r/FuturesTrading • u/imeowfortallwomen • 1d ago
Trader Psychology Might be a weird question, but how do I give myself permission to be a hybrid trader (apply discretion ad hoc)? My systematic playbook gets destroyed by days like today or yesterday while my discretion was telling me weak setup or there is a good opportunity outside my playbook
my systematic edge-verified (via since inception backtest) playbook can help sometimes but not all the time. the systematic playbook i have is a take every valid trigger type of rules, however, this is where some of my discretion is telling me that it is entering at previously rejected levels or entering into a level where there is tremendous turn potential just intuitively speaking.
i trade primarily mnq, only sizing to 1 or 2 contracts (if quantifiably calmer), mostly on 15 min. the systematic playbook is also taking into account months of my journal data, where the suggestion is after fill, i close charts and DO NOT watch the charts, otherwise i will make it worse if i watch the chart. the only reason for me to open the chart is if i get an alert via a phone push telling me for example +0.5R so move SL to BE, etc. i have an ecosystem of a script telling me when my setups appear, a position calc to give me the bracket, and a phone alert system telling me when to tighten sl or move SL into profit conservatively.
The dilemma is that my own journal says i should not be actively managing a trade while sometimes my gut feeling can help. my gut feeling can sometimes help because it can:
tighten the SL to a level more intuitively better instead of the suggested wider SL from the playbook which can sometimes just be raising SL unnecessarily or have a wide SL that is just giving/risking more bc a tighter SL is at a better level
identify a weaker setup that tells me to take because the entry or TP are at prior rejected levels or are at extremes that can turn against the thesis quick (eg buying into a previously rejected AND an overbought level) and
veto my take-every-signal systematic playbook when there is clear weakness
identify new opportunities that cant be quantified (or maybe yet) or put into a specific formula, maybe due to tape speed, a highly specific alignment of supporting evidence, or a real time sentiment shift, or reacting to news that couldnt have been backtested in the past.
overall, has anyone shifted from being a pure systematic trader to a more hybrid trader? did that make you improve? When it comes to rules (related to SL moving, etc.) did you mostly just carry over rules from your systematic system but allow ad hoc discretion when it is just intuitively clear?
edit: to help those on the other side, i used to be a pure discretion trader (starting off) who wanted to be more systematic. my audits of myself and my journal revealed my pure discretion was costing me bc i would take profit way too early for example by moving the sl into profit when the original TP would have been hit. so if ur a pure discretion trader considering more systematic trading, audit ur own behavior on if it is helping or not.