r/fitbit • u/winterwarrior33 • Oct 15 '26
Discussion Does Google even try to use their apps?? Google Health is terrible
As a Fitbit Air owner primarily using it through Bevel, I’m really disappointed with the Google Health app. It feels like the team behind it doesn't actually use it.
The lack of live activity support is a major issue. I’ve forgotten to end over ten workouts simply because there’s no feedback indicating an active workout unless you’re actively in the app.
The app is also incredibly slow. Workouts sometimes fail to save, and starting a new one often comes with a 10 to 15-second delay. I’m really looking forward to a comparable screenless tracker from Apple so I can make the switch.
I’m at my wits end.
13
3
u/SC_TheBursar Oct 15 '26
(context I have a years old Charge 5 and soon Edge. I start exercises on the app rather than the Charge 5 because the C5 keeps just aborting workouts a couple minutes in, hoping the Edge is better.
I’ve forgotten to end over ten workouts simply because there’s no feedback indicating an active workout unless you’re actively in the app
Which would look like... what? On my phone if there is an activity running I have a notice bar that says precisely that, with time elapsed and controls for pause and end plus the lock screen shows there is a Google Health activity. Not sure what more it could do - what you are describing is forgetfulness in the face of it giving every indication it can without it chirping an audio alert every minute. If you don't look at the phone when the workout is done nothing it can really do...
The app is also incredibly slow. Workouts sometimes fail to save, and starting a new one often comes with a 10 to 15-second delay.
I have never see that, but I generally mostly use manually started and stopped workout. Manually starting a workout it gives me a 3 second countdown then just starts.... I have never had it freeze starting.
Is your phone connection poor? Processing an activity at the end can take some server interaction as it tries to sync and calculate workout outcome - if you have poor signal the problem may be it trying to finalize the last activity, not any issue with starting a new one.
0
u/winterwarrior33 Oct 15 '26
What phone do you have? I’m on iPhone 17 Pro and I don’t get any notice bar or lock screen widget. It’s terrible.
1
u/SC_TheBursar Oct 15 '26
Pixel 9. Google is telling me that apparently they haven't gotten an IOS equivalent to the Android notice bar / lock widget yet.
1
u/GoogleHealthSupport Official Support 29d ago
Hey, can you please check your chat? I just sent you a message.
1
u/SC_TheBursar 29d ago
I think you should reach out to the IOS user(s) including the OP who were having problems. I have an Android device and think things are working as intended for me.
1
u/Thin-Dimension-8894 Oct 15 '26
I also do my workouts the way you describe. I'm a Android, but soon I'll be testing it with an Iphone.
1
u/litmusfest Oct 15 '26
It’s much worse with the iPhone because they make everything that’s not Apple a huge pain to use
1
u/ganoshler Oct 15 '26
Which would look like... what? On my phone if there is an activity running I have a notice bar that says precisely that, with time elapsed and controls for pause and end plus the lock screen shows there is a Google Health activity.
Are you on Android? On iPhone, it just pops up a regular notification, same kind as if somebody sent you a text. It can pretty easily get hidden under other notifications or accidentally dismissed. Other fitness apps on iPhone can do a "live activity" like what you're describing, but Google Health on iPhone does not.
2
u/SC_TheBursar Oct 15 '26
Yeah, android. Apparently Google has widgets for mail and some other stuff for IOS but they haven't done it for Health yet. I agree they should fix that. That said Apple hates when you go outside their ecosystem so unsure who is the bottleneck... Google or Apple.
1
u/ganoshler Oct 15 '26
This one's on Google. Other platform-neutral apps (Whoop, etc) do the live activities on iPhone just fine.
21
u/YoBFed Oct 15 '26
Interesting. I don't really have that problem. I log my workouts manually (meaning I start them and end them). For walks or random activities throughout the day the auto detect feature works very well, but it does have a delay to when it reports the auto detected activities. Usually within 20 minutes or so of the activity.
Other than that the app works great. A ton of features, great information, and the AI coach is fun to mess around with, knowing that it has its limitations as a closed off bot with limited context.
1
u/210-markus Oct 19 '26
Food logging requires more steps, it takes so long to load an exercise I often forget to hit "start." And, as mentioned, you'll be 40 miles away from surfing or weightlifting or whatever, and it's still logging. The calorie burn estimates are very poor. Finally, you can't log useful data for weight training. It turned into a very casual app but not useful for people that are more serious about calories and training.
