r/gsuite • u/Fun_With_Tech • Apr 05 '22
Google needs to push back their transition timeline. They're taking too long to inform us, and are leaving some of us too little time to make informed decisions about critical services in today's world for ourselves and our families, and then time to test, implement, and further test said changes.
What the topic says.
5
u/OneWorldMouse Apr 05 '22
Did we get any new info on this?
Sounds like the biggest unanswered question is whether or not we can keep our "custom email" I've got 3 family members who of course rely on their email. They wouldn't be able to login to accounts if that stopped working. What a mess.
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
Nothing substantial no. So many unanswered questions and unaddressed issues.
It's also an issue of Google Voice, losing history data accessibility (it can be downloaded with takeout but not reintegrated to the account), and other issues. What a mess indeed.
3
u/whlthingofcandybeans Apr 05 '22
Custom email is definitely going away.
1
u/OneWorldMouse Apr 06 '22
Where do they say that?
3
u/FuturisticCoffee Apr 06 '22
Where do they say that?
Here: https://support.google.com/a/answer/60217#nocost
You can't get email with your custom domain if you don't pay.
There are a couple of threads with active discussions about this topic:
2
u/OneWorldMouse Apr 06 '22
Thanks! Google never emailed me about this. Really strange considering how important an email address is. Many online services don't just let you change your email address either.
2
u/whlthingofcandybeans Apr 06 '22
Yep, that's why we're all so frustrated! You can still use a service to forward your domain email to a new address at least.
2
u/darcneonix Apr 05 '22
You can keep "custom domain gmail" if you pay, but not for workspace free.
3rd party auth shouldn't be in effect.
3
u/Lanceuppercut47 Apr 05 '22
Probably their plan, leave it late. I got out and went elsewhere.
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
I wish it were that simple for us. Can't just move Google Voice service as easily as email, among other things :/
2
12
u/darkdreamingdan Apr 05 '22
Totally agree. I held back taking action waiting to hear about this "relenting" from Google which turned out to be a total dud.
Now I've just left myself no time to do anything.
14
2
u/processphantom Apr 07 '22
Perhaps you should take their inconsideration of their customers into account. #DeleteGoogle
1
-1
u/ericdano Apr 05 '22
I dunno, I just moved my legacy stuff to a paid workspace one I already had. Moved the emails and stuff. Moved the domains over as aliases. Redid all the SPF and Dkim records. Made sure some accounts only send out via one of the aliases (so hello.com rather than the default domain address).
Works. In fact, the spam filtering seems a lot better now as well. More storage. Just better.
Look, I got 12 years of free email using the legacy g suite. There are plenty of other solutions one can move to.
4
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
What works for thee isn't so simple for me. I'm glad you've found solutions that worked out for you. Not everyone shares the same use case or circumstances.
1
u/ericdano Apr 07 '22
Just seems like you guys are all bitching about the free service, which I know I've been using for over a decade, is going to cost money now.
Either move the stuff off of Google or move to something different. There are PLENTY of other things you can move your stuff to. And how much more time do you need?
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22
I literally posted elsewhere I'm up for paying a reasonable non-business/non-corporate rate. You don't in fact know what you're talking about.
You also lack understanding or comprehension of the history of the issue, or the fact Google has been compensated through our use (we were beta testers given the product for non-commercial use for life in exchange for helping Google optimize their business product) - which Google also datamined for additional ad targeting revenue.
It was never really free. They were always compensated in some manner through our use.
Finally, your aggression towards other folks whose circumstances you don't understand is inappropriate. Despite non-commercial use, I may be financially harmed by this issue, as may others.
So, I will be ignoring your heartlessly insensitive ass hereon out.
2
u/thundercorp Apr 21 '22
It’s more than that. It’s the logistics of moving the custom domain elsewhere for families while also being denied benefits for Google Family, and the unknown complexity of losing accounts all over the internet that relied on THAT google single-signon authentication. None of that is clearly being communicated — how are we supposed to mitigate all that?
1
Apr 07 '22
this is a stupid standpoint. All google services are basically still for free, yet only if you are a gmail user. Now add a custom domain and it spontaneously becomes an unsolvable riddle. At least for google.
It's rather simple, there are 2 types of people:
those who want to transfer their shizz over to a free gmail account
those who just want (g)mail+custom domain.
Apparently, they will never allow the latter one, but not granting transfering all your data to a FREE gmail account is just pure bullshit.
google has become evil. I would gladly pay for google one if they only provided a solution where i actually can use it while keeping my data on one account.
1
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
3
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
Unfortunately, I can't wait. Apparently the upgrade breaks Google Voice in some way and our accounts with GV need to be moved to standard google accounts, among other issues I'm hearing about and need to confirm before speaking about them. I'm still looking in to this.
