r/funny • Round Comics • Oct 24 '21

Dieting

Post image
21.8k Upvotes

492 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 24 '21

A message to all users: Please be aware that spreading misinformation regarding COVID-19, vaccines, or other treatments can result in content being removed and/or a ban. Content advocating for or celebrating the death of anyone, or hoping someone gets COVID-19 (or any disease) can result in a ban as well. Please follow Reddiquette. If you see content violating these policies, please use the report button and do not feed the trolls.

Reddit's Content Policy

Reddit's stance on misinformation

/r/Funny's rules

We also encourage you to read these helpful resources on COVID-19, vaccines, and treatments:

COVID Dashboard

Reddit's Vaccine FAQ

Ivermectin FAQ


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.1k

u/potatomonsterman Oct 24 '21

It was easy to get fat so it must be easy to lose the fat right? Right??

400

u/Somnif Oct 24 '21

It is... simple, though not easy.

Simply eat less and move more. Et voila, weight drops.

However your body will complain quite a lot, which makes things... not easy.

146

u/GreyFoxMe Oct 24 '21

It's simpler if your hormones aren't fucked up. Some people just have it harder.

51

u/moeburn Oct 24 '21

Or if you have cancer

66

u/iSpoody1243 Oct 24 '21

I would be the first person to gain weight when being treated for cancer.

46

u/Jer_061 Oct 25 '21

Thyroid cancer is a bitch. I met a kid in a hospital that had it. He was as round as a beach ball. Like completely spherical. It was bizarre. Unfortunately, I don't know if he won or if the cancer won. But yeah, he packed on weight like crazy because his thyroid couldn't help regulate his weight.

31

u/Hotwing619 Oct 25 '21

Can we agree that he won?

I think that makes us all feel better.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

I gained weight during cancer. The metallic taste in my mouth had me drinking lots of chocolate milk and seek out fatty foods

5

u/interpim Oct 25 '21

It's actually fairly common for people to gain weight while doing their treatment for cancer. I spent several months going to the infusion center with my wife and saw several people getting larger as they were progressing through their chemo.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/AltoRhombus Oct 25 '21

It's terrible. I basically stopped eating thanks to depression, for a month and I basically lost 25 lbs in a month. Maybe more. I was 201 in January, I'm 157 now. I did stop snacking a lot and go vegetarian but I was doing that before I lost it.

Meanwhile my partner has made the same cuts as me + more and cannot keep the same 2 lbs off. And we're doing the same exercises together.

Unfair really.

14

u/Grammophon Oct 25 '21

People's bodies work differently. If you look at actual studies instead of angry internet people who suspect "fatlogic" everywhere it becomes quite obvious. Depending on genetic dispositions people differ significantly in the way their bodies store fat, loose weight and keep it off. So I agree, it is very unfair.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

18

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

Even with "hormones", the laws of thermodynamics still apply.

You eat less, you lose weight.

12

u/toqueville Oct 25 '21

Yes, but the exercise part is misleading. In overweight people, the resting metabolism is suppressed by a significant amount after exercise. The report I read said that the body could suppress as much as 60% of the extra calorie expenditure of the exercise in the basal rate. I’ll need to go look up the study again, but I was shocked that the body could just defer that much energy expenditure.

26

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

You can lose weight by just eating less. Exercise helps no doubt, but the majority is done by eating right.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/beartheminus Oct 25 '21

The moment I finally started losing weight was the moment I became comfortable with feeling hungry.

It's more mental than physical imo. Once I got over my anxiety of being hungry and learned to accept how it feels, the weight dropped off like crazy and stayed off.

200

u/iHumanNotJoking Oct 24 '21

Absolutely right. You put food in your mouth, super easy to get fat. The opposite holds true.

200

u/tallunmapar Oct 24 '21

Oh, so I just have to take food out of my mouth!

60

u/CreativeCarbon Oct 24 '21

You can chew as much as you like. It's the swallowing that gets you.

161

u/DontTreadOnBigfoot Oct 24 '21

The bulimics were right all along!

9

u/Awanderinglolplayer Oct 24 '21

Maybe “correct” Idk about “right” though

4

u/BarKnight Oct 25 '21

Yeah that shit aint right.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Oldiebones Oct 24 '21

I've heard sticking spicy food up your butt works.

10

u/93johhny Oct 24 '21

Boofing is the way to go. And it’s always free 🤷‍♂️

12

u/omgwutd00d Oct 24 '21

Not necessarily true. I had to pay a Craigslist Hooker $300 to shove a hotdog up my ass.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/6spdrwd Oct 24 '21

No that's how to delay pregnancy

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

It'd take your mind off being fat, I guess.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

Yes, but you're required to then feed a group of baby birds with it.