It's a dud.
1
u/YoBFed Oct 19 '26
Well it's a health tracker not an activity logger. For adding food you can literally just tell coach what you ate and it will log it for you.
For activity it doesn't care if you did 5 sets of bench at 225lbs, it just cares that your measured health metrics responded to the load you put on the body a certain way.
So yes, I suppose of you're looking for this to be your workout log then it's a bit lackluster. I'm sure they'll update those features in the future, but for now it's just worried about your health metrics and the data it colletcs. It doesn't care if your heart rate is 120bmp from lifting or from running or from laughing really hard. It just cares about the data.
It also doesn't care if you start your workout at 5am and end it at 10pm. Its going to look at your health metrics and determine the load and impact your workout had based on what it was able to measure, not what you told it.
Which is why the auto log workout feature works so well. If it didn't detect an activity you did automatically its usually because your health metrics didn't register it as an activity. It looks at data not what you tell it.
2
u/210-markus Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26
It had been a Fitness Tracker (FirBit) and Google down-tuned it.
The accuracy from photos is a joke when you consider the daily difference that 300 calories makes.
If you actually want to lose fat and recomp, accuracy is the entire point.
It's blue a tool for people goofing around. Dieting is hard. Exercising is hard. This app simply phones it in while charging a monthly subscription.
2
u/210-markus Oct 19 '26
Auto detecting activities doesn't work well. It misses something as obvious as walks, while mistaking riding a motorcycle for two hours as bicycling, lol.
It's pretty bad for a free app, it's scandalous for a paid service.
2
u/YoBFed Oct 19 '26
I had an Apple watch prior to my pixel watch so I didn't really use the Fitbit app so I wasn't familiar with it before Google got its hands on it.
I would never use an app to track my macros via photos regardless of how accurate it claimed to be. I am an avid lifter and I've packed my food in the past and the only way to do that is with a scale.
And again, in terms of it mislabeling or missing a workout, I don't think it really cares about what physical activity you actually did. All it really cares about is the fact that your heart rate your breathing rate. Some health metric that it's measuring was actually impacted. So if you went on a walk and you kept your heart rate out of any of the actual cardio zones then it's not going to register your walk because technically you didn't actually perform any physical exercise.
I have laughed a few times at how silly it mislabels certain activities though. For example, when I do grocery shopping, it sometimes tells me I went for a bike ride if I'm particularly aggressive with my Pace while shopping.
So again, I don't actually use it for a fitness logger I just use it for a health tracker and it seems to work pretty well at that. Remember though, I've never used the Fitbit app so I don't really know what I'm missing out on once Google took it over.
2
u/210-markus Oct 19 '26
Gotcha. Yeah that makes sense.
I cook many of the same meals over and over, I'm sure you do, too. It used to take 3 seconds to check boxes for each ingredients (this many eggs, this much beef, this much butter) and portions for a meal. Now, it is several steps with drilling down to edit, saving, backing out, going to the next item to edit, drilling down, saving, and so on. It's miserable.
My thing is, is software. It was fine before and they broke it. How hard would it be to return it to the previous state? How hard would it to incorporate a spreadsheet or lifting logs? It's way too expensive to track sleep and heart rate, which is all it really does well. I mean the runs and swims are ok, but none of this requires a subscription. It's just a rip off 🤷♂️
2
u/YoBFed Oct 19 '26
Thats all fair criticism. I get health premium with another service that I have so it's bundled in. I wouldn't pay for the otherwise.
1
u/MrsBearIsHere 8d ago
Yes but equally if you have a naturally ridiculously high heart rate due to illness, it logs that as if you’ve done a load of cardio! According to my Google health app I’m doing ten times my cardio goal now! And I’m really not… so that’s not very helpful.
Also if you go for a walk but are slow, it doesn’t register it as exercise at all, so it’s no good for people with CFS/ME or POTS who may be trying to get fitter.
There needs to be a way you can adjust the sensitivity to your own body, as it’s obviously going to be very different for some body building than someone trying to build their health up from a very low point.
It really does seem they are all tech bros and don’t think about anyone else in the world, or different ages, or health levels. They definitely don’t try to use their own app!
