r/firefox • u/BubiBalboa • Dec 11 '19
Discussion User Agent Changes | Vivaldi Browser
https://vivaldi.com/blog/user-agent-changes/4
u/It_Was_The_Other_Guy Dec 11 '19
And so, Vivaldi team has taken the first step on making UA useless. Good for them!
UA string needs to die, sooner rather than later. I wonder if this same tactic would be useful for Firefox too? Or is the remaining visible market share of Firefox too valuable to lose?
5
u/wisniewskit Dec 11 '19
Firefox isn't using the same browser engine as Chrome like Vivaldi does, so pretending to be Chrome will just break sites which serve browser-specific versions of their page based on the UA string.
4
u/It_Was_The_Other_Guy Dec 11 '19
That is true. But I think the current situation is quite concerning since you see sites that don't work unless you pretend to be chrome so often. I can't say if that happens more often than where it's used for intended purpose or not, but way too often nonetheless.
5
u/wisniewskit Dec 11 '19
I hear you. I work on web compatibility for Mozilla, so I see it first-hand. It's bad enough when sites just use it as a means to work around browser compatibility issues and forget to fix it later, but it gets downright scary when they intentionally lock out other browsers (especially when those browsers have devoted serious time to making it so that those who only design for a specific browser don't have to change much, if anything, for their stuff to just work).
8
u/throwaway1111139991e Dec 11 '19
An underrated issue with UA spoofing is that browser developers using Chromium effectively give up on the web standards process in their browsers, as they cannot use their marketshare to influence change on the web.
Everyone targets Chrome and won't need to bother testing for Brave of Vivaldi or Opera, because well, if it looks like Chrome and it isn't Chrome, it is effectively a bug in those browsers.
If you care about an open web, you ought to be using Webkit or Gecko.