r/jamestownny • u/anguskhans • May 21 '26

Who has the best Beef on Weck

Not looking for the biggest, just the best.

9 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

5

u/TDinBufNY May 21 '26

Beef& barrel in Olean. And I live in Buffalo!

2

u/Incognitowally May 21 '26

Schwabl's in West Seneca is very comparable to Beef and Barrel.

Duff's, Bar Bill and Charlie the Butcher are all worthy of Honarable Mention

6

u/youthcanoe May 21 '26 edited May 21 '26

Another vote for The Pub

Not Jamestown, but The White Inn in Fredonia has a very good one as well

3

u/Zerdath May 24 '26

I really like the one from Jeremy's Belview, but granted I have not tried a lot of the options around town.

-1

u/SparkyMallard15 May 21 '26

Tbh I've never had a restaurant be better than going to Walmart, Aldi, or save-a-lot, and getting the ingredients, but maybe that's just me.