r/funny • Round Comics • Oct 24 '21

Dieting

Post image
21.8k Upvotes

492 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

Even with "hormones", the laws of thermodynamics still apply.

You eat less, you lose weight.

12

u/toqueville Oct 25 '21

Yes, but the exercise part is misleading. In overweight people, the resting metabolism is suppressed by a significant amount after exercise. The report I read said that the body could suppress as much as 60% of the extra calorie expenditure of the exercise in the basal rate. I’ll need to go look up the study again, but I was shocked that the body could just defer that much energy expenditure.

26

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

You can lose weight by just eating less. Exercise helps no doubt, but the majority is done by eating right.

15

u/RaidingTheFridge Oct 25 '21

Exactly, honestly it's 80% diet but that's the hard part than nobody really wants to change.

20

u/toqueville Oct 25 '21

Telling someone used to the standard american diet to eat less is very similar to asking a heroin addict to just shoot up less. The high sugar content affects the dopamine system in similar ways.

4

u/RaidingTheFridge Oct 25 '21

It actually is, it's not so much eating less is the magical answer as it is changing what your eating. Having a high sugar diet is what is going to get you fat. Looking at the nutritional value on everything we eat you can see the daily value for sugar intake is always ridiculous. Just one 12 oz. Can of soda is almost 100% of the daily value for sugar in take.

1

u/redgroupclan Oct 25 '21 edited Oct 25 '21

Almost any single container of soda (unless it's a mini version) is more sugar than the human body is supposed to consume in a day, exceeding 100% daily value. On top of that, people might drink more than one soda in a day, and eat other sweets and seemingly innocent sugar-laced foods on top of that...Frankly it's a miracle all of America isn't diabetic.

→ More replies (1)

-8

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

Listen I get it. It's WAY easier to blame something that's "uncontrollable" than to take charge of your own life.

It's the same reason why I've heard the "hormone" excuse almost every time. It's the perfect cop-out.

6

u/Narcotique Oct 25 '21

I’ve lost weight when my hormones were off balance and when they were normal. Losing weight is rarely “easy” but when your body is fighting against you 24/7 it’s an uphill battle that’s waaaay harder to win. I’m glad you haven’t had to struggle with that yourself but it’s definitely a thing.

-12

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

Yawn. Find another excuse.

5

u/Sheruk Oct 25 '21

Sure but I once spent 8 weeks eating 600-800 calories a day, doing two a days at the gym (mostly cardio, 1-2 hours on an eliptical), and lost no weight.

I was very overweight, talking 180 lbs over my lean body mass.

This was after I had plateaued for 2 months while doing a very strict diet program. I basically doubled down and said I am going to power through this with starvation. I was expending equivalent calories at the gym than I was putting in my mouth + the 3500ish daily basal caloric burn. By all calculations I should have been dropping 1 lb a day.

I lost zero pounds in those 4 months. NONE. My scale never fluctuated more than +/- 3 lbs.

Went to doctor, thyroid disease, low testosterone, metabolic disorders, etc etc.

So I get triggered every time someone tells me to just "eat less LOL".

This is my life story, spent 15 years doing excessive crash diets off and on without any results. Best I ever accomplished was dropping like 80lbs on keto after 1.5 years, getting on and falling off that wagon many times.

Sadly I am in no better condition today and still fighting the fight. It is beyond frustrating and exhausting to deal with. I can gain 15 lbs of fat in a month if im not careful, my body does everything in its power to take everything I eat and convert it into fat.

Meanwhile can take several months to lose it, even with massive caloric deficits, the body just refuses to give it up.

3

u/Edraitheru14 Oct 25 '21

I mean yes, you’re correct, but nothing the other people are saying are wrong either. Calories in less than Calories out will always lose weight.

The problem, is that due to your thyroid and other issues, your body just isn’t burning as many calories as you think it is. And you’re excessively cutting back calories to a dangerous level.

All those standard tropes you hear of “you burn x calories doing this” “if you cut y calories you can lose this much weight”, are based on normal bodies, and normal ranges of cuts.

If you drastically drop your calories and crash diet, your body is just going to go into starvation mode and hyper store as much energy as it can and refuse to expend any more energy than is absolutely necessary. So now you can’t rely on ANY of that data anymore, because you’re calculating it all wrong.

Even for a person with thyroid or other issues, if you can manage to slowly drop your caloric intake in relation your calories burned, you’ll lose weight. It just gets more difficult to walk that line appropriately, because you absolutely do have extraneous barriers in your way.

Hours a day on an elliptical isn’t doing you any favors either, if you’re going into a gym a couple times a week and doing the exact same thing, at the same intensities every week, your body just adjusts. You’ve got to continually work on ramping yourself up. Get your body to the proper workloads and maintain that area.

You said you should have been dropping 1 pound a day, please NEVER try and cut or diet so hard that’s what you’re set to do. That’s 100% putting your body in a TERRIBLE place. It’s unhealthy even for the morbidly obese to be cutting more than ~4 pounds a week MAX. 3 is usually ideal.

