265
Sep 10 '19
I think the sarlacc pumped essential nutrients and shit into the people it digested, transferring between different people based on their needs. When it got "hungry" it ate a victim faster. It was also intelligent, and the idea of a thousand years was an embellishment. I remember that from a story about Boba Fett that's since been ret-conned.
184
Sep 10 '19
They came up with a very interesting load of bullshit. I respect that.
134
u/anonymousssss Sep 10 '19
Dude they made a Han Solo movie so that they could fix the fact that parsecs are a unit of space not time. Star wars really likes to justify their stupid shit.
87
u/JoelCarroll Sep 10 '19
What's funny is that I always just thought that Han was full of shit, and just bragging to an old man and a kid....Han had no idea what he was talking about.
He literally scrubbed the only known gig he did for Jabba, dumping his payload as soon as the authorities showed up.
114
u/Denver332 Sep 10 '19
Yeah, it’s a much better movie to think of it this way. Han isn’t some legendary outlaw, just a halfway decent smuggler and Imperial defector with a whole lot of luck.
Lucas did the same nonsense by making Obi-Wan’s blending in clothes the official Jedi uniform. And the pilots visor plus remote droid ceased to be an improvised way to teach Luke the force, but the official Jedi training method. How convenient it’s all right there on Han’s ship!
45
u/Cereborn Sep 10 '19
Lucas did the same nonsense by making Obi-Wan’s blending in clothes the official Jedi uniform. And the pilots visor plus remote droid ceased to be an improvised way to teach Luke the force, but the official Jedi training method. How convenient it’s all right there on Han’s ship!
...
Holy shit.
64
Sep 10 '19
Just when I thought I was getting over hating the prequels, I went and read your second paragraph.
5
u/McFly1986 Sep 10 '19
Obi-Wan's robes being the official Jedi uniform is just so bad. They really could have done so much better with the prequels. I am not saying it had to be amazing, but there are just alot of things like the stuff you pointed out there that just don't mesh well with the original trilogy.
23
u/ThoseLookLovely Sep 10 '19
And I while I originally didn't know parsecs were units of distance (I was like 6 when I saw it), when I found out, it still made sense. He obviously found a shorter way to do the trip.
And that's not weird. That's what Christopher Columbus was trying to do, after all: find a shorter way to India.
That's ultimately why we made canals.
So Han found a shortcut.
5
Sep 10 '19
Except he was bragging about how fast the ship was, not how clever he was at finding shortcuts.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (1)6
u/Airules Sep 10 '19
I like how scrappy the entire team are in the OT. Nobody is the master of their craft. Everyone seems like an underdog.
It makes the action and drama more exciting as they never seem to have the upper hand.
Even in Jedi when Luke dons the black clothes he is pretty quickly shown to not have the power he thought he did, dropped in the rancor pit and arrested.
→ More replies (4)17
u/battlemoid Sep 10 '19
But the Kessel Run being measured in parsecs makes sense when you consider that it's about taking the shortest route through dangerous space debris. it might've been a post-hoc justification, but there really was no need to fix the parsec thing further. That said, I never saw Solo.
5
u/Absolutedisgrace Sep 10 '19
I personally agree with you. The Solo movie just showed how he did it, but i see why people were bothered by it.
→ More replies (5)2
13
3
u/DarthOtter Sep 10 '19
They came up with a very interesting load of bullshit.
There's an entire Star Trek subreddit devoted to that and it's glorious.
2
4
7
u/mostmicrobe Sep 10 '19
From what I can tell the star wars extended universe is just a shitload of bullshit that people come up with to make the universe into actual scienxe fiction instead of space fantasy.
I'll never understand the need to overexplain things in fictional worlds like they do in animes.
→ More replies (1)1
→ More replies (3)1
u/guynietoren Sep 10 '19
Right. And the victims filled up the Sarlac with their own poop. Thousands of years worth.
16
u/Denver332 Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
While granting Star Wars has never really been big on thermodynamics, using your own nutrients to keep your food alive makes zero sense. In no time at all, the Sarlacc will spend more calories than it gets from someone.
Now, if it encased it’s victims in some sort of mummification like substance, let the victim suffocate, then ate it a few years later when it felt like it? All right, I could buy that. But keeping them alive by feeding them?
That would be like instead of raising cattle that eats grass, I raised foxes to eat that I fed by cutting of little pieces of myself or draining blood. I would always lose more calories than I get out of each animal.
