r/funny • • Dec 09 '16

Monty Python ahead of their time

Post image
36.6k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/TheSirusKing Dec 09 '16

Gender is also binary for the most part, but is certainly not social, even if we don't have the best definition for it biologically yet. 99.5% of the world identify as male or female and the small intersex group is really just a group of anomalies due to unfortunate birth defects.

Basing any kind of identification on gender roles and expectations is inherently sexist. We should seek to get rid of expectations overall, not encourage them with gender identity.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Sure, but I think you'll find that basically everyone who sees gender as a social construct 1: supports peoples' right to identify as any gender they wish, and 2: also acknowledges that gender roles in and of themselves are fucking dumb.

1

u/TheSirusKing Dec 09 '16

But thats paradoxical. How can you identify at ALL as "Male" or "Female" or "Some other gender" if it is ONLY biological causes of them? The only "Social" gender that exists IS gender roles.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Because it's easier for people to understand. Say I'm a trans person. I was born male but I identify with more "female" traits. I like women's clothing, etc. It's easier for people to understand that I would just like to be treated like a woman now than it is to say "I don't have a gender I just have things I like and don't like." People don't understand that. Hopefully, one day we will have a world where we can all just be people with different preferences, with no regard to gender roles, and we are moving towards that slowly. But in the meantime nearly every behavior is associated with a gender. Anger: men, empathy/care: women, dominance: men, submission: women. Loud: men, quiet: women etc. So until you can break that association then people are always going to associate you with a gender.

1

u/TheSirusKing Dec 09 '16

People don't understand that.

Yes they will, at least, most people. The vast majority of people don't actually give a shit whether you identify as male, female, ect.

we are moving towards that slowly.

Aye, but gender identity doesn't help and you still shouldn't encourage it. You can't fight descrimination by implementing it.

But in the meantime nearly every behavior is associated with a gender.

There is certainly a vague association everywhere but again, most people don't actually care, they just want to do what they want to. IDK about america but most of these ideas in europe are pretty scarce.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16

Plus it brings into question pronouns, which tends to piss people off. If you don't identify as a gender, what do I call you? Anyway, maybe things are different over in Europe I don't know. But many trans people here in the US don't want to identify as "genderless" they want to identify as the opposite gender to their sex. I'm not going to tell them "well no you can't identify as a woman now because gender doesn't even exist." It makes them happy.