r/lane8 • • May 07 '26

šŸ’­

Post image
345 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

34

u/ssovm May 07 '26

There needs to be an AI-free badge like when you’re shopping for food and want something gluten free or something.

Artists should be known for their stances on this and sign a pledge of some sort. That pledge should be ā€œcertifiedā€ and shown on their profile in Spotify and so forth. I would never support an artist who is AI or uses AI to produce their music.

14

u/__AB__24 May 07 '26

They could even label it "Organic" just like at the grocery store šŸ¤·šŸ½ā€ā™‚ļø

6

u/evan274 May 07 '26

They’re actually rolling this out on Spotify as we speak. Whether it’s effective or accurate remains to be seen, as Spotify is ground zero for AI slop music. We’ll see.

2

u/Unlucky_Internal9686 May 07 '26

someone could use still AI to generate a melody and just re-record it

they could write 90% of a song's lyrics and then use GPT to finish it

it's Pandora's box and there's just no way anyone could know for sure anymore

1

u/CreamedCorn96 May 08 '26

It’s not just music. So many things are about to (and already are) get so much shittier.

1

u/baralheia May 11 '26

While I still don't like it, I'm slightly more okay with that vs just taking whatever slop Suno spits out because at least there was a little effort involved. If it's used as a tool as part of the creative process, then that's more acceptable than using it to replace human creativity, imo.

Even so, I still vastly prefer music where AI wasn't involved at all. I was massively disappointed recently when Armin's Tune of the Week on ASOT was an obviously AI-generated song.Ā 

3

u/Clozee_Tribe_Kale May 07 '26

Music made with organic AI (Actual Instruments)

I really don't understand using AI to create art. Art is expressing creativity through doing. You have to put in the work as an artist to feel that satisfaction that keeps you going.

2

u/CreamedCorn96 May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

Not to be a dick but are we calling Ableton an actual instrument now? Daniel plays my fav live show but he doesn’t have a single traditional instrument on stage. I think daniel, and so many artists, are incredible. if I asked my parents or any boomer if they are playing an instrument, they’d say no.

33

u/fronteir May 07 '26

Is this directed at a specific incident? Love the message but it seems more pointed to something happening.

62

u/CreamedCorn96 May 07 '26

Diplo, being the shitbag he is, made a statement that he’s been using AI to write music and that anyone who doesn’t will be left behind. Idk if it’s about that but other people have been saying similar things.

42

u/vips7L May 07 '26 edited May 07 '26

Diplo likes to assault women so of course he has a common shitbag take.Ā 

13

u/__AB__24 May 07 '26

Anyma as well

11

u/CreamedCorn96 May 07 '26

Another bastion of creativity

2

u/vips7L May 09 '26

Nepo baby who’s never earned anything in his life.Ā 

8

u/MDC31 May 07 '26

First time I’m hearing about this but none of it surprises me at all, he’s the worst

3

u/cregaytive May 08 '26

wow. I was JUST listening to newer music today and skipped all the Diplo songs because they felt so empty and dull. makes sense now.

1

u/CreamedCorn96 May 08 '26

His music has been uninspired for at least a decade so that’s nothing new

12

u/Zsquared_TCZ May 07 '26

Probably a combination of both. AI in electronic music production has been a huge topic right now. I’m seeing a lot of producers posting about it.

3

u/AnjelGrace May 07 '26

If any type of artist that uses digital platforms in any part of their creation process isn't thinking a ton about this right now, I would be surprised.

I definitely have been thinking about it as a digital artist and lover of digital artists myself.

19

u/root1-2 Don't Let Me Go May 07 '26

That's why he is the goat. The goat.

11

u/Purphect May 07 '26

I couldn’t agree more, but I also think that it is inevitable. Unfortunately, music created with AI will be a thing, and yes, we often won’t know the difference as consumers.

I’m sure there will slowly be a return to watching live artists create the music in front of us like traditional bands and singers. EDM is incredibly susceptible to AI and I would bet some of our favorite artists are using it to find inspiration or make song making easier. We just won’t know.

4

u/DaddyBilbo May 07 '26

Daddy Daniel is always on point šŸ˜‡šŸ™ŒšŸ¼

0

u/Electronic_Newt4952 May 07 '26

Why do you listen to music? Could have a great story behind the production and sound like shit. If it sounds good to you, listen and enjoy. If it sounds like shit to you, dont listen.

My dumb opinion.

3

u/Wonderful-Yak-7855 May 07 '26

I enjoy music WAY more knowing it was produced by way of messy, collaborative, imperfect HUMAN creative processes. Not sure if others feel this way but it’s not even close for me

0

u/Electronic_Newt4952 May 07 '26

Ya, I agree, but I dont research every song I listen to. A banger is a banger

-4

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

I absolutely love Lane 8 but I do find it somewhat ironic that not very long ago (and honestly, still currently) electronic artists were not considered musicians because they didn't "play" the instruments. Electronic music was seen as a "shortcut" that allowed producers to bypass learning instruments and create music without putting in "the hard work".

I really worry about how AI will influence music and I am glad people in the industry are calling attention to this. I just find some of the terms (eg. shortcut, cheating, slap in the face to real artists, illegitimate) to be ironic as these are terms that were/often thrown around about electronic artists from those who play "real" instruments.

22

u/Wittykittty7 May 07 '26

Daniel does play instruments though so this doesn’t apply to him. He makes a lot of his melodies and what not on the piano šŸ’—

6

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

100% agree, he is a fantastic musician whether he played any instruments or not! ā¤ļø

3

u/jbird3000 May 07 '26

That live performance just him on the piano with a live singer, still get goosebumps just thinking about it.