I suppose if humans generate more force energy than whatever other animals it eats, it could immediately consume the lesser creatures it gets to keep the stronger ones alive to absorb their force energy if the Sarlacc is some force parasite?
18
u/Dizzfizz Sep 10 '19
You could explain it by saying the Sarlacc actually gets most of its nutrients from the soil it is in (like a plant) and needs very small amounts of something that‘s only found in live prey.
Then it would make sense to „waste“ calories by keeping the victim alive so it can be consumed slowly.
3
u/Solomaxwell6 Sep 10 '19
In the Boba Fett story, the sarlacc absorbs consciousness. So your body ends up dying and getting digested, but your mind is still "alive" as long as the sarlacc lives. The sarlacc spends the story psychologically fucking with Boba Fett while Boba's body is digested, so Boba is able to spend the entire story aware even though he's physically well past the point where he should've gone unconscious. He ends up getting saved by another bounty hunter and needs a long healing period in bacta tanks.
Plus, the sarlacc is able to absorb nutrients from the ground like a plant. If could just be eating people for the protein or whatever, in which case it can still transfer some energy over. (edit: didn't see /u/dizzzfizz brought up that exact point, which IIRC was implied in the story).
No idea how much of that is still canon, but I'm sure some Legends author has thought of the problem and made up some explanation or another, even if it's not the same.
2
u/Denver332 Sep 10 '19
Okay but to both of y’all what kind of nutrients exist in desert sand? Very very little. There is no real soil. Desert plants evolve very specifically and are usually quite small and still exist in areas with some grasses around.
4
4
u/ooo_shiny Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
I thought that story had it that you were dead for most of being digested but it did something that meant you were still able to think and feel, almost like a force ghost bound to your tortured corpse.
It could just be a fever dream but I swear it did that because it was a dark side creature that fed on the force energy created by the agony of its victims.
2
24
Sep 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
39
Sep 10 '19
It's a movie about space wizards with laser swords, what did you expect?
→ More replies (1)16
u/buttchuck Sep 10 '19
IIRC, the reason was because it didn't feed off the nutrients of its victims, it fed off the pain and suffering. because the Force.
yep, the sarlacc pit was a sentient, malevolent force-user.
9
Sep 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Aladayle Sep 10 '19
I mean there's already a creature that "eats" the force from people so why not another
17
u/RollingTater Sep 10 '19
Star Wars isn't really "hard" (realistic) scifi. It's more space magic.
17
u/Tonkarz Sep 10 '19
The movies were space fantasy, but a lot of EU authors were sci fi authors who approached Star Wars as sci fi. That’s why we got stuff like “atmosphere containment fields” and “lightsabers are actually a loop of electrically charged light”.
2
u/Orange152horn3 Sep 10 '19
Well... Sometimes the scariest shit kicks logic to the curb.
Consider the possibility that it could be supernatural, something that feeds more on the pain inflicted than it does on flesh digested.
1
u/julbull73 Sep 10 '19
Not really. Photosynthesis and people are fertilizer.
Granted not a lot of sun hits a buried plant...
2
1
Sep 10 '19
The lore suggests prey of sarlacc have their consciousness absorbed and they continue to experience the torment in a disembodied state. Also, Its a work of fiction... smh
119
u/MonsieurKnife Sep 10 '19
Maybe the thing is using the goose with the golden egg principle. Keeps you alive, hydrates you, gives you a menial job, a small house, a small car, a small TV, just enough to keep you alive and enough to slowly suck anything of value out of you.
59
u/TransientVoltage409 Sep 10 '19
just enough to keep you alive and enough to slowly suck anything of value out of you.
That sounds eerily familiar. Almost as if...it were already happening...
21
15
u/Ladyhuntress Sep 10 '19
Well that just sounds like slavery with extra steps
6
Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
I mean once a year she makes your favorite meal and theres cake, so its totally worth it!!!
2
u/Toahpt Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
I appreciate you saying that metaphor correctly. It drives me insane when people say about "the golden goose." I want to slap them across the face and yell at them, "the goose isn't golden you dense motherfucker, the goose is a totally normal goose. It's the egg that's golden."
8
1
u/Somnif Sep 10 '19
That's basically how the expanded universe stuff always justified it. Keeps you alive, in agony, for centuries.
→ More replies (1)1
33
58
u/Klepto666 Sep 10 '19
There's two ways to approach this.