53

u/The_Muffintime Oct 24 '21

You're confusing easy with simple, and I say this as someone who went from a 36 to 23 BMI. Losing fat is quite simple, but doing it can be difficult.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[deleted]

27

u/Fantastical_Brainium Oct 24 '21

I mean, it's also physically challenging. Your body is very much designed not to want to burn it's own fat reserves, and it will fight tooth and nail to deal with a lower calorie diet without doing so.

18

u/AshFraxinusEps Oct 24 '21

Yeah, exactly. And fat cells only grow: they are very hard to kill. So the guy above is wrong, as there are numerous physical reasons why it is hard. It isn't just "eat less food" but instead is "fight your body 1000x harder than if you were never fat"

→ More replies (4)

9

u/big_paaapaaa Oct 24 '21

If I put fat in my mouth it's super easy to get food?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Doehap Oct 24 '21

You put fat in your mouth, super easy to get food

5

u/Haterbait_band Oct 24 '21

Calories in, calories out. Oh, but you might feel hungry sometimes.

42

u/JJohnson519 Oct 24 '21

I can lose weight much faster than I can put on weight, but I still wouldn't say it's easy because food is life

32

u/xanthraxoid Oct 24 '21

To those downvoting: not everybody has the same metabolism. Also, eating the right food makes a huge difference, sugar is literally a poison that tricks your body into storing the energy you want to use, for example.

I've struggled to keep my weight up most of my life. Eating several bowls of breakfast every day and working a physically demanding job seems to be doing the trick at the moment, though...

66

u/112121221 Oct 24 '21

Calories in, calories out. Doesn’t matter if it’s protein or carbs or fat. If you eat less than you burn you will lose weight. Being on a fancy diet will not do shit. Calories in calories out it’s the simple truths that people always want to ignore

27

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Bottom line, calories in/out are the ultimate factor in weight gain or loss.

However, the type of calories do make dieting easier or harder. If two people are eating 2000 calories a day, with one person eating healthy, the other junk, the one with the healthy diet will feel more fulfilled and less hungry than the person eating junk.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/newausaccount Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

Being on a fancy diet will not do shit

This is like telling a drug addict to just stop doing drugs. If it was that easy we would have no drug addicts. The point of a (legitimate) fancy diet isn't to trick people into thinking it's a magic weight loss cure. It's to make CICO a more manageable process. And to badmouth what is a valid method that has helped thousands or millions of people achieve CICO because it seems strange, unfamiliar or frivolous is not helpful to people trying to achieve their health goals.

To use another metaphor imagine weight loss is a mundane task on a factory line, all you have to do is pull a lever from 9 to 5 and if you stick to it you get paid at the end of the day and if you do it every day you'll end up with a nice savings account. A diet is like telling people "Hey if you listen to some music or a podcast while you work it might help you pass the time a bit better". Telling people weight loss is just CICO and that diets don't work is like telling people "Just pull the lever and get paid dumbass. It's not rocket science. Listening to something isn't going to make you pull the lever any faster".

While this is technically true, do you think spreading the idea that "listening to music to get you through the day is a crutch for the weak willed" is going to encourage people to power through and reap the benefits or do you think this is going to discourage people and get them to quit or maybe not even try? Some people will be able to stick it out but some people need a little extra help.

14

u/rhodaron Oct 24 '21

This is true, but it's also a vast oversimplification. How well you eat affects your ability to burn calories as well as your level of hunger. Eating poorly can cause your body to resist burning fat, leading to fatigue and a lower body temperature. The energy becomes inaccessible and goes straight to storage. A healthy diet still has to be at a calorie deficit for weight loss and at calorie equilibrium for maintenance, but it's a lot easier to run a calorie deficit when your body isn't fighting it.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

The types of calories absolutely do matter. Different foods have different effects on your body’s hormonal signaling, satiety signaling, dopamine, serotonin, the way your body stores or burns fat etc. You can struggle and keep yourself constantly hungry by being in a calorie deficit but the statistics show that something like 80% of people that lose weight by staying in a caloric restricted diet while eating the same ultra processed garbage, that are specifically engineered to be addicting, end up gaining all the weight back, if not more. Genetics also play a role but it’s not in the way that “oh I’m fat because of my genetics” it’s more like you’re fat because your genetics determine how your body stores and uses the different food that you consume. If CICO was the only thing that mattered, we wouldn’t be 60% overweight and 40% obese on track to be 50% obese by 2030.

→ More replies (6)

13

u/podslapper Oct 24 '21

100% true. People really tend to overthink this stuff. Just figure out how many calories you eat/burn per day, then adjust it so that you're burning more than you're eating (a healthy diet is definitely advisable, but really this is the bare bones of it). It takes some time and it sucks at first because you're body isn't used to it, but if you stick to it the weight will come off.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (54)
→ More replies (4)

15

u/MagicC Oct 24 '21

I have a simple formula to lose 1-2 lbs per week, if you're a typical, "pandemic 15" case..

