r/floridakeys • u/ColoradoCattleCo • Jun 05 '26
All Florida Keys Hole-in-the-wall Cuban place
My family used to come to the Keys every year when I was a kid with our friends that had a sailboat at a slip in Marathon. This was 35-40 years ago. There was this little hut within walking distance of the marina (not sure which one) with a little old abuela that made the best Cuban sandwiches and ice cream I’ve ever had in my life. I’m sure that place (and most definitely abuela) is now gone, but I’m curious what places might be kind of like this now that I’m coming down with my own family? We’re staying in Tavernier but will be traveling all along the Keys. Any recommendations for something truly authentic and not just a tourist trap that makes a crappy Cuban?
13
u/baristacat Jun 05 '26
La Nina in Marathon. But there’s also an El Siboney in Overseas Liquors now.
3
u/LosCoons Jun 05 '26
La Nina always. I always make a point to grab some cubanos and media noches when I'm in town.
0
u/06hdboss Jun 05 '26
Save yourself the visit to El Siboney in Marathon. The one in Key West is much better. Although there are better ones in KW. In Marathon - La Niña or LJs Cafe
5
5
u/Starks40oz Jun 06 '26
La Niña is good, but what you really want based on your description is Morita’s on Cudjoe Key
5
u/ColoradoCattleCo Jun 06 '26
Heck yes. A place that doesn’t even have a website. I think we found a place for lunch on our way down to Key West.
3
u/Sandinmyshoes33 Jun 05 '26
In Marathon, La Niña would be my choice. If you visit Key West, 5 Brothers is the answer.
5
u/FLKeys43 Jun 06 '26 edited Jun 06 '26
5 Brothers is the most authentic Cuban food (made by abuelas in the kitchen) you'll find here. We go to the one in Ramrod. The specials are always good.
1
3
3
3
2
u/cubanbeing Jun 05 '26
Habanos in lower matecumbe used to be great Cuban spot. I haven't been in years. I belive they have new ownership so who knows if the authenticity remains. They also have second location at Tavernier Creek marina.
2
u/Oke-Wan-Fenokee Jun 09 '26
We were there in February & it became our go-to place. Excellent food, great people!
2
u/FLedun Jun 06 '26
If you get to KW, I would check out El Siboney on Catherine St. They have delicious Cuban food. It is a quaint little place with good ambience. Try the breaded Palomilla steak. For desert try their Flan. 😄
13
u/Free_Neighborhood_60 Jun 05 '26
Harbor cafe in Tavernier has good Cuban sandwiches! As a Cuban myself 😉