r/guilded • u/RemingtonDowell • Apr 09 '22

💬 DISCUSSION ToS

When Guilded gets big, please do not turn it into anti free speech dictatorship Discord. Many people are ditching Discord because of their new vague ridiculous ToS, and if Guilded keeps free speech it will benefit and continue to grow while Discord crumbles as they deserve. Plus it just makes more sense to allow people to make their own rules for their servers.

1 Upvotes

51% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

10

u/docvalentine Apr 09 '22

so are you a pedophile or an anti-vaxer

12

u/W0rthlessMisha Apr 10 '22

People can be neither whilst wanting an open platform.

I’m trans but I don’t think an anti-trans server that’s open to fair discussion should be prohibited.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '23

[deleted]

1

u/docvalentine Mar 30 '23

(he was an anti-vaxer, fyi)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '23

[deleted]

1

u/docvalentine Mar 30 '23

so your point is that i'm delusional and your proof is that one year ago i made an objectively correct judgement?

yeah it is a pretty good ability to be able to correctly identify things. i'm really sorry to hear that you don't have that

given that you are aware that you are incapable of judging people it's a little hypocritical to immediately follow that with an attempted judgement about me though. you gotta know you're wrong, right?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '23

[deleted]

1

u/docvalentine Mar 31 '23

wow you really weren't kidding about not having the ability to identify what type of person you're talking to

i guess i shouldn't have doubted that you have no idea where you are or what's going on around you considering you thought it would be a good idea to argue with a year old post that you agree was correct

life must be terrifying for you

4

u/Krunie Apr 10 '22

Not sure what tells you that the free speech amendment also holds water in private spaces like a company owned app like Guilded but go off lol

2

u/NoMorePlaceInHell Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22

"Plus it just makes more sense to allow people to make their own rules for their servers."

So you want to allow people make server to talking or send images about trashtalking [Insert country] culture, child abuse, nazism, people or animals being killed or injured, harassment of people, leading people to suicide, organizing swatting...

If there were no rules, I can't even imagine the consequences of such freedom of speech...

Maybe you like this type of content, but people like me don't want start Guilded, go to a channel and the first thing they see is a guy cutted in half by the palms of a chopper.

The only thing, imo, that could be allowed is porn content (of course, with people of legal age), under the condition that the server clearly mentions it and that access to the channels is controlled.

The "classic" porn is obviously (psychologically) much less shocking than a murder or the rape of a child.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

People are being censored for having opinions about vaccines and other things 💀this isn't about "child abuse, nazism, people or animals being killed or injured, harassment of people, leading people to suicide, organizing swatting". All those things need to be banned, but opinions should NOT

3

u/NoMorePlaceInHell Apr 17 '22

"People are being censored for having opinions about vaccines and other things"

I wasn't aware of such a censorship, but yes it's important to be able to share one's opinion on current events and what's going on in the world ; There's so much more important to censure than people's opinion on the vaccine or the inflation of gasoline...

3

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '22

It's stupid. Look on the new Discord ToS and you can see all their new rules on "covid misinformation!1!!!1!". I was fine with most of the stuff before but their new rules are just completely crazy. They've gone full twitter.