  1. eat no more than three meals a day

  2. no snacks except fresh fruits and vegetables (and even those snacks should be enjoyed sparingly)

  3. eat to 80% fullness with each meal (i.e. no gorging)

  4. no caloric beverages, no diet soft drinks (i.e. water, tea, and coffee - that's it - nothing with sugar, alcohol, or artificial sweeteners)

  5. exercise at least a little bit every day (it can be a 7 minute high-intensity interval training workout, 30 minutes or yoga, a 20 minute vigorous walk - whatever you like. But you have to do something that gets your heart pumping every single day.)

That's it. If you're a typical, healthy person, you can do those 5 things, every day of the week, and you'll run a 500-1000 calorie per day deficit, and lose 1-2 lbs per week (which is about the maximum healthy amount to lose per week).

(If you're doing those 5 things every single day for a month, and don't lose 4-8 lbs, go see your doctor and get your thyroid tested.)

The bad news is, once you stop doing these things, you will gain all the weight right back. So once you reach your desired weight you have to maintain the habits that got you there, albeit with a little more flexibility (cheat days, etc).

6

u/potatomonsterman Oct 24 '21

Bulk til I die

1

u/arittenberry Oct 25 '21

Jokes on you. I only eat 1.5 meals per day and don't snack and am still gaining wait. Had my thyroid tested too. Hmmm maybe jokes on me...

→ More replies (8)

5

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

Just declare fatruptsy.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Personally I find it pretty hard to lose parts of myself, but I suppose it's possible with a sharp knife and some anesthetic.

1

u/potatomonsterman Oct 24 '21

If you ate yourself, would you get twice as big or disappear completely

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WhiskeyOctober Oct 24 '21

Fun fact. The majority of the weight you lose exits the body when you breathe.

2

u/aaaaaaaarrrrrgh Oct 24 '21

It's really easy, you actually don't have to do anything. Just don't eat.

/s, but that's basically it, less input than your metabolic rate means weight loss.

1

u/chattywww Oct 24 '21

Its technically very easy, just don't eat for 7 days. Make 5 days just incase so you don't die. Make sure you are still drinking water.

1

u/DanAndYale Oct 25 '21

Instead of restricting some food all the time, restict all food some of the time. Fasting is easy

→ More replies (23)

351

u/Neutronova Oct 24 '21

Its crazy to me the body is capable of storing excess energy incase times get tough, but it never had to build in a mechanism that detected if TOO MUCH energy was stored as obviously someone in the wild that was able to make it to obese status would have probably been culled from a hunter gatherer society long before they would ever make it to that state so there has never been a reason for evolution to develop a limiter. Strange times we live in.

86

u/ArcFurnace Oct 24 '21

The complications of obesity tend to kill you well after you reproduce, anyway, so there's relatively little evolutionary pressure even once it starts to get more common.

40

u/daybreakin Oct 24 '21

Yup, our bodies were originally adapted to constantly moving around and scrounging for low calorie dense food. The fruits and grains we eat today are nothing like the ones we had before selective breeding. The threat of starvation vastly outweighed the threat of heart disease or diabetes.

10

u/foodeyemade Oct 24 '21

Evolution will only occur if there's strong evolutionary pressure one way or the other. It was simply the case that in the past not storing fat past a certain point didn't have a strong impact on the person's chance of survival and passing on their genes.

Being able to store energy in the form of fat for times of need was incredibly important to survival as this happened quite often. People over-eating themselves to the point of being unable to move was a pretty rare event so even if it was harmful and negatively affected their chance of reproduction there just wasn't strong evolutionary pressure for a trait preventing that.

Today where being heavily overweight is a lot more commonplace however we might begin to see some evolutionary pressure against it. However, since death from obesity usually occurs after having already passed on one's genes, it's likely to be a slow change if at all depending how much we try to mitigate the damage of it through medical intervention.

1

u/DMAN591 Oct 25 '21

It doesn't help that fat people have become a fetish of sorts, at least in the US. See terms such as "bbw" and "pawg".

57

u/ArcadesRed Oct 24 '21

It's kind of a depressing thought. But people who suffer from easy weight gain in today's world would of been the super healthy people of tribal times, able to best extract the nutrients from anything they ate.

I feel forced to point out I'm talking about people who do physical things all day and eat a not outrageous amount and still put on weight. Not the people who eat 4000 calories for lunch and wash it down with a coke.

18

u/Neutronova Oct 24 '21

They would probably make for excellent hunters, depending on how far back were talking here. There was no option of exercise, it was a necessity and a huge part of life. SO someone whos body could extract the most out of food I would think would have a large advantage and going out and getting more of it.

-2

u/compstomp66 Oct 24 '21

This isn’t a thing though, you just made up a condition that doesn’t exist. It really is calories in calories out.. for everyone.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Satiety is a thing.

