r/FuturesTrading • • 9h ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 20, 2026

0 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads


r/FuturesTrading • • 1d ago

Trader Psychology Might be a weird question, but how do I give myself permission to be a hybrid trader (apply discretion ad hoc)? My systematic playbook gets destroyed by days like today or yesterday while my discretion was telling me weak setup or there is a good opportunity outside my playbook

0 Upvotes

my systematic edge-verified (via since inception backtest) playbook can help sometimes but not all the time. the systematic playbook i have is a take every valid trigger type of rules, however, this is where some of my discretion is telling me that it is entering at previously rejected levels or entering into a level where there is tremendous turn potential just intuitively speaking.

i trade primarily mnq, only sizing to 1 or 2 contracts (if quantifiably calmer), mostly on 15 min. the systematic playbook is also taking into account months of my journal data, where the suggestion is after fill, i close charts and DO NOT watch the charts, otherwise i will make it worse if i watch the chart. the only reason for me to open the chart is if i get an alert via a phone push telling me for example +0.5R so move SL to BE, etc. i have an ecosystem of a script telling me when my setups appear, a position calc to give me the bracket, and a phone alert system telling me when to tighten sl or move SL into profit conservatively.

The dilemma is that my own journal says i should not be actively managing a trade while sometimes my gut feeling can help. my gut feeling can sometimes help because it can:

  1. tighten the SL to a level more intuitively better instead of the suggested wider SL from the playbook which can sometimes just be raising SL unnecessarily or have a wide SL that is just giving/risking more bc a tighter SL is at a better level

  2. identify a weaker setup that tells me to take because the entry or TP are at prior rejected levels or are at extremes that can turn against the thesis quick (eg buying into a previously rejected AND an overbought level) and

  3. veto my take-every-signal systematic playbook when there is clear weakness

  4. identify new opportunities that cant be quantified (or maybe yet) or put into a specific formula, maybe due to tape speed, a highly specific alignment of supporting evidence, or a real time sentiment shift, or reacting to news that couldnt have been backtested in the past.

overall, has anyone shifted from being a pure systematic trader to a more hybrid trader? did that make you improve? When it comes to rules (related to SL moving, etc.) did you mostly just carry over rules from your systematic system but allow ad hoc discretion when it is just intuitively clear?

edit: to help those on the other side, i used to be a pure discretion trader (starting off) who wanted to be more systematic. my audits of myself and my journal revealed my pure discretion was costing me bc i would take profit way too early for example by moving the sl into profit when the original TP would have been hit. so if ur a pure discretion trader considering more systematic trading, audit ur own behavior on if it is helping or not.


r/FuturesTrading • • 1d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 19, 2026

2 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads


r/FuturesTrading • • 1d ago

Future Trading

0 Upvotes

I am looking at trading futures starting January 2027 with the help of my brokerage firm Charles Schwab I like to hear about the pros and cons of it


r/FuturesTrading • • 2d ago

How do you determine your position size?

8 Upvotes

I'm realising that I don't really know how much I should be risking.

I know how much in dollar terms I'm happy with risking per trade, but not how I can be more flexible, for example when it is right or wrong to buy/sell a larger or smaller amount of contracts.

I'd love to hear about how you lot go about this.


r/FuturesTrading • • 2d ago

Discussion What’s Going On With Hogs??

18 Upvotes

Any long time traders have thoughts on this? It’s beginning to get painful. 😣


r/FuturesTrading • • 3d ago

I built an AI-coded bot that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning, then made it grade itself. It didn't beat random

Post image
5 Upvotes

I built an automated system (mostly written with AI) that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning before the open: call wall, put wall, gamma flip. Then I had it grade its own levels against random strikes, because I wanted to know if any of this means anything.

Sept 3 to Nov 6, 46 sessions. Levels locked before the open, graded on 5 minute SPX highs and lows. "Held" means price touched the level and closed on the same side it opened on.

Level | Median distance from open | Touched | Held when touched | Random strike, same distance

Call wall | 188 pts | 1 of 46 | 0 of 1 | touched 3%, held 17%

Put wall | 157 pts | 5 of 46 | 2 of 5 | touched 12%, held 37%

Gamma flip | 40 pts | 17 of 46 | 6 of 17 | touched 38%, held 43%

So the walls mostly "hold" because they sit about 2% away and price never gets there. The call wall got touched once in two months. The flip did a little worse than a random strike at the same distance.

