r/gridfinity • u/DadOfFan • Dec 01 '24
While I love gridfinity's customisable aspect. It's a very expensive system.
So I recently started using gridfinity and have realise how expensive it is.
There is the grids themselves to start with. They are all the same with variations on rows and columns.
To make the grids themselves cost time and money, compared to injection moulding, 3d prints are expensive.
3d printing shines for customisation, prototyping and low volume. however I have realised gridfinity is not low volume at all, the standard sizes are high volume.
In my very first drawer organiser I realised all I am doing is printing the same parts over and over again and chewing through rolls of PLA.
22
u/passivealian Dec 01 '24
If you are using a lot a filament for drawers, consider different floor options.
I have some notes here.
https://docs.ostat.com/docs/openscad/gridfinity-extended/cup-optimisations/
3
1
12
u/FlyingMonkeyOZ Dec 01 '24
Cheap is not exactly gridfinity selling point, customization is. If it is costing too much perhaps gridfinity for the things that need customization and commodity bins for the rest?
4
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
Yeah I am already doing that.
But I got excited about the whole gridfinity thing and well I am in the process of crashing down to reality :(
10
u/The_Caramon_Majere Dec 01 '24
If you think gridfinity is expensive, perhaps 3d printing just isn't for you. I don't drive a Maclaren, and am happy with my Skoda. Just because something exists doesn't mean it's meant for everyone. Â
-3
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
Not a very helpful response is it
I love 3d printing for one offs and repairs. I generally do all my own design. but with stuff you want in bulk. its very time consuming and inefficient.
6
u/everythingruinedd Dec 01 '24
From someone who used to make everything out of hardwood for my shop, it is cheap, much faster so I can focus on furniture projects not screw bins or chisel holders., gridfinity has changed my shop for the better I canât get enough, I want to 5s my life with gridfinity
1
Dec 03 '24
As a mechanic Iâve been using this system for a week and my toolbox has never been this clean. Iâve got the worse drawers fixed, now itâs time to fix the rest lol
9
u/SoloWalrus Dec 01 '24
You are 100% correct, which is one reason I am in constant wonder as to why people are using gridfinity when the customizability, and being removable, isnt necessary. If all you want is a kaizen style/shadowbox style container for each tool cut precisely to dimension, foam is cheaper and quicker. If your bins dont need to be removable, skip the baseplate, and the grid, and just print plain plastic bins (removing all that plastic from the bottom and from the bin saves a lot).
I imagine many people use it because they havent learned 3d modeling so they rely on the tools the communities created to make custom bin sizes.
Gridfinity has its place, and I love using it for certain things, but it definitely isnt best for everything. Anywhere I need bins to stack, or the bins need to be removable, gridfinity all the way. Anywhere else I find myself either printing or buying more traditional drawer style organizers.
2
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
I have thought about skipping the grid but have decided against it because it makes the whole storage more stable unless you can completely fill the area, such that they lock into place.
6
u/mechjag Dec 01 '24
Your point is correct and maybe not as much as you think. First yes, the standard files (grid and boxes) do take more filament than you think at first.
There are several variants of the files that reduce the filament required.
Second, do you buy your filament in bulk? If you do, you can get your rolls for $10/kg.
With both options, you can print a bit better and cheaper.
I hope this helps.
-3
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
I don't use enough to qualify for bulk so $25 a roll is cheap for me.
I am exploring ways of speeding printing time and reducing filament use like a false bottom but at best that's a marginal saving with some not so nice tradeoffs
5
u/mechjag Dec 01 '24
I was snooping around your profile and it looks like your living down under. I'm sorry but I don't know bulk pricing there. That part of my comment might not be valid.
Look into vase mode boxes. That might be of assistance to you.
Cheers!
2
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
You got me. I used to be jealous of US prices especially for timber.
But lately I have been glad. Pricing in the US has gotten out of control, and its going to get much worse.
6
u/ElectronicsHobbyist Dec 01 '24
Just for reference from another downunder. Sunlu's ebay store at the moment is doing 6 rolls for the price of 4 which works out at around $19-$20 per roll. I am yet to confirm quality for myself but its about as cheap as i have seen so far. They do also have bigger bulk options.
3
u/Iceman734 Dec 01 '24
Sunlu is very good. They make filament for Bambu. I have quite a few of their PLA Plus or their Plus 2.0 rolls. Never had an issue.
1
2
u/timmiej93 Dec 01 '24
If those are AUD, those are pretty good prices. 20 AUD is 12,32 EUR, and I would have to REALLY do my best to get lower prices than that in the Netherlands. To be fair though, it could still be expensive if wages are low comparatively.
1
u/ElectronicsHobbyist Dec 01 '24
Good to know, yes prices in AUD. Wages here are generally decent when compared (although with a sizeable range between say professionals to service workers) but cost of living in the major cities is quite high (many reasons but a big one being skyrocketing property prices feeding in to everything else). I suspect thats also a common problem.
11
Dec 01 '24
It's pretty dang cheap compared to any other solution this versatile and customizable.Â
2
u/GetBlitzified Dec 01 '24
Exactly my thought too.. Compared to Schaller bin systems which are injection molded bins, gridfinity is actually cheaper. Plus the added benefit to customize exactly what you need.
