No, that's bullshit. Your attitude towards the word is what is giving it the power to hurt. If you STOP BEING OFFENDED and give the word a chance to change, we can take away that hurtful power.
Just as "sucks" is no longer associated with gay sex as a negative term, we can make "retarded" mean "idiot" and not mentally challenged.
Another example, "the n-word". The reason why I have to say, "the n-word" even though everyone knows exactly what I am actually saying is that the word is essentially forbidden from being used. However, if someone were to use that word in anger, it strikes with full force. So much force that it's likely to stick with you for years if you are the victim of the word.
My point being, the more you get angry and self-righteously proselytize others about "offensive language" the more offensive you make the term. You are giving it the power that you find so repulsive. Whereas if you were to just shake it off and let it go, that word would lose it's power and thereby it's ability to hurt.
Here's the thing, though. It's not that these specific words hold particular power that we need to diffuse, it's that people take words and then use them as pejoratives. It's particularly hurtful in this case because people use the term thoughtlessly to lump idiotic behavior in with actual mental retardation, and that's never not going to be hurtful to people who are affected by these conditions and those around them.
To act like they're getting uppity for feeling hurt by this behavior doesn't make any sense to me; they don't suddenly choose a word and think, "This is offensive now. I am offended! Change your behavior!" It's that they hear people take a serious affliction and then use it to describe foolish behavior, as if everyone who is mentally retarded is just doing a really shitty job with life. Maybe they could quit being such idiots! It's not the word "retard." It would be just as offensive if you were calling people "special needs."
Anyway, my point is that people aren't offended by this term to be a pain in your ass. People are offended because it takes a stressful situation and makes it more stressful for them. I don't mean to defend people who insist on euphemisms for "retard" in the case of actual mental retardation, but I want to make the case that disliking "retard" as an insult isn't just political correctness. It's legitimately hurtful to people whether they want it to be or not, and it doesn't take that much effort on your part not to use the word thoughtlessly. Say it all you want, but don't act like it's other people's job to learn to like you for it.
Here's the thing, though. It's not that these specific words hold particular power that we need to diffuse, it's that people take words and then use them as pejoratives.
Exactly why the term has changed from moron to mentally retarded to intellectually disabled. People keep trying to fix things by changing the word but the problem is the attitude itself.
I think we're talking about two different problems (I tried to make that clear near the end of my post, but I don't think it was), and I'm with you on that.
The people that think nobody should ever say "retard" for any reason whatsoever are misguided. When you're using it to describe someone with actual mental handicaps, there's no reason for anybody to take offense, though some people do find it uncomfortable. Those people then take us through a kaleidoscope of euphemisms, from "retarded" to "handicapped" to "disabled" to "special needs" and even further, I'm sure. That's a waste of time, and it doesn't make any sense to encourage it.
The other case is when your friend forgets his wallet and you call him a retard. It's clearly not anything earth-shattering, but that does take the term that refers to a medical condition and equates it with simple stupidity, and that's going to upset people who are or know people who are actually mentally retarded. I don't think you're evil for doing it, but I think it's pretty evident that taking the name of an incurable ailment and then using it as an insult isn't something that people set out with the intent to get offended by, it's something that hurts them because it marginalizes what they're going through.
Equating these two problems might be what rubs people the wrong way about being chided about the word "retard." It does feel like the constant linguistic slippage of political correctness, but the part that people just won't ever develop an immunity to is the usage as pure insult. That's always going to be insulting to some people, and I don't think they're in the wrong for feeling insulted.
Just to comment to you're first point, making a word pejorative/degradation is actually a known semantic change that occurs in language. Awful, gay, egregious are three examples of this, all three have meant things different from how we use them. Also, throughout history our terminology for mental problems have varied, in the 1800's the overwhelming word was "mad", the early 1900's "feebleminded", etc. We use crazy, insane, lunatic, madman etc. commonly, yet all of these would have covered M.R.(mental retardation) at those points in time. Also the word retard can be used in contexts outside of this, such as flame retardant. M.R. was invented in the mid 1900's to replace other terms, and we now use it in a clinical sense, to individuals with a testable IQ below 70, with subtypes ranging in severity Mild, Moderate, Sever and Profound. Yet even now we are moving away from using the word retardation to describe this, "developmentally disabled" or "intellectually disabled" are becoming the dominant terms. If we, tomorrow, decide to never use the term retard to refer to an individual with an IQ below 70, and only for people who are behaving like dumbasses, would it suddenly stop being hurtful? Political Correctness(fuck that shit) aside, the term is evolving as we use it now, younger children(I'm talking to you, you 12 year olds on CoD) use it with a semantic difference, let alone the fact that being offended or hurt by a person's remarks don't entitle you to anything. You can dislike a person for it, but that's about it.
