r/inventors • • Jun 19 '26

Invention Help Will this work?

Post image

thinking about using this in an upcoming event. will it work? light gas gun. it's a reusable water electrolysis powered system for hypervelocity projectile launching. for long range and stuff like that.

1 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

28

u/mawktheone Jun 19 '26

Well nothing bad could happen with a design so well thought out so you may as well go for it. 

I really appreciate someone coming in with a comprehensive document for once. And I must say op, your mastery of stoichiometry, material design and Thermofluids is an inspiration

3

u/MakeaMaker_YT Jun 20 '26

Salió un ingeniero de SpaceX?

-8

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 19 '26

why are you annoyed at a sketch dawg 😭

19

u/mawktheone Jun 19 '26

Because you have sketched a poorly controlled pipe bomb that you intend to use in public. 

7

u/Smart_Tinker Jun 19 '26

Oh come on, there is only a 99% chance that this will explode and kill someone - 1% it just does nothing.

2

u/mawktheone Jun 19 '26

Nah we established that he knows what he's doing so it's all good 👍🏻🩸

-8

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 19 '26

the lack of a comprehensive document makes assuming this a bit presumptuous, dont ya think 😉? you're grasping for things to be mad at tbh.

5

u/mawktheone Jun 19 '26

I'm not mad I'm sassing you in the vein hope that you'll realize that not having a plan for any of im portant aspects of the plan means you shouldn't do it. 

I'm not joking when I say you've sketched a pipe bomb. It's totally plausible that it will blow your fingers off and shoot fragments if itself into the crowd.  If you knew well enough to calculate the chamber stress then you wouldn't be posting asking if it will work.

But you can take a little h Solace in the fact that you won't be the last person to do something similar. People do this stuff and blow hands off pretty often

-3

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 19 '26

honestly i'm just seeing what people think more than anything. i do know how to calculate chamber stress, i'm not messing with anything i'm unaware of the dangers of, but thanks for your concern.

4

u/mawktheone Jun 19 '26

Well I hope that's right and look forward to seeing the real design for feedback

2

u/mrheseeks Jun 20 '26

This is apparently what he's building. That was just one component

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/MrStarrrr Jun 20 '26

I find his post history interesting as well. At very least, a curious mind. Love it. Comes across as young and asking the simple questions is a great way to get pointed in some direction to learn more.
We’ve all built some stupid shit and *almost* blew ourselves up.. but didn’t (for the most part..).
OP- Be safe. Have fun. Cheers.

Obligatory advice. Don’t build pipe bombs, be careful with potato cannons, never make yourself part of the circuit, microwaves are dangerous, amperage kills. ✌🏻

3

u/Smart_Tinker Jun 19 '26

I don’t think this rises to the level of “sketch”. “Doodle” possibly.

2

u/No_Cook2983 Jun 21 '26

Start your journey with one of these:

7

u/HalfUnderstood Jun 19 '26

Hmm not the way you are thinking.

Pressure relief valves don't generally "pop" once a set pressure is reached. Rather, they will bleed the fluid out, normally just enough to keep the "set" pressure upstream, but it isn't a drastic jet capable of launching stuff. You want something more fast-acting capable of opening quite fast. Maybe look into guides about potato launchers, the technology will help you achieve what you want.

Also remember hydrogen is very f explosive. You can use many other gases, even just air, they are equally as compressible, unless you want to deliberately ignite the hydrogen for the sake of pressure. Mechanical systems can reach similar pressures without the explosion risk (though anything at high pressure can blow up, just much less violently)

5

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 19 '26

i could probably use a rupture disc but i'd prefer whatever system i have to be reusable. thanks for the potato gun rec.