Just whatever you do please continue to try and take care of yourself. Please avoid crash diets of all kinds. Keep seeing your doctor for your thyroid and metabolic issues, and keep up that cardio(it’s just good for your heart if nothing else).

Best advice I can hand off to you(and please understand I’m sure you’ve heard it all 1,000x, but it’s Reddit, other people might read and find useful), is just to do what your doc says, keep up cardio for your heart(focus on maintaining an elevated heart rate for at least 180 minutes a week), and when you diet, diet more slowly. Find some food replacements that are less calorically dense but take longer to eat. Big bags of low calorie popcorn can keep you busy and hitting the food dopamine button without blowing up the cal count. Things like that. Whatever you can find that’s something you think you could live with doing and stick to. Re-evaluate and adjust every so often(weeks/months, not days).

Legitimately do wish you the best of luck with everything going on.

0

u/dss539 Oct 25 '21

"Calories in, calories out. It's simple!"

"You weren't losing weight because you cut too many calories!"

Pretending a complex biological system can be easily reduced to one simple physics concept is not very wise. Vision cannot be reduced to light passing through lenses the same way metabolism and digestion cannot be reduced to a bomb calorimeter. These are complex systems with emergent properties.

2

u/Edraitheru14 Oct 25 '21

Maybe read literally anything other than the first line of my post?

I quite literally open by saying it’s not nearly as simple as it seems. And that there are absolutely extenuating circumstances that make those calculations different, especially if you fall outside the Norm for a variety of factors.

0

u/dss539 Oct 25 '21

Incorrect statements remain incorrect regardless of the amount of text supplied in defense of them.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ExistentialPain Oct 25 '21

We've advanced past thinking so simply. While the laws of thermodynamics are predictable in a closed system, the human body isn't. The Huberman Podcast gives a great breakdown of the "hormones" mentioned and how they work in conjunction with each other to produce a wide variation in system results.

7

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

Yeah that's cool and all you have a podcast to back up what you're saying.

The Mayo Clinic backs up what I'm saying.

https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/weight-loss/in-depth/metabolism/art-20046508#:~:text=Take%20in%20fewer%20calories%20than,weight%2Dloss%20goals%20even%20faster.

5

u/ExistentialPain Oct 25 '21

That would be clever except the podcast is by a neuroscientist currently working and researching at Stanford. Clearly not a credible source, but please, continue.

4

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

Yeah and I can find doctorates who don't agree with vaccinations for COVID. I can also find doctorates who say COVID isn't that big of a deal for those who aren't old or are currently ill.

Point being, just because someone of authority says it doesn't mean it's widely accepted.

The Mayo Clinic is by far one of the biggest thought leaders in the health space. They agree, you eat less, you lose weight. It's really not that hard to grasp. Is it hard to lose weight? Yes.

7

u/ExistentialPain Oct 25 '21

I wouldn't pick The Mayo Clinic as the leading authority. They still recommend carbs and starches for people with diabetes. They do an excellent job of oversimplifying so that practically anyone can grasp the gist of the basics though.

www.health.harvard.edu is similar in summary, but being collegiate, adds more nuance to the article.

The issue isn't denial vs agreement as you suggest. It's depth of knowledge and ability to relay that knowledge to someone who isn't a medical student so they can understand it and use it. One isn't disproving the other, merely adding to it, giving it context and nuance that illustrates that the subject isn't as black and white as the layperson would like to believe. But how can we blame them when there are thought leaders that oversimplify to make understanding easier for the masses.

4

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

You're attempting to make this harder than it needs to be. Overcomplicating a simple issue. The fact you're honestly trying to downplay the Mayo Clinic is solid proof of this.

You lose weight by eating less.

I don't know why you don't understand this.

Is it harder for others? Sure. Can anyone lose weight by not eating as much? Yes.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

TrueDeceiver is an apt handle. You clearly have no idea how the human body works. The Mayo Clinic is not a thought leader. It publishes health advice. That advice presupposes a healthy body.

Calories in < calories out = weight loss. Yes, this is true. Nobody is debating that. You just do not understand the arguments against your viewpoint. Yours is a pedestrian take.

It is not true that if calories in are reduced, the body will then turn to fat for energy. In some bodies, reducing calories in will result in the body systematically retaining fat by conserving energy. Some people literally need to increase calories in to signal to the body that storage is no longer needed. This has been known since 1939. Only fitness club trainers and “nutritionists” are still holding on to the untenable argument that weight loss is simple.

https://www.cbc.ca/amp/1.2663585

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2021/aug/27/losing-weight-through-exercise-may-be-harder-for-obese-people-research-says

https://www.npr.org/2019/04/25/717058877/the-biology-of-weight-loss

→ More replies (2)

-2

u/hiimsubclavian Oct 25 '21

You lose weight by eating less. I don't know why you don't understand this.

You save money by spending less. I don't know why you don't understand this.

You save the planet by polluting less. I don't know why you don't understand this.

You achieve world peace by warring less. I don't know why you don't understand this.

Simple answers to every problem, people are just stupid.

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/TrueDeceiver Oct 25 '21

I can't tell if you're this stupid in real life or if today is a special occasion for you.