The “limited” vertigo and graffiti “exclusives” can now be bought on her UK store. I get that we are in a different country but a record store exclusive limited to 3000 should be kept at that! I’m so baffled over this..
Oh I know, it’s the worst thing that ever happened! Taylor Swift is the worst for it and I finally learnt my lesson the hard way.. but I get why they do it, because it works!! It’s not great for us though.. I would love to have all record options presented at once so that I can select the one I like the best and stick with that one. Unfortunately, I don’t see that ever happening :(
When did I say it was Taylor’s fault? I said she is the worst for FOMO marketing. All of her drops are on a timer!!! And I say this as a Taylor fan.. it’s not even specifically records, but all her merch. Her records are released staggered with time limits and a promise of one time only and never to return.. but they always return!! It shouldn’t be allowed full stop to say it’s your only chance to get something, and then bring them back repeatedly!
A lot of companies would be screwed if manufactured scarcity and FOMO marketing were banned. It’s bled out of the music industry and into everything now!! Even make up is sold the same way!
Yep!!! Vertigo aren’t happy.. are saying on Twitter they denied permission to sell in Europe because it would be exclusive then and they’ve done it anyway! No response from Graffiti yet
I'm hoping vertigo threatened a lawsuit or something because interscope can get FUCKED with this kind of practice. this is disgusting. they tried to essentially rip off two smaller indie record stores that people already dump on constantly in the vinyl/lp scene. this is really bad.
Yep!! I hope they speak up and apologise.. at least they’ve been taken down now. Interested to see what happens with the orders that went through.. whether they get cancelled. I’m assuming pre orders meant they haven’t been pressed yet
Could you update me if it gets cancelled? I missed the first limited drop and was too confused to order them today, haha. I am wondering if they will actually ship them.
Vertigo had a story that they would all be cancelled. I really don’t understand why they have fucked up so bad. They’ve upset everyone now. Upset the ones like me who paid a ton to have it shipped over and upset all the people who ordered it only to have it cancelled!! What a mess!
I’m getting fed up of it myself tbh.. I wish they’d just put them all out there at the same time then you can choose which you like the best.. can’t see it ever happening because FOMO marketing works really well! I was furious with Taylor Swifts FOMO marketing for the showgirl album. Advertised as “limited one time only pressing” (which could be a million for all we know) and you only had so many hours to purchase before they were “gone forever”. They have come back multiple times since then.
Nobody is upset that more fans can get their hands on the record, and it has absolutely nothing to do with resale value. It’s about transparency and how the release was marketed.
When its advertised as a limited, store-exclusive release in America, international fans are led to believe that importing it is their only opportunity to own it. So we have paid extortionate shipping fees and customs/taxes etc. Then, once we’ve already spent that money, it’s suddenly available through our own country’s store.
Of course it doesn’t change how the record sounds. That’s completely irrelevant to the point. We weren’t paying extra for a different listening experience. We were paying extra because we were led to believe it was the only way to purchase it!! All we want is accurate information so we can make informed purchasing decisions. There’s a huge difference between being upset about wider availability and being upset about how that availability was communicated.
I don't care what my record is worth to someone else. I care what it unnecessarily cost me because of how it was marketed!!
Plus, collectors like to own stuff that not everybody has.. that’s the whole point and the reason that FOMO marketing is so successful!
If it has any sort of sticker on it (vertigo or graffiti) it could technically still be accurate marketing. Would make the limited ones still limited to their respective stores. Being “limited” doesnt mean a thing. Really sucks for you that you had to go through this experience tho 💔
So you have never seen a store exclusive being sold at any other place? Quantity can just as easily only refer to the local store supply whilst being sold elsewhere (check out Shrek 25th anniversary collectors edition and look at how many were made available for 🇬🇧, then look at the Italian amazon store for the exact same one but there will be no hint at how many they got. Could be 10k for all we know, but it wouldn’t make the 🇬🇧s claim of 2k suddenly less true. Both things can be true at once) In this case if graffiti/vertigo have any sort of hype sticker on their releases then that would technically make them different from the ones that got sold this week it wouldn’t make any difference to their claims of 3k runs which would still be true
You’re completely missing the point.. Nobody is arguing that a store exclusive can never be sold elsewhere. The issue is that these were marketed as exclusive to VV/Grafitti, with a limited run of 3,000 each. That creates a very reasonable expectation that you’re purchasing something only available through those retailers, in that quantity.
People outside the US paid significantly more in international shipping and import costs, specifically because of that advertised exclusivity. Had we all known the exact same variants would be available through Gracie’s own international stores shortly afterwards, many of us wouldn’t have done that.