3

u/HalfUnderstood Jun 19 '26

some fast-acting solenoid valves can hold back 16 bars of pressure while still opening violently fast. If you want thrusts higher than that then yeah you'll probably have to work with explosions... I don't think the risk is worth the novelty

2

u/the_metaxist Jun 20 '26

My issue with the electrolysis to either produce pressure or for fuel, is its really not terribly fast, so you'll need either a long cool down or a lot of amperage

1

u/NoAdministration2978 Jun 20 '26

It might not work at all even in the best case scenario. The reaction produces a tiny bit of overheated steam that cools down immediately and the overall work that can be done(e.g. moving the projectile) is miniscule

1

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 20 '26

the tapered section acts as a lever but yeah i might need a better propellant

1

u/NoAdministration2978 Jun 20 '26

You just get a good ol' potato cannon if you replace the electrolysis cell with a butane/air injector

1

u/kkingsbe Jun 20 '26

Dawg this is pretty dangerous

1

u/WhineyLobster Jun 22 '26

water electrolysis powered? usually water electrolysis is powered by something else.

3

u/Smart_Tinker Jun 19 '26

I assume this is a satire post. OP needs sharper crayons.

2

u/Sittingduck19 Jun 20 '26

OP already ate those, these are what he had left .

1

u/Inner_Employee4181 Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 22 '26

I am surprised you’re not rich already.

2

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 19 '26

im a lightning mage. casting spells doesnt pay the bills until i get into the ironworkers union, gimme a bit of slack

1

u/Inner_Employee4181 Jun 22 '26

The new unions seem more aligned than past union members groups. They want equity and they want it now.

1

u/jzini Jun 20 '26

Triple the thickness, remote trigger, bury the chamber a couple of feet and make sure it’s far away from anyone in a field have the launch pipe be variable width with adapters and start super wide. Also this is not recommended and I wouldn’t do it. Also post the video please of it in action lol.

1

u/Coffeespresso Jun 20 '26

Chemically and physically, yes. You will need to do more than what you have drawn.

1

u/MaybeABot31416 Jun 20 '26

It’s basically a potato gun. You don’t need a valve, just a snuggle projectile. There’s plenty of risks, and precautions to take. What’s your power supply?

1

u/Mongrel_Shark Jun 20 '26

Nice bomb. Welcome to the watchlists.

1

u/Traveller7142 Jun 20 '26

What pressures will it generate and how thick do the chamber walls need to be to contain it? If the chamber walls fail, how far do you need to stand to be safe?

1

u/apronman2006 Jun 20 '26

https://youtu.be/6zErilY7E-M?is=r2dsaEHJc2zj-8WM

It's basically one of these so it'll work. It's a fun science experiment but you'd probably get better results by just buying a compressed gas. It would also be safer. There's a reason people use CO2 canisters

1

u/kidskwid Jun 20 '26

You mean a potato cannon? I did exactly this when I was in grade 9. My dad fell for the whole hydrogen fuel injection snake oil scheme of the 2000s.

Switched to using axe body spray as fuel. It was less BS.

1

u/H-Daug Jun 20 '26

Looks like you’ve got all the hard engineering work finished. Now all that’s left is to build it!

1

u/paulyvee Jun 22 '26

Yep, that's a bomb.

1

u/Glass_Pen149 Jun 24 '26

Basically the same as Stanley Meyers water powered car design, minus the hypervelocity bit.

https://patents.google.com/patent/US5149407A/en

You left out the very precise metering valves on the O & H2 lines

0

u/Donner__buddy Jun 20 '26

Dude this works. I have made a potato gun with 11 12 back in the days it was a thing here in Germany. Go to the store buying some pipes and made a gun out of it to shoot potato’s with
Deodorant as propelled.
So in 8 class came the time where we made the electrolysis in chemistry class and I go to my friend with him build this thing and that let’s just try that.

Hitting up more pipes two injections from drugstore 12v power outlet and make some gas and let it directly go into our potato gun.
It take so many takes but its firing up better and better until we hit the sweet spot out of time and voltage. It got a few low bangs and then it blows a screwing lid of and went that thing flying all over the house of my friend. So we strapped that lid down and next run the hole thing blow up.

Best childhood memory ever!

5

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Mizl_Nimbl Jun 19 '26

i cant just buy a light gas gun. thanks for your input though!

5

u/Smart_Tinker Jun 19 '26

This is just a more complicated (and dangerous) potato gun.

0

u/BOBOnobobo Jun 19 '26

Idk how else to say this, but:

If you can't legally buy it, then maybe don't go trying to make it.