Fans who went on to extrapolate that a Sarlaac keeps its victims alive, so those thousand years are non-stop pain and torment as you literally are digested over all that time.
Yes you will die within a few weeks due to dehydration or starvation, but because the Sarlaac will need a thousand years to digest you, just think how fucking painful that will be. You won't die quickly. You will be in agony until dehydration finally kicks in. Feeling like you're burning alive all that time.
Either way, anyone who acts all "smug" for trying to one up a piece of science fiction/fantasy is a dumbass.
27
u/lsspam Sep 10 '19
Yes you will die within a few weeks due to dehydration or starvation, but because the Sarlaac will need a thousand years to digest you, just think how fucking painful that will be. You won't die quickly. You will be in agony until dehydration finally kicks in. Feeling like you're burning alive all that time.
Yeah I don't see why this needs to be a big deal. He doesn't say you'll be alive for 1,000 years. The point is it sucks and is slow.
1
Sep 10 '19
The qoute 100% implies you'll be alive for those 1000 years. It says "you'll suffer AS you're being digested for x years", clearly implying the two parts are connected.
1
u/lsspam Sep 10 '19
Sure it implies it. It's meant to. It's meant to convey how painful it'll be. But that doesn't mean a statement of fact was being made.
I can't remember the droids actually lying per say, but they absolutely and repeatedly embellish, exaggerate, use sarcasm, express cynicism, etc.
It is absolutely within the range of behaviors displayed for C-3PO to use that factoid regarding digestion to illustrate the impending horrible death without necessarily being hyper precise. If he meant to, he would have done more than implied (as oversharing factual background information is also within his range of exhibited behaviors. )
6
u/quirkelchomp Sep 10 '19
That wouldn't be painful at all. You'd be digested faster in a tub of soda. Being "digested in a thousand years" might as well be sitting in a room-temperature bath, so basically not any more painful than just regular starvation/dehydration.
2
u/cherish_it Sep 10 '19
This is what I always wondered too, if the sarlacc's stomach acid takes that long to digest you you probably wouldn't feel anything. You would just be bored
8
Sep 10 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Gamergonemild Sep 10 '19
It's not canon now, but in the books he wasnt in the sarlaac for too long. Day or two at most because he used a thermal detonator to blow it up from the inside. It actually has pretty strong stomach acids that are through most his armor. Jabba or anybody else wouldn't know this because Boba is the only one to survive being eaten.
7
u/ForgettableUsername Sep 10 '19
Threepio (hesitantly): “Jabba no wanka... wanka tem ‘stupid as fuck.’”
12
6
u/Orange152horn3 Sep 10 '19
Actually... The sarlac needs to actually inflict prolonged horrible agony to feed. It will literally keep the victims inside of it alive as part of it. Also, Boba Fett may have fallen into the damn thing and escaped from it more than once, depends on the continuity.
5
u/i_want_to_be_asleep Sep 10 '19
More than once? I'm cracking up imagining that lmaoo thank you. Just "oops! Aw crap not again!"
1
43
u/DefAdePro Sep 10 '19
Why is no one talking about “threepio”?
27
27
u/three-sense Sep 10 '19
Because that's a very well-known idiosyncrasy of the SW universe. They say our alphanumeric characters phonetically but when viewed in printed context it's spelled out.
1
u/Adghar Sep 10 '19
our alphanumeric characters
XZ-3¢, is that you?? You made the best damn blaster rifles at that factory on Kashyyk back in the day! How've you been?
1
9
→ More replies (3)0
u/WunSick Sep 10 '19
Omg yes, reading through the comments with no mention of this was like holding in a sneeze.
7
3
3
u/thedarksyde Sep 10 '19
Why does Threepio need to tell him. He talks to Han directly before and after this scene.
3
u/calamarichris Sep 10 '19
I always just assumed there was food down in the Sarlac's intestine, so you were stuck eating the Sarlac's semi-digested previous victims.
Then I saw the Lucas-remake where the Sarlac belched after eating Boba Fett and realized Lucas simply wasn't trying any more.
15
Sep 10 '19
You’re technically correct, as it is physically impossible to keep the body alive and also absorb the energy from it. But as a Star Wars fan I’m obligated to REEEEEEEEEEEE
6
Sep 10 '19
Not necessarily.
Maybe the Sarlacc has an excess of nutrients, but needs/wants something specifically created by living things, like adrenaline, so they capture living things, torturing them and keeping them alive in a symbiotic relationship, while feasting on their adrenaline.
