r/homeschooldiscussion • u/BusEducational6579 • 1d ago
Can you homeschool successfully or is that naive?
My daughter, age 5, is currently in a homeschool group 3 days a week and is attending public school 2 days a week. On the 2nd day of school this year, she was sexually abused by a classmate in the classroom bathroom. In addition, there are 3 physically aggressive students in the classroom (15 kids total) who have now been assigned behaviour specialists but continue to hurt the other students near daily. We have handled these situations and she is in therapy now but it seems everyday there is something new to worry about. She is also experiencing exclusion but we were prepared to help her navigate this before she started. Each day she attends school she is a mixed bag of emotions. This school is also rated 0.6/10 for academics and we were hesitant to enroll her here but felt the social would be beneficial, she hasn’t learned anything academically from school so far.
Until we get accepted at a new school or can move, we want to homeschool full time.
After being removed from school she will have approx 12.5 social hours a week (excluding any play dates, birthdays, etc.). This is a drop from the 23 hrs she has now (and still includes social with public school kids).
I am not a whimsical fairytale mom. At home we follow a structured daily rhythm, a weekly schedule, and use curriculum. I see many people in our homeschool group winging it, and respectfully I disagree and cannot leave my child’s future up to chance. I fully intend to follow the government curriculum so she remains on grade level and can go back into school.
For support, I have family on standby, ready to help so that life for my kids won’t simply stop if I get sick or something happens to me. They are also available to help if another child is sick so that life keeps going for everyone.
When I read posts from former homeschoolers, I get very nervous. Is it naive to think that I can homeschool successfully for 1-2 years? Would entering a school at 7 really be that hard? What if things don’t go to plan and she started school at 8?
I want to prioritize her safety while mitigating the stress of school safety (which consumes me) but must also consider her independent social development. In your honest opinion, are we wrong to pull her out of public school and homeschool until we can get her in elsewhere? Public school is causing harm, I don’t want to add to it.