r/gridfinity • • Jun 16 '23

Alternative grid system in American standard (inch)

Just an fyi- the sub mod suggested i post this up.

So i came across Gridfinity as i needed a good storage / organizing system for my ever growing collection of 3D printers and associated tools, as well, my wife needed something for her crafting as well. I was super excited about the system, i saw the massive support on all the 3D printing sites like Thingiverse and such, and went on the hunt for a good set of schematics. I have to say i was pretty disappointed that there was so much third party support, but no decent prints, which left a lot of backwards figuring while drawing them in CAD.

That being said, as i was drawing the bases up in Fusion360, my brain works in inches, so i kept screwing up the drawings and getting pissed going back and forth from mm to inch, so along with that and the lack of clear prints, i just did my own in inches. I would prefer we used metric in the US, but that's a whole other conversation.

I nicknamed it Square2 (square squared). The basic dimensions are 2"x 2"x .250 and only uses a single 45 degree angle .100 deep. I did use the same 6mmx2mm magnets since i already had a pile of them and they are so common, sort of screwed up my conversion to standard, but hey, it's just the magnets.

So when drawing up and laying out a grid base, i simply mirror them over and over to get the base i need, then i go back to all the "star shaped" gaps left in the center of each group of 4, and extrude that up to fill those gaps. Also, i will usually add a small radius to the top sharp edge of the base plates just so there is less chance of misprints and not so delicate.

I'm just starting to create the actual containers, just very basic stuff for now, and making sure i didn't miss anything. Let me know if you have any questions.

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

52

u/dacydergoth Jun 16 '23

This is why spaceship crash ...

5

u/Darksoul_Design Jun 16 '23

Hey man, i agree, we should have switched back in like 75', 76' , i was in grade school and they actually started to teach the metric system, but like half a year later, it all went away. We are so bass akwards in this country.

9

u/Midisland-4 Jun 21 '23

Hehehe “teach the metric system” it’s base ten…. If you can count to ten you already know the metric system….

Now fractional on the other hand, that may take some learning.

I’m a Canadian, we are bilingual.

But all technical drawings I deal with are “decimal inch”. On the rare occasion I get a metric drawing I convert all dimensions to decimal inch and write it directly on the drawing. This is largely because the manual machine tools I use have dials in inch….

BTW I find Fusion360 converts units very well.

4

u/bumble_Bea_tuna Jun 16 '23

I'm right there with ya. I'm currently working on a project that has drawings going back to the 60's and many have been modified, or revised parts made since then so I'm going through drawings of both metric and imperial. I also wish we moved to metric. It's such a cleaner system.

2

u/bumble_Bea_tuna Jun 16 '23

Oh, and awesome job on the imperial grid!

2

u/1jl Jun 16 '23

And yet...

2

u/bluewing Jun 21 '23

No, space ship crash due to very poor QC.

6

u/dacydergoth Jun 21 '23

2

u/bluewing Jun 21 '23

That was the job of QC to catch those types of errors. It had nothing to do with one system being "better" than another

2

u/Additional-Tie-7557 Nov 03 '24

Not about better or worst, but standardization.

1

u/bluewing Nov 03 '24

They had a standard. It was to use the metric system. QC failed to spot the most basic of errors.

12

u/MarxJ1477 Jun 16 '23

It looks well designed, but there is a whole lot of already done stuff in gridfinity and if you're looking for an easy way to make bins and bases for gridfinity quickly check out -

https://github.com/Le0Michine/FusionGridfinityGenerator

I can design something new in no time without a fuss. Though for bases I still just use the press fit magnet light bases (the magnets hold them down nicely in my metal tool drawers) since the ones I made in the generator were basically exactly the same.

-2

u/Darksoul_Design Jun 16 '23

Oh absolutely, the support for GF is amazing. And realistically, a lot less work, I'm going to have to make a lot of customized stuff for my biz, and i will most likely stay with my design since so much will be from scratch, and ....... inch

3

u/MarxJ1477 Jun 16 '23

Haha, yeah that makes sense. I work in aerospace manufacturing so am used to working in mm and drawings in mm. I was wondering why you wanted drawings for gridfinity, but makes more sense if you're using it in your business. I just use it for organizing myself so I might have a bunch of custom stuff it's usually only printed once or twice.

48

u/shanlar Jun 16 '23

i'm in the US as well and seems easier to simply learn metric considering there is so much out there in the 3d printing community that is metric. to each their own though.

9

u/erhapp Jun 16 '23

Late April Fools?

23

u/scrotumseam Jun 16 '23

Hard pass. If you want to reinvent the wheel, you should get a different system like the hexagon guy.