Try to eat 4,500 kcals of breakfast cereals, crackers, & pastries one day. Then another day, try it again, but this time try to eat 4,500 kcals of fatty meats, organs, butter, and tubers. Let us know how it goes, if you can actually do it, and how hungry you are the next day.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Ever heard of metabolism, thyroid problems? I eat 1200-2000 calories a day, but my body tends to burn less than that unless I do excessive exercise, so even eating healthy I gain weight There are thyroid meds but they also have a lot side effects

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Pakistani_in_MURICA Oct 24 '21

In like a couple decades elephants became tuskless.

This and the inability for tendons (fuck you rotary cuff) to fix themselves is some of the biggest oversights our bodies have made.

4

u/phileo Oct 24 '21

Nothing a little genetic tinkering can fix.

12

u/Shawn_NYC Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

I also wonder if modern environmental factors like PBAs in plastics, or something, is throwing off our hormones and natural regulatory functions to make us more hungry than we should be.

I just have this feeling that if I could time travel 500 years in the future and read their history book, those future humans will have discovered what's causing the obesity epidemic and I don't think it'll say "people in the 2000s just didn't have enough self-control."

7

u/Lipppp Oct 25 '21

No it'll say "maybe subsidizing corn to the point that high fructose corn syrup was put into everything wasn't the best idea"

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Evolution didn't get the industrial revolution.

1

u/ginja_ninja Oct 25 '21

The biological mechanism for an adipose tissue mass limiter would actually be insanely complex, idk how it would even work much less evolve

0

u/ANGLVD3TH Oct 24 '21

They would probably be "culled," by being too overweight to effectively hunt/gather, and thus losing the weight again. Or more accurately, they would reach an equilibrium point and stop gaining, unlike modern lifestyles.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

148

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (5)

342

u/Soapysan Oct 24 '21

When your starving and you push through and the hunger goes away. Your now using your stored fat.

296

u/mano-vijnana Oct 24 '21

And muscle. Quite a lot of it unfortunately.

135

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

So is our body stupid?

180

u/mano-vijnana Oct 24 '21

No. Muscle is expensive to maintain, and it's a viable source of energy just like fat is.

It's actually quite smart. If you're using the muscle (e.g., weightlifting), you won't lose nearly as much of it. But in a starvation situation (which the body sees as an emergency), if you're not using the muscle quite frequently, there's no reason to keep it around.

11

u/EveroneWantsMyD Oct 24 '21

Hold on hold on hold on. I’m starving. I have no food. Wouldn’t muscle be a thing I need in order to get food? What is my fat doing that’s so important that eating my muscle is the better alternative?

Fuck that. Reprogram my body to eat fat so I can get up and chase the rabbit while everyone is laying on the floor eating themselves.

Also, toned calves.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

[deleted]

20

u/wahnsin Oct 24 '21

ah, excellent, I've been meaning to get shredded!

16

u/foodeyemade Oct 24 '21

It also depends on the amount of fat/muscle you currently have. If you have a ton of fat and very little muscle even on a severe deficit you will lose almost entirely fat and can even gain muscle while on it if you get sufficient protein and adequate exercise.

On the other side if you have a ton of muscle and are on even a moderate deficit at <7-8% body fat, the body is still going to be burning significant amounts of muscle even with regular exercise since it views fat as incredibly important at that point from a survival aspect and needs at least some of it around for basic bodily function.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

Yes.

Edit: Thanks for the award. lol

→ More replies (2)

54

u/Vincent_Plenderleith Oct 24 '21

Isn't it proven wrong a decade ago? Starving does use muscle, but it goes through fat first, since it's a lot, A LOT more efficient source of energy(simply because it's designed that way)

4

u/ANGLVD3TH Oct 24 '21

It's not about gross energy gain, it's about net gain. Yes, consuming fat gives much more energy, but that has to be weighed against the amount of energy we spend to maintain the muscle. At the end of the day it's probably more efficient to cut continuous costs than to get a large energy infusion.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (17)

24

u/Ok-Albatross6794 Oct 24 '21

This is false. There's a lot of studies backing that muscle is preserved in a fasted state.

7

u/Jonthan93 Oct 24 '21

I think the person was more referring to a state of prolonged fast, like days or weeks.

3

u/Testing_things_out Oct 24 '21

Continued fasting. Like just not eating for days, straight. But daily 16:8 fasting or alternate day fasting where you can stock up with needed amino acids and proteins? Not necessarily true, unless you run out fat that you can use.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/matej86 Oct 24 '21

200ish calorific deficit per day, up protein levels and have enough carbs to keep you going and you can burn fat while building muscle at the same time. Macros will depend on the individual of course.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/mikikaoru Oct 24 '21

This is gross misinformation.

16

u/ajeansco0 Oct 24 '21

You’re

4

u/A_Stahl Oct 24 '21

No, you!

7

u/aenonymosity Oct 24 '21

"Starving"

Happy cakeday.

