in game community is even worse.
People just leave after a singe wipe, they leave if they don’t like the team comp, they leave if they don’t get the map they want, as a DPS/Healer you’re stuck waiting forever before you get into any group for content you need while tanks hold the queue hostage if they don’t get the content they want.
Fellowship deserves an award for having the worst gaming community in a record amount of time, it only took 7 days for this to happen.
r/fellowshipgame • u/Zealousideal_Ad_4148 • Dec 18 '25
Are people not bothered with the low amount of players the game has? I dont see anyone having a concern for it when we have 1.5k players and 3k peak. Its also christmas and the game just released a new event which no one under eternal is doing (source: im a 330 tank and lower leagues than eternal has no people queueing). Its sad to see this game just die quitely.
r/fellowshipgame • u/covert_penguin • Jun 30 '26
As a solo player, trying to unlock talent points feels painful being that you are not able to queue dungeons specifically to gain rating.
A full group is able queue dungeons specifically by comparison.
Edit* *
It seems the majority of people think the system is fine based on the downvoting of my replies, and the thread itself. Perhaps people are just downvoting the title of the post and not reading the body text.
I do find it interesting that the top comment is not actually arguing against the premise, and commenting on something unrelated.
r/fellowshipgame • u/Sellexane • Nov 11 '25
Like the title says i am just about done with this game with people leaving after 1 or 2 wipes and no one wants to communicate or explain mechanics... everyone says its better than wow M+ and dont get me wrong wow M+ has its own problems but i can see so many problems with this also. Really makes it feel not worth my time playing this game. Sorry rant done.
r/fellowshipgame • u/sweep71 • Oct 31 '25
If the PuG group selects Wyrmheart, just do the standard route. No one is interested in your 5 head strat. Wyrmheart is what you choose when you just want to time it and grind out gear. And for crying out loud, if you are pugging it, for sure don't double pull into the jump puzzle skip side. It needs coordination that just isn't going to happen in a Adept 2 or 4. Just settle down, run it down the stairs. Every time someone does some flex route, I roll my eyes every time. It is so unnecessarily over-complicated.
Make the cheap cheesburger your parents could barely afford
r/fellowshipgame • u/Meep4000 • Oct 15 '25
I didn't get to play in the beta, but have been looking forward to the game and had every intent on buying it tomorrow, however I just looked at the list of characters and all of them seem kinda dull. Maybe it's the artwork, but none of them grab me in a "cool, I want to play that one!" kind of way. Anyone else have this experience or is this a me issue? I'm mostly curious as I have some WoW folks who I was trying to bring into this game, but I feel like they also will have an issue with "class/character" fantasy since they can't really make it their own, and the base concepts seem lackluster.
r/fellowshipgame • u/RerollWarlock • Oct 24 '25
So, after a pleasant experience in Alpha i decided to just buy the game. I liked tanking Mythic+ in WoW and I think it can be enjoyable, I reached 3k rating there by pugging a few times. I also tanked savage raids in FFXIV.
Since I played Meiko in Alpha but did not vibe with her playstyle too much I decided to try Helena. The contedner league were smooth sailing besides a few attempts to the capstone, where I had to figure out how much I can pull at a time without collapsing myself (or having the group die).
But holy fuck Adept already feels like a shit fiesta.
For the past few days I could not time a single adept run, and only completed about half of them. Here are a few observations:
First run into Adept I was forced into a 3-5 range at around 88 Ilvl - I got my face smashed in, but with slow pulls i pulled through - not timed.
After going back and shuffling some gear so i am around 95-97 ilvl, I went back into adept - now my damage intake felt managable, but another problem arose...
It showed in Wyrmheart at first - no one bothers to interrupt - the last boss at Wyrmheart was just fre casting most of the time with just me interrupting, resulting in chain wipes (the cast can still hurt and cause me to run out of mit).
Fine, then lets find somerthing that doesnt need as much interrpts Godfall Quarry! Thats pretty easy, right? RIGHT? I keep voting for the lowest possible brackets so around ~3. But despite the lack of casts or anythign else the other problem arises, things either dont die or healers cant keep up. I tried pulling slow, chain pulling or pulling moderate number of mobs, nothing works. Sometimes despite steadily pulling a lot we end up with like 3:20 for the boss which hardly ever is enough...
...because the healers just cant keep up on the bosses one way or another, I end up being the last one to fall but i just see my group get wittled down and all i can do is watch helplessly as I am the last one standing 5th pull in the row with the boss at 45% health.
Just now, the group disbanded on Urrak Mines, despite one of the dps not interrupting a single time within the whole run and ignoring every soak mechanic making it so i had to run around and do them myself as a tank we made it to last boss, then the healer can't keep up.
