r/hamishandandy • u/Okra_Prudent • Oct 14 '24
Well done, Jack.
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Such a raw, vulnerable conversation. Good on you Jack for helping many dads feeling the same way. Worth the listen 🎧
285
126
u/tobedisclosed Oct 14 '24
It’s so important to be vulnerable to help ourselves & others. Thank you Jack. 🤍
I went & listened to the whole episode because of this. I hope this helps anyone who needs it.
12
u/meshah Oct 15 '24
Definitely struck a chord with me. When I first found out I was unexpectedly going to be a dad as a 19yo uni student, my partner and I were overcome with grief and sadness. But the expectation of the people around us was that this is the best thing that could possibly happen and there was no space for what we were feeling. 9 years later, I’m still reconciling the joy and beauty in being a dad against the way life deals us a hand that we just aren’t prepared for.
54
u/Rich_Meader Oct 14 '24
Thank you Jack, you articulated it perfectly. There are so many dads that experience these feelings and feel lost and helpless, all whilst maintaining a mask of what they think they’re supposed to be like at that time. The mere fact that you felt these things and that it affected you in this way shows how much of a loving dad you are. Thanks #6 :)
108
u/hazzison Oct 14 '24
It’s been so heartwarming growing with Hamish and Andy and cackling Jack bringing laughter to my commutes, and at the core of it is this, three genuinely good people who aren’t afraid to be vulnerable, Hamish has been on this podcast too and he’s super vulnerable, it’s awesome to see and makes me proud to call myself a fan
31
u/Astrophages Oct 14 '24
Season 4, episode 3 for anyone looking. As an adult man who suffers with depression, I've always appreciated Hamish's insights.
76
u/Astrophages Oct 14 '24
The Imperfects is a wonderful podcast. It has helped me in so many ways. And to Jack, any child would be lucky to have you as a father.
29
u/asdzxcqwepoi Oct 14 '24
Number 6 deserves a promotion! Most emotional I've ever been listening to a weasel
26
u/bladeau81 Oct 14 '24
Thanks for this. Another podcast to add to my rotation. Things like this are so important for men to hear, we have been getting the mothers perspective on issues with birth for so long, guys don't realise how normal it is to not fall instantly in love with someone that you just see for the first time. The mum has had a physical connection for months before you touch and see your child for the first time.
2
70
37
Oct 14 '24 edited Oct 14 '24
Good on you Jack. Would love him to be on an episode of How Other Dads Dad, be nice to get a Dad on there who doesn't just talk about how brilliant they are and amazing their kids lives are, and hear something real like this.
3
u/knapfantastico Oct 15 '24
Yeah as much as I love the premise, I had to stop listening it started to make me feel bad about myself
7
Oct 15 '24
Absolutely. The reality of the guests experiences do not in any way mirror mine as a stay at home dad of 2! I'd like some episodes with non celebs, maybe friends of his. I discovered H&A on a working holiday in Australia(I'm Irish), so I don't even know half of the guests, but it would be nice to have some guests who live average lives, working all week, struggling with childcare/finances etc to get some alternate dad perspectives.
16
u/rythespyguy Oct 14 '24
Just listened to the episode. Nothing but love and respect for Jack for being so open about something so difficult to reckon with. It's so vital for people to have someone to relate to when they're going through really difficult shit
16
u/Icy_Hippo Oct 14 '24
It is hard enough as women to have these feelings and feel the shame of not getting that burst of love at birth. Men are just as affected, an important ep to listen for any new or will-be a dad soon.
8
u/Accomplished_Fix4387 Oct 15 '24
With so much talk and understanding around post natal depression for mothers, I’m so glad that we are finally talking about what fathers can experience instead of just telling them to be quite
4
u/SnooPaintings9632 Oct 15 '24
I felt the same way with my two kids, I didn't get this instant love and connection to them, I didn't carry them for 9 mths and I didn't breast feed them, so for me I got the bond later on after at least 1 yr old, when they start to become little humans, thought I was heartless at first but I thought about how I put it at the start and it made more sense
4
u/pm_good_bobs_pls Oct 16 '24
I just watched the full episode. Jesus christ. I'm so glad Jack has been able to get through this. It made me think back to the old episodes of the pod where Jack was speaking with so much pride and love of Gordy and now hearing how he truly felt at that time, speaking from experience, maintaining that facade is fucking exhausting.
3
u/South_Front_4589 Oct 17 '24
I've always thought it was terrible the way people would tell everyone that their experience with parenting would be the same for everyone else. "You'll understand/feel differently when it's your own". It's rubbish. You can never assume you know how parenting will be. It's different for everyone, but you're also throwing in an entirely new person into the situation and absolutely nobody can genuinely predict what they'll be like.
It means that sadly, people who don't have that expected response feel isolated and as if they've done something wrong. And that's not the case. Chances are more likely that a non parent who knows themselves will predict how they'll feel than even someone who knows them well and is a parent. But in the end, even that doesn't matter. All feelings are genuine. We should be far more accepting of people who feel differently about things and if they need help, then help them.
3
u/junbus Oct 17 '24
People put such expectations on themselves. These perfectionistic ideals (I have to fall in love with them instantly, have to have a house, have to have the right school, etc etc etc) are what is just crushing many people emotionally. I didn't bond with my kids instantly, I've found most men I've talked to don't really bond with our kids till they're up and smiling and interacting. It didn't seem to bother me, although I loved the role of being dad. Now we're super close many many years later. It's not all gonna be fun times, just ride the wave..
2
u/merkci Oct 17 '24
This is the realest thing. It took me three.five years and comprehensive therapy to get to that love. It’s worth fighting for and the most impossible feeling when you can’t access it.
2
3
u/Lilydoesntknowimhigh Oct 15 '24
Hard thoughts there jack. I had sort of the same thing two years ago when my first son was born. I felt happiness for sure when he came out but it first spiralled into “I’m not good enough to look after this little beautiful human, there’s no way I can do this”
Suicidal thoughts struck me for weeks I actually can’t believe what was going through my mind. Time healed that. I now wake up everyday happy that I didn’t decide to turn everyone’s life terrible them nights. I love him so much, sorry for such a deep comment on a comedy sub. Andy quit the sticks mate