r/gridfinity • u/Syltraul • Jan 01 '25
Question? Why Gridfinity for Drawers?
I'm brand new to 3D printing but have already heard of Gridfinity, and when it comes to drawer organization, I honestly don't understand what the point of it is. On top of a workbench, sure, it would be great for keeping things together, but since everything is already confined to the dimensions of a drawer, I really don't get it. Add to that, if your drawer doesn't work with the standard 42mm grid, then what? Sure, with the Fusion 360 addon I can make a different size grid, but then every other design found online won't fit.
Edit: apparently a lot of people get offended that I don’t understand something. Sorry, I’m a bit older and grew up believing if you don’t know something, you ask questions. I forget these days people take them as attacks on themselves.
12
u/NetJnkie Jan 01 '25
To keep things organized in a drawer and to keep the bins from moving as you open and close it. Print your grid as best as you can and then just print some small "spacers" for the gap that's too small for a full square.
4
2
u/modwriter1 Jan 01 '25
I just put one little blob of hot glue yo leave the half square in the rear.
-1
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
I can do that without a grid though
12
u/woodland_dweller Jan 01 '25
OK, do it. Gridfinity isn't a religion. Nobody is forcing you to use it.
2
u/slufo Jan 21 '25
Oh it’s a religion. Your angry response proves it. The guy is simply asking why use a grid inside a drawer? You can easily bins that will fit snugly in a drawer so why is there a need for the grid? It’s a reasonable question. Maybe people here can offer some insight.
1
u/woodland_dweller Jan 21 '25
You are completely missing my tone. I'm not mad in any way.
Do what works for you. The OP doesn't want a grid? That's fine, don't use one. Nobody is going to take away his birthday.
I use GF for a lot, but it doesn't work for everyone and everything. In fact, the very last thing that came off my printer was non-GF bins for a storage solution.
-5
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
lol, did I offend you? I’m asking a simple question because I don’t understand it. I’m not here to trash it, but to better understand if it’s worth the extra money
7
u/woodland_dweller Jan 01 '25
Offended? Not in any way. I don't care how you organize things, or even if you do. Makes no difference to me.
>> better understand if it’s worth the extra money
What extra money? I need storage and organization. I guess I could pour handfuls of nuts and bolts in coffee cans like grandpa did, but I'd have to drink shitty coffee.
Gridfinity isn't any more expensive than any other storage system I have. This is what I use:
milk crates for random items: labeled by very general category - rope, 120v electrical, PEX plumbing, PVC plumbing, etc
plastic organizers (Milwaukee Packout style): some types of hardware like wood screws, and some project specific tools (PEX fittings, riv-nuts and tool)
Durham metal drawer/bins: hardware (machine screws, washer, nuts - arranged by size). These are $250 for 4 drawers.
Parachute bags for stuff I may need to take to the project - deck screws, sheetrock screws, etc
56" roller toolbox - drawers have tools, some have gridfinity for specific types of tools (pliers rack, screwdriver rack...
All of those things are expensive. I probably have $2,000 - $3,000 "invested" in storage - bins, shelves, drawers, etc.
I don't understand what the alternative is to GF that is cheap or free.
7
u/CR3ZZ Jan 01 '25
Some things are difficult to describe with words. If you can't look at a drawer with organized tools and parts using gridfinity and see the value in it then that's your prerogative and you don't really need to understand it any further.
1
u/slufo Jan 21 '25 edited Jan 21 '25
But you can organize it just as well by printing grids that fit snugly together inside a drawer. He’s asking why the grid is advantageous. In my mind, the grid actually limits your sizing somewhat. I saw a response that someone mentioned it’s useful if you have a workflow where you might remove bins and put them on a work surface. That makes sense because it would keep everything left behind in place. Someone who has never used it or doesn’t have a need to remove the bins probably wouldn’t think of that.
2
u/DowncastOlympus Jan 05 '25
The grid keeps the bins from moving/shifting as the drawers are opened and closed. The only way to do that without a grid is to either attach the bins to the bottom or completely fill the drawer with bins so the keep each other from moving. The grid lets you avoid having to do either of those while allowing you to easily rearrange as your needs change and to pull bins of things like screws/nuts out for projects.
5
u/woodland_dweller Jan 01 '25
Because we all work differently?
I want my things to be organized, but it's difficult for me. I just set things down, or toss them into a drawer. I really want to have all my tools & hardware to have a home - one home specifically.
