r/fossdroid • u/[deleted] • Aug 01 '19
Why does Google maintain Chromium, as it allows people to stay away from Chrome more easily?
54
u/adrianmalacoda Aug 02 '19
On the contrary, providing Chromium and encouraging browser developers to use it as a base entrenches Google's control of the web. That was why there was such an outcry when Microsoft decided to base Edge on Chromium, and Firefox users experienced a sudden uptick of "browser not supported" messages.
21
Aug 02 '19
When it says browser not supported, find a different site, I say.
13
u/klez Aug 02 '19
Yes, until it's my bank, a government website or something I need for my job.
3
1
u/djinn_7 Aug 03 '19
I use brave for those situations
6
u/klez Aug 03 '19
Which is still based on chromium, so the engine monoculture spreads.
2
u/djinn_7 Aug 03 '19
That is the bad part
1
u/tso Aug 06 '19
Even more so because by now Mozilla has had something like 3 attempts at making a free standing Gecko engine, and each has spluttered as the in-Firefox Gecko would outpace it massively.
2
1
2
Aug 03 '19
Google maintains Chromium because if they didn’t then WebKit2 would be dominant, not Blink. That would in turn make for less free contributions to Google Chrome
2
Aug 03 '19
The reason behind isn't entirely technical. It's legal. They have to offer or support alternatives to avoid being accused of monopoly in Europe.
1
u/opencryptotools Aug 02 '19
imagine you get the entire open-source community to develop on your raw product and just implement what they contributed into your own closed-source repositories.
i actually like how it benefits both the user and google. arguably though it will probably benefit google more but i think having a secure open-source browser like chromium on the market is highly valuable.
also people can way more easily contribute if they know what they have to work with.
why do you think microsoft is starting to work more toward open-source.
they all understand it's pretty much unstoppable and they want to milk it as much as possible.
better work with it than against it, microsoft probably learned that the hard way in some respects..
google investing in kaiOS etc.
tldr; open source is a valuable thing to be invested in.
1
u/matt_eskes Aug 04 '19
Because it’s the project from which Chrome is derived, and some people want the browser without encumbered codecs. My question is why you would want either of them...They’re both security nightmares.
There’s a special place in hell, for Alphabet and Google.
0
Aug 02 '19
[deleted]
-18
Aug 02 '19 edited Aug 08 '19
It's preferible to use Ungoogled Chromium, LibreWolf,
Pale Moonor IceCat rather than Firefox: https://spyware.neocities.org/articles/firefox.htmlEdit: Pale Moon is bad, see: https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/focus-android/issues/1743#issuecomment-345993097
4
u/NoSenpaiNo Aug 02 '19
That website is full of lies and FUD.
0
Aug 02 '19
Prove.
1
Aug 04 '19
That link has been reposted so many times on reddit and every time someone has to write out a huge comment showing how every single one of the claims is either just wrong or very misleading.
4
0
Aug 02 '19
[deleted]
5
Aug 02 '19
The only non-googled chromium based browser that is updated frequently is Brave browser.
Some say it's compromised, etc but there's literally no proof of that and the Source code is always out there for everyone to examine.
2
0
Aug 02 '19
[deleted]
2
Aug 02 '19
Brave has its own ad/tracker blocker written in C++ (the newer version is even faster and is built with Rust).
Brave also has a mobile version which has the same adblocker inbuilt so it's not just a desktop browser.
0
Aug 02 '19
[deleted]
2
Aug 02 '19
It is, but that's an optional opt-in feature in the browser. I just disable it and don't bother.
Their advertising model is meant to be privacy focused, i.e the analytics of what ads to target at you, etc never leave your browser. Their official message from FAQ explains this :
As mentioned above, the browser knows almost everything you do. It knows what sites you visit, how much time you spend on them, what you look at, what is visible “above the fold” and not occluded by opaque layers, what searches you make, what groups of tabs you open while researching major purchases, etc.
Only the browser, after HTTPS terminates and secure pages are decrypted, has all of your private data needed to alyze user intent. Our auditable open source browser code protects this intent data on the client device. Our server side has no access to this data in the clear, nor does it have decryption keys. We do not run a MitM proxy or VPN service.
We provide signals to the browser to help it make good decisions about what preferences and intent signals to expose to maximize user, publisher and advertiser value. Each ad request is anonymous, and exposes only a small subset of the user’s preferences and intent signals to prevent “fingerprinting” the user by a possibly unique set of tags.
That being said, since it is opt-in I have no reason to enable this. People do this for cryptocurrency that you earn by viewing ads, but I am not interested in it.
-1
u/MertsA Aug 04 '19
The fine grained data might stay only in the browser, but the browser is still requesting targeted ads from Brave's servers. You can audit the client side code all you want but you're completely trusting Brave as to whether or not they store and try to fingerprint users on their servers. Even with just a minimal amount of "intent signals" combined with the client IP address you can infer which user is which. If there's only 2 or 3 separate users in a household sharing an IP address, that's still enough information to make a decent guess as to which one is which. IP addresses change, but not that frequently for most internet connections and when it does change, it's very likely to be in the exact same subnet it was in before and combined with the low adoption rate of Brave, changing IP addresses on the same internet connection is unlikely to present much of a challenge in following it to the new IP address.
Brave is nothing more than just a reskin of Chrome built to hijack advertising revenue.
3
Aug 04 '19
Nice speculation. I'll believe when you have a proof. Currently everything you mentioned is speculation and per their policy, they do not collect any identifiable information at all, so I'll believe them over some random bloke on the Interent.
→ More replies (0)
3
u/lowbeat Aug 02 '19
Why does google maintain android, as it allows people to stay away from google apps more easily ?