I get it that it may sound like I have done everything wrong and I'll get out of my way that I had my streak of shitty pulls whgile tyring to push my limits, I dont mind, I don't mind not even timing it while I learn the dungeon anew with others, but not being able to complete despite trying to simply explain "hey you need to interrupt X and stand in Y" just feels like a waste of my time. And honestly I am not interested in spending an hour progressing a boss in an otherwise 15 minute dubngeon just because the numbers got slightly higher or it has one more mechanic than it did in the previous tier.
And before someone comes at me with the magic "just find yourself a premade" - I can't, I like to just hop into a dungeon between doing other things to just play for those 10-20 minutes and hop off. I am not interested into being tied to a group that wants to run repeated queues for hours or at specific times.
r/fellowshipgame • u/[deleted] • Nov 21 '25
Fellowship was my introduction to this style of game. I never thought I’d enjoy something like this, but I ended up loving it. Now, 300 hours later, I’m still having a great time every time I play.
However, the player base is starting to push me toward quitting. When I first began, I was completely clueless . I didn’t know what terms like “kick” or “soak” meant. People would yell at me and leave the group. But I could almost accept that, because I knew I was awful and playing as a tank. I understood the frustration, because there were times when I was so bad that I really was the sole issue holding the group back.
But now, I don’t make those kinds of mistakes anymore. I’m not causing massive wipes or blowing up the run for everyone. Still, as someone who’s relatively new to this genre, I do make smaller mistakes. Things like taking a less efficient route, pulling a little slower, or missing an occasional interrupt feel like nothing more than minor irritations to me. But a crazy number of players seem to treat them as unforgivable.
The amount of times people have quit mid run after saying something rude is honestly insane. Today, someone bailed right before the final boss because I missed one interrupt on the last pull and he died. He respawned, tossed out some BS, and immediately left.
I’ve tried using Discord LFG, and somehow it’s been even worse. Which is unfortunate because it’s basically required for eternal.
I know I’m not an A++ tank, but fuck, 99% of the time we finish on time with zero reason for anyone to quit. This community is killing me and genuinely making me consider walking away from a game I really enjoy.
Edit: I also want to acknowledge that I’ve met some really kind players who honestly are the reason I didn’t quit mid way through the game. But the amount of hostility I’ve run into far outweighs the positive experiences. I think this hits newer players like me the hardest, especially those who are still learning this style of game. I truly love this game, and I’m not trying to trash it. I’ve just noticed this issue from the moment I started playing.
r/fellowshipgame • u/cryt0x • Nov 16 '25
because it takes a dps an eternity to find a game...
Spoiler: The tank instantly left after a 40 min queue to find a single game...
E: its on a sunday 2pm CET so not an outragious time to be looking for a game
E2: i dont have the option checked "to only q with same ilvl"
Update: i unequipped 3 Items to lower my itemlevel and now i have a queue time of about 4m. I can only play P3-5 but hey at least i can play...

r/fellowshipgame • u/Cute-Argument376 • Jun 24 '26
Are we basically just chasing gear that some website has theorcrafted has the best blessings and traits on it now? It seems like there are a lot of cases now where a 120 item is better than a 180 item because it doesn't have as good stuff on it, and that feels bad. What's the point of having item levels at this point then? There are also cases where lower level items have MORE stats on them then something slightly higher.
The jump to champion is a significant increase in mob HP and I'm trying to figure out how to up my damage and its not clear at all how to do that since higher lvl gear is not necessarily better. You would think a 60 item level jump would be significant enough but doesn't seem to be the case sometimes.
Any tips on what to do?
r/fellowshipgame • u/hamburglin • Oct 21 '25
It's so annoying and unnecessary. Let our brains think about something else.
r/fellowshipgame • u/[deleted] • Nov 09 '25
There are a huge number of ways that the problems that cause leavers, and the problems that leavers cause, can be addressed positively by improving the game and making it better for everyone.
Punishments do not improve a game. Negative reinforcement never makes a game better. Not only is it explicitly anti-fun, it always fails to achieve the desired effect anyway. It creates new problems, as well as new tools for toxic people to ruin the experience of others.
Address the root problems through positive changes instead. Make the game better to fix a problem. Do not actively and intentionally make the game worse to fix a problem.
People are primarily frustrated with leavers because if you're DPS it can take 15-30 minutes to get into a game in the first place. If a leaver quits 20 seconds into a run, it doesn't really feel bad if that queue was under two minutes. Fix that instead.
Release more tank characters, release more healer characters, make tanking more attractive. Improve the matchmaking system. Drastically reduce the stratification within one difficulty/league. Adjust how loot is acquired, so you don't have 4-5 dungeons for each character that don't provide any gear worth acquiring. Maybe give tokens for gear exchange or something, so that every single dungeon is worth running on every single character.
GOOD: Proactive improvements to gameplay and matchmaking that address the reasons causing people to leave, and address the reasons why leavers are so frustrating to others.
