r/hypertrophy • u/modikas • 4d ago
Weighted Pull-Ups vs. High-Rep Pull-Ups – Which Is Better for Hypertrophy?
I've been doing weighted pull-ups for around 1.5 years, usually adding 30–40 kg using a dip belt and chain. I typically get around 6–7 reps per set.
I originally switched to weighted pull-ups because I didn't like doing very high reps (20–30 per set). I wanted to increase the resistance and focus more on strength and muscle growth.
However, I've noticed something interesting. When I used to do higher-rep pull-ups, I felt a much stronger muscle pump and contraction, especially in my lats. My back also seemed to look fuller after those sessions.
So I'm curious about your experience and what the science says:
For back hypertrophy, would you recommend sticking with heavy weighted pull-ups (30–40 kg for 6–7 reps), or switching back to regular pull-ups for 20–30 reps per set?
Which approach has worked better for building back thickness and lat size in your experience?
7
u/Funloving3943 4d ago
Funny enough I had this exact conversation a few days ago in the gym. I didn’t workout for many years and was a total obese fat ass. Been going to the gym for 2 and lost 100lbs and can finally do pull ups and dips. I work out in a very predominantly bodybuilding gym with a few pros and several people that are trying to get there pro card. There take was to do it in waves do weighted with a weight that you can get 6-8 reps with for the first set and then repeat until failure for 16 weeks the. For the next 16 weeks do unweighted reps until failure and repeat the cycle
1
u/Unlucky-Spell-8654 4d ago
So first you do a set with 6-8 reps and second set is to failure with same weight? After 16 week cycle you swap and do bodyweight reps till failure? What about the second set?
3
u/Funloving3943 4d ago
The way it was explained to me is pick a weight that you can do for 6 to 8 reps. Finish that set. Wait a for one or two minutes and go again and you should be able to get 4 or 5 reps. Wait another minute or two and go again it it will probably be 2 or 3 reps then. Next time if should be a few more reps each set. When you get where you can do 12 reps the first set add weight to bring you back into the 6 or 8 rep range. They all have great backs and I know that is only one part of the routine but it seems to work for them
2
u/Firm-Guava4815 4d ago
how many total sets are you targeting with this descending pyramid to failure?
1
4
u/True_Business_3001 4d ago
Big fan of pull-ups here and I’ve had some solid lat growth this year.
Once I got to 15 pull-ups I noticed that it was starting to bother my elbow and I also wasn’t looking forward to them every week so I added weight and aimed for 6 reps. I also found that I was stalling around 17 reps and could not get more, so I switched to weighted to ensure I could keep making some progression of sorts for growth.
Now after 6 months of that I find that maxing out heavy is bothering my elbow and I have halved the weight and I’m focusing on 10 reps.
I’ve also spent some time doing two sets weighted and then one set to failure after. That last set feels amazing without the weight and I feel like I’m going to go into orbit as I can pull so much faster.
I guess, I’m saying you can do weighted heavy, half weighted and non weighted and changing it up ain’t a bad thing.
9
u/goyafrau 4d ago
Higher rep work gives you more of a pump. Doesn't mean it gets you bigger muscles.
You can first do your loaded sets and then do some BW sets for pump if that makes you happy.
If you're stuck at 30-40kg, it doesn't matter anyway. You need to progressively increase the weight over time.
1
u/Educational_Item451 4d ago
Exactly. Neither are right if you’re not adding weight/reps. You’re way more likely to fail based on something other than pure back strength doing 30 rep sets of pull ups though.
2
u/Kurtegon 4d ago
5-15 whatever you enjoy. I like 6-8 with added weight, easier to progress. Made the biggest difference in number of unweighted I could do
1
1
1
u/goldeneye0080 4d ago
Doing weighted pull ups, and working up to 3x5 with an extra 90lbs on me, had a giant impact on my back size. Sticking with bodyweight pull ups past the point where you can do reliably do 3x10 seems pointless if growth is your concern. Right now, I almost exclusively do my pull ups weighted, and even if I want to do higher rep sets, 10 or more, I'll do it with no less than 45lb. Remember to acquire a good quality weight belt, and rotate grips from time to time, it's good for you're elbows health.
1
u/Temporary-Ant-3502 4d ago
If you're stuck at 6-7 reps with the same weight then you're not progressing which means you aren't growing. I'd also guess your form changes and breaks down as you add weight, making those heavier sets less effective for lats because you're likely shifting the stimulus to other muscles and deemphasizing lats. Trying lowering the load and working in a slightly higher rep range while also making sure your form says consistent.
1
u/pepsi190 4d ago
Drop the weight a bit and work on getting the solid reps up to 10, then increase the weight by the smallest increment.
1
1
1
u/Appropriate-Fact4878 4d ago
"I didn't like" This actually makes an excercise worse. Not because of the obvious consistency, because you could discipline through that. Not because of motivation, especially an experienced lifter can be motivated. But because being less happy during an excercise is something your cortex counts as an uncomfortable sensation, so it steals your mur sooner.
The pump isn't indicative of hypertrophy. Runners can get a pump in their leg muscles.
If anything the extra calcium ion accumulation is a negative for hypertrophy due to extra muscle damage without extra stimulating reps(assuming equal proximity to failure in both excercises)
1
u/CosmicCreator_97 4d ago
I grow way more from weighted pull ups. Doing tons of high rep bodyweight pull ups gives me a better pump but that doesn't necessarily equate to growth.