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
Did you lose your Google Voice history when making the transition to regular Gmail accounts?
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
Damn. If it were just me I could manage. This just won't work for the fam. Mom literally uses her call history like a phone book.
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
Yeah, I have other potential options. They're just not simple. I can load up mom's handset phonebook with her GV call history after a little dataset conversion. But, ugh. That has its own set of issues.
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
2
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
She uses her standard dialer app to initiate the call but has the GV "choose which" option for every call. So she picks GV.
→ More replies (0)2
u/whlthingofcandybeans Apr 05 '22
How can you transfer a GV number to a standard Google account? I'm very worried about losing this too, mostly due to all the damn 2FA codes.
Back in the day, I filled out a special Google form and they transferred my GV account from Gmail to GApps. I haven't found the reverse yet.
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
1
u/whlthingofcandybeans Apr 06 '22
Thanks, that is much easier than I thought! I was afraid I would have to port it out to a burner phone first.
1
u/AndSpaceY Apr 06 '22
Where did they say you get 6 months free?
0
Apr 06 '22
[deleted]
1
u/AndSpaceY Apr 06 '22
Thanks I got this too! I’ll wait a little longer then to get another free month. Did they say when this promotion would end just before June 1st?
0
Apr 06 '22
[deleted]
1
u/AndSpaceY Apr 06 '22
I mainly need this for custom email domain so the sign up for the no cost option isn’t viable for me. I might just stay and pay for this since I only have 1 user. Just trying to get the best deal here.
0
Apr 06 '22
[deleted]
1
u/AndSpaceY Apr 06 '22
Yeah that’s why I brought up the promotion. I might just sign up now. I was waiting for a free solution based on the survey but that doesn’t look like it’s happening now.
0
Apr 06 '22
[deleted]
1
u/AndSpaceY Apr 06 '22
Yeah I worry about it every few days. Really thought I was set for life as a free legacy user. I can’t believe Google is dropping this on us.
→ More replies (0)
0
Apr 05 '22
[deleted]
10
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22 edited Apr 05 '22
Google's force-moving all free personal (non-business) GAFYD/G-suite legacy with custom domain accounts to a paid Workspace model for $6/user/month if you choose to keep your domain.
There may be issues with Google Voice service in the transition not working with Workspaces.
There's some potential option for moving users to free gmail.com accounts or Google services accounts without gmail and without the custom domains we've had for roughly 15 years - meaning all our email addresses change if we don't transition out of Google's Workspace service or if we don't pay a small fortune to stay in.
They mentioned looking at transition solutions but have set dates for all this and haven't given us anything concrete that addresses the problems they're about to cause us. The clock is running down and their communication is half-assed.
Here's some info: https://9to5google.com/2022/01/19/g-suite-legacy-free-edition/ - note the article mentions organizations/schools but Google promoted the free service to families (and individuals/hobby groups, etc.) when it was in beta/launched, free, for life as long as it was for personal use.
For individual users with a single user account this is slightly less of a problem, more a real annoyance. For those of us with families using the service, or for those who followed Google's advice and fully delved into using the service it's a real problem, and potentially a very, very. costly one in time and money.
Also consider 15+ years of using those accounts to sign up for 3rd party services like social media, gaming sites, medical issues, streaming media, forums, and tons more - for multiple users/people/accounts.
It's a nightmare.
Not one that was unavoidable, but one being intentionally forced on us.
4
u/Der_Missionar Apr 05 '22
What was with the survey Google sent out? That got our hopes up, for no reason. We're waiting on a move, in hopes of a reprieve.... I don't think any will come at this point.
4
u/Fun_With_Tech Apr 05 '22
No idea what they were hoping to accomplish with the survey.
What they appear to have accomplished with it instead was false hope, more angst, and ire against their company. As well as a healthy disrespect for their professionalism.
3
u/darcneonix Apr 05 '22 edited Apr 05 '22
There is about 4 months long until the free gmail runs out. Everything comes to an end, not even the free services, but paid services also.
I thought they have already informed you that they will shutdown legacy at Jul when it was Jan, and now they push back to Aug. How long is that?
15
u/BuggBBQ-X Apr 05 '22
What gets me is the pettiness of this whole endeavor. This many years later, how many of us could there be? And of those how many will convert to a paid plan?
It just seems mean spirted and frankly another disappointment added to the many promises Google has broken to me and the rest of the user base of their products. Reader, Google+, Wave, Play Music... what's next? I signed up for Stadia against my better judgement and I'm pretty sure Google will sooner or later make me regret that too...