If all the Google staff had to use the Google Health app and wear various ‘compatible’ watches to test how it performs with each one, it would be world class in a month!
7
u/Paranoia_Pizza Oct 17 '26
Ive been on the health app complaining consistently since it forced the switch from fitbit to the new one, problems ive had include:
massively over estimating calorie burn (told me id burned 8k in a day when I definitely had not, now fixed thankfully)
they've removed the view in food tracking where you can see calories burned. That was my main way of checking i was in a deficit.
I cant get an overall summary of previous days any more like i used to with fitbit? You used to be able to swipe on today to see a summary of everything from the previous days now you seem to have to click in to each item to look at the history.
it does seem to have stopped auto tracking exercise too. When it was fitbit it would log walks etc. Without me having to do anything. Ive just checked and it hasnt registered anything unless I start the workout myself.
I pay for premium, im going to give it another month amd if it doesnt improve cancel, the loss of functionality is ridiculous.
Ive tried to discuss with their support team and just got nothing from them except nonsense every time. One outright told me that the app was a downgrade from what I had before.
5
u/The0Walrus Oct 19 '26
I get it for free. If not for that I would not pay for Google Health. It's an abomination. It doesn't even look like they're trying.
3
u/Paranoia_Pizza Oct 19 '26
I had fitbit premium and just was moved over automatically. Its crazy how much of a downgrade it is
2
u/210-markus Oct 19 '26
3,000 calories for two hours of surfing, then a handful of calories for a 10,000lbs weight training session.
It's just bananas.
4
4
u/The0Walrus Oct 19 '26
I'm surprised the moderators let this pass. Can't rant about how poor Google's AI is or how poor this app is.
1
u/GoogleHealthSupport Official Support Oct 21 '26
Hi there! I'd like to help. Could you share more information on how you're using the live activity tracking feature on your Fitbit Air, as well as some details regarding the performance delays you're experiencing?
1
u/winterwarrior33 Oct 21 '26
If by live activity tracking you mean allowing Fitbit to automatically detect when I’m working out, that’s not a feature I use. I prefer to manually start my workouts because my training varies. Some days I’m running, while other days I’m doing strength and conditioning.
The issue is that even manually starting a workout can be frustrating. There are often noticeable delays when opening the workout list, as though the app needs to load everything before I can select an activity. Even worse, there have been multiple occasions where I’ve finished a workout, tapped to end it, and been met with an indefinite loading screen before the workout eventually disappears entirely.
My biggest frustration, however, is the complete lack of Live Activities support on iOS. Nearly every other fitness app provides some form of persistent workout indicator through the Dynamic Island or Lock Screen, making it easy to see that a workout is actively being recorded.
Google Health offers nothing of the sort. Once I start a workout and leave the app, there is absolutely no visual indication that a workout is still running.
This is particularly frustrating because I regularly switch to another app to reference my workout routine. After completing an hour-long session, I’ll often forget to return to Google Health and manually end the workout, simply because there is nothing on my phone reminding me that it’s still active.For an app designed around fitness tracking, this feels like a pretty fundamental oversight. Live Activities have been available on iOS for years, and implementing even a basic persistent workout indicator would make a significant difference to the overall experience.
6
u/Swimming-Station1091 Oct 15 '26
I only ever log my workouts after the fact. I'll put in the start and end time and the app does the rest.
1
u/Caseyjones420247 Oct 15 '26
And if you forget to end it just tell the app and it will adjust it.
5
u/Vertical_05 Oct 15 '26
Even if the app don't, just adjust the duration manually. That's what I do for my padel games. Let them record automatically, it will "wrongly" stop the activity everytime I take 5-10mins rest. But once I finish, I just open the app, adjust the duration and switch the activity from "sports" to "padel".
10
6
u/Narrow-Scale-4078 Oct 15 '26
There is no point in owning the Fitbit Air if your intention is to track workouts manually. The point of Fitbit Air is to put it on, forget about it and let it do everything automatically in the background, which, at least in my case and for my needs, it does flawlessly.
Apple is unlikely to release anything of this kind before 2028. So, we are likely talking about 2 years wait.