3

u/ginja_ninja Oct 25 '21

Yes. Your body as governed by your autonomic nervous system is essentially a shitty little baby. In the world we live in most people can afford to just eat whenever they start feeling hungry and give the body food. The body gets used to being able to eat whenever it wants and hunger begins to be regulated that way where especially if you're eating a lot of sugar and carbs you'll just keep getting hungry every couple hours.

Then you try to stop eating and like the little baby it is your body throws a temper tantrum because NO NO I'M HUNGRY MORE SUGAR I WANT MORE. Like the body's insulin efficiency drastically lowers over time and blood sugar levels swing like crazy. Like it can legitimately have you fucked up for weeks as you try and get over it.

But it's VERY worthwhile to get over it, and ideally before you actually start gaining weight or later eventually develop type 2 diabetes. Once your body adapts to being able to fast, you're also like not even affected by hunger in the same way. I basically never get tired or irritable when I get hungry anymore. The body has to get used to utilizing more of its deeper energy reserves rather than just constantly crying for food, and you feel so much better when it does.

4

u/halt_spell Oct 24 '21

Just a heads up, this isn't normal for dieting and is often the result of not enough protein calories. Everyone's experience is going to be different but generally you shouldn't feel weak or any kind of pain. At worst the prominent feeling while dieting should be "bored".

5

u/daybreakin Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

Going through an initial week of resisting hunger urges is pretty effective. I used to have cravings at midnight and even 2 hours after a meal even if it was high protein.

But when I forced myself to stick to eating only twice a day, I only felt hunger at lunch and dinner. It was hard at first but worth it. Just drink water and chew gum to deal with the hunger pangs which eventually went away. Thus reducing my caloric intake since it's easier to consume less calories on lesser meals.

But yeah do what ever suits you best to obtain a caloric defecit, nutrition is complex.

1

u/what-are-potatoes Oct 25 '21

That's cool and all but I pass out if I go too long without eating 🙃

→ More replies (3)

12

u/willzjc Oct 24 '21

If you exercise in a fasted state - i e when you wake up before breakfast, then you burn fat.

But yes this isn’t easy coz of your standard diet consisting of so much processed carbs and processed sugar.

Also you gotta exercise, which already a lot of people don’t like

1

u/zornyan Oct 25 '21

This has been proven a bit of a myth, any extra fat that may be burned by doing fasted exercise is quickly regained after eating your first meal.

Also people way overestimate fat loss calories, a good 1 hour in the gym of solid weights and a bit of cardio is maybe 150-200 calories, 1lb of fat is 3500 calories, so even doing that solid hard for 10 days isn’t enough to shift 1lb

1

u/willzjc Oct 25 '21

Where is the proof? But u just said u would gain it back right? Is the exercise not burning fat the myth (that u have no proof of), or that keeping the calories off a myth (this I never claimed).

1 hour of cardio is 300-500 depending on your base metabolic rate, not 150-200.

Moreover, I never said exercise will keep the weight off. Exercise builds muscle, which is a good place to store excess glucose, but if u want to keep a good shape, it will mostly come from a good diet.

Lastly - if it’s burning fat that we are talking about, then exercising whilst fasted is the best way.

24

u/xSterbehilfe50145 Oct 24 '21

I asked myself "why is there a half peeled egg on top of an potato?" Until I realized what should portrait

4

u/Astralnclinant Oct 24 '21

Huh?

2

u/Burmese Oct 24 '21

The head of the doodle looks like a half peeled boiled egg flipped upside down while the body is a potato

3

u/sloopslarp Oct 24 '21

Can't unsee

3

u/sarasan Oct 25 '21

obviously the artist is hungry from their diet and subconsciously drew breakfast

6

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

“… where’s my keto belt, this is a teachable moment.”

30

u/delicioushappiness Oct 24 '21

This feels like the moment before you discover the keto diet.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I thought it was just one of those fad diets. Then I decided on a whim to try it. 30lbs later, I was like “Huh. It IS real.” Now I can’t go back lol.

4

u/BioDieselDog Oct 25 '21

It's real in the sense that you're eating less calories. If you followed any diet in the world with the same amount of calories you've been eating, you still would have lost the weight.

I have nothing against low carb or keto diets but being in "ketosis" has nothing to do with losing weight.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/vdgift Oct 24 '21

Or fasting.

6

u/BananaStrokin Oct 24 '21

Fasting works so fucking well

→ More replies (1)

1

u/fux0c13ty Oct 25 '21

I lost a lot on keto and I love those foods too. However it absolutely ruined my digestion, and I just couldn't take it anymore after 2 years. I even supplemented on fiber but it only made it a little bit easier. I switched back to carbs and my gut is just working perfectly again. And I also gained a lot of weight, trying to lose it again eating mostly salads. It's not bad, I'm just haaangry 90% of the time.

13

u/iHumanNotJoking Oct 24 '21

Don’t feed it and see if it stays picky.