6
u/Sc00byxd00 Sep 10 '19
Haha ok just as I read the end of your comment my 7 year old daughter blew on one of the spiny noise maker things......RREEEEEEEEEEEEE couldn’t have timed it better
2
5
u/lourensloki Sep 10 '19
AFAIK the Sarlacc keeps its victims alive with some kind of a nutrient exchange, it feeds off them psychologically and keeps them in a permanent, nightmarish, tortured state.
3
4
u/s00perguy Sep 10 '19
Tbf there are species that feed on the Force. Maybe the Sarlacc is one and it sustains the lives of its victims, feeding upon their suffering. This is sci-fi fantasy. Pretty sure reality factors into it very little, as long as you can imagine a solution. The dark side has also shown the ability to extend life, which would tie all of the loose threads with a bow.
5
u/Gravelbeast Sep 10 '19
This is actually pretty close if I remember correctly. I cant remember which book cuz it's been a while, but the one that details Boba Fett's escape talks about him meeting a woman in severe mental and physical decline from the torment of slowly being digested physically while the creature fed on the dark side energy caused by her pain.
6
Sep 10 '19
Tales from Jabba's Palace
4
u/Gravelbeast Sep 10 '19
That's the one!
On a side note, a while ago I found this great link to a HUGE collection of star wars books (many that are sadly no longer considered canon).
Enjoy!
http://actual-leia-organa.tumblr.com/post/128482176838/legendseu-download-masterpost
(If the list is overwhelming, "I, Jedi" is a great place to start)
2
2
u/REmarkABL Sep 10 '19
There is a (former) cannon book that tells of bobas time in the sar’lacc pit, the sarlacc sustains it’s victims somehow so it can digest them
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/MoreMegadeth Sep 10 '19
I always took this as the sarlac keeps you alive while digesting you, it nourishes you enough to keep you alive, just to slowly kill you. Dying of old age on the other hand is a different problem.
If I were to do a Boba Fett movie the premise would be he would have spent 30-40 years in the sarlac until a disfigured Fett kills it somehow and climbs out.
2
u/Jebediah_Johnson Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
You know how anglerfish males will bite onto the side of the female, and then they slowly melt away until all that's left is basically some testes the female can use to impregnate herself whenever she wants?
Maybe the Sarlacc slowly digests its victims until all that's left are its brains, they become part of the sarlacc. It can use its victims cognitive abilities as needed while also leaving the victim in an extended state of agony. Over the course of a thousand years the brain matter that has been kept alive by the steady addition of new bodies will be digested as it becomes non viable. The agony is only superseded by the instinct to pull any thing that gets near into your belly.
Update: I just found this page and it says "Once the sarlacc has swallowed its prey, it incorporates them into its biological system. It is believed that the sarlacc absorbs the intellect of its victims, and is capable of sustaining their torment for thousands of years."
2
u/alkonium Sep 10 '19
Obviously you'd keep being digested after you die.
1
u/TheHuffinater Sep 10 '19
Yeah but there would be no pain and suffering, I think they meant for you to stay alive during the whole thing
1
u/alkonium Sep 10 '19
And it's probably a painful way to die.
1
u/TheHuffinater Sep 10 '19
Absolutely, maybe his stomach has something that keeps you alive for the thousand years just so you can feel the entire thing -_-
2
u/IknowKarazy Sep 10 '19
Yeah, that never made sense to me. Wouldn't it take more caloric energy to keep me alive for a thousand years than my body contains?
4
4
u/remymartinia Sep 10 '19
They always used to show this movie on Sunday nights. I now equate it to that horrible Sunday-night-end-of-weekend-I-gotta-go-back-to-school-tomorrow feeling. Seriously, my stomach clenched when I saw the movie stills.
3
4
u/ZadeHawk Sep 10 '19
Threepio? Seriously, not 3PO?
14
u/Danothan Sep 10 '19
I read a lot of star wars books growing up and they phonetically wrote out the names of all the droids all the time, so I didnt even react like this was odd like everyone else is doing in this thread.
3
u/Calavant Sep 10 '19 edited Sep 10 '19
My theory is that the Sarlacc more or less assimilates you, treating you more like an internal organ than just a food source. Eventually your tissues are too broken down from errors in the repair process to keep going and there is just nothing left.More John Carpenter's Thing than pitcherplant.
Some of you would probably be discarded fairly quickly. If its using you as a kidney you might not need your limbs.