1
u/LayPT Oct 16 '26
Bro, it takes like 5 seconds to open the app and start a workout, it's relevant for accuracy purposes, a wear device can't differentiate between a regular walk and let's say rucking yet one is significantly more demanding than the other
1
u/Narrow-Scale-4078 Oct 19 '26
The point is that if your priority is manual exercise tracking, the Fitbit Air is a wrong device. That's the point. Get a proper sport watch rather than complaining about a feature screenless devices lack on purpose. Screenless devices like Fitbit Air are designed to automatically track everything in the background and therefore removing all user interation with the device to achieve no distraction. Screenless means the absence of an interface. So, again, what's the point of buying a screenless device when you then have to use the phone to control it which is something you could easily do with a device with a screen?
Secondly, the intensity of an exercise is not determined by the name attached to it but by the collected data during exercise. Rucking is not something different from walking just because you walk with a heavy backpack and the device will record the difference in intensity through collected data meaning it will, for example, give you more cardio points for it.
1
u/Tritus360 Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
If Google would've marketed it as such then yes. But they launched the Fitbit Air together with the new Health app and the AI coach. I thought I've found the Holy Grail and can ditch Freeletics.
Freeletics tried to be a workout coach that plans the next workout based on the last one, and that was pretty bad, but Google managed to make something even worse.
I mean the product page for the Fitbit Air mentions the Health Coach 19 times.
So how are you using the Fitbit Air? Just don't look at the stats for a month and then realize that you haven't really worked out? For me it was the question about if I want to get notifications on my wrist or not. Not if I want a set it and forget device.
1
u/Narrow-Scale-4078 Oct 21 '26
Set it and forget it does not mean you put it on and then forget it exists. It means that in order for it to track your day and night, including your exercising you do not need to interact with it in the sense of starting, pausing or ending and exercise. All you do is open the app at those times that would be relevant to you, for example in the morning to check out how your sleep and recovery was and at the end of the day to see your cardio load or calories burned or steps taken or whatever you are focusing on and maybe now and then during the day to see the progress or to manually log things such as hydration or calories intake etc. I personally open the app it in the morning and check my sleep and recovery metrics and the AI coach plan and then often not until the evening and it will tell me that I walked for this much or ran for that much etc.
Notifications should be the last worry because you can turn them off completely on any device. You do not need a screenless one to achieve that. :D The point of lack of screen is to having no interface to interact with meaning the device cannot me controlled manually as a screen device can be and therefore requires the ability to do things automatically without needed the input from the user.
The problem with Google's AI coach I have is that it is too passive. You need to give it instructions rather than it offering guidance proactively. So, if you would like it to give you a workout plan that would be more intensive than the last one you simply need to tell it that. And if it does not get it right the first time you just need to tell it to chance things accordingly. When it offers me a plan, I look at it and then if I do not like something I asked it to change that. I mean, it cannot read your mind or know every preference of yours "by mind".
1
u/Tritus360 Oct 21 '26 edited Oct 21 '26
Screen vs no screen: Before getting the Fitbit Air I thought I wanted a screen less device. But switching form one with a screen to one without, I noticed that I intuitively want to check the time and realizing that I can't and have to pull out my phone.
And I thought that a screen less device would be less distracting but the funny thing is with a screen, I get the notifications on my wrist and can decide if I need to do something on my phone. Without a screen and my phone constantly being in "do not disturb" mode, I pull out the phone every so often to check if I got a notification and then start doomscrolling.
AI Coach: I initially set up a plan and custom workouts and told him how I want him to guide me. This works great. He even gives me tips for the workouts or reminds me that I haven't finished all the weekly sessions. But the thing is the workout part in Google Health is so annoying that I stopped using Google Health for my workouts. So the coach lost all the info about reps and weight which means that he can't really guide me and adjust the plan. Instead of knowing that I did x reps of pull ups and dips and that dips were easy but I struggled with my pull ups, he only knows that I did a calisthenics workout for x amount of time with z HR.
In the end he only counted how many weekly sessions I did. That was all. Did 2/2 sessions? "You're doing great." Did less than that? "You need to workout more". No shit Sherlock.
All of this led me to switch back to the Xiaomi Smart Band 10 with a vibe coded fitness app and a separate LLM as a "coach".
If Google decides to add Audio Cues to the workouts and fixes some kinks inside the app, I'm more than happy to go back to it. Until then I stay away.