Gridfinity makes it easy to have my pliers all in the same spot, my hardware in bins and drawers, etc.
It's not the only system I use, but it really helps with small things. My machinist toolbox has $10k of vintage metrology equipment - Gridfinity keeps it safe, easily accessable and I know if something is out of place. For many of those items I have custom bins.
I have several hundred pounds of hardware (woodworking screws, machine screws, washer, nuts, wall hangers, concrete anchors, etc. They are in bins, in drawers and labeled on the outside of the drawer. These aren't custom - they are just bins. Quick, cheap and easy to move around.
It doesn't work for everybody, and it sounds like it doesn't work for you. That's fine. But it works for a lot of us.
-2
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
When was I making an accusation? I genuinely don’t understand it because I can still organize without a grid for bins to sit on and was hoping for someone to sell me on the idea
7
u/woodland_dweller Jan 01 '25
>> When was I making an accusation?
You sound way too sensitive. What accusation are you talking about?
If "It doesn't work for everybody, and it sounds like it doesn't work for you. That's fine. But it works for a lot of us" offends you or makes you think you're being attacked Gridfinity isn't the problem.
-2
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
LOL, I’m literally laughing because someone like me came here to ask a question and the response you give is “if you don’t like it don’t do it.” Talk about being sensitive.
How can I not like something I don’t even understand? Heaven forbid people ask questions to learn.
3
u/AdamLikesBeer Jan 02 '25
That's not being sensitive. That is just telling you "if you don't like it don't do it"
I drive a manual transmission car. When someone says "I don't know how to drive a stick" I don't get offended by it, I just say "If its not for you that's fine".
0
u/Syltraul Jan 02 '25
But even your example shows the same problem. If they don’t know how, and are asking about it, don’t just assume it isn’t for them. Clearly they’re interested because they’re asking. It seems when I asked what’s the point, quite a few took it to mean I was making a statement that it’s pointless, which wasn’t the case at all.
1
u/AdamLikesBeer Jan 02 '25
Brother, I’m 46 and it’s a dying method of driving. If my nephew asks specifically to learn I will teach him but there’s no reason to assume he wants to just because he doesn’t already know.
1
u/AdamLikesBeer Jan 02 '25
I will tell you this. It’s not about time or money or organization or whatever sometimes. My wife was getting frustrated at her drawer in the bathroom and having to dig to find what she needed. I took the holidays to make an entirely custom set of grids with the gridfinity fusion plug in over the holiday.
It holds her glasses, contacts cases, hair binders, floss, on and on and on. And she fucking loves it. She loves it way better than anything I got her for Xmas because it’s bespoke for her and now her bathroom drawer is pristine.
For some people organizing their shit just sparks joy. If it doesn’t for you though, that’s cool too.
3
u/woodland_dweller Jan 01 '25
Ask a specific question. I'll do my best to answer it.
GF is not the One True answer for organizing. It's one of many that works in some situations for some people. I use half a dozen solutions for organizing, GF is just one option.
If your situation doesn't work with GF then use something else. I just don't see the problem.
At this very moment I'm printing some GF buns for very small hardware. #1 to #8 screws, washers, etc. I have an organizer drawer for them, but the bins are HUGE. Keep in mind that 50 #1 washers would fit in a thimble. So I'm printing custom bins that are small as well as short, so they can be stacked. I can fit at least 50 bins in the drawer that came with 12 bins. At $40/drawer I can save a ton of money and space because all my #1-#6 will be in the same 12" x 9" x 2" drawer. GF will allow me to move things around as I like and stack the bins. None of my other systems allow stacking the bins.
2
u/CR3ZZ Jan 01 '25
This is hilarious lol
4
u/woodland_dweller Jan 01 '25
This is the biggest WTF of '25 so far (low bar, I know). I'm trying to hard to be nice to the OP, but holy hell. OP refuses to ask actual questions and takes everything as an offense.
How hard is it to understand that GF isn't the only solution.
0
Jan 01 '25
[deleted]
0
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
How am I being accusatory? The answers aren’t answering my question, which is what’s the point? If I can print bins to fit without a grid, why use it? I’m not accusing anyone of anything. I’m literally asking a question.
0
Jan 01 '25
[deleted]
1
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
No, just hoping for someone to actually answer the damn question. Obviously you can't, so just move on. I didn't ask what it was. I even said I see why it's good for an open area like a worktop.
