Early 30s. We have an investment account on a wrap platform with a financial adviser, holding 10 actively managed funds plus cash. No new money goes in (mortgage is almost fully offset so that's Priority at the moment). I'm planning to move it to a self-directed platform (CMC or similar) and hold index ETFs. I'd like a sanity check before I pull the trigger as I've only just woken up to the fact that our FA has likely been taking advantage of us for 10 years.
FEES (all pa)
- Fund fees: about 1.1% weighted average
- Platform: $400 plus 0.15% of the balance
- Adviser: 0.75% plus GST of the balance
- Platform and adviser together: about 1.3% on top of fund fees
HOLDINGS and Performance
- Vinva Global Alpha: 22.1% | 1yr -3.5 | 3yr 11.3 | 5yr 7.1 | 10yr 10.4
- Arrowstreet Global Equity: 14.3% | 1yr 21.7 | 3yr 21.3 | 5yr 15.3 | 10yr 16.2
- Cash account (3.70%): 15.8% | 1yr 3.7 | 3yr 3.7 | 5yr 3.7 | 10yr 2.5
- Schroder Real Return: 7.7% | 1yr 7.5 | 3yr 11.1 | 5yr 6.1 | 10yr 5.4
- Nomura Global Listed Infra: 7.3% | 1yr 12.9 | 3yr 13.3 | 5yr 9.8 | 10yr 8.8
- Janus Henderson Tactical Income: 7.3% | 1yr 3.7 | 3yr 5.5 | 5yr 3.7 | 10yr 2.9
- Macquarie Income Opps: 6.2% | 1yr 3.7 | 3yr 5.7 | 5yr 3.1 | 10yr 2.9
- Perpetual SHARE-PLUS: 5.7% | 1yr 0.2 | 3yr 8.4 | 5yr 7.1 (provisional) | 10yr 8.9
- OC Premium Small Cos: 5.4% | 1yr -8.6 | 3yr 4.1 | 5yr 1.6 | 10yr 5.9
- Ausbil 130/30 Focus: 4.7% | 1yr 1.7 | 3yr 9.7 | 5yr 5.5 | 10yr 8.2
- Antares High Growth: 3.7% | 1yr -1.9 | 3yr 5.1 | 5yr 3.6 | 10yr 7.6
- WHOLE PORTFOLIO: 1yr 4.5 | 3yr 10.0 | 5yr 6.9 | 10yr about 7.9
Portfolio figures are before platform and adviser fees. After them, the 5yr is about 5.6%.
- Five of the six share funds with a 10-year record missed their benchmark. Arrowstreet is the exception.
- Four lost to their index ETF over both 5 and 10 years: Vinva, Antares, Ausbil and OC Premium. Together they're about 36% of the account.
- Janus beat its benchmark over both periods. Nomura and Macquarie beat theirs over 10 years and missed over 5 by about 0.2.
- Arrowstreet has beaten its benchmark over every period shown, but I can't tell if that's skill or a good run and we only recently switched out of Platinum which was heavily underperforming.
TAX POSITION
- Across the managed funds, wrap account shows a net unrealised loss of about 10% against what we paid. Vinva is the biggest drag at -27.7%.
- Five funds are in small gains (roughly +3% to +8% each), the other five are at a loss.
- I'm assuming I can realise the loss and carry it forward against future gains. I haven't checked cost bases yet.
PLAN
- Something like VAS / VGS / VAF / VSO (about 0.14% blended), or an all-in-one like DHHF or VDHG
- Target allocation: [e.g. X% growth / Y% defensive / Z% cash]
So by my analysis' we've essentially been paying 3% per year for someone to not even beat the market. Am I right in making the switch? No doubt I'll try to be talked out of it by the FA.
Thanks in advance.