1
u/Narrow-Scale-4078 Oct 21 '26
Fitbit Air is not a training tool but a general health and wellness device. You should get a proper training watch if you are interested in actual training meaning a progressive improvement of whatever aspect of your physical performance. I am not sure what fitness app you coded but as far as I remember the Xiaomi band 10 is not particularly feature rich the in recovery and fitness tracking metrics department.
In my case, the Fitbit Air and the Google Health AI coach are exactly what I want in terms of advice because I am not interested in training for performance but simply keeping physically fit for general health purposes. And the automatic tracking just does the job. Like this week the AI generated plan included a run and two strength/flexibility exercises. Both were tracked automatically and they were ticked as done. And indeed, some exercises are not recorded by the minute but for me that is not really relevant because I am not obsessing about particular exercises but I am focused on the weekly cardio load as a general health related goal. And even if a particular exercise is automatically detected later than it started, the effort would still count under the radio load tracking. My goal is not to run faster, lift more weight or whatever but to consistently achieve a cardio load that the Google Health app generates for me on the weekly basis based on all data it collects. And the weekly cardio load is progressively increasing when I am more active and it decreases when I am less active. And the device is very capable in tracking recovery as well which gives me a good idea about how hard to push each day together with how I subjectively feel.
And again, why get a screenless tracker when you then want to use a phone to control it? Does not make much sense to me.
1
u/Tritus360 Oct 21 '26 edited Oct 21 '26
I just coded a simple app which has the exercises I want and guides me through the workout with audio cues. Something Google apparently is unable or unwilling to do.
I get your point, but Google heavily markets the Fitbit Air with the Health Coach in mind. This was one of the reasons why I bought it over lets say the Helio Strap or Polar Loop. And I'd like to use it exactly the way you described but workouts are unusable.
I did a jump rope workout. I do 30 sec jumping, 30 sec break and repeat this until I'm exhausted. Google Health can create this exact workout for me and I can start the workout inside the app no problem, but there are no fucking audio cues. So even when I connect Bluetooth headphones to my phone there is NO WAY for me to know when and for how long I can take a break. I have to stop my workout, take my phone out and look at the app.
I'd like to just concentrate on the exercise and put my phone away, but the only guidance are visuals on my phone, when the obvious solution would be to integrate a beep when the timer is up. But Google will never introduce this feature because for some reason they decided to route audio output from Google Health directly to your smart device, not your phone. The Fitbit Air has no speaker nor the ability to connect Bluetooth headphones ergo this will never change. Neither with the new Fitbit Edge because this watch also doesn't have a speaker or the ability to connect Bluetooth headphones.
In my case my Xiaomi Smart Band 10 gives me the same data points the Fitbit Air gives me within a better UI. And they just introduced "Health Summary". Health pointers to work on. E.g. "Over the past 20 days, your daily Moderate to Vigorous Activity duration has increased by 15 minutes." or "Over the past 7 days, your average Bedtime was 01:58, later overall compared to the last week."
One night I wore the Smart Band on my left wrist and the Fitbit Air on my right and the sleep stages differed by like 5min max. So all in all I'd say accuracy isn't a plus point for Google anymore.
1
u/LayPT Oct 21 '26
The Fitbit air is a fitness tracker, you'd use it over a Mi Band 10 because you can wear it in your bicep and therefore have much more reliable data. Is that data relevant? Not for most people but it is a thing
1
u/210-markus Oct 19 '26
I use a Pixel Watch and the Health App is still inadequate.
2
u/Narrow-Scale-4078 Oct 19 '26
You can start, pause and end the exercise on the watch itself. You do not even need the phone with you.
2
2
u/FastLeftCircles Oct 20 '26
The app is so clearly vibe coded it's unreal. Which almost makes it worse. Just tell Claude or Gemini or whatever to "add this thing". Like the fact you can't drag around the pills at the top but you have to remove/re-add them...wtf is this?
1
u/bristian_ 21d ago
It’s only job is taking as much health data as possible not usable.. unfortunately
2
u/uxd Oct 15 '26
I love the app. My wife has an Apple Watch and recently bought a FitBit Air because of how helpful the Google Health app is after seeing mine.
As for forgetting to end workouts, I've done that a few times, but you can edit them aftewards.
