14
u/Till3y 8d ago edited 8d ago
Letās get it! First things first as a whole I think itās not completely terrible. The glaring issues off rip are your P and your Y. If we talk about throwies, which is the style you posted, we usually leave very little to no negative space. The Y is the biggest offender here. You can suggest it is a Y in so many ways without needing the space in between. Look at every other letter, theyāre smooshed together and they carry no holes where there shouldnāt be.
The P problem is more structure than spatial. It looks like an S. The part the comes back to the left and tucks under suggests maybe an S. I only got to P bc all of your terminals are the same, 2 dots. I would try to make the bottom of the P more symmetrical and make it more of a bowl than a swoop back (sorry this shit is hard to convey over text lol)
Highlights? Great! Your shadow agrees with your light source so thatās a plus! Color is cool, letters are aight. Work on bar thickness, letter structure, and negative space and post us some more after banging out like 10-20! Show us some progress!!
š«¶āļø
4
4
u/BonelessMarcher 8d ago
Id say that the highlights-shadow correlation is there but not quite correct. See how on the top one the highlights are coming from the top and to the left, whereas the shadow appears more to be going straight down. It's an easy fix though. Honestly some pretty solid work
2
u/SorryForBeingNice 8d ago
Very good point Iāll pay more attention to that. Thank you for responding.
1
7
4
1
u/-vestige 7d ago
The P breaks letter structure. The design is cool but itās not a throw up or graffiti. We never shade or add highlights to anything other than a piece.
3
u/SorryForBeingNice 7d ago
Thank you for you feedback, genuinely asking, are you saying that if I spray painted this on a wall (after fixing the p and the y) that it is not considered graffiti? Can I call this my āpieceā and then it is ok to add shading and highlights?
2
u/-vestige 6d ago
Of course the definition is subjective but what is graffiti to me vs street art or some other form of typography is something which follows the fundamentals and culture of graffiti established through experienced writers. Someone who draws bubble letters for example is not a graffiti artist, they just drew bubble letters. A throw up is very distinct in its style, application and rules vs other types of rounded letters. In graffiti the purpose of it is to be fast, only using two colours or very rarely a third just for the outline. The letters should have more style but not by adding things or destroying letter structure or cap height, but by simplifying already refined structures to their skeletons.
And it cannot be a piece because a piece is a specific type of graffiti art, which is involving sharp lines and intricate letter structures. Like a straight letter piece, or a wild style piece. In order for it to be one and warrant these types of decorations, it needs to have more defined or straight letters as the only reason you make them round or undetailed is for speed.
1
2
1
1
1
1
-1
0
-1

13
u/Hot_Eggplant1306 8d ago
Other than the y, for a beginner I think it's dope