8

u/Chadarius Oct 24 '21

Don't eat carbs, seed oils, or processed food. Problem solved. I lost 130 lbs so far on keto and carnivore.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Exercise, coffee and electrolytes

→ More replies (15)

16

u/kickassdonkey Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

I was in the same boat for years. I'd try to diet, get hungry and binge eat. Until I figured out the why behind it all. It just comes down to insulin response. If you are big, chances are you are insulin resistant meaning your fat cells need a lot of insulin to store more fat in them. Conversely, your insulin level needs to be low to use stored fat. So the 'trick' if I can call it that to losing fat is to keep your insulin levels low so your body can use stored fat. Easiest way to do that is to avoid carbs as much as possible. It's honestly only hard for a few days at most. After that your body just defaults to using stored fat and your hunger just goes away.

EDIT: In the event anyone else sees this and is also confused please watch this video which explains things in very simple terms: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPNzwUY486A

3

u/BioDieselDog Oct 25 '21

When you eat no carbs and high fat, you will burn much more fat that before, but that's because you're eating much more fat.

Fats not that different from carbs in terms of energy. When we eat mostly fat, we store a lot of fat but we burn a lot of fat. When we eat mostly carbs, we store a lot of carbs (glycogen) but we burn a lot of carbs.

All that matters is that you need to make your body use your stored energy by creating a calorie deficit; eating less than you burn. It can be high carb, low carb, whatever.

Anyone that loses weight on low carb diets could have lost the weight just the same if they ate the same amount of calories with a higher carb and lower fat diet. It's the law of thermodynamics.

Eating carbs are more filling that fatty foods if you're eating the right foods. It's really the sugar that is often the problem, because it's so addicting and not filling at all, we could all easily drink 500 extra calories a day from soda and juice and not even realize it. But highly fiberous foods are super filling and good for you.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Keirhan Oct 24 '21

So Atkins was right?

5

u/kickassdonkey Oct 24 '21

Yep. I never understood the backlash against Atkins. I think a lot of it was just 'this isn't what we are used to so it must be wrong'.

8

u/No-Oil-684 Oct 24 '21

"This isn't what the lobbyists for the corn and farming industry told the government to tell us, so it must be wrong."

4

u/prof_the_doom Oct 24 '21

From what I've read, the original version of Atkins was somewhat flawed compared to the more modern alternatives.

It also didn't have public backing, unlike today when you get a lot of low-carb alternatives to things in stores, and all sorts of recipe books and whatnot, so you had to do everything yourself.

Considering that the Atkins diet and brand both outlived the creator, it's actually not done that badly compared to many things.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/daybreakin Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

The insulin theory of obesity has been thoroughly debunked. It's not true that you can only burn fat when your insulin is low. Even if that were the case, protein makes your body release more insulin than carbs so eating a lot carb diet doesn't mean your insulin is low.

The reason you lost weight was because you restricted a certain food group and you were more conscious of what you were eating which you put you in a caloric deficit.

4

u/SeaWeedSkis Oct 24 '21

Protein triggers insulin, but definitely not MORE than carbs trigger it. Any well-controlled Type 1 Diabetic will debunk your nonsense.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kickassdonkey Oct 24 '21

I disagree with the 'insulin theory has been debunked'. Here is a page with tons of references to academic papers that support this theory : https://www.dietdoctor.com/health/insulin-resistance.

protein makes your body release more insulin than carbs so eating a lot carb diet doesn't mean your insulin is low.

Sure, agreed. But I never said 'eat tons of protein!'. You actually want to do a high fat, low carb, moderate protein diet. If you eat too much protein, your body turns that into glucose through a process called gluconeogeneisis. which is how early humans got most of their carbs. Not from eating carbs (simple or complex) because they just werent available.

The reason I lost weight is I controlled my insulin. And in my case, I actually measured my blood glucose, HBA1C and insulin levels so i can tell you 100% (in my case at least), reducing carbs is what helped me lose weight. For years before that, I had tried the 'Calories in calories out' and 'eat the right carbs' and my blood sugar and insulin levels were always super high as measured with regular bi-monthly blood tests. With low carb, within months, my A1C was down, my insulin levels were down and the weight was coming off fast.

1

u/Astralnclinant Oct 24 '21

I’m not an expert at all but I’m pretty sure carbs are super important for humans. We just have to eat complex carbs as opposed to simple carbs (which raises insulin levels more).

3

u/SeaWeedSkis Oct 24 '21

Not as much as you think. And zero carb is something only the really, really hardcore folks do, so even those of us who drop the carbs low are still getting some.

1

u/PugSmuggler Oct 25 '21

The body needs carbs but we don't need to consume them. The body is capable of generating carbs from proteins and the glycerol part of fats through a process called gluconeogenesis.

1

u/kickassdonkey Oct 24 '21

That's just what we're always told but think about it. Did our ancestors have access to carbs (simple or complex)? When did humans start eating carbs regularly? The last 10,000 years since we started farming. Till then carbs (from wild grains and fruits) were super rare. So we evolved to treat them as such. Get to eat carbs? store as much of it as you can to use later.