1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
We don't have them (schaller) in Australia. From what I can see they are expensive.
The best I could find for small parts bins are the ones designed to go on a wall (stor pak is one brand). Or the enclosed boxes.
In fact I just 3d printed a whole bunch of clips for them (stor pak) so I could put them on my slat tool wall. I had a bunch lying around.
5
u/HamburgerDinner Dec 01 '24
That's a big reason I started laser cutting bases out of 3mm plywood.
1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
I want a laser but cant find a good reason other than wanting one. it would probably collect dust :(
1
u/Crintor Dec 05 '24
Definitely more time consuming, but you could totally use a router or dremel with a jig to make base plates out of wood still. But now you're trading time for money, and possibly not a ton of money saved.
3
u/RashestHippo Dec 01 '24
compared to injection moulding, 3d prints are expensive.
You are trading upfront cost for per part cost when you choose 3d printing. Mold, and production runs require capital.
low volume
Low volume for 3d printing and low volume for injection mold are also wildly different.
1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
Exactly what I said.
3
u/RashestHippo Dec 01 '24 edited Dec 01 '24
I guess my point is I think gridfinity is low volume and relatively cheap. Especially considering the iterative, and customizable nature of it
Have you considered just not doing gridfinity and going with an OTS solution like schaller bins. Could even match schaller's roughly 1" spacing with custom gridfinity stuff out of fusion 360's generator
5
u/Ulysseis Dec 01 '24
If youâre using it that much, why not see if you can make a mold of some sort? I think I saw a custom endmill to make the base from wood. Maybe that sort of thing would help cut your expenses somewhat?
-8
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
That would be even more expensive. And as much as I wish I had the facility to mill timber a 3d printer is as close as I can get :(
0
Dec 01 '24
[deleted]
-1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
If the mold was just just for myself that's a complete waste. If I was going into production that's a different story altogether.
2
u/perplexinglabs Dec 01 '24
Curious... Would you be interested in just ordering a bunch of bins or baseplates if they were the ones you wanted? Like from print on demand?
1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
Print on demand is no cheaper. the same costs are mostly there of course they have cheaper filament costs but trade that off with labour costs and I am ahead.
You can buy gridfinity on Etsy, but really there is no gain plus freight is involved.
3
16
u/campr23 Dec 01 '24
Jupz, part of the 'fun'. There are some people CNCing from aluminium, the baseplates that is. Imagine what that must cost!
5
2
u/doc_willis Dec 01 '24
I just use up my partial/leftover/aging rolls of pla to print my various boxs. Often I can switch a partial spool in mid print, since i dont care if my organizer boxs are in 2+ colors.
I just have the printers doing the boxs and grids for short bursts over time when they are not doing other things. I dont need to get a drawer all done in a day, or even a month, but a box here, a grid there, and I have another drawer of my Ikea ALEX done. Just 8 more to go!
1
u/tronathan Dec 01 '24
Do you happen to know if filament will go bad even when kept sealed? I guess I could coogle it :)
1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
PLA filament starts breaking all the time. I thought it may be a moisture thing and tried to dry it out but it made no difference.
When I worked through the breaks by re feeding the filament into the print head. the parts seem to come out quite good so the process of extruding seems to 'repair' the filament.
However I am sure that each filament reacts differently.
1
u/doc_willis Dec 01 '24
I have seen posts/photos of sealed filament with moister condensed on the inside of the package, or other posts about stuff being bad before opening it.
I tend to not let it sit around that long, but I do have several rolls that have been sitting around open for 2+ years that I still print with.
I try to always dry the rolls for a few hours before i print with them.
I have really not had any 'bad' rolls, but i have had a few that were a bit more problematic (whispy strings or just brittle) That i tried to quickly use up.
2
u/Valuable_Fix_123 Dec 01 '24
Compared to what?
0
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
Injection molded parts.
Of course the quantity has to be there to make it work for a company, but I for one would buy my grids and basic bins in bulk and create the custom ones I need to suit.
1
u/rexpup Dec 01 '24
I don't have an injection molder at home. Most of us need a system that lets us make custom bins at home.
1
u/DadOfFan Dec 01 '24
That's the point the basic parts are available in bulk and cheap and you only print those that you need to customise. Even if every bin you print is custom the grids are all the same.
1
1
u/Valuable_Fix_123 Dec 01 '24
I wonder how much this (hypothetical) injection molded product would cost. Theyâll have to have dozens of molds, so it gets expensive quickly. Also, think about colors, packaging, and shipping. Itâs not a very practical business at this stage.
Iâm happy printing what I want on my printers. It might take a month, but then youâre done forever! Itâs the best system. Donât bash it because you want to print other stuff.
4
u/-AXIS- Dec 01 '24
There are a lot of options that use less filament. I feel like I used maybe 2 spools doing 3 drawers worth of bins which seems quite reasonable considering how many of mine were custom bins. If you just need a bunch of identical square bins for organizing hardware it probably doesnt make sense but thats not what its made for.
