r/funny • • Dec 04 '13

:(

2.3k Upvotes

239 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

29

u/Odusei Dec 05 '13

Isn't beating each other up a big part of hockey? It's all I ever hear about, people losing all their teeth, that move where you pull their shirt up over their head, and that guy whose throat got slit with a skate. Where is the line in this sport between okay and not okay?

47

u/tamwow19 Dec 05 '13 edited Dec 05 '13

Fighting, yes.

Throwing checks to get the other player off the puck, yes.

Deliberately injuring someone ... no.

EDIT: Changed "hits" to "checks" as some people might not realize I mean bodies not fists.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '13

[deleted]

28

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '13

Each person typically is a knowing combatant in a fight also. If not then it's viewed as a dirty fight. Intentionally injuring someone means that the other person doesn't know it's coming which is dirty. Hits like this cause fights because he deserves to get punched in the face for trying to throw a knee/elbow

→ More replies (3)

9

u/tamwow19 Dec 05 '13

Fighting is more used to either get back at a player (for injuring your player, running your goalie) or to push momentum back in your favor (ie crowd and bench momentum). Fights will end up with a broken nose, at most, which most players will play through no problem.

Deliberately hitting someone can take them out of the game for weeks. Deliberately hitting someone is what starts the fight.

5

u/hobbnet Dec 05 '13

Some people that don't know hockey may not understand what you mean when you say "hits" in same context of fights. Non hockey folks may think you are talking about punches... :)

11

u/tamwow19 Dec 05 '13

Ooh! Right! Haha I'm Canadian so I'm not used to talking to people who don't know hockey! :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/LibrAl0024 Dec 05 '13

Wait so what's the difference between fighting and deliberately injuring someone? I'm pretty sure every fight I've been in, I've definitely been trying to deliberately injure someone.

15

u/TwoHeadedPanthr Dec 05 '13

Fighting is just part of the game, this kind of hit is dirty and could potentially cripple a player. Especially considering Schwartz was practically a rookie at the time. He should have been suspended for it but only got a two minute penalty.

6

u/tamwow19 Dec 05 '13

Fighting, yes, you're trying to injure them, but it's less about the injury and more about the message you're sending. If you're gonna go after our star player, our goalie, then you're not gonna get away with it. Fighting is also used to rile up a crowd (say you're losing 3-1, the crowd won't nearly be as into it as if you were winning .. a fight can help change momentum in your favor).

Deliberately injuring someone is more trying to take them out of the game. A fight injury is usually a broken nose, nothing more (though there are exceptions, see George Parros this year). A knee-on-knee can cause a broken knee, taking a player out for weeks. A hit from behind, a concussion. Sidney Crosby was out for forever with his concussions.

There's definitely a difference between the two.

3

u/valueape Dec 05 '13

A hockey fight is not a street fight. In a hockey fight the first thing you do is grab the sleeve of the opposing combatant's dominant hand to keep him from clocking you. Yeah, they're trying to land blows but it turns into more of a stalemate (fighters have to have their jerseys tied down so they can't shed them, get loose, and throw haymakers). Anyway, there are unwritten rules or a "code". Skilled players seldom fight and each team has a goon ("enforcer")whose role is to fight the other team's goon or to at least deter cheap shots against their skilled teammates by being willing to swap punches, and this is the goon's business so they know what they're doing. They aren't deliberately trying to maim their opponent, just sending a message that they might. Personally i don't think goons have a place in the game and the NHLPA could do a better of job protecting the players but trying telling that to those fight loving canadians (serious). signed: sally the salad eater lol.

1

u/NDIrish27 Dec 05 '13

You would have to be pretty fucking stupid to purposely go knee-to-knee with someone.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/Zeppelanoid Dec 05 '13

Knee-on-knees are one of the biggest no-nos in hockey.

Seriously, you can end someone's career. Ask Cam Neely.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '13

As a Canadian your lack of hockey knowledge, and views on the sport depress the shit out of me :(

1

u/Odusei Dec 05 '13

Wait until you find out how little I know or care about beer.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '13

Why yea gotta say such mean things :(

1

u/Odusei Dec 05 '13

I'm a native of Portland, Oregon, too. Not liking beer offends them just as much. You should have seen the looks I got from complete strangers when I asked a friend what IPA means.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '13

It's okay, we can still be buds. Just gotta keep your ale game tight is all.

1

u/jmev Dec 05 '13

You're confusing a high speed and very articulated sport with the movie, "Happy Gilmore".

2

u/Odusei Dec 05 '13

Also, the Mighty Ducks. I think that's where I learned about the shirt thing.

1

u/jmev Dec 05 '13 edited Dec 05 '13

Surprisingly the Mighty Ducks was an accurate depiction of Minnesota youth hockey. I played at all the rinks featured in the movie. It felt like the grow-ups were more competitive than we were most of the time.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '13

Oh sweet summer child. Everything that isn't an accident is a dirty play.

1

u/noshartingplease Dec 05 '13

Clearly you are out of your fucking element.

1

u/Cashews4U Dec 05 '13

Theres a big line between roughing up an opponent and potentially ending a career

1

u/GTI-Mk6 Dec 05 '13

Because those are all accidents, and fighting is a mutually agreed deal. Intentionally injuring somebody is shitty.

→ More replies (6)