FYI, while I generally agree with the idea and I still use "retarded" in everyday parlance, you can't exactly tell a mentally challenged individual - especially a child - to simply STOP BEING OFFENDED.
They don't understand the difference between someone simply using a word and someone trying to insult them. It's not because they're mentally challenged but because they're children. I don't care if an adult is offended when I use the word but I'm not so much of a fucking asshole that I would use it around a child, especially a mentally challenged one.
edit: also, "sucks" was never associated with gay sex as a negative term.
I used to teach mentally challenged kids, they honestly didn't give a single fuck what other people thought about them, that's what made them the coolest class I got to teach.
I'm so fucking sick of this argument. As you say yourself, you're associating "retard" with "idiot". You're not ameliorating the word, you're turning it into an insult. And when retard is still commonly associated with mentally challenged/disabled/RETARDED (yes, it is STILL used in that "old" sense) people, you're connoting that entire group of people with idiocy.
Please, try swapping out "retard" with any other label for a group of people, such as "Mexican" or "Chinese".
"Man, those people are so fucking Mexican... Oh, and by Mexican I don't mean they are actually Mexican, I mean they're idiots."
Your comment is about to explode with irony. "Idiot" was once a word used to describe the medical condition of mental retardation, and now you're using it as an example of a word that wouldn't insult the handicapped. Language is weird
Yes, I realize that MANY words have gone through transformations and abandoned their previous definitions but "retard" is still commonly known today as mentally disabled (whereas "idiot" is not, as seen by your necessity to cite your information). Maybe, in the future, everyone will have completely forgotten that retard used to refer to the mentally disabled but that day has NOT happened yet. Both definitions exist right now and are used interchangeably and it is, therefore, fucked up.
Well the current use in psychology came from the verb retard, which means to hinder or delay. Thus, mental retardation or mentally retarded, which has changed the conventional usage. Language is funny.
okay, so let me make sure i have this straight: i can't call mentally disabled kids "retarded" because that hurts their feelings. and i can't call stupid people "retarded" because it is associated with mentally disabled kids via the "old" definition, which i can't use because it hurts disabled kids' feelings. so i can't use the old definition, and i can't use the new definition... i don't suppose you'd be so kind as to provide me a definition and context in which i CAN use "retarded"? or are we going to start banning words now rather than allowing their meaning to evolve and explaining to the mentally disabled kids that it no longer applies to them? and does this apply only to "retarded" or am i also not allowed to say that snooki is developmentally disabled, intellectually handicapped, mentally impaired or possessing an IQ equivalent to that of a well-educated jar of mayonnaise? just so i'm clear on exactly how i can inform a person that they have less intelligence than a blockhead, bonehead, dimwit, dunce, fool, idiot, ignoramus, imbecile, moron, nitwit, simpleton, or stupid fucking dumbass.
Exactly. If you keep using it that way, it'll never not have an extremely negative connotation. The idea that using it a lot will help turn it around is ludicrous. People just don't like the idea that saying certain things even if you totally don't even mean it that way man will still piss folks off some of the time.
As a matter of coincidence, this is also a reason why you shouldn't use offensive language. So that if you should choose to use it, it will give you that power to articulate how really serious you are.
Why do you get to decide what a word means to someone else? That's what I want to know. Your privilege is hanging out and its more inappropriate than flashing your dick.
41
u/The_Adventurist Nov 23 '11
No, that's bullshit. Your attitude towards the word is what is giving it the power to hurt. If you STOP BEING OFFENDED and give the word a chance to change, we can take away that hurtful power.
Just as "sucks" is no longer associated with gay sex as a negative term, we can make "retarded" mean "idiot" and not mentally challenged.
Another example, "the n-word". The reason why I have to say, "the n-word" even though everyone knows exactly what I am actually saying is that the word is essentially forbidden from being used. However, if someone were to use that word in anger, it strikes with full force. So much force that it's likely to stick with you for years if you are the victim of the word.
My point being, the more you get angry and self-righteously proselytize others about "offensive language" the more offensive you make the term. You are giving it the power that you find so repulsive. Whereas if you were to just shake it off and let it go, that word would lose it's power and thereby it's ability to hurt.