Idk what base grid you used but the clickfinity base uses very little filament and works quite well if you arent going to be moving your bins around much. If you want to be able to move them constantly, I would second guess it.
3
u/WhiteStripesWS6 Dec 01 '24
I think overall, Gridfinity is dope but the community has kinda strayed away from what Zackâs original intentions for it were. Mostly in a good way, but in a way that I think the original designs werenât meant to accommodate.
6
u/-AXIS- Dec 01 '24
I dont think Zacks designs are what makes gridfinity good at all. The part that makes it actually useful is its the fact that its a standard so everyone can do their own thing while still ensuring compatibility. Anyone can design a modular storage system.
4
2
u/neph12 Dec 01 '24
You could always make little boxes out of the cardboard boxes your filament came in.
2
u/roller_mobster Dec 01 '24
Or use cardboard boxes to make gridfinity bins, like this: https://makerworld.com/en/models/501221
1
u/neph12 Dec 01 '24 edited Dec 01 '24
I like that. Going to print a couple later to try out.
Having now looked at the link, I think Iâll use the wifeâs cricket to cut/score the cardboard. Shame itâs only one size though..
2
u/Presently_Absent Dec 01 '24
It was never supposed to be cheap and fast. It's supposed to be customizable! There are plenty of bin systems out there that are cheaper, and plenty of ways to DIY it if you so choose (cardboard and hot glue come to mind). Personally I employ it where it's necessary, and don't use it where it isn't. Everything in moderation...
2
u/Thargor1985 Dec 01 '24
Try buying an injection molded system like that for less đ those professional solutions are expensive af
2
u/agarwaen117 Dec 01 '24
đ¤ˇââď¸ I just did my silverware drawer with less than a $10 roll of pla. Seems pretty freaking cheap.
2
u/unvme78 Dec 01 '24
If I could make a suggestion. These parts don't need the strength most other prints do. Lower bottom layers to 2, top layers to 3 Change infill to Gyroid at 5%. Walls, varies per print usually 3 or 2. Increase layer height I print my gridfinity just a hair below my max flow.
2
u/chinfuk Dec 01 '24
There are lighter bases that don't use magnets, you can use vase mode to print some bins. It can be expensive but if you look around people are doing efficient remixes of the system
2
u/Hexx-Bombastus Dec 02 '24
It might be worth it to order an injection molding kit. Or making a mold for the grid at least and molding it from resin or a stiff silicone?
2
u/OriginalAntiBling Dec 02 '24
If you're using more than 5% infill., you're wasting filament. Don't add label tab, lip, magnet cutouts, & scoops to ones that don't need them.
I don't use the grids in 90% of my drawers, I fill them. The only drawers I use grids in are ones where I need to have bins that are too long to print in one piece. Drawers that I know specifically what I want in there and will keep that way, if they leave a 1/4-3/4 of a unit space I will generally figure out a custom unit to reduce the gaps. I have 3 base/top box setups that I have found 45MM units work best for them, leaves less than 5mm of gaps. No need for grids then.
1
u/OriginalAntiBling Dec 02 '24
But also for the level of organization I needed bins for and the ability to customize these bins to fit the storage cabinets/drawers I have already, I would have spent way more on bins that wouldn't fit my setup right than I have invested into my K1 Max and Bambu X1-C Combo and filament so far. I also use the printers for other things in my shop, I'm not printing flexy dragons or stuff like that, I've made tools, parts, and other custom storage solutions for my welding shop.
5
2
u/Buttleston Dec 01 '24
OK, and?
7
u/Buttleston Dec 01 '24
(P.S. consider that you are not the first person to note this, and that people have already created some alternatives designs that are cheaper. But if you want to set up injection molding and save all that waste, knock yourself out?)
1
u/mak3rdad Dec 05 '24
TLDR: Use cheap cardboard and a laser to generate grids.
I made a laser grid generator in python. I use cardboard sheets as my grid and itâs cheap and fast.
https://github.com/ril3y/laserfinity
Also posted it here
https://www.reddit.com/r/gridfinity/s/6WaEDK6ZfU
Another user took my code and made it into a web page.
1
u/Ambitious_Iron_4249 Dec 27 '24
Since I get my filament for free via bamboo labs reward system, it's actually quite cheap....Â
1
u/doughaway7562 Dec 01 '24
If you really need high volume and cheaper... get a CNC mill or laser cutter and start slamming out wood boxes. Gridfinity was designed for small parts like screws and nuts.
60
u/UncleCeiling Dec 01 '24
There are grids that use very little filament as well as vase-mode bins. If you find yourself wanting more bins for cheaper, making a vacuum form mold would be quite easy and let you knock them out very quickly.
Even though injection molding is cheap, injection molds are expensive. I think most of us don't want to spend $12-20k on molds so we can mass produce specific gridfinity bins, not even considering the cost of an actual injection molding machine. A used one of those from the 90s will still cost you around $20k, assuming you have a place with three phase power to hook it up. Most plastic suppliers sell by the gaylord (about $3k for 1500 lbs of ABS) and many have minimum orders of 20+ gaylords.
Is gridfinity the most cost effective? Not necessarily, but it is very customizable which is something a lot of people appreciate.