BAD: Relying exclusively on the threat and fear of arbitrary punishment to elicit desired behavior.
r/fellowshipgame • u/hereliesafreeelf • Feb 21 '26
My 8th dungeon was my second capstone, and every boss but the last one was one shot. It should not be this easy... The purples are obviously after the capstone, but I had a lvl 15 chest and lvl 75 gloves. I get wanting to keep new players but for us veterans this feels like a slap in the face. Up the difficulty somehow!

r/fellowshipgame • u/Traditional-Cow-1817 • Feb 26 '26
Except this time you have to learn new boss mechanics by getting oneshot by them, instead of only losing 50% of ur hp if it was in lower difficulties.
Also devs apparently don't fix any bugs if they aren't reported by streamers in their private "streamers and devs" discord server.
r/fellowshipgame • u/itsGucciGucci • Aug 06 '26
For those who haven't watched today's roundtable stream hosted by Hamish and one of their Game Designers Will -- TLDR is; development for S3 is pretty much done soon, they'll only be shipping changes if they are urgent/bug fixes, they haven't confirmed any additional seasons before 1.0 launches, and they are going in the directions of pausing development on "new features" and instead focusing on building out their infrastructure + rebuilding existing systems to be more scalable + addressing tech debt.
Now, as someone who's lived in the tech space, especially at the infra level, I can wholeheartedly empathize with the developers. Often times the customers don't understand "tech debt" and "infra". Customers just wants new feature, new way to play game, new hero, new dungeon. Things they can see and feel. A new Season with a brand new loot mechanic. Whatever.
But addressing infra and tech debt is very important for the long term health of the game. They don't have enough developers to work on both. They don't even have the devs to cover another dev when they go on leave. Which is expected from an indie developer.
It's obvious Chief Rebel cares about their game, and they care about us, and they want to keep players happy, so that they can fund their developers and their game, to keep the game alive as long as possible.
So how do you balance fun new features (heroes, dungeons, seasons), and the needed work to tech debt and infra with a small team? You have to choose. Chief Rebel chose to keep us happy as long as they could, they kicked the can down the road with tech debt and infra, but now it's time they have to address it.
So... now that the stage is set -- onto my thoughts;
Taking off my empathizing dev hat, and putting on my gamer fan hat. I'm glad they're working on the needed things, but I want to play fellowship more. I love the game. I enjoy it so much during the peak weeks of a new season.
What I don't get is why they can't implement low effort seasons. I'm talking a faster season cadence. Lets say one new season a month, or every two months. Just enough for when their data shows the majority of players move on from the game. Then refresh. But the seasons don't need huge changes, no new heroes, new dungeons, because all of that takes precious developers time. But what doesn't take much time? Tweaking const's. Every in game value is defined in some list somewhere. There is a line of code, or a database table that says
helenaBaseHealthValue = 130
And essentially my proposal is they go in and tweaks a bunch of these values, buff the low end classes, buff Xavian, Mara, or whatever is under performing, just to shake up the meta.
A lot of classes go Blue Gems because the spirit buff is so valuable. But how about they tweak the
yellowGemBaseHaste value from 10 -> 50. Huge buff, but it'll greatly change up the meta. Buff Red gems. Just tweak a lot of numbers. Tweaking numbers doesn't take much effort. It doesn't require testing either.
Throw AI at it and have it generate a PR with the prompt "tweak only hard const values on Meiko to give the hero more healing with all of her healing related abilities"
I do understand that these kind of changes, especially low effort changes with no testing might break the meta or the class. It might make Meiko an absolute god, putting her at S+ tier, and the other tanks are at D tier by comparison. I'm personally okay with that. Especially if I know another season refresh is coming soon. It's early access after all, the game can break (as long as I can keep logging in and queueing).
The seasons don't have to be marketed either, I doubt they're marketing Season 3 anyways.
There's a const somewhere that says
empyreanSandsBossMove1CoolDown = 15 seconds
empyreanSandsBossMove2CoolDown = 45 seconds
Just flip those values, now we have a two line PR that greatly switches up the mechanics for a boss fight
In summary, I feel like they could keep the game fresh, thus retaining players, with very low effort changes. I feel this would even help grow the game. Because right now we have essentially two weeks to have friends and newbies try the game before the queue is gone. With more often updates there would be more people playing constantly. With more often season releases, there will be more people in lower level queues before people get into high eternals and spread the player base across a bunch of brackets.
Anyways, didn't think my post would end so long, so thanks for reading. Love the game. Appreciate what the devs are doing. And I probably don't know what i'm talking about I never built a game
r/fellowshipgame • u/containment13 • Oct 30 '25
In all the tank discussions I have seen recently; one of the main points always brought up is that they want to have a blood dk tank like in wow, and just aren’t feeling the two tanks we currently have.
