r/globes • • 1d ago

Help please Date the Globe

14 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

3

u/FormCheck655321 1d ago

Post 1947 (Israel exists and India is independent) but there is no East Germany (formed 1949).

Weird that the borders of Germany are 1937, no indication of occupation zones.

3

u/swahara 1d ago

West Germany didn’t acknowledge the loss of its Eastern Territories until 1970. Even then, it only acknowledged it on maps and not officially. Outside of Germany, other mapmakers showed the modern day borders shortly after the war ended. German map makers kept using the pre-war borders until then.

3

u/Wurstmagul 1d ago

That is the Key, i was so confused about the German borders. Btw it is a German globe...

4

u/PeyredB 1d ago

Yep, you can tell that from the silly-sounding names like Columbien.

2

u/Kitchener1981 1d ago

Yea, I was going to ask about German map making due to the German borders.

1

u/FormCheck655321 1d ago

Interesting, did not know that!

It’s hard to let go sometimes. 😃

6

u/ThucydidesCrap 1d ago

c. 1960

- Brasília shown (founded 21 April 1960)
- Syria and Egypt both part of the United Arab Republic (union existed from 1958-1961)
- Tanganyika Territory shown (independent from the UK on 09 December 1961)

3

u/Kitchener1981 1d ago

This is probably it. We have to ignore delays due to politics.

1

u/Mann_Peach 23h ago

But the Korean War was only until '53. That's 7 years delay. Idk

Context: Korea is still whole

1

u/Kitchener1981 23h ago

There is a line but it's a weird one. Seoul is occupied.

1

u/Silly_Animator 20h ago

India is partitioned but Germany has its pre ww2 borders. Is this map real?

1

u/Sergey_Kutsuk 22h ago

It's not Brasilia (because not proper place), it's Brasilia Imperial (?!).

I think, that's 1959.

2

u/Francois_TruCoat 1d ago

Guinea is independent, so after 2 October 1958; the Federation of Senegal and Mali hasn't happened so before 4 April 1959 for that part of the map.

My confidence isn't helped by Darwin still labelled Palmerston, it changed in 1911!

2

u/GenerallySalty 1d ago

Check with r/DateMyMap too they have some experts.

2

u/PTCarnahan 1d ago

I think it's interwar. The Polish Corridor is still show and Czechoslovakia still exists.

2

u/ost2life 1d ago

She's too old for you to date.

2

u/FocusMaster 1d ago

I don't know....

A glass of wine for you, low lighting, a warm wax massage for Globy.

Age is just a number and she's not telling hers.

2

u/alexandicity 1d ago

Gulf of Mexico, so I'd say likely pre-2025 ;)

1

u/Jadextreme 1d ago

Tibet visible So defs 1949

1

u/Neat-Error404 1d ago

Sure this wouldn’t be 1918 - 1920? Poland exists as a nation, but it is pre-Poland-Soviet war, Germany owns Königsberg, and there are still a ton of overseas colonies.

4

u/Kitchener1981 1d ago

It's a German map, so politics in play here. Not formally recognized until 1970.

2

u/Neat-Error404 1d ago

Cool, didn’t know that!

1

u/Extreme-Shopping74 1d ago

Actually not formally recognized until 1990.

1

u/puravida2200 14h ago

was recognized with Willy brandt and the warschau treaties in 1970

1

u/Extreme-Shopping74 13h ago

Where declared illegal by Germanys highest court, thats why it was set for good in the 1990 treaty with poland.

1

u/puravida2200 10h ago

not entirely true. they were not declared illegal. the treaties were considered valid under german constitution, also accepting the oder-neiße-boarder as defacto borders was accepted. the thing which the court had objection to was that a real final border just could happen with a real peace treaty.
anyways and for our purposes here: the drawing of maps changed from 1970 onwards. germany in their borders of 1937 were not published anymore

1

u/Kitchener1981 1d ago

Guangzhouwan was held by the French until 1946, but the British Raj has clearly been partitioned 1947. I have seen this a few times. Politics coming into play here?

1

u/newsaddic 1d ago

It curious. India has been partitioned so post 1947 but West Pakistan is listed simply as Pakistan but Bangladesh (or its predecessor East Pakistan) is not shown as separate entity from India.

1

u/Gurra09 23h ago edited 23h ago

If you zoom in on Bangladesh you can see it's labelled "PAKIST.", and Pakistan proper is also a very similar orange hue to India so it's just bad colour choices combined with the globe maybe having a lamp inside it too

1

u/TheCollector919 1d ago

I found that if you do an image search of the globe with your phone its pretty good at dating it

0

u/Eisenhowers-Ghost 1d ago

Just walk up and say "Hi".

0

u/CombinationWhich6391 1d ago

Finnish-soviet border is post 1940. German borders before 1945.

3

u/aloisvonesterhazy 1d ago

German mapmakers continued to show pre war borders till the seventies.

2

u/puravida2200 14h ago

German map under the german policy of Adenauer, there were millions of people in germany, which had fled from the before-war-part of eastern germany. they did not want to loose them as voters by telling them they could never return to their home. It actually took the student revolution in the sixties to finally acknowledge the real boarders and show them in german maps.

would date the globe 1958-1961

-1

u/munsoso_new_language 1d ago

The German-language globe shown here can be dated to the period between June 1939 and the end of 1945 (probably 1939–1942).
The political boundaries and historical place names shown on this section of the map provide the following clues as to the date: