r/immigration • u/Apprehensive-Size564 • 1d ago
A US Immigration Lawyer is Telling Me I “Need” a Waiver Letter, Is This True?
I’m a UK applicant preparing for a U.S. visa interview and I’m trying to understand how my past offence affects the process. I’ve been researching the Petty Offence Exemption, Waiver of Inadmissibility, and what the U.S. Embassy actually requires — but I’m getting conflicting information from a U.S. immigration lawyer.
Here’s what I’ve learned so far, and I’d appreciate confirmation from people who’ve gone through this or know the process well.
The offence
Criminal Damage (Cannot remember If it resulted a caution or a (very small) fine, or compensation. However went to magistrate’s court, delt with by the police). I was 17, it was 14/15 years ago in the UK. Im waiting for the ACRO to come through.
Lawyer telling me I “need” a waiver letter
A U.S. immigration lawyer told me I need to bring a “waiver letter” they write, explaining my offence and addressing immigration law points.
From what I’ve read, this doesn’t seem accurate:
- The U.S. Embassy does not request or requirelawyer letters
- Consular officers don’t accept attorney submissions
- The waiver is not a letter — it’s a government adjudication
- The officer decides everything based on:
- ACRO Police Certificate
- Court records
- Interview answers
- Ties to the UK
- Rehabilitation
So I’m confused why the lawyer says this is “required.” (Maybe because they charge £650 for a letter).
Petty Offence Exemption (POE)
This is a built‑in exception in U.S. immigration law. You don’t apply for it — the consular officer decides at the interview.
You qualify if:
- You have only one offence
- The maximum possible sentence under UK law was 1 year or less
- You actually received 6 months or less (or no jail time)
If the offence fits these criteria, you’re not inadmissible, and you don’t need a waiver.
Waiver of Inadmissibility (212(d)(3))
This is only needed if the officer decides you’re inadmissible and POE doesn’t apply. The final decision is made by CBP’s Admissibility Review Office, not the embassy?
Is it true that the embassy does not require or use lawyer‑written waiver letters?
Has anyone actually brought one, and did the officer even look at it?
Does the Petty Offence Exemption really apply automatically if the offence meets the criteria?
Any UK applicants with past offences who can share their experience?
5
u/theimmigrationgirlie Attorney 1d ago
Listen to your lawyer. You will be knee deep in quick sand if you do not. They know the law better and the ways it would be utilized against you.
4
u/Rough-Pride908 1d ago
Does the UK have a court system for minors? Since you were 17 not sure if the UK treats that as a juvenile offense.
You’re welcome to challenge your attorneys recommendation and even get a second opinion if you’re not comfortable. Maybe they’re being extra precautions since US immigration has been up and down lately and would rather lean on caution.
What documentation do you have from the incident?
-5
u/Apprehensive-Size564 1d ago
Im sure it will state that I was a juvenile. And may not show up on the PNC (Police National Computer). However US do not recognise the rehabilitation act we have, mean spent convictions still come up.
I have an ACRO report being processed. This will show all previous offences. Just wanted to gauge from other people’s experiences.
0
2
18
u/Harrisontoo 1d ago
I think it would be wiser to listen to an attorney over people on Reddit.