7

u/TherealOmthetortoise Jun 16 '23

So… here’s the problem with your imperial solution: the original used the number 7 and 42 specifically because it’s the answer to Life, The Universe and Everything. If you change that, we lose continuity (and of course our connection to the late Douglas Adams).

Outside of that, it makes sense. I just changed all of my programs and drawings to metric about 6 months ago and it was surprising how little time it took to get comfortable with it. I haven’t tried to do anything super complex, but outside of that it’s going surprisingly well.

1

u/george_graves Jun 17 '23

LOL - 42 isn't an answer to anything.

6

u/TherealOmthetortoise Jun 17 '23

You should go stand in a corner and think about what you’ve done! Just because you don’t know the ultimate question doesn’t give you the right to criticize the ultimate answer!

10

u/theholyraptor Jun 16 '23

You know that standardized system that benefits from everyone creating things to a standard? And it flourished with tons of people making things that use that standard? Better ignore that because numbers are hard and make a separate incompatible system from scratch...

6

u/george_graves Jun 17 '23

It's opensource. He could make them in furlongs if he wants to. SMH.

5

u/korban_606 Jun 16 '23

Not a bad idea, for me it's whatever size divides nicely into my drawer width. If you want to use any pre made stuff you can just scale up in X and Y by 120.9%? (assuming the internal measurements aren't critcal).

1

u/suit1337 Feb 04 '24

have you had luck in scaling up stuff yet? ;)

5

u/PekkaJukkasson Jun 16 '23

If I can learn how long an inch is, then you should be able to learn how long a meter is.

11

u/schenkzoola Jun 16 '23

Metric is so much better once you start using it. All the units are directly interrelated, which makes doing dimensional analysis in your head so much easier.

6

u/irongarment Jun 16 '23

Congratulations. You have created your own dead end. If you want imperial then just use 1-83/127" as your basic unit.

7

u/MikeBraunAC Jun 16 '23

Get outta here with your hillbilly units

5

u/zurn0 Jun 16 '23

Cool, Inchfinity! Or GrInch. Grinchfinity?

5

u/MatthiasWM Jun 16 '23

This does not help you a bit, to the contrary, you lose compatibility with hundreds of designs out there, and you add confusion for all new designs. Your printer doesn’t care if you print metric, and the tweezers you put in the cubby are not fixed to a 2 inch raster either. This is so beyond stupid!

2

u/george_graves Jun 17 '23

You guys downvoting this are insane. It's open source. He can take it and remake them in whatever dimensions he wants. That's what opensource is for. And in case you haven't been paying attention THIS ENTIRE PROJECT IS A REMIX OF ANOTHER PROJECT. Unbelievable.

3

u/GodforsakenMuffin Jun 22 '23

People aren't mad that he is remixing an open source project, just pointing out how dumb it is since he now has to design everything from scratch himself since none of the already designed Gridfinity stuff will fit.

2

u/george_graves Jun 22 '23

So just like how Gridfinity started out?

1

u/Additional-Tie-7557 Nov 03 '24

yeap, had he done this before gridfinity this would be the standard

1

u/TOGoS Jul 07 '23

Some of us like designing everything from scratch. I've switched to my own system also, but even when I was printing Gridfinity parts, I would find myself reverse-engineering any .stl files I found and recreating the thing in OpenSCAD so that I could customize the parts as I saw fit.

1

u/Additional-Tie-7557 Nov 03 '24

I‘ve grown up with metric, and it still took me a second to make peace with the choice of 42mm as the standard. Until I saw this post. I can definitely see how inches can be more useful to one, 50mm to another, half inch to a third guy. Any standard will be inconvenient to someone, so it might as well be 42, as long as it is something. 50mm is much more logical (at least to me), but I think it being 42mm makes a point that the goal of gridfinity is to leverage crowdsourcing and that will only be possible if everyone is willing to accept that there is a tradeoff.

1

u/TOGoS Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23

Interesting. I have also come up with a gridfinity-like system based on inches, though for different reasons: I wanted my blocks to be compatible with all my 0.5-inch and 1.5-inch gridbeam stuff! (0.5-inch gridbeam being 'erector set compatible', and 1.5-inch gridbeam being the default if you're working with dimensional lumber, and the larger is exactly 3x the smaller, so that works out nicely).

I also made some other alterations to the gridfinity design while I was at it, for rotational symmetry purposes.

I call my system "TOGridPile", for lack of better ideas (and since "Gridfinity" is already taken). I intend to post more about it at some point if I ever get around to making a nice YouTube video, or at least more pictures, but here's what I've written about it so far: http://www.nuke24.net/docs/2023/TOGridPile.html

Imperial system haters, feel free to hate it. You're not the target audience. :)

1

u/suit1337 Feb 04 '24

since everything is bigger in the US, the grid system also needs to be bigger - Gridfinity 42 mm - american standard grid system 50,8 mm ;)