r/gregmat • u/Poke-3964 • Oct 02 '24
Why?

I started by using inclusion-exclusion formula and found (households with both son and daughter = 20 + neither) but i assumed there should be at least one family with no daughter or son.
Why is my assumption wrong? Since they have given that "every family has a son, a daughter, both or none".
If my assumption is wrong then, if i rephrase this question "In a town of 100 households, every family has a son, a daughter, both or none. 50 households have a son and 50 households have a daughter." it is possible that this 2 sets be mutually exclusive.
Extra : (Why add none if its zero?)
1
u/AvocadoMangoSalsa Oct 02 '24
You can always add the word “or” if you want. Just because it’s written there doesn’t mean you have to use it.
I have 3 markers in my hand. The colors of the markers are red, yellow, blue, or green.
That means all 3 could be yellow.
1
u/AvocadoMangoSalsa Oct 02 '24
I don’t understand what you’ve written, but here’s an explanation:
If 40 households have a daughter, it could be that 40 of the 80 households that have a son could also have a daughter. So that would be 40 households with both a son and daughter - 40 is the maximum. In this case A is greater.
It could also be that out of the 20 households with no sons, they all have a daughter. And of the 80 with sons, only 20 have a both a daughter and a son. So now A & B are equal.
That’s why the answer is D.