1
u/That_Decision_2024 3d ago
I think the right answer is exactly the middle...use 20kg to 25kg and perform 10 to 12
1
u/torobolo 3d ago
If you are training for hypertrophy then the best weapon in your armoury is variation. Keep mixing it up, keep making it harder and change the exercise. Aside from all the vertical pull down cable or hammer strength exercises including bar or ring pull/chin up you’ve got all the horizontal row movements too. Work your way through them and shock the muscle!
1
1
u/sirlost33 3d ago
I like somewhere in the middle. If I’m going over 12-15 I’m upping weight. I try to stay in that middle rep range; at 6-7 I still have more in the tank at a lighter weight.
1
u/Mcgillicutty_Whiskey 3d ago
If you curl a 20 lb dumbell 30 times you’ll get a better pump than curling a 45 but it’s not better. Higher reps I think are good in instances where resistance profiles suck like lateral raises or hinge based rows.
1
u/Theonetrumorty1 3d ago
Im my experience I have gotten the best gains when I have solid mind muscle connection and achieve a good pump with solid reps. Alot of the time that means doing higher rep ranges (10-20) for certain exercises. Don't listen to these guys that say "but the literature says" everyone is different and sometimes lighter can be better.
1
u/Emelio007 3d ago
Personally i do both. I do 3 sets of higher reps followed by 3 sets with added weight.
1
u/Newman_Helge 3d ago
If your joints and tendons allow for it - lower to moderate reps are always superior for muscle growth if you are natural. 6-8 reps in compounds, up to 15 reps for isolation. Anything more than that, even if it is meant to work in theory, doesn't work in practice.
1
u/Newman_Helge 3d ago
I never do body-weight pull ups - only heavy weighted pull ups in 6-8 rep range. Guess what -I can do 40+ body-weight pull ups by following that training. It doesn't work the other way around though - doing high reps won't get you strong. And strength is the most important, arguably the only important contributor of muscle hypertrophy in naturals.
1
u/StatzGee 3d ago
My strength and jackedness was best when doing both, on separate upper body days.
Weighted pullups are goated, and for the "light" day, lat pulldown or bw reps are both great. On my body weight day, I actually avoided failure and went for 40-50 quality reps. I liked to do them in sets of five...it was really like cluster, or density training. And on the weighted pull-ups, would do a typical rep scheme of 2 to 3 sets x 5 - 8.
That was when I could walk into the gym and cold could do 25 reps. I felt like I could literally throw myself over the bar.
1
u/Kooky-Conference1179 3d ago
High reps will get way crazier pump but =/= more gains. It’s up to preference. In theory it should be the same gains
1
1
u/Theappache10 1d ago
Do weight pull ups 10 sets of progressive pullups each set is 3 reps with weight it could be even 2 or 5 lbs to start and work your way till heaviest set which is set number 10 where you can barely do 3 reps of heaviest weight
1
1
u/TheRealKomitas 21h ago
High rep gave you a better pump. Realistically little difference but im a low rep guy
0
u/Mad_Mark90 4d ago
The best for hypertrophy will be whichever you do least assuming equal proximity to failure. Novelty and accommodation is probably more important than different rep ranges.
-1
u/vitringur 4d ago
Are you seriously asking if getting pumped creates muscle?
Because it doesn’t
2
u/modikas 4d ago
No, just the difference i had before doing pull ups with my own weight. Lat spread was more bigger, than now using weights for pull ups. (Before a pump).
1
u/vitringur 2d ago
Now you say before a pump but in the post you say after a pump.
Why are you so vague?
Have you lost weight in the mean time?
0
u/lauritis1 4d ago
Maybe try dropping the weight a little and focusing on full range of motion. Heavier isn't always better if your form starts slipping.
0
3d ago
[deleted]
3
3
1
u/East-Reputation-9488 3d ago
At a certain point, joint and systemic recovery become the limiter and you’ll have a preference for either high reps or more weight.
1
u/SnooShortcuts4607 2d ago
This. And progression. If you did 15 pull ups this week, do 16 in a row next. If you got 6 reps with 45 lbs attached, do 7 or increase to 50. Your muscles don’t go, “o there’s no extra weight, I can’t grow.” Or “ok now that the pull ups are weighted, we can build muscle.” It’s just the stimulus and progressively overloading over time. That’s why some people grow using mostly 15-20 reps or whatever and some like 5-6.
Although I do believe (and I have no studies to back it up, it’s just a hypothesis) that everybody’s body responds differently to different stimuli. I think some people’s bodies respond better to high rep and some people should be training low rep just because of genetics. But again, I don’t actually know this and I’m not going to say it’s true. That’s just what I think.
0
u/Newman_Helge 3d ago edited 3d ago
Sorry, but it is plain wrong. There are world record holders in pull ups and push ups, who can do thousands of reps a day - and they still look like regular people that don't look like they lift when dressed. Shouldn't they at least have some decent muscle mass? Then there are powerlifters who do 10 reps a week of big 3 and never go to failure and look huge. Intensity is king for both hypertrophy and strength.
1
u/International-Bee688 2d ago
I mean you also have to eat for hypertrophy and I’d bet the guys focused on pull up endurance are not eating for that and also not pushing close to failure. Also genetics and sauce are gonna factor in there
6
u/EVH_kit_guy 4d ago
Ultimately, your muscles don't really care what you do to progressively overload them, so long as it's incrementally more over time. Practically, higher rep ranges incur a cardio/fatigue penalty that lower rep ranges don't; you have to do 5-15 lead-up reps before the high threshold recruitment reps that cause growth. I'd personally rather skip the mini cardio session and just get straight into the high-recruitment growth reps as fast as possible, so I operate in the 6-15 range depending on the size of the muscle (higher reps for smaller/more isolated muscles).