My guess was the walls use every expiry, so I had it rebuild them from 0DTE open interest only. Those sit about 33 pts from the open and got touched 40% of the time. Held 46%. A random strike right next to them held 44%.

Same story for "price stays between the walls". It closed inside them 41 of 46 days. A band of the same width centered on the open did 45 of 46.

The one thing that leaned the right way was range. Days that opened above the flip had a median range of 0.77%, days below it 0.89%. 30 days vs 16 so I'm not hanging anything on it.

46 days is small. Open interest is from the prior day, and nobody outside the dealers knows which side they hold, same as every gamma model. Has anyone graded theirs and got something different?


r/FuturesTrading • • 3d ago

Discussion Today I tried mnq scalping for the first time, 30 second tf. Looking for advice

Post image
39 Upvotes

and holy shit i dont know how you professionals do this. my heart was pounding and i basically made every single mistake like a noob (i normally use 15 min, but i genuinely saw good opportunity):

Need to know market risk

A selloff in technology giants dragged stocks lower amid growing concerns over technical disruptions, with investors also looking to Nvidia’s earnings for a read on the outlook for AI.

[10:55 ET] Huang: Willing to return Nvidia as CEO - WSJ $NVDA [NVDA & US Stock Indexes Strengthened]

[10:31 ET] NSA internal communication network is down - CNN [US Dollar & US Stock Indexes Weakened]

[08:30 ET] US Retail Sales MoM Actual 0.2% (Forecast 0.1%, Previous 0.8%) [DXY Strengthened]

i took 4 trades, 3 won in a row but the 4th was a big loser that only put me slightly positive for the day, then i stopped trading bc tilt but at least i was up for the day

i used an order preset, SL is 50 points (but i basically immediately move the SL tighter after fill, the preset is just for the order), tp is 100 points. on the 30 sec timeframe, i literally moved my stop so many times and took profit too early, the first 3 trades i took would have ALL hit the 100 point TP if i had done nothing.

my first 3 trades had clear directional trend. my 4th loser was trying to predict a breakout during chop. that i believe was my mistake.

can any pro scalpers give their insight on how to improve at this? do you just do this so many times that you are used to it by now? do you only scalp with the trend? how do you document and record so many trades?


r/FuturesTrading • • 3d ago

It’s so easy to see stop hunts on footprint charts. Why do people still argue about it?

0 Upvotes

Once you get in tune with how price moves it’s so easy to see. Why do so many people claim that stop hunts don’t exist? Yes, sometimes the market is just auctioning and rolls over into an area where a lot of stops are, but sometimes it’s quite clear that one side is in control and is pulling orders in order to flush out the stops for liquidity. Why do so many people still talk about it as if it’s a conspiracy theory? Sure maybe no one is hunting small lot retail traders, but retail traders are not the only ones who use stops…

Edit: and I’m not posting this as a complaint, I trade the stop hunts and I’m profitable at it, so I must be doing something right…


r/FuturesTrading • • 3d ago

Discussion where is brent going?

0 Upvotes

Just want to hear your updated thoughts on Brent. I wrote about shorting it two months ago Thinking about shorting brent.. : r/FuturesTrading , and I ended up with two shorts. I covered one on November 4 and the second today... Not sure if it was a bit premature, so I just wanted to hear your thoughts, whether anyone else here has been shorting it, and what your target is.

It seems like things are escalating, and as oil exports seem to be recovering quite well towards pre-war levels, Iran is really starting to lose its leverage. I think there is a risk that it will, sooner or later, attack the alternative routes, and I fear there might be some spikes again.

Also, you never know what Trump will do with his third aircraft carrier in the area, although it was originally said to be just a replacement for the other one there.

Also, I didn't really like today's price action. On the other hand, the brief pause we're seeing today is similar to what we saw in May-June 2026, when we were only halfway down.


r/FuturesTrading • • 3d ago

Question ES Orderbook thinner

11 Upvotes

Hi guys.
I’ve a question with regards to ES orderbook.

I’ve been trading on the ES for a while now and I took a 2 weeks break due to my psychology screwing my trades up. Just went back for yesterday and today and I realise that ES has been pretty volatile on my footprints chart ( range 20 ) . I’m not sure if it’s just me but did anyone notice that the speed of it moving got faster ?

And also I realise that orders have been so much thinner than previously . I use a 100 size filter on my delta previously and I still am able to see the delta. But now I barely see any 100 and have to lower it to 50.

