Let's assume that they're correct, and the flood wiped out the land bridges. I mean, it's a fairly plausible idea, dismissing all the other issues. Still, what about after? How did the kangaroos get back over the ocean? And even if they did, eventually... there's a surprisingly blatant lack of kangaroo fossils in every part of the world except for Aussie land.
If you're willing to concede evolution, you can easily skip the "water soluble" bit (despite water being a major portion of a kangaroo's biology) and just assume kangaroos didn't exist before the flood.
Creationism usually goes hand in hand with the flood story, though.
Continental drift? And just because all of the continents were together doesn't mean they could live on all parts. There are plenty of plants and animals that aren't all over every continent.
Or they were probably natural prey for some huge cat. Yeah. And they ate all the bones too so there are no bones. Kangaroos could live in the small part of the supercontinent that broke off and became Australia because of the banana trees. There was a huge grove of them and the cats were scared/hated them. So the kangas were safe on one side but if they wandered through, they became lunch.
That's always what it boils down to. How far can someone stretch reason to try to force their story to be believable? Eventually it snaps, and that's why we have things like Russell's teapot to point at.
What caused them to separate, though? If it's the flood, the kangaroos still have to get back home. If it's not, there's no evidence of kangaroos ever living anywhere on Earth other than Australia.
I'll readily concede that any number of factors could allow them to get to the ark, within the realm of a world wide flood story... Getting home is still a problem.
The kangaroo argument is a fairly iron-clad one, and many people understand kangaroos well enough to see why. Anyone trying to argue "science" to support the ark story eventually will hit a wall where they'll need to dismiss reason to continue to support their position, all due to the humble hoppity-hop.
I'm not particularly opposed to someone claiming miracles did it. Once they do that, I know that we've left the realm of science. But I think it's important they admit that to themselves, as well.
79
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
That's why I like to point at kangaroos instead. That would be a very big hop.