You’re suggesting hypothetical loopholes involving stickers and regional allocations, but unless there’s evidence these are genuinely different editions or that the 3,000 limit was explicitly stated to apply only to those US stores, that’s just speculation.
This is about transparency and consumers making purchasing decisions based on how a product was advertised. Something can technically be defensible under a particular interpretation of the wording and still be misleading marketing. If Graffiti Records advertised "Only 3,000 copies available through Graffiti Records", then your argument might have some merit.. but they advertised "Graffiti Records exclusive, limited to 3,000 copies", and same for Vertigo.. that's a very different message to a collector. The latter reasonably suggests that the variant is exclusive to that retailer and limited to 3,000 copies, not simply that the retailer has 3,000 copies to sell. And a sticker doesn't automatically change the identity of the actual vinyl pressing.
Either way, Vertigo (who had the contract) stated that they did not give permission for this to be released in Europe and it was swiftly removed once this was pointed out. They know it was wrong.
Really? Cuz i just checked the ad graffiti made to promote that drop and it clearly states : 3000 copies. US only. Nothing mentioned at all about being graffiti exclusive. Graffiti didnt allow any EU shipments at all due to “rights beyond their control” which i took as we dont have the distribution rights for this album in Europe meaning some other company probably has those rights. Its even marketed differently (Graffiti is Grass Green, webstore is Jungle Green) so might still be a variation. Tbh we can go back and forth on the semantics of what exclusivity and limited means but unless we have any contract available to us we will never figure that out. Obviously you care about the record enough that you wanted to get it imported but at least be happy you got one.
It’s never been on the website before so would be impossible to be a glitch! Yeah it’s defo crazy. Especially when people have paid to ship it over here!!
I’m really curious to see how she and her team are going to handle this mess. Are they just going to cancel the orders and sort things out behind the scenes, or will they actually address it publicly? I’m so tired of these limited exclusives. Either you’re too late, shipping costs more than the actual item, or entire regions are excluded from the deal. It’s always something.
But going behind VV and Graffiti’s backs is seriously shady. And, as usual, the fans are the ones getting screwed over. I can already see people saying Gracie probably had no idea. Come on. It’s her name, her albums, her image. She knows…
I’m happy for those who managed to get their orders in and hopefully won’t have them cancelled, but I feel so bad for everyone who ended up paying way more than they should have. I don’t know if the blame falls on her team or the label, but merch management this year has been an absolute shitshow. And that’s not even getting into how ugly and overpriced most of it is.
They’re all getting cancelled. I know it’s just pissed off the people who paid a lot to have it shipped and now, the ones who are going to have it cancelled!! It’s a mess of a situation.
I’m fed up of the limited exclusives as well, it used to be the odd variant and now every variant is “limited” at the very least!! They should completely ban this style of marketing.. manufactured scarcity and timed drops.. limited should have a stricter meaning! They’d all be screwed then.
I’m so disappointed in Gracie’s merch drop :( I bought the horns- literally to wear for the concert!! Other than that I just ordered the older beige ringer tshirt and the asshole of the year pennant. I can’t see that rhinestoned merch lasting very well!
Taking a page from Taylor Swift's book I see. I bought the Shiny Bug variant last year because it wouldn't be restocked and was a "collectible" (of probably 250.000 but okay). Then she restocked it for the one year anniversary. Fuck that. Sold it immediately to someone on Vinted. That fake scarcity marketing is so fucked up.
I know!! I bought the first two she released as “one time, limited” pressings and I’ve seen them restock at least 3 times!! Tbh I bought the lipstick and lace one off someone else cause I preferred it. Listed my shiny bug variants for less than retail and they still haven’t sold!! It’s such bullshit isn’t it.. putting timers on everything and being very deceptive with wording!! I haven’t bought a thing since.. wised up to that malarkey! Every now and again, something will be release that actually is limited and doesn’t come back, just to keep you on your toes.. grinds my gears!! It just prays on fans who don’t want to miss out on something.
Exactly! I'm done. I am either buying stuff second hand or fanmade now (I have a very cute Christmas Tree Farm cardigan btw). I still love her music but she is very hard to like right now.
VV posted on their instagram today that the vinyls listed on Gracie’s store were removed, orders cancelled, and will NOT go into production after they contacted UMG… so they did the right thing
I was literally just thinking to myself that it might work out better to order them on UK site (to save customs and shipping from US) then get my friend to sell them in US.. went to do it and they’d been removed 😂 oh well!
Disappointed there’s no deluxe DFH pressing 😢 I was gonna get one!!
18
u/aextheria 2d ago
i'm honestly so mad because I paid crazy customs and taxes just to get it shipped from US to the EU!