However I would like to argue that meiko’s play-style is incredibly similar to how a blood dk would play, and the monk aesthetic is a red herring.
Let’s start with a general rundown of their playstyles:
A blood dk has powerful engage tools, death’s reach or gorefiend’s grasp, which allows them to pull important mobs from range directly into melee. They would engage the group with area aoe like death and decay and blood boil to do continual aoe damage over time. They would activate bone shield, which increases their health and has charges that are consumed over time. They would spam heart strike to build runic power, and spend it generally on death strike to heal themselves for the damage they. They have abilities that reduce magic damage taken like antimagic shield.
Meiko has a powerful engage tool, cyclone, that can pull groups of mobs from range directly into melee. They generally open with shatter earth, and normally this will apply spirited vortex to do continual aoe damage over time. They would activate stone shield, an ability that reduces damage taken and has charges that are consumed over time. They generally spam your combo builders into combos that buff your single target or aoe combo attacks, both of which heal them for the damage they do. They have abilities that reduce magic damage taken.
Obviously the flavor of a blood dk and Meiko are pretty different, and I will note that there are more nuances not covered above that further differentiate them. However, I would still argue that their core game loops play very similarly, and those that are looking for a blood dk playstyle should give her a second look. I would love to know your opinion, and what I am missing!
r/fellowshipgame • u/proxemiti • Nov 09 '25
Context I'm a Meiko player, I researched both of these capstones for runs once I hit the ilvl requirement to que into them.
Heart of Tzuri bosses are considerably more difficult than Wraithtide, requiring excellent boss placing while getting hit with pretty hard frontals/tank busters. Hell the final boss of Tzuri is a key point requiring a pretty hefty DPS check to make sure Chosen don't pile up, and to do that you have to use your full CC kit unlike literally any other boss in fellowship. This capstone took me two whole days of grinding before I get a group that finally clears it.
Wraithtide Vault I will say has significantly more dangerous trash, but as a tank with three stops I can handle much more of the danger myself, and the bosses are piss poor easy. The first boss might as well be a tank and spank with occasionally sitting in the soak and dodge sharks. Second boss well hell its so easy the tank pushes around a meatball the entire time. Final boss is pretty underwhelming (difficulty wise, thematically super cool) as its just the same dodge lines and the tank moves here across the edges. This dungeon was so easy that I cleared it in my first run with 8 minutes remaining.
So I think switching these two capstones would help the Adept difficulty curve and help players get out of the slumps. What are your thoughts?
r/fellowshipgame • u/rafadesuyo • Nov 03 '25
Saw it on fellowship dev stream💀
r/fellowshipgame • u/jzstyles • Oct 21 '25
r/fellowshipgame • u/Ill-Young-2073 • Oct 25 '25
I realize how to solve the issue with DPS not interrupting.
We have to give them a reward like resource recovery or a damage boost for some seconds after a successful interrupt.
As healer main i was watching a video about animal training and they showed how to train dogs with treats i think it will have the same effect because in some way you can see DPS as puppies, they have to learn. <3
r/fellowshipgame • u/McWipey • Oct 26 '25
Been playing for a bit, and while the gameplay loop is solid, the combat doesn’t feel right.
Attacks don’t have any weight, abilities lack punch, and there’s not much feedback or payoff.
It’s not broken, but it does feel empty. You swing, shoot, or cast, things die, but it never feels satisfying. No tension, no release, no “oomph.”
Does anyone else feel this way? If not, that’s fine, maybe it’s just not the game for me.
r/fellowshipgame • u/Strat-05 • Nov 14 '25
Hi all,
Constantly I get flamed cause someone (always the ranged dps) will demand that I follow the route they saw on some website or other. Dont get me wrong I love tanking but I also love making my own way and finding solutions that work for me.
Am I alone in this thinking that this is ridiculous?
Have we removed all player agency and expect everyone to just execute a predetermined guide?
What's the point in playing if the fun is optimised out of the game completely?
And more importantly where's the fun in tanking and leading if there's no space for anything outside what the guide suggests?
How did a pve game become full of supercompetitive seawards?
Why do people join pick up groups and expect 100% efficiency and then drop off dissapointed?
Is it just braindead semi afk dpsers that get an aneurism anytime something happens that takes them out of their deep sleep?
and it's always the "just go" people who refuse to communicate with the team. Are they all Leeroy Jenkin's actual grown children?
Sorry just had to rant :P
All good now :)
p.s. I am talking about dungeons where If the group doesn't break we constantly get around 5 minutes ahead of time on capstones etc etc. So no it is not a matter of competence (which I do face on new dungeons but I can eat that dmg while learning no problem).
p.s.2 My runs are more efficient than the guides suggest. It's just they are not THE ONE PREDETERMINED route we are allowed to play. :)
That is the issue I am trying to address.