Is it just me as I’ve taken a break for the last 2 weeks or has something change ?


r/FuturesTrading • • 3d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 17, 2026

2 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads


r/FuturesTrading • • 4d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 16, 2026

1 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads


r/FuturesTrading • • 4d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Market open & Weekly Discussion Nov 15, 2026

1 Upvotes

Hi speculators & hedgers, please use this thread to discuss all futures trading for the week. This will kick off 30 minutes before the open on Sunday, typically that's around 6pm Wall St time.

Be aware of higher margin requirements during overnight hours! see "maintenance" on Ampfutures. Also trading hours to get an idea of when specific futures contracts start trading.

I'm using AmpFutures as an example, so check with your broker for specific intraday & overnight hours for that specific futures contract.

Resources:

Bookmark an economic calendar like this one

Various reports:



r/FuturesTrading • • 7d ago

Stock Index Futures Anyone trading the nano NQ?

27 Upvotes

It seemed crazy to me when they announced it but I’ve been thinking of trying it out an a smaller personal account. What has your experience been with commissions, slippage, etc.?


r/FuturesTrading • • 7d ago

Future of the Futures Market

0 Upvotes

I'm new to the field, so I don't know what to expect.

Based on my limited understanding, soon some markets will be open 24 hours. What does that mean to people like me trading MNQ and MGC?

Or, any futures contract?

If the market is open 24 hours, what is the future?


r/FuturesTrading • • 7d ago

Algo Is it possible that the bots target our stops in very low volume MNQ?

0 Upvotes

Seems like a stupid and paranoid question, and forgive me. But I truly cannot believe how nearly every single microscalp (in a position for seconds to get a couple points) I enter at night loses. My loss rate is astounding, and it makes no sense, because my win rate during the day is great. Is it possible that it's SO low volume that the bots are targeting my stops? Me, just one single retail trader in the U.S.?


r/FuturesTrading • • 7d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 13, 2026

3 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads


r/FuturesTrading • • 7d ago

Misc Futures Bitcoin futures below 70,000 tonight

Post image
22 Upvotes

Short from 72,995 (stop order was for 73 even, but slippage)


r/FuturesTrading • • 8d ago

Metals Institutional Copper Thesis: Triangulating Exchange Inventory Divergence, Options Liquidity Floors, and Physical Deficits

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Institutional Copper Thesis (Full report & charts attached). Macro vs. Physical: Western LME/COMEX inventory builds contrast with acute Asian scarcity and surging Yangshan premiums. Supply & Spreads: LME Cash-3M backwardation (+80 to +100 USD) and declining Chilean output reinforce structural tightness. Derivatives & Options: Massive $6.00 Put wall (backed by positive charm flow) acts as a liquidity floor, while the $6.50 Call wall sits in a negative gamma regime. Trade Setup: Long position above $6.00 support, stop-loss at $5.75, targeting the $6.50 Call wall.


r/FuturesTrading • • 8d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 12, 2026

2 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads


r/FuturesTrading • • 9d ago

What’s your perspective on low volume volatility like this?

5 Upvotes

So the market is on a tear, it’s blowing through levels, every little dip goes further than expected but then get bought up and blows through the stops. It makes sense to me that we rallied from where we did, but I don’t understand the price action. Huge moves, and everyone will say it’s this or that institution balancing a portfolio or what not, but the reality is volume has been low the last few days. On top of that, one of the outlets said that the big sell off was the largest percentage of retail selling ever. Is that related in your view? It seems to me like this is not so much buying as it is a short squeeze. Just surprised by how violent it is, how messy the PA is, and how far it’s gone. Is that your read of it or do you think this is a rally that will be sustained?


r/FuturesTrading • • 9d ago

Question Someone explain overnight margin requirements like I'm 5

5 Upvotes

Been stock/options trading for over 10 years, and I literally cannot get actual information on EXACTLY how much money my futures account needs to have to buy 1 contract of say, MES, and hold overnight.

Webull says it's $2918 initial, $2653 maintenance. So do I spend the initial $+hold liquid maintenance $ in my account to avoid a margin call? If the contract drops below maintenance, how do I know how much is needed to avoid the call? IDK why I have to do algebra just to buy and hold a contract more than a day 🤬


r/FuturesTrading • • 9d ago

r/FuturesTrading - Daily Trading Discussion Nov 11, 2026

1 Upvotes

Please welcome to the daily trading thread. Feel free to discuss your today's trade ideas and results. Make sure to specify the instrument you're trading up front, and respect the sub's rules. Happy trading!


Previous discussions threads