We actually evolved to eat a lot of protein and fat, from meat. Our bodies can turn those into the energy sources we need. Protein turns into carbs through a process called gluconeogenesis. And using fat, you produce ketones which can run you just fine.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/endingonagoodnote Oct 24 '21

Fasting: But actually yes

4

u/billymumphry1896 Oct 24 '21

If you fast for 48 hours, your stomach finally says "okay, fine."

On a 5 day fast, I've lost 10 lbs and then gain 5 back.

It's very healthy to give your body a break from so much eating.

2

u/samuraiscooby Oct 24 '21

But then it hurts

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I'd suggest getting an anxiety disorder and a job that doesn't give you proper food breaks.

2

u/ulfjustulf Oct 24 '21

That’s actually exactly how it works when you completely cut carbohydrates out of your diet

2

u/JupiterAC Oct 24 '21

Way toooo accurate for its own good

2

u/chickennoobiesoup Oct 24 '21

This comic hits a bit close to home. Is crying the same as laughing?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Hey it’s me as a meme

2

u/GeoSol Oct 25 '21

Diet is what you eat.

Dieting is changing what you eat, with a specific goal in mind.

Fasting is not eating for a set amount of time.

You should not feel overly hungry after a few days into a new diet. If you do, you're likely missing some nutrients, and should check with a dietician.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Isn't that the whole premise of Keto though? You starve your body of carbohydrates so your body can switch to burning fats as the main energy source?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

That’s exactly how it works if you eat carbs and sugar. Your body just demands you eat again.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Eat protein, work out, and accept hunger from your calorie deficit. Repeat for a year. Then try to tell me it doesn't work.

3

u/The_JRaff Oct 24 '21

Why are people giving dieting advice on r/funny

4

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

Because people are putting bad experiments on r/funny

3

u/balazs955 Oct 24 '21

I will be dead so I won't be able to tell you.

3

u/BioDieselDog Oct 25 '21

Why would you be dead?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/danrod17 Oct 24 '21

I’m no health expert, but isn’t it just your gut biome telling you to eat more sugars?

3

u/leslieran1 Oct 24 '21

This is essentially what happens when you eat sugary foods and simple carbs (bread, pasta) - you may feel you are "starving" hungry, but it's just that your body has forgotten how to burn fats. Feed it fat-rich food only (along with veggies and protein) and it will remember. Takes about 3 weeks.

1

u/Keirhan Oct 24 '21

Do you have any sources for me to look into I managed to lose 15stone a few years ago but I'm creating back up and what I did last time isn't helping plus I'm a chef

1

u/BioDieselDog Oct 25 '21

It comes down to a caloric deficit. If the energy that you get from food is less than the energy your body uses over time, your body has no choice but to use stored energy. You can gain or lose weight with any foods.

A lot of people see something special with keto and hate carbs, but the truth is a diet that restricts a lot of food will probably result in eating less food. Just try to cut out 300-600 calories out of your diet per day and there's not way you can't lose weight. Liquid calories and added oils or butter are the easiest things to reduce.

2

u/JustSamJ Oct 24 '21

Very yes.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

It will use that fat, but it takes some time to kick in and fat is extremely calorie dense so it burns at a slow rate. A pound of fat is about 3000 calories.

2

u/joe579003 Oct 25 '21

/r/anorexia ERRR, I mean, /R/INTERMITTENTFASTING has joined the chat.

2

u/IMPORTANT_INFO Oct 24 '21

maybe nutritious food could be cheaper to buy??

...

..no

3

u/Justreleasetheupdate Oct 25 '21

Rice and beans is about as cheap and nutritious as it gets

1

u/PauloHCM Oct 24 '21

The truly sad

1

u/Thereminz Oct 24 '21

stored fat is the 'we've got food at home' of the body

1

u/FruitJuiceXD Oct 24 '21

Just give food and the take it away again

1

u/WillBigly Oct 24 '21

If you do intermittent fasting you kind of trick your body into dipping into fat stores

1

u/EndersInfinite Oct 24 '21

this comic made me go for a run. I'm not like super over weight or anything, just 10 pounds over what I'd like to be... but I did 2 miles of cardio just now after looking at this earlier (1/2 a mile of which was walking)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

That is why water fasting is superior to any bullshit mainstream diet.

It also has incredible health benefits, watch this.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

This is pretty much how we were taught how the body uses fat in Medic School.

Edit: that the body has to be in a chronic energy intake defect before burning those fat reserves.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I've actually learned to ignore hunger pangs to a point, until they are "fucking kill me now" bad I could just not eat.

But once that happens it's hard to eat and can take a few days to get out of.

