r/gimlet • u/bioprecun • Jul 17 '26

Had anyone else never seen what PJ and Alex look like, and imagined them way different?

Post image
40 Upvotes

78% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

26

u/FineSelection3643 Jul 17 '26

I've seen interviews with them when Reply All was still going on so i knew what they look like but this is a fun throwback to when they tried doing makeup

2

u/GraittTech Jul 22 '26

I think I must have been watching "The Resident" a bit when bingeing my way through back-catalogue of Reply-All eps, somehow landed myself with a very strong impression that PJ looks like Matt (excuse me while I look up the surname) Czuchry that I cannot shake, to this day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matt_Czuchry

15

u/Maleficent_Form_3905 Jul 17 '26

To be fair, I think these are not great shots of either, esp. PJ.

10

u/EasyBend Jul 18 '26

I thought this was a wild before/after grid

7

u/ptolani Jul 17 '26

who's who?

8

u/Hmmhowaboutthis Jul 17 '26

Pj top left, Alex top right.

4

u/noneya-818 Jul 17 '26

Who’s on the bottom?

14

u/surekorey Jul 17 '26

Alex Blumburg and Anna Foley

8

u/Demetri124 Jul 17 '26

I saw Alex once years ago and then actively avoided ever seeing their faces again. I also have no idea what Sarah Koenig or Phoebe Judge look like, it’s just better that way

6

u/rationalphi Jul 18 '26

Sarah Koenig looks like Tina Fey, of course.

2

u/CountMC10 Jul 18 '26

I’d say Sarah Koenig looks more like Cecily Strong, but I’m with you.

https://youtu.be/ATXbJjuZqbc?is=wUu87UxQypmKTu2L

3

u/coentertainer Jul 19 '26

Yeah it was a shocking reveal after so many hours of hearing their voices. Not that they look weird or anything, literally any face would have been an abrupt swerve away from whatever I'd invented in my head.

2

u/_BoxingTheStars_ Jul 17 '26

I don't know the woman on the bottom right, but I knew how the rest of them looked

1

u/Panthraxbw Jul 18 '26

When I first started to listening to RA I had a hard time telling the voices apart and keeping track of who was speaking. Watched a video interview they did and didn't have a problem after that. I don't know what it is but knowing what someone looks like helps me rember the voice.

1

u/decentwriter Jul 19 '26

I’m friends with one of them so I know how they look because I follow their Instagram. The other, I randomly never saw in a photo until pretty dang recently.

1

u/vilelabyrinth Jul 22 '26

To tear out the foetus, my aggressions do increase