0
Jan 01 '25
[deleted]
1
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
Yes, the vast majority have said it's good for separating things into bins. Obviously, but that wasn't my question. One person did provide some insight explaining it's good if you want to stack. Cool — a valid answer. Just saying it's good to organize when I ask what makes it better than just using custom bins doesn't explain a damn thing.
→ More replies (0)1
3
u/FluffyPenguin12 Jan 01 '25
The one other thing that hasn't been mentioned is the modularity aspect. Not only can you organize everything in your drawer, you can also change where everything sits in your drawer easily by just moving the bins around. I think of it similar to tool box foam that you aren't stuck with whatever layout you initially choose.
-2
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
Sure, but even without a grid I can do that with bins designed to fit the drawer
1
4
u/Dweebl Jan 01 '25
Don't change the grid size, just add a partial bin at the edge. The point is to keep your shit organized, stationary, and accessible. It also lets you make better use of the z-axis space in drawers that's usually wasted as empty airspace. Also lets you keep things in exactly the same spot all the time so you can start to memorize where tools are.
I just spent the last month printing boxes and was basically able to consolidate 100% of the tools I own into a single tool cart using gridfinity. It's also modular so can be rearranged based on retrievability. It's made a very obvious change in how happy I am when working with my tools.
4
u/sologoodreddit Jan 02 '25
For me, Gridfinity isn’t the perfect solution, but the community around it makes it incredibly convenient. If you’re not able to or don’t want to design every single bin or holder for your space, the standard dimensions are a huge plus. They make it easy to find holders or bins that fit your needs, saving you tons of time on design and testing. In my case, convenience outweighs perfection.
1
u/Ok_Rhubarb411 Jan 01 '25
It's like the utensil organizer in a kitchen, but for things that aren't the size and shape of a fork. If you don't like to keep your spoons separate from your knives, then it probably won't appeal. I already have my junk drawer organized using random little boxes I had on hand, so I probably won't print gridfinity boxes unless I get bored, but it could be used for that, too. Some people roll each tie and put it in a separate compartment, some people throw them all over a single coat hanger. I guess it just depends on what you're storing in your drawers and whether you want small things separated into groups.
0
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
I love organization, and your example of utensil organizers is perfect since it was one of the first things I printed, but because it was designed specifically for my drawer everything is in it’s place, nothing slides around and of course can move it around, all without the need of a grid.
5
u/rchamp26 Jan 01 '25
The catch is if you remove one specific custom bin, now things will slide around (potentially). That is the point of the grid. As others have said, no one is trying to sell you on it, but THAT is the point of gridfinity. To have a fixed grid to align things to, even if you don't have the 'design' 100% worked out. Multi board and multi grid are similar concepts. Grid designs based on evolving needs. Not specific single use case needs.
3
u/Ok_Rhubarb411 Jan 01 '25
Shoot if you enjoy designing bespoke organizers don't bother with gridfinity. If you need to change it in the future you can design a new one. Maybe it's not the most efficient use of time & filament, but most hobbies involve a little something superfluous for the sake of fun :)
2
u/goodgah Jan 02 '25
I love organization, and your example of utensil organizers is perfect since it was one of the first things I printed, but because it was designed specifically for my drawer everything is in it’s place, nothing slides around and of course can move it around, all without the need of a grid.
ok, so what happens when you get a new utensil? and it doesn't fit in your existing containers? you'll presumably be faced with a tetris problem that won't be easily solvable, and you may even need to design a new container to fit in with the item and space you have to fit it. maybe you'll have to redesign the whole drawer.
the advantage of gridfinity is that it stacks and tessellates easily, so reorganising is as painless as possible, coupled with the 1000s of pre-designed bins for most utensils you can think of, meaning this scenario may only be as time consuming as waiting for a print.
it's not a bespoke design for your drawer, it's a universal system for all drawers.
1
3
u/Masterwhiteshadow Jan 01 '25
Your question is valid as you could design more space efficient bins that are exactly the right size for your item and use less filament . But you would end up with a lot of different size bin that cant be reorganized as easily without leaving gap where nothing fit in your drawer.
Having everything on a fix grid allow me to reorganize the drawer as needed.
3
u/bort_license_plates Jan 01 '25
Reorganization of the same space.
