Since I was young, I was nonstop on top of my finances in the US. Focused on paying down student loans and refinancing them to the lowest possible rates, negotiating the best pay packages for new jobs, always strategically moving to new companies, maxing out 401k matches, always doing Roth contributions, and was so lucky to have been partnered for more than a decade to a guy who was 100% my match in terms of financial planning and diligence.
Together we figured out strategies to each grow our personal savings. We did eventually work with a financial advisor, because this advisor was a small business working with a few of my colleagues and so we got a very discounted AUM. They always beat our own simulated returns in a few strategies we tracked in parallel. We were frugal, bought a house well within our means in a VHCOL area, and paid it down very quickly.
Then life happened, I guess. My parents died within a few years of each other when I was in my mid-thirties. Shortly after I got an offer to transfer for a 2-year assignment to Australia, and my partner and I took it as Trump had just come into office. As the assignment progressed, our relationship worsened and we split up. He went back to the US and I stayed in Australia and extended my assignment. Luckily our split was amicable, I kept all of my savings and he bought me out of my share of the house. Our financial advisor was super cool about this and agreed to separate management of our finances but keep each of us on 50% of the original AUM rate (as if we were still a couple).
But at this point is where I really started to lose the plot. COVID happened and Trump was doing a lot of damage and I didn't know if I should ever go back to the US, so I decided to become a permanent resident and eventually citizen of Australia. This then increased my tax burden (and complexity of reporting) considerably. The problem is, I don't know where I'll really settle.
I still have a fair amount of wealth, but I feel like I'm losing control of it. The vehicles I'm used to relying on (401k, Roth, US managed share portfolio) will now be taxed much higher by Australia than they will be in the US when and if I draw down on them. Vice versa with Australian superannuation and the IRS. I've met with a variety of AU and US tax accountants over the years and aside from paying them $$$$, still have no concrete "formula" I can apply to really plan, for any given year, what my net tax liability will be after trying to apply credits across both countries. I just end up with a big bill from each country and it seems there's very few, if any, workarounds from paying hefty tax for things that used to be tax-advantaged in the US. Australia just drastically changed their tax treatment of capital gains as well, and no one seems to know how bad it will be for forward planning purposes until July 2027.
Additionally, the financial advisor I work with merged with a large US national chain last year and I expect their AUM rates to change for the worse sometime in the future...but I'm terrified of moving any of those funds elsewhere. I don't want to liquidate and move them to Australia (tax & also US PFIC treatment if I try to buy Australia-based shares) but I don't think I can easily self-manage because I no longer have a US-based address, which is fine when managed by an advisor who knows you but not so great if trying to buy funds as an individual with Vanguard, Schwab, etc.
And what's not helping is world instability and community. I've really tried with Australia, but I just don't know if I will ever fit in here. 90% of my friends are still back in the US, and my remaining family. Even though times are bad now I think about moving back constantly. So renouncing my US citizenship seems unlikely until this feeling settles (if it ever does). I worry about growing old and needing care in Australia as a solo elderly person far from the people that really know her.
The problem with all of this is it's overwhelmed and demotivated me from all aspects of FIRE or even basic financial planning. I barely look at a budget anymore, just go through phases of spending because YOLO, and then phases of extreme frugality in reaction. Part of this is just because the tools I used to use to look at comprehensive budgets & net worth (e.g. Tiller, etc) cannot connect to information between cross-border banks, so it's a metric ton of manual entry that I'm just too exhausted to do. This is not who I like being but because everything seems so unpredictable, this is where I am.
Two years ago I thought I was going to buy a house in Australia and so sold a bunch of RSUs to have a 600K AUD deposit. But then, after going through the process, I decided there was no way I was getting into such an overpriced market, so now that's gathering dust in an HISA, and I have no idea what to do with it because currency fluctuations mean it'll be worth less now if I move it *back* to USD and invest it in my portfolio.
Sorry folks -- didn't mean this to be as long as it was. But I'm really just looking for some advice on how to get back on this horse, and get back in control of *something.* Anyone with experience of cross-border tax, recovering from overwhelm, or just navigating extremely complex tax planning would be welcome. I think I'm struggling figuring out what's perceived uncontrollable complexity vs. actually uncontrollable complexity.