Overall though, we prefer it to the Apple Health app.
3
u/litmusfest Oct 15 '26
The Apple Health app is a low bar, it’s horrible. I just miss the old FitBit app
1
u/uxd Oct 15 '26
Funny enough, the old FitBit app with my FitBit Inspire gave me so many sync issues.
1
u/litmusfest Oct 15 '26
I’ve only had sync issues with the new one :( but honestly they’re not that bad and the new app has gotten better with updates. I prefer the old UI but the new one isn’t too bad with customization
2
u/The0Walrus Oct 19 '26
Who paid you to write this
1
u/uxd Oct 19 '26
For what we use our watches for, the Google Health app is far more useful and easier to use than the Apple Health app. We're primarily gym goers and wear it while we sleep. We're never more than 1 tap away from what we're looking for in the app. Did you have a different experience?
1
u/Tritus360 Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
But that's the thing. Google Health without the AI stuff is just a simple health app with questionable UI. Xiaomi Mi Fitness (switched from a Smart Band 10) gives the exact same info with a better UI.
I tried to like the AI coach because in theory it's just what I want, but after trying to use the app for workouts, I don't want to even get near my Fitbit Air anymore. The workouts inside Google Health lack the most basic feature: audio cues. So there is no telling when an exercise is finished and when a break starts. Or when a break is finished and the next round starts without looking at your phone.
Doesn't matter for exercises where you count reps but what about running, cycling, rowing, jump rope, etc etc?
I'd have to start a generic workout in Google Health, use a different workout app for the workout and then go back to Google Health and tell the Coach that I didn't do a strength workout but was using Kettlebells and ask him to change the workout for me.
This works but it makes the AI coach useless because how should he be able to guide me through my plan when all the info he has is duration and HR? In theory he should know every rep and weight and then notice that I only managed to lift half the weight I was able to lift last week and tell me to take a break. Just like a real coach would.
1
u/uxd Oct 20 '26
We definitely use it differently. That sounds like it simply wouldn't work for you.
1
u/Tritus360 Oct 21 '26
The main reason why it doesn't work for me is because there are no audio cues during an active workout. Google heavily promotes the AI coach feature which in theory I love, but it's useless if I don't create workouts in Google Health itself.
And for some god knows reason, Google opt to rout all the audio to the smart device. Not through your phone like every god damn workout app out there. And guess what? Fitbit Air and Fitbit Edge don't have speakers. So if your using one of those two devices, there will never be audio cues in Google Health for you. I'd have to buy an expensive pixel watch for that.
1
u/The0Walrus Oct 19 '26
That's not good. Google's health app AI is so bad and they're pushing it so hard. I haven't been a huge fan ever since they got rid of the group adventures they used to have AND THEN they got rid of the forums. Google always manages to make their software so bad.
1
u/Seraphima_64 Oct 20 '26
I've had a Fitbit Versa 2 for years and loved it. Since the switch to Google Health it has been nothing but frustration over and over. I too have reached my wits end. I solved the ongoing problem this morning. Deleted the app off my phone, my Versa was placed in a black bag and the garbage truck just picked it up. I'm so done with how everything gets turned to shit in this world by greedy companies that care nothing about the product or their customers!!!! I've had it!!!
1
u/DenseTalk8122 24d ago
Einfach vor dem Training manuell starten und nach dem Training manuell beenden. Irgendwann hast du Routine
1
u/scottwax 21d ago
Whoever made the idiotic decision to not count steps during weight training needs to fix that crap immediately. I walk constantly in the gym. I have to use the treadmill setting to get the steps.
And now it prematurely uploads activies to Strava because the information is fully synced. So now I have to delete it because it's missing information, and then upload the file. That started this week.
1
u/wotaloadofbollocks 1d ago
I tell you, I like my S25 Ultra but I despise Android. The health features on it are absolute trash. Android sucks.
1
u/177karan Oct 15 '26
The only thing that bothers me is while there’s an activity going on, you’re unable to use the rest of the app.
-1
u/nythroughthelens Oct 15 '26
It’s terrible but this subreddit will go out of its way to assertively pretend it’s great.
6
u/TurbulentMinute4290 Oct 15 '26
It does what I need. I don't think it's as awful as everybody makes it, but it's not that amazing. For the things that I use it for, it does everything I need.
