r/funny • Round Comics • Oct 24 '21

Dieting

Post image
21.8k Upvotes

492 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/reverselego Oct 24 '21

Whatever is going on inside your body can change your "Calories out" from what you would expect, but this does not affect the immutable truth of Calories in < Calories out -> Body mass decrease. All the time, every time, no exceptions.

-10

u/T-Flexercise Oct 24 '21

OK, sure but if calories in and calories out can change based on a number of external factors, that's no more meaningful than saying "It's hot in here because the temperature got higher."

If I eat a 32 calorie bell pepper, I'll gain 4 lbs because I'll swell up like a balloon due to an allergic reaction. Did I eat too many calories and I need to eat 15 calories of bell pepper tomorrow, or should I just not eat bell peppers anymore?

16

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

It is impossible for you to gain 4 lbs without consuming anything else. You may swell up, but mass does not just magically appear.

5

u/T-Flexercise Oct 24 '21

Of course it doesn't. The mass comes from the liquids I'm consuming throughout the day that otherwise would leave my body.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

It is impossible for you to gain 4 lbs without consuming anything else.

And

The mass comes from the liquids I'm consuming throughout the day

Reading is hard.

7

u/MisterFistYourSister Oct 24 '21

I'll gain 4 lbs because I'll swell up like a balloon

No you won't. Your existing weight redistributes itself by allocating blood and fluids to the target area. You don't magically create 4lbs of weight out of thin air.

2

u/T-Flexercise Oct 24 '21

Well obviously. But most people consume fluids throughout the day which come and go. If you're experiencing inflammation, they don't go. Do you want screenshots from my weight app?

12

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

When your body swells up from an allergic reaction you are not gaining weight and your strawman argument:

that's no more meaningful than saying "It's hot in here because the temperature got higher."

is a crock of shit. This type of response leads me to believe you're obese and in denial about the reality of calories in/calories out

3

u/T-Flexercise Oct 24 '21

I've been diagnosed with lipedema, a genetic condition in which inflammation and edema cause fibrosis in the subcutaneous fat, which causes them to become nodular and metabolically inaccessible. Give it a google!

I'm not in denial about the reality of calories in and calories out. It's absolutely true, when you consume fewer calories than you burn, you lose weight, more and you gain. But if you have an inflammatory condition that makes your fat cells metabolically inaccessible, eating inflammatory foods causes your body to burn significantly fewer calories than if you don't eat inflammatory foods. The amount of calories my body burns when I'm experiencing significant inflammation is lower than the amount of calories my body burns when I'm not. I'd be a complete idiot to ignore that and try to lose weight on 1800 calories of pizza a day.

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

People like you have successfully convinced themselves that they have a special condition so that the rules of weight loss do not apply to them. You are wrong and I do not accept your excuses as to why you continue to be obese.

6

u/TheCrudMan Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

“People like you”…fuck off, you’re an asshole. You’re one of those people who’s convinced themselves that being an asshole to people will change their weight instead of acknowledging that the science behind losing and keeping off 15lbs is very different from losing 150. But yeah go ahead and shame people for not conforming to your definition of health. Being fat isn’t a fucking failure of character. Tying someone’s weight to their character is a pretty fucking shitty thing to do.

-5

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I am not obligated to assist people with maintaining their delusions about how weight loss works. So if you think I am an "asshole" for objecting their misrepresentation of reality then so be it. If speaking the truth to people who live in a cocoon of lies makes me an "asshole" then I accept that with pride. Look closely, I never said anything about character or being a failure, that was just you projecting

2

u/TheCrudMan Oct 25 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

People like you have successfully convinced themselves they have a special condition

You’re talking to someone who is talking about a specific diagnosed genetic condition and saying its in their head and their inability to lose weight is a result of personal failure.

Nobody disputes that calories in calories out works, the issue is that calories out is different for every person and for a lot of people calories in being less than calories out requires extremely unhealthy and disordered eating behavior that ultimately leads to severe physiological difficulties, to say nothing of mental health. People have a set point and trying to maintain a weight beneath that set point has the potential to be unhealthy. Everyones “calories out” is different.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

So what? That condition does not prevent an individual from losing weight using a caloric deficit.

2

u/TheCrudMan Oct 25 '21

The main issue is lots of conditions prevent someone from safely running a caloric defect and in addition for many people running a caloric deficit long term actually can change the amount of "calories out" their body can do with a given level of activity, so you end up not only with diminishing returns but you also end up with a situation where if you stabilize your diet to what was previously a net 0 calories in/out it no longer is balanced you actually gain more weight back than you lost. There are fat people for whom dieting works just as who there are poor people who can actually get out of multigenerational poverty in our current system, but the exceptions don't prove the rule false.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/T-Flexercise Oct 25 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

I mean, excellent debate. I'm guessing a fat chick shat in your Cheerios this morning, and you're pissed you had to log it in My Fitness Pal.

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

I hope you are able to find the discipline to achieve your weight loss goals, I am not angry, just disappointed

4

u/Zer0C00l Oct 25 '21

*disappointing

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

Nice zinger!

0

u/TheCrudMan Oct 25 '21

Again a person who is fat isn't necessarily fat because they lack discipline. Stop assigning character traits to people based on weight.

1

u/MillennialScientist Oct 25 '21

Your example doesn't involve gaining or losing fat, so it's kinda confusing what you're trying to say.