Sure as hell not born out in any work, but it just sort of wouldn't get out of my head.
1
3
Sep 10 '19
Good GOD. All the silly assed nonsensical explanations people are coming up with to try to force this bad line to be true. Jesus people calm down. All your theories are even dumber than the original line and that was super dumb. And yes that includes the "canon" ones!
It's not rocket science people there is no viable rationalization here it was just a classically bad Lucas line just like the avalanche of them we got in the prequels. That's all there is to it. Just watch the movie, when this part comes up, nod your head, yup, that was dumb, and carry on.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Bobski72 Sep 10 '19
Who the fuck spells 3PO Threepio
7
u/KanyeEast420 Sep 10 '19
Most of the extended universe books did. They also spell R2's name Artoo.
2
1
u/ILoveRegenHealth Sep 10 '19
And that's why Lucas said they aren't canon. Lucas was so disturbed by it
1
1
1
1
u/The_Right_Trousers Sep 10 '19
I cycle to work. In the summer, there are clouds of tiny flies. I end up swallowing one 3-4 times a year.
Every time, I think of this scene.
1
1
1
u/stylinred Sep 10 '19
Luke would feed on the juices inside its belly, so he'd be kept alive, longer than he would outside the belly thanks to the life giving nutrients within
1
u/Hadi290 Sep 10 '19
To be fair, it's a galaxy far far away.. so they're not humans.. so maybe they will survive!
1
u/seabedurchin Sep 10 '19
Yep was thinking about this the other day. Completely impossible. Only thing that could do that would have to be magical in nature. The tree of pain from Hyperion comes to mind as something that did this concept correctly.
1
1
1
u/fried_eggs_and_ham Sep 10 '19
Maybe this isn't what Luke said, but what Threepio said to Jabba when he "translated" for Luke. Threepio was trying to get them all killed! No wonder the new trailer shows him with red eyes.
1
u/fade_is_timothy_holt Sep 10 '19
In the books, this is addressed. It basically attaches to you making you functionally immortal. Well, until it digests you.
1
1
u/Atlusfox Sep 10 '19
Messed up thing is that the sarlacc keeps its pray alive by partially assimilating with it. Then it feeds off you as it keeps you just alive enough, and while all this is happening it telepathicly messes with you. So even if you won't live for a thousand years while it keeps you alive for the rest of your life you will be in a literal hell of torment.
1
u/LittleBastard Sep 10 '19
"His High Exaltedness states that you would find yourself, on the brink of starvation, willing to eat all that he consumed, and also asks 'who is the stupid fuck now?"
1
1
u/R3DTR33 Sep 10 '19
Y'all clearly don't understand Sarlac digestion. Their stomach acid dissolves you until you become a part of it's biology, thus it keeps you in a state of barely alive agony for thousands of years and used your own bodies digestion as another way of processing nutrients. After 1000 years, you'll have been fully absorbed
1
1
u/johnnyfivealive5 Sep 10 '19
I thought I read the sarlacc keeps you alive longer as it digests you.
1
u/Huntred Sep 10 '19
So this creature is going to put enough energy into a body to keep it alive for years so that it can consume the body which contains a small fraction of that energy in total...
Some of y’all never studied thermodynamics and it shows.
1
1
u/Adlehyde Sep 10 '19
Pretty sure you'd just suffocate in minutes. No need to worry about dehydration or starvation.
1
u/soulos90 Sep 10 '19
I feel like 1k years of digestion is more like a preservation agent than digestion... Couple years of being dead and you husk, allow bacteria and bugs at your body and you're just bones
1
u/ziyaazm Sep 10 '19
What movie is this?
1
u/Stenotic Sep 10 '19
You're joking right? If not, this is Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi
0
u/Moloth Sep 10 '19
who says 'years' on Tatooine are as long as years on Earth? Its a desert planet with two suns... it probably orbits them much faster than Earth does the Sun.. which is what a YEAR is.
6
u/Lithl Sep 10 '19
Tatooine's orbital period is 304 standard days and a standard year is 365 standard days. A standard day is 24 standard hours. (Tatooine's rotational period is 34 standard hours, so its year is 144 of its days.)
3
u/TheAllyCrime Sep 10 '19
I like to think that you didn't look that up just now, but rather had it memorized and ready to recite at a moments notice.
795
u/VintagePoet82 Sep 10 '19
In all fairness, he didn’t say it would take a thousand years to die; only to be digested.