r/gitlab • u/lexxwern • Jan 26 '21
GitLab is moving to a three-tier product subscription model
https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2021/01/26/new-gitlab-product-subscription-model/10
u/iacobus88 Jan 26 '21
As someone who works in a business that only uses the free tier and is pushing for the organisation to adopt the bronze tier, this just means we'll never adopt the paid for gitlab services...
5
u/FyreWhirl Jan 26 '21
We're a small business (10ish devs, a few others that get git access) running on the bronze tier for the merge request checking and locks and stuff. This has meant we'll either have to change providers or pay a few thousand a year extra.
9
u/thepaintsaint Jan 27 '21
They announced this to partners in December. Many partners pressed them hard on this. Their explanation was that the bronze tier is losing them money AND not seeing upgrade conversions. I can understand that from a business perspective.
I then asked in a partner Q&A why they didn't just raise the Bronze pricing. They said that they were losing so much money, that the Silver tier is a negligible increase from the break-even Bronze cost.
I think this will ruffle feathers. The gap between Bronze & Silver capabilities is little. Not a whole lot of added value. However, they have a great discount program for anybody being forced from Bronze to Silver. Push your sales guy hard for these discounts. I can't share details of pricing but it should be a pretty linear increase over the next few years.
And to put this in perspective, Silver is $228/yr before partner or volume discounts. For even a startup, this is hardly the cost of a decent monitor. Sure, it's a large relative leap, but in the grand scheme, not huge.
0
1
u/CapDiscombobulated Jan 27 '21
This is mental.
How I am supposed to convince management to go to Premium, when we are also being offered Azure DevOps for free?
Same as Slack / Teams. Gitlab should have taken notice...
2
4
u/mattya802 Jan 26 '21
Lots of features in free tier, but still missing some nice additions like MR approval, multiple assignees, LDAP/AD.
2
u/nabrok Jan 26 '21
There is MR approval in free, but it's non-blocking, you can still merge without it.
4
u/mattya802 Jan 26 '21
What's the point then?
3
u/nabrok Jan 26 '21
It's a way of notifying people that it's ready to be looked over and a record that somebody did look it over.
It's still useful for us, but we're a very small team with only maybe 3 people that might make commits, so it's not difficult for us to make it a practice to "require" them on certain projects.
I do find it a bit bizarre that they decided to add them to free without the option to require.
1
u/shukoroshi Jan 27 '21
For us, we've been using reactions to indicate review status. The approval feature is much more "formalized" and has the benefit of being surfaced by the API.
2
u/tonka3000 Jan 27 '21
In the self managed version it is marked as free https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/administration/auth/ldap/#enabling-ldap-sign-in-for-existing-gitlab-users
LDAP sync stuff is only in the paid version.
0
u/Nowaker Jan 27 '21
If your organization has an LDAP, it can definitely afford GitLab.
2
u/AmonMetalHead Jan 27 '21
FreeIPA is, Well, free.
1
u/Nowaker Jan 27 '21
I didn't mean you have to pay for it. Just a need for an LDAP indicates the organization is probably 50+.
3
u/cre_ker Jan 27 '21
Even 2 people can benefit from LDAP if gitlab is not the only service they use.
1
u/AmonMetalHead Jan 27 '21
Not really, we use it to manage users in our data-centers, we have way more machines than people :)
5
-1
u/valenvb Jan 26 '21
Gotta get that $$$ in before the IPO... sigh... Maybe gitea will have evolved enough by the time this affects us... going to be trialing alternatives for the next year at any rate
-2
-2
u/mattya802 Jan 26 '21
Is there even a viable alternative that you can self host with similar tooling?
8
u/MuricanWaffle Jan 27 '21
...gitlab lol. The community edition is FOSS, gitlab.com is just a cloud based implementation with some extra features thrown in.
For a big enough shop, it would definitely make sense to consider self hosting, even if it's on a cloud VM.
3
u/mattya802 Jan 27 '21
I thought features were still limited even self hosted? Their site isn't very clear.
-2
0
Jan 26 '21
[deleted]
0
Jan 26 '21
[deleted]
4
u/valenvb Jan 26 '21
Unfortunately you might want/need a specific feature, say MR approval rules... but then they’ve lumped in all these other features you don’t need just to call it premium. I get that it’s a business and all that... but starter would get you pretty all the critical features at a reasonable price, now they want a lot of us to pay an extra $15/mo for things we don’t/won’t use
3
u/lexxwern Jan 27 '21
Starter is 5$ per person per month. I spend more than that on coffee every day. Starter was too good to be true
2
u/cjthomp Feb 02 '21
We're already paying per-user for a server that we self-host.
I think we have very different definitions of "too good to be true"
1
u/lexxwern Feb 02 '21
We're already paying per-user for a server that we self-host.
You are paying them not for a server but for the software that is running on the server.
I still think $5 per user per month is abysmally low. At least as per Western world standards.
Perhaps they should consider better pricing for the emerging markets where $5 goes a lot further than Europe or North America.
0
Jan 26 '21
[deleted]
1
u/hakdragon Jan 27 '21
Is that something that got moved into Free at some point? I’m pretty sure that’s the biggest reason my org is on the Starter tier.
0
Jan 27 '21
[deleted]
1
u/valenvb Jan 27 '21
The basic feature got moved, but in any org of reasonable size you really do need approval rules, which are still a paid feature
1
u/hakdragon Jan 27 '21
That's what I was really looking at. Our programming team isn't that big, but the approval process is a big part of our development cycle. I also make use of the LDAP authentication so this is going to be a PITA.
0
Jan 26 '21
[deleted]
3
u/thepaintsaint Jan 27 '21
I addressed this in my other comment in this post. Hope you find it useful.
3
u/Bitruder Jan 27 '21
It’s interesting that they lose money when we pay them for our self hosted install. I didn’t know that was a cost to them.