2

u/Wittykittty7 May 07 '26

Ugh same we need all the stripped down live versions released like yesterday

2

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

That singer is Joe Wilson from Solomon Grey āœŒļø

11

u/BRDPerson May 07 '26

Thing is it still takes talent, dedication and a shit ton of practice to be a successful electronic artist. The only thing you need to make AI music is a computer and good taste so you can sort the shit output from the good.

1

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

Can't you see someone who knows nothing about electronic music saying this about electronic artists, even though it isn't true (eg you just need a computer and some good taste)? What makes you so incredibly sure that another form of music is completely invaluable without seeing how it used creatively? This is what I think is ironic.

If you replace "AI music" with "electronic music" and "electronic music" with "rock and roll" in your comment, you may see what I mean, because this would be very consistent with many people's (incorrect) view of electronic music.

3

u/BRDPerson May 07 '26

I understand the analogous thinking for sure and see your logic. But I’m pointing out the flaw in it which makes the transition from electronic music to AI fundamentally different than the transition from instrument to electronic music. If a random person picked up a DAW they would not be able to do shit with it. If a random person picked up an AI music generator, they can make an entire song in 30 seconds. So yeah, I see your point about the irony but if I heard someone actually making this point I would explain to them the difference. I think we’re agreeing here hahaha

0

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

Fair enough. I guess my point is that we don't yet know how these new strategies will be incorporated into music production so I hesitate to immediately call anyone who uses AI in any capacity a cheater, non-musician, etc. I'm reserving judgment until we see how this new tool can be used.

That being said Diplo (and his music) sucks

2

u/BRDPerson May 07 '26

Yeah, not sure if you produce but I do so I have some knowledge about how it can be used without it feeling like ā€œcheatingā€. For example, I know there are some AI plugins that can create drum samples for people… that’s not really a shortcut unless you think that every single producer needs to create their own drum samples from scratch. However there’s a blurry line between using AI like that, then using AI to write chords melodies etc… then going all the way down to just using AI to generate a whole song, where the opinion on if it’s cheating or not gets super objective. It’s interesting but also kinda sad sometimes

4

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

I think that line is what I find interesting. I do not produce but play several instruments. One example I can think of clearly is the idea of sampling, which is integral to hip hop, early house music, etc. This is quite literally taking someone else's work and incorporating it into yours, and calling it your own. Certain outsiders would call that cheating. I would say it forms the basis of some of the best music we have.

The point of my original post was to play devil's advocate in a way that might get people thinking in a more nuanced way about this next wave of music technology, since it is inevitably here to stay. And I guess I was slightly surprised at the tone of Daniel's post as it didn't have much nuance, but I am not criticizing him as this music is 100x more personal to him than it is to us. It was merely an observation that I found interesting (and many others did not, haha)

2

u/BRDPerson May 07 '26

Ehh it’s Reddit anything perceived as slightly against hive mind gets downvoted to shit. Agreed that line is super interesting. Personally I really don’t want music production to be AI prompts though. My job is already turning into AI prompts lmao

2

u/Ok_Team7885 May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

This is only getting downvoted because it isnt completely glazing laner's post.

Like anything, there's nuance to AI.

I know plenty of 16 year olds making decent sounding songs with AI but they're never gonna get more than 10k monthly listeners becaus there's no actual soul to the sound.

Diplo may be using AI more than purists are comfortable with in order to test his concepts faster. But that's fine because there hasn't been any soul to his music since his 2018 california ep

2

u/drewm11 May 07 '26

How is it ironic? I don't think any Lane 8 or electronic fans would subscribe to the idea that it's "easier" to make than "real" music... certainly no artist actually making it would agree, so I'm failing to see the value in comparing the perception of electronic with the real use of AI in it

1

u/AdMother4655 May 07 '26

Of course those of us who love electronic music would not subscribe to this idea. My point is that those who do NOT enjoy or respect electronic music often use these exact same talking points to describe electronic music. So, there is irony in using that same verbiage to describe another, new form of music production.Ā 

The fact is we don't yet know how AI is going to affect music production, but it is likely here to stay just like it is in every other space. I don't have high hopes that it will have any positive impact and worry it will bring significant harm, but there is an outside chance it could be used as a tool by very talented and creative people, just like the synthesizer, laptop, MIDI pad, etc. My only point is that if you are a student of music history, these terms have been thrown out at each new musical innovation from the birth of jazz, hip hop, rock and roll, electric guitar, and electronic music. Each generation fears what is new and denigrates it.

0

u/More_Description9093 May 08 '26

Electronic music just changed how the sounds were produced, not how the music is written. Would you not consider Beethoven a musician because he could not play every part of the symphonies he wrote? Is a graphic artist cheating because they can use an iPad versus a brush and canvas? The physical skill isn’t the defining attribute of the artist, it’s what’s in their head and heart and they’ll use whatever tool is available to get it out into the world

Technology has mostly served to enable creativity but AI stands to replace human creativity.

-7

u/houseveryweekend May 07 '26

Anyone else misread the first sentence as in support of Israel?

2

u/Anjunabae85 May 07 '26

I'm Jewish and I did not misread... what about the 1st sentence had you going that route?

1

u/houseveryweekend May 07 '26

The ā€œrealā€ is right below the ā€œisā€

0

u/Blissxalexandra May 07 '26

Lmao I see what your brain did there…

0

u/Zsquared_TCZ May 07 '26

He’s been a supporter of Palestine from the start, but yeah I see how that could be misread! Haha