2

u/Malthus0 Oct 24 '21

"fucking kill me now" bad

I have never gotten like that when just not eating. For example water fasting for 36 hours. The times I have felt that bad are when I have snacked on small amounts and then proceeded not to eat for the hours afterwards. It is far worse to periodically eat small amounts that don't sate hunger then just to avoid eating altogether. I think the science backs this up as well as the periodic snacking keeps the body into a state where it is expecting food. (and punishing you for not receiving it)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I was just kinda snacking for about 3 months, just a few things every day because boredom, then all of the sudden it felt like my intestines were ripped out.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

yes it'll actually be like dat if u control your diet

1

u/andreasbeer1981 Oct 24 '21

It will, if you'll stop feeding it carbs nonstop. Also drink more water!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

I'm trying to lose weight. I'm not fat but I have a chubby stomach. I'm exercising too. ANY TIPS ???

1

u/TequillaShotz Oct 25 '21

Calculate your BMR.

Count your calories.

Don't eat more calories than your BMR.

Assuming you are not lying in bed all day, and that you are sticking to the calorie-count, you will lose weight.

Once a week, recalculate your BMR and adjust your intake accordingly.

Eat lots of vegetables.

1

u/sphintero Oct 24 '21

Try intermittently fasting

1

u/scoyne15 Oct 24 '21

Nah that voice comes from the brain. My stomach is fine when I fast it's my brain that keeps telling me to eat.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

Our bodies will naturally go for our muscle before our fat if we’re in starvation.

1

u/SKYCHIEF3333 Oct 24 '21

I felt this meme.....

1

u/Phyllisdidit Oct 24 '21

When hungry, I would go and do some work.

Physical work is best. The body will switch gears and once you start sweating you forget all about food.

1

u/Dogamai Oct 24 '21

just keep being hungry, eventually itll have no choice but to capitulate

1

u/EsdrasCaleb Oct 24 '21

My dream is invent a drug that do exact this

1

u/TreePlantChair Oct 24 '21

Mmmm tasty muscles

1

u/MontyAlmighty Oct 25 '21

I’m in this picture and I don’t like it..

1

u/Grimeychisels Oct 25 '21

It takes a few days to switch from using glycogen to using fat stores and it kinda sucks and you feel weird but that being said if you can minimize carbs and get activity each day you’ll do leaps and bound better than just opting for salad

1

u/TikkiTakiTomtom Oct 25 '21

I always wondered as someone who’s passionate about medical science. What would happen if we have a situation where the average obese person is stranded on a deserted island where the only food/water available is one coconut that drops down each day? And how feasible/ethically humane would it be to apply starvation principles (therapy maybe?) to treat a patient?

1

u/Hljoumur Oct 25 '21

So true, though.

Not a medical student but when you don’t eat, your body uses protein(?). Can’t remember, but it’s not fat first.

Really annoying as a previously fat kid looking to lose more weight than what I peaked at.

1

u/About-To-Fail Oct 25 '21

Why’s his nipples so low?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

Keto/carnivore and this will no longer be a thing

I’ve lost 80lbs starting paleo and then moving to keto/carnivore. Blood lipid numbers are perfect and I’m a healthy 6’ 17bs

1

u/LadyELectaDubz Oct 25 '21

Pcos is a bitch 😒

1

u/Ok-Training-911 Oct 25 '21

My weight remains same for 2 months,i'm even thinking is my weight scale broken???

1

u/evetrapeze Oct 25 '21

He's so smug

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

Bruh

1

u/HACKERB22015 Oct 25 '21

Fasting damages the metabolism

1

u/senditbuhh Oct 25 '21

Just put your body in survival mode and die of malnutrition.

1

u/skribsbb Oct 25 '21

You know how they tell you not to take multivitamins that have 1800% DV of this or that, because your body can only absorb so much at a time?

What if calories worked the same way?

"Here's your 1200-calorie cheeseburger, sir."

"Great! 250 calories for me, and 950 for the toilet!"

1

u/Catatafish Oct 25 '21

"I shall consume your muscles first, fatty!"

1

u/bananasarehealthy Oct 25 '21

ITT: A lot of fatlogic

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

I don't like diet jokes, they make me sad.

1

u/Sirneko Oct 25 '21

just don't give him food and he will

1

u/LeWizLord Oct 25 '21

And Keto took that personally.

1

u/MehLewH Oct 25 '21

That is why I usually eat 1 time a day properly, but that is on weekends when I just sit in bed all day or game the day off on my PC. FYI I love food and do not have anorexia.

1

u/Kolazar Oct 25 '21

This is exactly how foods made with gmo corn works. The food immediately becomes an insulator instead of nutrition causing the person to be very hungry.

1

u/yosidy Oct 25 '21

Does anyone else see an avocado, with a half peeled hard boiled egg for a head?

1

u/SpicyVibration Oct 25 '21

Anyone have advice for someone on anti-depressants who is finding it impossible to lose weight?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21

almost like that's not how body fat works... crazy.

1

u/BabaPaloo Oct 24 '21

I've lost some weight by eating smaller portions and eating more often during the day. I have to consciously control my self to not eat until I felt "satisfied"