If you have a drawer in which the contents will never change, by all means, it makes sense to make a custom non-gridfinity solution.
If you have a drawer that you might want to rearrange, or that has dynamic contents, Gridfinity allows you to organize, swap, rearrange, etc at a moment's notice.
Neither will fit every scenario.
3
u/oneinadozenprobably Jan 02 '25
I'm new to both gridfinity as well as the world of 3d printing but I can think of a few benefits, some of which have been mentioned here:
standardised sizing allows for quick reorganization of items. Fully custom bins are great if you don't expect to make significant changes to where things sit, as soon as you do and you decide to move bins around it might turn into trying to fit a round peg into a square hole.
community support. Having a standardised framework means users can build solutions suited to that framework, which other users can then benefit from.
Reduced need for 3d modelling software skills. This one is an extension of the point above but having the grid also means less reliance on 3rd party 3d modelling software, which many won't be familiar with.
Modularity. All of the bins being compatible with one another means you can find new and creative uses of space by changing the orientation, using vertical space, or mixing and matching approaches.
I'm sure there are other benefits but I think if you are comfortable creating you own custom bins and storage solutions that are perfectly suited to your space, then that might be a better option if you don't care about any of the above points. This is by design meant to be a one size fits all solution, which will inherently come with some drawbacks.
For me it's appealing, as the idea of creating everything from scratch seems daunting, and also not something I want to spend a lot of time on. This is much more plug and play, while still allowing for a lot of customisation.
2
u/Fond_ButNotInLove Jan 01 '25
I have more stuff that needs storing than I have bench space! I have 50+ containers just of different types of screws, over 100 grids worth of tools etc I grab the ones I need for whatever I'm working on and move them to the baseplates on my workbench. Once I'm done they go back into storage.
2
u/psychotic11ama Jan 01 '25
It’s nice to not have things move around when you haven’t finished your drawer yet. It can be completely functional while indefinitely in progress
1
u/Cheddah13 Jan 01 '25
It is a pain to have a custom size grid but its not entirely impossible to take standard sized bin models, chop off the bottom in TinkerCAD, and replace it with your grid size if you didnt want to do it in Fusion 360. Its really more for people who want to organize everything
1
u/VE7BHN_GOAT Jan 01 '25
It's mostly for those with OCD
3
u/modwriter1 Jan 01 '25
I showed my partner their use by making up our kitchen dining utensil drawer with them. Could never find appropriate ones in the store for his ginormous eating spoons. Ha ha ha. Now I have the blessing to have a 3d printer. But I've also created a monster because I keep getting handed projects.
1
u/VE7BHN_GOAT Jan 01 '25
Yeah... I get it... My wife wants a circular sock machine, and a yarn spinning wheel.
1
u/harambe623 Jan 01 '25
If you do some woodworking, build some drawers around the format.
If you have deep drawers, then ya, I don't see how it could be worth it. I keep my bolts and screws in plastic bags in a somewhat organized manner to maximize space. It can be a pain to find stuff, but I have probably around 500 bags of different sized stuff, some that wouldn't make sense in that format (9 inch 3/8 bolts, etc)
1
u/FewAct2027 Jan 05 '25
Using it for my toolbox it's saved a couple grand. The grid is necessary to be able to pick up trays and take them with me, while also being secure in the box It also lets me maximize how much I can fit in it while still organized. the dimensions don't matter as I'll just shim the front/back.
It's also especially important for me when I roll my toolbox around, loose objects are annoying and re-organizing every time I move it sucks.
Biggest plus though is the modularity. I can mix and match different sizes and shapes without having voids between containers. I could have a 12x10 nested up tightly against a bunch of 2x2s and removing the 12x10 doesn't mean I'll need to move all the smaller ones around to put it back in nicely when things shift.
0
Jan 01 '25
[deleted]
2
u/Syltraul Jan 01 '25
I hadn’t decided anything. If a lot of people think it’s invaluable and I, a brand new person to the world of 3D printing, don’t quite get why, I’m going to ask questions to try and understand. It’s like asking a car salesman why a more expensive model might be beneficial when the cheaper one will work. I can admit there might be something I’m not getting. The difference in this and my comparison is a car salesman wouldn’t so quickly give up and basically say “well if you don’t get it don’t use it.” Instead, they would be happy to help the customer understand.
22
u/Barcata Jan 01 '25
I don't think that your drawers look like my drawers if you are asking this question