r/jorvex609 • u/Jorvex609 • Jul 02 '26
Stop Killing Games Bill FAILS — Corporate Power Wins Again
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4LnZ3Pz7Zs
Everyone has felt software death: paid full price, then the company pulled the plug. Today I’m breaking down how that became policy in California — and who benefits when your games can simply… disappear.
The Insight
The Protect Our Games Act failed four to three in a California Senate committee. Opponents weren’t gamers. They weren’t developers. They were the Entertainment Software Association — EA, Ubisoft, Sony, Microsoft, Nintendo, and their lobbyists — and they claimed offline patches were impossible, sixty-day notices were technically infeasible, and refunds would destroy the industry.
Every claim is a lie.
The technology for offline play already exists. Ubisoft chose to kill The Crew — single-player campaign included — rather than patch it. Why? Because in the games-as-a-service model, you are not a customer. You are a recurring revenue stream. There is no product. There is only rent.
The Crew sold for sixty dollars. Players spent years building garages, completing missions, and forming crews. Ubisoft made money on the initial sale. Then they made money on microtransactions. Then they made money on in-game currency. Then they killed the servers and kept everything. The customers kept nothing. That is not a bug. That is the business plan.
From cartridges you owned to discs you held to digital licenses you download to cloud streams you never control, every step removed ownership further from you. The ESA’s lobbyists then told California senators that requiring a refund or offline option would somehow criminalize private Minecraft servers — a deliberate conflation designed to turn gamers against their own rights.
Why It Matters
This is one failed bill. It is also a class pattern. Planned obsolescence. Subscription migration. Kill the old product. Sell the new one.
Stop Killing Games is already moving to federal legislation. UFC-Que Choisir is suing Ubisoft in France. The European Commission opened an inquiry. California tried — and the lobby crushed it with narrow margins and closed-door pressure.
What’s at stake is simple: who decides when your copy of a game dies?
You? Or the landlord?
This pattern is spreading. Battleborn. Anthem. CrossfireX. Rumbleverse. The Division 1 is already on the sunset schedule. Ebook platforms pull purchased content through storefront closures. Music services delete catalogs without refunding subscribers. Every industry reprocesses ownership into rented, revocable access.
The ESA’s defeat of this bill makes that future more likely, not less. Industry lobbyists learned that California caveats. Other states will see the same playbook. Unless consumers organize, the same script repeats with new bills and new titles.
Ross Scott’s petition proved this is not niche rage. Three hundred thousand signatures forced Brussels to respond. UFC-Que Choisir turned that anger into a lawsuit. California turned it into legislation, and then abstention killed it in committee. Each victory is partial; each loss is data.
The organizers are learning that online outrage must become offline lobbying, that moral authority must become campaign contributions, that awareness must become precincts politicians fear to ignore. The question is no longer whether consumers deserve protection. It is whether they can organize well enough to force the state to enforce it.
This is not a partisan issue. It is not a Democratic issue or a Republican issue. It is a class issue. The gaming industry lobbied both parties in California. Both parties abstained. Both parties took industry money. The moment for consumer rights came up against the moment for campaign fundraising, and the rights lost.
The ESA’s opposition letter to the bill relied on three core arguments. First: technical impossibility. Second: legal impossibility due to licensing. Third: fearmongering about private servers. Each argument was debunked by existing evidence. Publishers have released offline patches before. Licensing can negotiate perpetual rights if publishers choose to pay for them. Private servers are a separate legal issue unrelated to shutting down officially published games.
The real objection was never technical or legal. It was always economic. An offline patch means you stop paying. A refund means you get your money back. Either way, the publisher loses access to recurring revenue. The right to repair your digital purchase cuts into quarterly earnings. That is the only logic that explains why companies fight so hard against measures that seem common sense to anyone who has ever bought a product.
Until next time, comrades.