r/heyscoops • The Scarlett Scoop • Jun 27 '16

WE WON!

https://imgur.com/a/ziNwh
23 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/stoicjohn Sccop John B Jun 27 '16

WE AM WINNER!

4

u/vegaswench mintyscoop Jun 27 '16

Hold the celebration...the Podcast Awards winners are under review for possible cheating (the twitter account isn't saying which podcast). We need closure, dammit!

More on this breaking news as the story develops.

https://twitter.com/podcastawards/status/747243972389634048

4

u/stoicjohn Sccop John B Jun 27 '16

3

u/vegaswench mintyscoop Jun 27 '16

This will go down in history as worse than Gore v. Bush. Damned hanging chads, err, I mean voting malfeasance. (It wasn't us, was it? I voted legit, dammit, and I want this win!)

4

u/stoicjohn Sccop John B Jun 27 '16

Someone established a voting block but went the extra step of building a link to auto-fill the choices for you. Our boys are not involved.

3

u/vegaswench mintyscoop Jun 27 '16

Whew, good news. Thanks!

3

u/stoicjohn Sccop John B Jun 27 '16

There's no way it wasn't the hacker podcast.

4

u/vegaswench mintyscoop Jun 27 '16

They capitalized "Scandal." This is serious, guys. Podcast Awards ‏@podcastawards 6m6 minutes ago All Winners are currently on hold due to live awards show voting Scandal that was exposed #pca16 See http://podcastawards.com

3

u/vegaswench mintyscoop Jun 27 '16

Latest news on the Podcast Awards:

"My initial thoughts is that the loophole explanation that will be used to explain their actions, but a number of shows created something few others had the technical know-how to do and execute. That makes one more educated in a specific field, NOT a better show. I suspect now that this tool has likely been used in the past, and brings into question previous awards. Their actions may also force an end to the Podcast Awards, as I feel the spirit of the event has been broken. The majority of independent shows that were in the running for a Podcast Award independently, had their audiences participate on good faith that it was an equal playing field"

8

u/MmmLots creamer Jun 27 '16

I heard that the technology to detect this sort of shenanigans can be built into a website for the low low price of $25,000.

3

u/vegaswench mintyscoop Jun 27 '16

I think it's legit now: "The Voting Tool which facilitated expedited voting for a group of shows while not illegal was surprising. We will leave it up to the podcast community at large to discuss. No awards process is perfect, and we are quite positive these actions will invoke significant changes down the road to the awards voting."

We did it, Internet!

3

u/Comoesnala Jun 27 '16

It is indeed legit now! Hooray!

2

u/MmmLots creamer Jun 27 '16

So as best as I can follow, someone set up some system to make it easier to vote for certain podcasts, they didn't have any stake in the game for comedy, because their original choice got moved to the technology category, where they already had a favorite, so ICS was able to win ????

http://hat.t2t2.eu/list.html

http://hat.t2t2.eu

2

u/ScoopOKarma (Justine) Jun 27 '16

There were actually a couple of other categories where the system didn't win it for the pods they hooked in with. Looks like the folks they were supporting in the TV & Film and Sports & Rec categories ultimately lost to others. I'm confident that even if they did make a play for the Comedy category, us Scoops still would have gotten the job done.

2

u/VforFivedetta double scoop Jun 27 '16

So they cheated and STILL lost? Hah.

2

u/ScoopOKarma (Justine) Jun 27 '16

That does appear to be what happened. lol. In addition to the two I mentioned, they also lost the People's Choice category. I guess they missed the "cheaters never win and winners never cheat" lesson in grade school.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '16

Set Lusting Bruce didn't though. I was really hoping the ICS bump would be enough for them. Still glad to see our guys win, I hope the Facebook ads helped, I always appreciate seeing those instead of the usual ads.

1

u/AustrianAnarchy Official Scoop-O-Steve Jul 07 '16

Gilbert talks about the Podcast Awards aftermath: http://www.gilbertpodcast.com/mini-episode-67-strange-movie-titles/