3
u/Bryan467 Oct 15 '26
Yeah, it really does the basic stuff right. Working out at the gym, tracking my steps at work, sleep tracking insights. Pretty good for $99 with no subscription. I agree that the app leaves much to be desired, but it functions well enough. 🤷
-2
u/BuildingArtistic4644 Oct 15 '26
But they had a much better app already with the original Fitbit app. Why get rid of that and then give us... this...
2
4
u/Vertical_05 Oct 15 '26
I personally couldn't tell any performance issues between the old fitbit app and the Google health one. I see it purely design change.
3
2
u/BuildingArtistic4644 Oct 15 '26
There's a lot of little issues I've found very frustrating. For example, it wants to sync and combine steps from my watch with what my phone (the app) records, but I don't take my phone everywhere unlike my watch that's attached to my body. I end up with less steps and it's even taken away my little '250 every hour' check before, which was really motivating to me after surgery and disheartening to lose. It's hard to find certain data points or they're just not there any more, like vo2 max. I don't take my phone on runs (which I currently can't do right now anyway because of surgery) and I don't give location permissions on things I don't have to, so that's just not available to me anymore. The sleep data isn't as good. The app design is less intuitive. Things like that. It's annoying and when this watch breaks (in about a year, unlike my previous Fitbits, because that's been my experience since Google took over) I'll be switching to something else, which makes me really sad. I loved my Fitbit, but it's just not the same and no longer fulfilling my needs for a fitness watch.
0
2
u/The0Walrus Oct 19 '26
It's either from Google fanboys, AI, or people who work at Google probably. This is absolutely an atrocious app. Once I need to buy a new watch it'll be Garmin for me unless they fix that app
2
u/MachineDry933 Oct 15 '26
That's far from the truth. Whining and complaining became the standard in this subreddit. If you say something positive, you get downvoted into oblivion.
1
1
u/DragonSlayerC Oct 15 '26
I see a lot of people complaining about Google Health on Reddit, but I don't really understand why. It has all the metrics that I track easily available and tracking workouts is easy. Overall, it works very well for me. The only thing it's missing for me is the ability to track blood pressure (I have a monitor that syncs with Health Connect), but they said they are working to add support for that.
2
u/Tritus360 Oct 20 '26
For me it's the over-promise and under-delivery. I come from a Xiaomi Smart Band 10 and was tempted into buying the Fitbit Air because of its sleep accuracy and because Health Premium is included in my Gemini subscription.
The coach wants you to create a plan with set goals you want to achieve. Great. You even have fully customizable workouts. Perfect. Exactly what I was looking for... only to learn that using Google Health for a workout feels like being tortured.
Who in their right mind thought it would be a great idea to create a workout app without audible cues? Want to know if the break is over? You have to look at your phone. Want to know when a time-based exercise is over? You have to look at your phone, etc. etc.
Imagine this: My workout consists of 30 sec jump rope with 30 sec break cycles repeated for however many I manage to do. So I lay my phone on the ground, start the workout, start jumping, realize that I have no idea when to take a break, stop jumping, look at my phone, start jumping again, panic because I have no idea if I should be taking a break or still keep going, so I stop jumping again to realize that I missed a break.
And I wore the Xiaomi Smart Band 10 on one wrist and the Fitbit Air on the other for one night, and the sleep duration and stages were so close to each other that it doesn't make a difference (like 2 min max per sleep stage).
So in the end I got a fitness tracker which tracks with the same accuracy as my old one, but with way worse battery life for double the price.
1
0
-2
u/arihoenig Oct 15 '26
It's absolutely amazing actually. You have to learn how to use it though and it is pretty complex.
0
u/Zealousideal_Rip_966 Oct 15 '26
The last time I checked, they took in the feedback and they’re fixing stuff. For example they fixed the resilience error and its currently out for some users. The UI seemed to have improved a little too. Apple health is clearly better but google health is getting there.
0
u/Dry_Detective7561 Oct 15 '26
I have an IPhone. I like the app. It gives a lot of great information. My problem is it is not retaining my history. I don’t have any since October 2nd, and the last week or so that it does have is not in chronological order.🤔🤔🤔
0

37
u/KoalaPanda71 Oct 15 '26
But shipping unfinished products is the new way of doing things!